Article

September 29, 2026

Roles and Competencies in School Management: Comparative Study between São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE

Roles and Competencies in School Management: Comparative Study between São Paulo/sp and Sobral/ce

Alexandre Gama de Souza; Tatiana Giselle Guimarães Lopes

DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202602609

Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.

Summary

A comparative study analyzed the job descriptions and competency development in school management in the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE, based on official documents published between 2015 and 2024. The objective was to identify patterns, gaps, and contributions in the selection notices and public examinations for positions of director, pedagogical coordinator, and school supervisor, justified by the strategic relevance of school management for educational quality. The investigation adopted a qualitative approach, descriptive and comparative in nature, using documentary analysis of official public sources. The Requirements No. 02/2015, from the Municipality of São Paulo, and the Requirements No. 009/2021, from the Municipality of Sobral, which met the defined criteria, were selected. The results showed that both municipalities required higher education in teaching degrees and minimum teaching experience. However, they differed in central aspects: São Paulo favored stability, statutory employment, and emphasis on legal and theoretical bases, while Sobral adopted commissioned positions, selection processes focused on analytical skills and socio-emotional leadership, as well as mandatory continuing education. The analysis indicated that the models reflected distinct philosophies of people management and the role of the school manager, but converged in the valuation of permanent training and pedagogical leadership. It was concluded that school management should be understood as a strategic space for articulation between technical, pedagogical, and relational competencies, essential for strengthening public education networks.

Keywords: Continuing education; Educational management; Competency-based management; Pedagogical leadership; Public policies.

1. Introduction

School management is configured as a central element for the effectiveness of educational institutions, directly influencing the quality of education and pedagogical processes. Its strategic relevance is undeniable, as it directly impacts the learning environment and student development.

In the Brazilian context, public policies for basic education face significant structural challenges. The fragmentation of actions and the lack of articulation between different management levels are factors that frequently compromise the implementation of consistent educational practices (Dourado, 2007). In this scenario, educational management assumes a strategic role, requiring not only technical competencies but also the ability to articulate innovative paradigms that respond to contemporary complexities (Lück, 2007).

The organization and management of the school, as highlighted by Libâneo (2007), involve the integration of pedagogical, administrative, and human dimensions. To this end, school managers need skills to mediate conflicts, promote democratic participation, and align educational practices with institutional reality. The figure of the educational manager is fundamental, acting as an articulator of public policies and a promoter of an inclusive and efficient school environment (Silva, 2009).

However, studies indicate that the performance of these professionals is often limited by bureaucratic structures and lack of autonomy, factors that hinder innovation and adaptation to local demands (Oliveira and Vasques-Menezes, 2018). This reality highlights the need to improve management models so that they can effectively contribute to the quality of teaching.

The problem of this study lies in the need to understand how job description and analysis in school management can contribute to the development of skills aligned with contemporary educational challenges. To this end, a comparative analysis is proposed between the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE. These locations are recognized for their distinct trajectories in educational management, with São Paulo representing a scenario of great administrative complexity and Sobral standing out nationally for innovative educational policies and significant results in performance evaluations.

The relevance of the research is based on the urgency to improve management models that value not only formal requirements, such as academic background, but also behavioral and strategic competencies. As Lück (2007) demonstrates, educational management must transcend traditional approaches, incorporating practices that encourage collective participation and creative problem-solving. The analysis of official documents, such as hiring notices, allows for the identification of patterns and gaps that can guide the professionalization of school management (Libâneo, 2007). By integrating theoretical contributions from authors such as Dourado (2007), Libâneo (2007), and Oliveira and Vasques-Menezes (2018), this study seeks not only to broaden the academic debate on school management but also to offer practical subsidies for the qualification of educational public policies. Thus, the objective of this work was to comparatively analyze the job descriptions and the competencies required for school managers in the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE, based on official documents, aiming to identify patterns, gaps, and contribute to the professionalization of educational management.

2. Material and Methods

The present research adopted a qualitative approach, of a descriptive and comparative nature, according to the classifications proposed by Gil (2002) and Cervo et al. (2007). This methodology was considered adequate for the analysis of organizational phenomena in the context of educational public management, allowing for an in-depth understanding of the dynamics involved in job description and competency development.

The main technique employed was documentary research, which was based exclusively on official and public secondary sources. The data were obtained through institutional portals of the selected municipalities, ensuring the authenticity and accessibility of the information used for the study.

The investigation was designed as a multiple-case study, with the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE as units of analysis. The choice of these locations was justified by the relevance and notoriety of their educational networks, which present management models with contrasting features in policies for training and valuing education professionals.

This methodological configuration favored the identification of structural similarities and differences in the practices of analysis and formalization of educational leadership positions. Thus, the aim was to understand how distinct conceptions of public educational management influence the formulation of requirements for school managers.

The data were collected through the selection and analysis of official documents, focusing on public tender notices and selection processes. These notices were intended for the provision of the positions of school director, pedagogical coordinator, and school supervisor, published between the years 2015 and 2024.

The documentary search was conducted systematically on public transparency platforms and the institutional websites of the Municipal Secretariats of Education. During this process, criteria of authenticity and currency of the documents were rigorously observed, ensuring the reliability of the sources.

For the inclusion of documents in the analysis, specific criteria were established. Only those with unrestricted public access, clarity in the description of job duties, competencies, and requirements, and relevance to the people management policy in the public education network were considered.

Additionally, the documents should have been published between the years 2015 and 2024, with the objective of covering the most recent and representative calls for proposals. This temporal delimitation allowed for a focused analysis of contemporary educational management policies and practices.

In the period from 2015 to 2024, the search resulted in the identification of only one public notice in each municipality that fully met the established criteria. For São Paulo/SP, Public Notice No. 02/2015 was selected, and for Sobral/CE, Public Notice No. 009/2021, which served as the main sources of analysis.

The analysis of the documents followed an interpretive qualitative approach, based on categories constructed from the theoretical framework of public and educational management. The analysis categories included the structure of positions, duties and responsibilities, and the requirements for training and experience.

The technical and behavioral competencies required were also analyzed, as well as the language and intentionality present in the normative texts of the requirements. This categorization allowed for a detailed exploration of the elements that make up the profile of school managers in each municipality.

The documentary analysis was guided by the principles proposed by Cellard (2008), which advocates for a critical and contextualized reading of the documents. Elements such as the authenticity, representativeness, and internal coherence of the information contained in the Requirements were considered.

This analysis strategy allowed us to understand how different conceptions of educational public management influence the formulation of leadership positions in schools. An emphasis on the more technical and managerial aspects was observed in São Paulo/SP, and an orientation towards the more pedagogical and formative aspects in Sobral/CE.

Two guiding questions were adopted for the analysis: What were the patterns, gaps, and contributions identified in the analyzed documents for the professionalization of educational management? And what are the profiles of the managers outlined by the analyzed calls for proposals?

3. Results and Discussion

This section presents the results obtained from the documentary analysis of the selection notices for school management positions in the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE, published between 2015 and 2024. The findings reveal significant convergences and divergences in selection criteria, evaluation processes, methods of filling positions, continuing education strategies, and performance evaluation mechanisms for school managers. The discussion of these results is carried out in light of the specialized literature, seeking to interpret the meaning of the findings in relation to the research problem and the study’s objective, which was to comparatively analyze the job descriptions and the competencies required for school managers.

Initially, a characterization of the municipal education networks of São Paulo and Sobral was carried out to contextualize the management models. Sobral/CE stands out in the Brazilian educational scenario, with approximately 107 schools and 29,060 students, served by about 1,540 teachers. The quality indicators for education are remarkably expressive, with the municipality achieving a Basic Education Development Index (IDEB) of 9.6 in the initial years and 7.9 in the final years of elementary school in 2023, values much higher than the national average.

Regarding adequate learning, Sobral’s data for the 5th grade in 2023 indicated that 98% of students reached adequate levels in Portuguese Language and 98% in Mathematics. For the 9th grade, the percentages were 88% in Portuguese and 87% in Mathematics. Educational equity is also a strong point, with 90% of students from low socioeconomic status (SES) in the early years achieving adequate learning in Portuguese and 92% in Mathematics in 2019, while for those from high SES, the rates were 95% in both subjects.

However, the analysis by race/color in Sobral revealed some disparities in the initial years of 2019, with 81% of Black students achieving adequate learning in Portuguese, compared to 93% of White students. In Mathematics, the percentages were 82% for Black students and 93% for White students. In the final years, the differences were more pronounced: students from low SES achieved 71% in Portuguese and 61% in Mathematics, while those from high SES achieved 85% and 74%, respectively. By race/color, the indicators in the final years were 73% for Black students and 84% for White students in Portuguese, and 64% for Black students and 74% for White students in Mathematics.

The age-grade distortion rate in Sobral is also low, with only 2% in the initial years and 2.9% in the final years in 2024, evidencing a more fluid school trajectory. This data reinforces the perception of Sobral as a school system with high academic performance and relative equity, although still facing challenges in reducing socioeconomic and racial inequalities, especially in the final years of elementary school. School management, in this context, assumes a strategic role in maintaining progress and addressing gaps.

In contrast, the municipal network of São Paulo/SP, the largest in the country, serves approximately 1,344,601 students in 2,701 schools, with 67,350 teachers. In 2023, the municipality registered an IDEB of 5.6 in the initial years and 4.8 in the final years of elementary school, values that indicate significant challenges compared to Sobral. Adequate learning in the 5th grade was 49% in Portuguese Language and 38% in Mathematics, and in the 9th grade, 33% in Portuguese and 13% in Mathematics.

Educational equity in São Paulo also presented challenges in 2019. In the initial years, 59% of low SES students achieved adequate learning in Portuguese Language and 49% in Mathematics, while for high SES students, the percentages were 75% and 67%, respectively. In the breakdown by race/color, 52% of black students achieved adequate learning in Portuguese and 44% in Mathematics, compared to 71% and 62% for white students.

In the final years, disparities persisted: students from low SES had 34% adequate learning in Portuguese Language and 13% in Mathematics, while those from high SES achieved 49% and 24%, respectively. By race/color, the percentages were 32% for Black students and 13% for White students in Portuguese, and 48% for Black students and 23% for White students in Mathematics. The age-grade distortion in 2024 was 3.6% in the initial years and 8% in the final years, indicating greater difficulties in the academic trajectory of students in São Paulo.

The political-institutional trajectory of each municipality also proved to be a determining factor. Sobral demonstrated notable political-party continuity since the late 1990s, which allowed for the construction of a long-term educational project, with right-age literacy goals and methods maintained for over two decades. This governmental permanence facilitated the transformation of local educational policy and consistent alignment in the training and selection of its management staff.

In contrast, São Paulo experienced frequent alternations in the municipal Executive Power during the same period, resulting in discontinuity of guidelines and successive reformulations of educational projects with each change of administration. This political volatility impacted the construction of provision models and training requirements, highlighting the importance of stability for the consolidation of effective public educational policies, as suggested by the literature.

Document analysis of the selected calls for proposals

The analysis of the selection notices for the positions of School Director, Pedagogical Coordinator, and School Supervisor in the two municipalities revealed both convergences and divergences. Both municipalities require a higher education degree in teaching, preferably in Pedagogy, and minimum teaching experience. In São Paulo, Notice nº 02/2015, item 1.3, pages 25-26, establishes three years of effective service in the municipal teaching profession. In Sobral, Notice nº 009/2021, item 6.1.6 f, requires two years of experience as a Basic Education teacher.

In São Paulo, complementary qualification is more specific, requiring graduate studies in the education field if the candidate does not have a degree in Pedagogy, according to Public Notice nº 02/2015, item 1.3, pages 25-26. In Sobral, complementary qualification is not mandatory, but it is considered a differential in the interview, according to Public Notice nº 009/2021, item 8 f. This difference suggests a greater appreciation for formal specialization in São Paulo, while Sobral focuses on competencies demonstrated in the selection process.

The selection processes also present substantial distinctions. In São Paulo, the positions of Director and Supervisor are filled through public examination of tests and titles, governed by specific requirements with formal stages and broad competition. The provision is for a permanent position, with appointment through public examination according to the Municipal Teaching Statute. In Sobral, however, the selection process is simplified, with qualifying and eliminating stages, including an objective test, profile analysis, and interview, conducted by the Municipal Department of Education to form a pool of school managers. The provision is for a commissioned position, with discretionary appointment and no permanent link.

Continuing education and skills development are addressed in distinct ways. In São Paulo, participation in training courses is foreseen, but it is not a mandatory step for entry. In Sobral, participation in a training course is a mandatory stage of the selection process, integrating the manager’s evaluation and preparation. This Sobral approach aligns with the perspective that continuous training is intrinsic to professional development and competency-based management (Fleury and Fleury, 2001).

Performance evaluation also differs. In São Paulo, it is mentioned in later regulations, with defined criteria for periodic evaluation of managers’ performance. In Sobral, remaining in office is conditioned on performance evaluation, with criteria established in the public notice and the possibility of dismissal at any time. This difference reflects the nature of the employment relationship and the people management philosophy of each municipality, with Sobral using evaluation as an instrument for strategic alignment and results induction.

Analysis and Discussion

The analysis of the public notices from São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE reveals that, although both municipalities demonstrate concern for the qualification of managers, their approaches diverge significantly, reflecting distinct models of educational management. In São Paulo, the emphasis is on the stability of public careers and the institutionalization of positions, with provision through public examination and statutory vínculo. This approach tends to provide greater security and predictability for professionals, which can attract talent in the long term, but may also generate some rigidity in allocation and development processes.

In Sobral, the model of provision through commissioned positions, with diversified selection processes and a focus on competencies, allows for greater flexibility and assertiveness in allocating managers to school units, according to profile and needs. This practice aligns with competency-based management, which seeks to optimize organizational performance through the continuous development of individual and collective capabilities (Fleury and Fleury, 2001). The absence of stability, however, can be a risk factor for the retention of qualified professionals, as argued by Chiavenato (2014), especially in networks that depend on the consolidation of successful practices.

The selection criteria verified in the two municipalities demonstrate a growing concern with the leadership profile and the competencies of school managers. Perrenoud (1999) already highlighted that educational management requires competencies that transcend the technical-administrative domain, including the ability to lead teams, formulate and execute pedagogical projects, and dialogue with the school community. The emphasis on teaching experience, continuous training, and interpersonal skills in the requirements corroborates the vision that the school manager must act as an articulator of the pedagogical project and a promoter of a learning culture.

Continuing education is a point of convergence, being valued in both municipalities, although with distinct formats. In São Paulo, participation in training programs is emphasized, while in Sobral, training is a mandatory stage of the selection process, strongly linked to the municipal political-pedagogical project. This linkage in Sobral allows for a clearer alignment between the performance of managers and local educational objectives, while in São Paulo, the challenges of scale and institutional diversity may limit the effectiveness of training actions, as pointed out by Dourado (2014).

Performance evaluation is also a common mechanism, but with different emphases. São Paulo applies mechanisms based on learning goals and institutional performance indicators. Sobral, in turn, monitors performance based on educational results and pedagogical articulation capacity, in line with the strategic objectives of the Municipal Department of Education. This results-oriented approach of Sobral reflects a management philosophy that seeks institutional effectiveness and the continuous alignment of individual competencies with organizational objectives (Chiavenato, 2014).

Profile of Managers expected by each call for applications

The profile of the expected manager in Sobral is multifaceted, combining technical, interpersonal, and legal skills, aligned with a culture of innovation and results. The Sobral notice requires knowledge of educational indicators such as IDEB, SAEB, PISA, and SPAECE, demonstrating that management is data-driven. The manager is seen as an analyst capable of diagnosing problems and planning effective pedagogical actions, transforming into a strategist who makes evidence-based decisions.

The emphasis on people leadership and the ability to build bridges is another pillar of Sobral’s profile. The public notice highlights the importance of organizational and educational leadership, as well as the need for socio-emotional skills. The appreciation of the relationship between “school, family, and community” aligns with Freire’s (1996) vision of educational practice as an act of autonomy and shared responsibility. Socio-emotional skills are essential for social progress, as the OECD (2015) highlights, and Sobral’s ideal manager is a leader who mobilizes and inspires their team and the community to achieve common goals.

Sobral’s manager profile also requires legal knowledge and an innovative bias. The list of legislations, including municipal ones, in the curriculum indicates that the manager must be an expert in their area, capable of navigating the legal framework to ensure management autonomy and implement innovations, such as the use of “new technologies in management”. The mention of publications from UNDIME, UNICEF, MEC, and INEP (2007) reinforces that the municipality seeks a professional who applies best practices and stays updated with educational trends, combining technical rigor with the capacity to innovate.

In contrast, the profile of the manager expected by the municipal network of São Paulo, according to the bibliography provided in the Requirements, goes beyond a mere administrator. He is configured as a pedagogical and socially engaged leader, with profound knowledge of the legal and theoretical framework of Brazilian education. The vast list of documents and references indicates that the manager must be an expert in educational policy, mastering the national curriculum guidelines for Early Childhood Education and Elementary Education, in addition to complex legislation on inclusive special education (Mantoan, 2015; Ropoli et al., 2010) and ethnic-racial relations.

This legislative emphasis in São Paulo points to a professional who understands the school as a space for guaranteeing rights and combating inequalities. The bibliography also highlights the role of the manager as a promoter of democratic and participatory management. The inclusion of works by Paulo Freire and Ferreira (2013) evidences the need for a manager who practices horizontal management and mobilizes the school community in the construction of the Political-Pedagogical Project (PPP). The São Paulo manager must apply theory to the daily practice of the school, transforming principles of autonomy and dialogue into reality, opposing a merely managerial approach.

The São Paulo network also expects a manager who acts as a curator of knowledge and an incentivizer of continuous training. The presence of references on curriculum, such as the works of Sacristán (2013), and on teacher training, with authors like Pimenta and Ghedin (2006) and Imbernón (2006), shows that the professional must be a mentor and an articulator of their team’s development. He is responsible for creating a learning environment for teachers and students, promoting a culture of reflection on pedagogical practice, interdisciplinarity (Tyhiesen, 2008), and the constant search for new knowledge, ensuring that the school is a space of constant renewal and academic excellence.

The Profiles of Managers in Light of School Management Literature

The comparative analysis of the programmatic contents of the calls for São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE allows for the identification of school manager profiles that, although distinct in their approaches, dialogue with the central functions of educational management established in the literature. In Sobral, the manager is outlined as a results-oriented strategist, with a strong command of data and analytical skills. This emphasis refers to the conception of management as a practice focused on institutional effectiveness, approaching the strategic role of People Management, which seeks to align individual competencies with organizational objectives (Chiavenato, 2014).

This perspective in Sobral also aligns with the concept of competency-based management developed by Fleury and Fleury (2001), in which organizational performance depends on the continuous mobilization of technical and relational knowledge. The appreciation of these competencies in the Ceará municipality is evident, indicating a search for professionals who not only possess knowledge but also demonstrate the ability to apply it effectively to achieve the desired educational results, contributing to the continuous improvement of teaching quality.

In contrast, the expected profile in São Paulo prioritizes the political-pedagogical dimension, based on a broad legal and theoretical foundation. This configuration aligns with what Libâneo (2007) and Paro (2015) advocate as the core of school management: the democratization of the school, the strengthening of the Political-Pedagogical Project, and the collective construction of decisions. The emphasis on authors such as Freire, Sacristán, and Imbernón in the public notice’s bibliography reinforces the conception of the manager as a pedagogical leader and social articulator, in line with Lück’s (2007) perspective, which understands educational management as a paradigmatic process of integration between administrative and pedagogical dimensions.

These differences highlight that school management cannot be reduced to a merely bureaucratic function, but involves the construction of specific competencies, as Perrenoud (1999) had already pointed out. While Sobral outlines a manager focused on measurable results and aligned with the monitoring of public policies, São Paulo structures a profile closer to what Oliveira and Vasques-Menezes (2018) describe as a mediating manager, responsible for ensuring the balance between legal requirements, democratic principles, and pedagogical needs, promoting an inclusive and participatory school environment.

The literature also highlights that the quality of management depends not only on institutional design, but on the continuous training and development of the professional. Silva (2009) reinforces the importance of the educational manager as an agent of transformation, while Dourado (2007) points out the limits of educational policies when there is no appreciation and adequate conditions for managerial performance. At this point, a convergence is observed between the two municipalities: both São Paulo and Sobral incorporate continuous training as a structuring element, albeit in different formats, recognizing it as an indispensable requirement for the improvement of pedagogical practice and management.

In summary, the profiles outlined by the analyzed calls for proposals, although distinct in their approaches, reflect concerns widely debated in the literature on school management. Both models seek managers capable of articulating technical, pedagogical, and relational competencies, value continuous training, and understand management as a space for transformative leadership, not just bureaucratic execution. The results indicate that school management should be understood as a strategic space for articulating technical, pedagogical, and relational competencies, essential for strengthening public education networks and improving educational quality, directly responding to the central objective of this study.

4. Conclusion

This study comparatively analyzed the job descriptions and competencies required for school managers in the municipalities of São Paulo/SP and Sobral/CE, based on official documents, seeking to identify patterns, gaps, and contribute to the professionalization of educational management. It was found that both municipalities required higher education in teaching degrees and minimum teaching experience, converging in the valuation of continuous training and pedagogical leadership. However, it was observed that São Paulo favored public career stability and emphasis on legal and theoretical bases, outlining a manager as a pedagogical leader and social articulator. In contrast, Sobral adopted commissioned positions and selection processes focused on analytical skills, socio-emotional leadership, and mandatory continuous training, configuring a strategist manager oriented by results. This analysis revealed that the models reflect distinct philosophies of people management and the role of the school manager, but both seek the qualification of the professional.

The main contribution of this work lies in demonstrating that the format of the people management policy is a critical variable in determining the direction of public education, offering subsidies for academic debate. Although the São Paulo model provides greater stability, it can generate rigidity in allocation and development processes. On the other hand, the flexibility of the Sobral model, while promoting agility and alignment with local policies, can present challenges in retaining qualified professionals due to the absence of stability. It is concluded that school management must be understood as a strategic space for articulating technical, pedagogical, and relational competencies, essential for strengthening public education networks and for improving educational quality.

Bibliographic References

Benvian, P.A.; Cervo, A.L.; Silva, R. da. 2007. Metodologia científica. 6ed. Pearson Prentice Hall, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Cellard, A. 2008. A análise documental. P. 295-316 In: POUPART, J. A pesquisa qualitativa: enfoques epistemológicos e metodológicos. Vozes, Petrópolis, RJ, Brasil.

Chiavenato, I. 2014. Gestão de pessoas: o novo papel dos recursos humanos nas organizações. 4ed. Elsevier, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.

Dourado, L.F. 2007. Políticas e gestão da educação básica no Brasil: limites e perspectivas. Educação e Sociedade 28(100): 921-946.

Ferreira, N. S. C. 2013. Gestão democrática da educação: atuais tendências, novos desafios. 8ª ed. Cortez, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Fleury, M. T. L., & Fleury, A. 2001. Construindo o conceito de competência. Revista De Administração Contemporânea 5(spe): 183-196.

Freire, P. 1996. Pedagogia da Autonomia: saberes necessários à prática educativa. Paz e Terra São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Gil, A.C. 2002. Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. 4ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Imbernón, F. 2006. Formação docente e profissional – Formar-se para a mudança e a incerteza. 6ª ed. Cortez, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Libâneo, J.C. 2007. A organização e a gestão da escola: teoria e prática. Alternativa, Goiânia, GO, Brasil.

Lück, H. 2007. Gestão educacional: uma questão paradigmática. Vozes, Petrópolis, RJ, Brasil.

Mantoan, M. T. E. 2015. Inclusão Escolar – O que é? Por quê? Como fazer? 1ed. Summus. São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Ocde. 2015.Competências para o progresso social: o poder das competências socioemocionais. Fundação Santillana, São Paulo, SP. Brasil. Disponível em: http://pt.calameo.com/read/002899327e71398e4d015. Acesso em: 11 mai. 2025.

Oliveira, I.C.; Vasques-Menezes, I. 2018. Revisão de literatura: o conceito de gestão escolar. Cadernos de Pesquisa 48(169):876–900.

Paro, V.H. 2015. Gestão democrática da escola pública. 12ed. Ática, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Perrenoud, P. 1999. Construir as competências desde a escola. Artmed, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.

Pimenta, S. G.; Ghedin, E. 2006. Professor Reflexivo no Brasil – gênese e crítica de um conceito. 4ª ed. Cortez, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Ropoli, E. A. et al. 2010. A Educação Especial na Perspectiva da Inclusão Escolar: a escola comum inclusiva. Ministério da Educação, Secretaria de Educação Especial, Fortaleza, Universidade Federal do Ceará, Brasília, DF, Brasil.

Sacristán, J. G. 2013. Saberes e incertezas sobre o currículo. Penso, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.

Silva, E.P. da. 2009. A importância do gestor educacional na instituição escolar. Revista Conteúdo 1 (2): 67-83.

Tyhiesen, J. S. 2008. Interdisciplinaridade como movimento articulador no processo ensino/aprendizagem. Revista Brasileira de Educação 13(39): 545-598.

UNDIME/UNICEF/MEC/INEP. 2007. Redes de Aprendizagem: boas práticas de municípios que garantem o direito de aprender. Brasília, DF, Brasil. Disponível em: https://www.unicef.org/brazil/pt/Redes_de_aprendizagem.pdf Acesso em: 11 mai. 2025

Article originating from the Course Conclusion Work of the Specialization in School Management of the MBA USP/Esalq

To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform

You may also like

November 10, 2026

Crest and Toe Deviations in the Effective Berm Width in an Open Pit Mine

The geometric assessment of berms in open-pit mines has proven relevant for operational safety and excavation compliance with the design. The study analyzed the extent to which geometric deviations of the crest and toe explained the variation in the effective berm width in Bench -120 of an open-pit mine, using the Excavation Compliance Index as an interpretation tool. The investigation was characterized as applied and quantitative, developed through a case study with real geometric data extracted from DXF format files. Crest and toe coordinates were processed in Python, interpolated with regular spacing of 1 meter, and harmonized along the common section of the geometries. Subsequently, descriptive statistical analysis, multiple linear regression, quantile regression, Random Forest Regressor, and an adapted application of the index were performed. The results indicated that 57.7% of the berms were classified as compliant, 30.0% as attention, and 12.2% as critical. Crest deviations were higher and more dispersed than toe deviations. Multiple linear regression indicated a statistically significant association between geometric deviations and effective berm width, albeit with low explanatory power. Quantile regression showed that the effects varied along the width distribution, and the Random Forest indicated sensitivity to non-linear patterns, but with a limitation of sequential generalization. It was found that crest and toe deviations were associated with the effective berm width, but did not solely explain its entire variability.

Keywords: geometric assessment; bench geometry; compliance index; quantile regression.

November 10, 2026

Applied marketing for strengthening brand strength, contribution, and value in credit co-operatives

In a competitive and demanding financial scenario requiring trust, brand relevance is crucial for sustaining preference and relationships in cooperative organizations. The study investigated how applied marketing strategies can strengthen brand equity, contribution, and value in a credit cooperative, aiming to enhance its competitive relevance in the market. To this end, a case study was conducted in a Brazilian credit cooperative, employing quantitative research. A Likert scale questionnaire was administered to 85 marketing department employees, selected by non-probabilistic convenience sampling. Data were analyzed using frequencies, descriptive statistics, cross-tabulation, and inter-section interdependence analysis. The results revealed a predominantly positive perception, with highlights in immediate recall, credibility, trust, and security, and favorable evaluations regarding the practical effects of the brand on preference, relationship stages, and recommendation. However, opportunities for improvement were identified in consistency across channels, the onboarding process and post-membership support, and the sufficiency of evaluation metrics. As managerial contributions, the research supported recommendations to standardize messages and contact points, strengthen the entry and post-membership stages, and consolidate indicator-based monitoring routines, with inter-departmental alignment and leadership support for more consistent decisions.

Keywords: multichannel consistency; performance metrics; onboarding; competitive relevance.

November 10, 2026

Formal compliance and practical ineffectiveness: on the presence of senior management in the practice of illicit acts in relation to Public Power

In recent years, the robustness of an integrity program has consolidated itself as a criterion for corporate credibility, notably in relations with the public sector. Nevertheless, despite its widespread diffusion in the corporate environment, recurrent cases of corruption involving companies and often involving senior management persist. The objective of this study was to analyze the relationship between the effectiveness of the integrity program, the role of senior management, and the practice of illicit acts in relation to Public Administration. To this end, an exploratory and bibliographic research was adopted, from a broad view of compliance, with an emphasis on the role of senior management as one of the main pillars for the implementation and development of an effective integrity program. Based on data made available by the Comptroller General of the Union [CGU] and widely publicized cases reported in the media, we sought to examine in an integrated manner the correlation between the inefficiency of an integrity program and the practice of illicit acts in relation to Public Administration. With the results, it was verified that, although compliance has become the rule in large corporations, as well as a requirement for contracting with public bodies, predatory management and the lack of leadership commitment are still a reality that weakens or nullifies the integrity programs implemented in the Brazilian corporate scenario, especially in the relationship with Public Administration.

Keywords: compliance; managers; offense; public bodies.

November 10, 2026

Behavioural Insights: The commercialization of data for strategic decision-making in the technology sector

The growing use of artificial intelligence and big data by technology companies has expanded the use of personal data as strategic assets, but has also intensified ethical risks related to privacy, consent, and transparency. In this context, we investigated how users with minimal knowledge about the General Data Protection Law (LGPD), artificial intelligence, and data perceive the legitimacy and ethics of using the Behaviour Insights product, developed by Meta, and what trade-offs they considered acceptable to authorize data processing. To this end, an applied research was conducted, with a quantitative, descriptive, and exploratory approach. Data collection occurred through a structured questionnaire, applied to 100 participants from the Southeast region of Brazil with minimal knowledge about LGPD, AI, and data. Data analysis was statistical and included triangulation for greater robustness. The results indicated that the presence of predictive algorithms is widely perceived, and 55.6% of users considered algorithmic recommendation systems positive for their experience. However, 82.7% of respondents negatively assessed the commercialization of their data to third parties without explicit consent. The perceived legitimacy of Behaviour Insights was not associated with technical sophistication, but with the existence of data governance, algorithmic transparency, and data subject control. It was concluded that the acceptance of predictive solutions, such as Behaviour Insights, depends on the perception of direct user benefit and clarity about data usage, with strong rejection of commercialization without consent. It is recommended that organizations explicitly state the purposes of data usage and the trade-offs offered to increase acceptance.

Keywords: Data commercialization; Combinatorial creativity; LGPD; Prediction; Privacy.

November 10, 2026

Information security controls based on ISO/IEC 27002:2022 in companies in Brazil

Information security represents a fundamental requirement for companies and governmental entities, especially in the face of increasing digitalization and the risks associated with data protection and system integrity. The objective was to analyze 25 controls from the ISO/IEC 27002:2022 standard, distributed into 15 organizational, 5 technological, 3 people, and 2 physical controls, in organizations in Brazil. To this end, an exploratory study with a quantitative approach was conducted, applying a structured questionnaire with 30 questions to 66 information security professionals. Data were collected virtually between February and March 2026 and analyzed using graphs and tables. The results indicated that organizations prioritized controls such as physical access restriction, malware protection, and removal of access after termination. In contrast, controls related to information security auditing, business continuity, and organizational learning were the least used. The analysis revealed that, although the prioritization of operational controls generates immediate results, it compromises the maturation of information security. It was concluded that the consistent implementation of structuring controls is crucial to strengthen corporate resilience and align the information security system with management and compliance requirements.

Keywords: compliance; organizational controls; governance; information security.

November 10, 2026

Model for supporting the financial analysis process of on-premises to cloud migration

Cloud computing has consolidated itself as a strategic alternative for cost reduction and increased flexibility in IT infrastructure management. However, migrating on-premises environments to the cloud presents challenges, especially for organizations with limited resources. The study aimed to propose a model to support the feasibility analysis of cloud migration, based on real usage and operational cost data. A case study methodology was adopted, in which data from a real environment were collected using the AWS Migration Evaluator tool, complemented by information obtained from an IT manager. From this data, the costs of the on-premises environment were estimated, and equivalent cloud scenarios were simulated, enabling the calculation of financial indicators TCO, ROI, and Payback. The results showed that the economic feasibility of the migration depended on the premises adopted, such as region, contracting model, and resource utilization profile. The application of the model revealed a robust economic feasibility, with a Return on Investment (ROI) of 451% and an estimated payback period of 6.5 months, driven by a 45% reduction in vCPU and 64% in RAM, resulting from the correction of over-provisioning. It was concluded that the proposed model contributed as a decision support tool, by providing a structured and real-data-based approach, promoting predictability and economic rationality for cloud migration processes in medium-sized companies.

Keywords: Cloud computing; Cloud migration; Payback; ROI; TCO.

November 10, 2026

Structuring of business profiles by financial indicators and multivariate clustering

The growing availability of financial data and the need to interpret it in a structured way have made multivariate analysis techniques relevant in the context of data science applied to organizations. The study aimed to identify and interpret clusters of companies based on selected financial indicators, in order to understand patterns of similarity and differentiation among the observed economic-financial profiles. To this end, an applied, quantitative, and exploratory-descriptive research was conducted, using a database composed of balance sheet, working capital, and operational liabilities variables. The data were processed, standardized, and aggregated by company, and subsequently analyzed using clustering techniques with the K-means algorithm, determination of the number of clusters by the Elbow and Silhouette methods, dimensionality reduction by Principal Component Analysis, and statistical validation by analysis of variance. The results showed that the segmentation identified distinct groups of companies, differentiated mainly by variables related to size, current assets, total liabilities, current liabilities, and suppliers, highlighting the central role of these dimensions in the formation of clusters. The projection by principal components confirmed the visual separation between the groups, and the analysis of variance indicated statistically significant differences in a significant portion of the variables. It was concluded that clustering constituted an adequate approach to identify business profiles based on financial data and that the integration between financial analysis and data science expanded the capacity to interpret the patterns present in the sample.

Keywords: Multivariate Analysis; Data Science; Clustering; Financial Indicators; K-means.

November 10, 2026

LOCATION OF DISTRIBUTION CENTERS FOR E-COMMERCE IN BRAZIL

The location of Distribution Centers (DCs) is a crucial strategic decision for e-commerce companies, influencing logistics costs and delivery times. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) face challenges in conducting robust analyses due to the scarcity of proprietary data and specialized tools. An analytical combinatorial optimization model was developed, integrating unsupervised machine learning (K-means) and meta-heuristics (Genetic Algorithm), based exclusively on public data, to support DC location decisions in Brazil. Data from IBGE, the Olist dataset (Kaggle), Google Trends, and the Google Maps Distance Matrix API were used to build an integrated database with geographic coordinates, demand proxies, and distance matrices. The methodology combined K-means clustering to identify logistically homogeneous regions and the Genetic Algorithm as a search heuristic to select municipalities that minimized total logistics cost. The results indicated the formation of six clusters with distinct regional patterns, concentrating 42% of the demand in the Southeast metropolitan region. The scenario with two DCs, located in São Paulo and Salvador, showed a 22% reduction in variable transportation costs compared to a single DC baseline, covering 70% of the demand within the two-day delivery window (SLA). Sensitivity analyses demonstrated the model’s robustness, with variations below five percentage points under different demand and cost scenarios. It was concluded that the proposed approach offers a viable and replicable alternative for SMEs to democratize access to analytical location methods.

Keywords: Genetic Algorithm; Distribution Centers; E-commerce; K-means; Optimization.