October 08, 2026
Risk management in R&D projects for the strategy of leveraging the Lei do Bem
Risk Management in R&D Projects for Strategy of Exploiting the Lei do Bem
Jonilton Pereira Almeida Junior; Bruno de Lima Santoro
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603054
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The risk management of Research, Development, and Innovation (RD&I) projects eligible for the Lei do Bem (Law of Good) was investigated for its contribution to structuring and compliance. The study aimed to develop a risk management plan for RD&I projects covered by the Lei do Bem, based on the guidelines of the PMBOK (6th edition). The research was characterized as applied, qualitative in nature, with exploratory and descriptive purposes. A scenario analysis of medium-sized organizations that engaged in technological innovation and calculated taxes under the real profit regime was conducted. Bibliographic and documentary research, as well as observation of the practical context of the Lei do Bem, were used. The methodology was based on the seven risk management processes of the PMBOK, covering planning, identification, qualitative and quantitative analyses, response planning, implementation, and risk monitoring. The results revealed significant governance weaknesses, particularly in technical documentation, traceability of eligible expenditures, and integration between the technical, tax, and legal areas. After applying the risk management plan, an improvement was observed in project structuring, predictability of results, and mitigation of fiscal and documentary risks. The systematic and integrated application of risk management strengthened the governance of innovation projects and qualified the interaction of companies with the funding instruments of Brazilian public policy.
Keywords: Project Management; Technological Innovation; Law 11.196/2005; Risk Planning; Public Policies.
1. Introduction
Technological innovation is widely recognized as an essential driver for competitiveness and economic development. In this scenario, public policies to incentivize Research, Development, and Innovation (R&D&I) play a crucial role by stimulating private investment and mitigating the uncertainties inherent in technological advancement (OECD, 2015; OECD, 2018). International guidelines for characterizing R&D activities reinforce technical uncertainty and unpredictability of results as intrinsic elements of innovation, which demands management methods that deal with risks throughout the project cycle (OECD, 2013).
In Brazil, Law No. 11.196/2005, known as the “Lei do Bem” (Law of Good), has consolidated itself as the main instrument of fiscal incentive for technological innovation activities in the productive sector (Brazil, 2005). Its subsequent regulation detailed the eligibility criteria, requirements, and expectations for technical and documentary proof, establishing a normative framework for the continuous promotion of business innovation (Brazil, 2006).
Despite the relevance of the Lei do Bem (Law of Good) as a public policy, studies indicate that its effective utilization remains below its potential, especially considering the number of eligible companies. The effectiveness of the incentive depends not only on the existence of the fiscal instrument but also on the companies’ organizational capacity to structure projects, establish adequate governance, and meet the requirements for control and proof of activities (Guimarães, 2006; Calzolaio and Dathein, 2012). Institutional reports indicate that difficulties in technical proof, documentary consistency, and information traceability are among the main causes of disallowances, rejections, and legal uncertainty in the use of the incentive (MCTI, 2023).
Among the factors contributing to this underutilization are challenges associated with the structuring of innovation projects, the characterization of technological risk, the quality of technical evidence produced, and the integration between the areas responsible for technological development, tax assessment, and compliance with ancillary obligations. The correct interpretation of the concept of technological innovation for eligibility purposes and the transformation of R&D activities into a consistent technical-fiscal dossier are critical points in the operationalization of the Lei do Bem (Moreira Filho, 2013; MCTI, 2020). R&D projects are, by nature, characterized by high levels of technical uncertainty and scope instability, which increases exposure to risks during their execution. When associated with tax incentives, these projects also incorporate risks of a fiscal, documentary, and compliance nature, the consequences of which may include the loss of the benefit and the establishment of tax liabilities (Souza and Martins, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
Risk management, as established by project management best practices, constitutes a structuring approach to deal with uncertainties, support decisions, and increase the probability of project success. The Project Management Institute (PMI, 2017) guide defines specific processes for systematically planning, identifying, analyzing, responding to, and monitoring risks, integrated with organizational governance. However, a still limited application of these practices is observed in R&D projects linked to the Lei do Bem, especially regarding the integration between technical and fiscal dimensions and the documentary consistency required by the incentive.
Given this context, it became relevant to investigate how risk management, based on PMI’s best practices, can contribute to the structuring and compliance of R&D projects eligible for the Lei do Bem (Law of Good). It is assumed that the systematic adoption of risk management processes acts as an integrating element between technological innovation, corporate governance, and regulatory compliance, enhancing legal certainty, predictability, and the qualified use of tax incentives (PMI, 2021; MCTI, 2020). Thus, the work aimed to develop a risk management plan for R&D projects eligible under the Lei do Bem, based on the guidelines of the PMBOK (6th edition), published by PMI (2017).
2. Material and Methods
This work was characterized as an applied research, with a qualitative approach, and exploratory and descriptive objectives. The research was structured from the analysis of realistic scenarios from the business context associated with the Lei do Bem (Good Law). The objective was to develop a risk management plan for Research, Development, and Innovation (R&D&I) projects framed within the Lei do Bem, based on the guidelines of the PMBOK (6th edition), published by the PMI (2017).
The construction of the risk management plan was based on bibliographic and documentary research, covering norms, literature, and public documents related to innovation and tax incentives. This foundation was complemented by the observation of the practical context of applying the Lei do Bem (Law of Good) and the researcher’s professional experience (Flick, 2009; Yin, 2015; MCTI, 2020). The study considered the corporate environment and specialized consulting that acted in structuring R&D projects and in technical-fiscal support, without identifying companies or using confidential data.
The methodology adopted was based on the seven risk management processes of the PMBOK (6th edition), from PMI (2017), encompassing planning, identification, qualitative and quantitative analyses, response planning, implementation, and risk monitoring. The planning began with the elaboration of a Project Charter, which consolidated the objective, justification, scope, and stakeholders (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023). From this charter, the Risk Management Plan was structured, defining the methodology and the record and traceability standard (PMI, 2017).
The risk categories aligned with the Lei do Bem and the process’s accessory obligations were defined, grouped into technical, documentary, fiscal, and compliance risks. Typical responsibilities by function and the minimum approval and validation rules for each type of evidence were established (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023). Finally, the probability and impact criteria, risk appetite, and plan review cadence were defined, establishing standards for documentary traceability (PMI, 2017; ABNT, 2018).
The identification of risks was carried out by mapping the typical operational flow of the Lei do Bem, from the execution of R&D activities to the consolidation of information in FORMP&D and integration with tax accounting. A risk checklist was built, which included technical eligibility requirements, documentary consistency, and fiscal compliance risks (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023). The identified risks were recorded in a Risk Register, with an objective description of the event, cause, consequence, and categorization into technical, documentary, fiscal, and compliance (PMI, 2017).
The qualitative analysis was conducted using the probability and impact scales previously defined in the Risk Management Plan (PMI, 2017). The impact was assessed multidimensionally, considering technical, documentary, fiscal, and organizational aspects (ABNT, 2018). Each risk was assigned a probability and impact score, allowing its classification and prioritization in a matrix. The quantitative analysis was applied punctually through scenarios built with realistic assumptions, aiming to estimate the order of magnitude of the financial impact of critical risks (Kerzner, 2017; PMI, 2021).
The planning of responses to risks defined the most adequate strategy for each critical risk, among mitigating, avoiding, transferring, or accepting, according to its nature, criticality, and implementation feasibility (PMI, 2021). For each prioritized risk, objective actions, functional responsibles, execution deadlines, and triggering events were described. The responses were structured to integrate technical and fiscal/accounting areas, and it was defined what evidence would be produced to demonstrate the implementation of the response (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The implementation consisted of operationalizing the planned responses, transforming them into routines and controls applicable to the project flow. Executable instruments were structured, such as a technical-fiscal checklist for dossier validation and a centralized evidence repository with version control and checkpoints (PMI, 2021). Responsibles for review and validation were defined before final consolidation, reinforcing traceability and documentary integrity, compatible with the incentive proof requirements (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The monitoring of risks was structured through a periodic cadence of review of the Risk Register and verification of the effectiveness of the implemented responses (PMI, 2017). Criteria were defined to re-evaluate probability and impact, record status changes, and incorporate emerging risks, ensuring that the process remained aligned with regulatory requirements (MCTI, 2023). The follow-up was planned to produce governance evidence and ensure that the process remained controlled until the final consolidation of information (PMI, 2021; ABNT, 2018).
3. Results and Discussion
The development of a risk management plan, based on the guidelines of the 6th edition of the PMBOK, was central to the structuring of Research, Development, and Innovation (RD&I) projects framed by the Lei do Bem. The analytical construction of the plan ensured traceability between methodological procedures and the generated artifacts, considering the technical, documentary, and fiscal compliance requirements of the incentive (PMI, 2021; ABNT, 2018; MCTI, 2020). The results demonstrated how good risk management practices were operationalized in the context of the Lei do Bem, connecting project governance, documentary traceability, and regulatory security, crucial aspects for the effective utilization of the fiscal benefit (MCTI, 2023; Souza and Martins, 2020).
The research revealed significant governance fragilities in R&D projects, especially in technical documentation, traceability of eligible expenditures, and integration between the technical, tax, and legal areas. The systematic application of the risk management plan resulted in improvements in project structuring, predictability of results, and mitigation of fiscal and documentary risks. This structured approach strengthened the governance of innovation projects and qualified the interaction of companies with the instruments of promotion of Brazilian public policy, according to the main objective of the study.
Risk Management Planning
The risk management planning constituted the initial stage of the proposed model, aiming to define the governance bases, analysis parameters, and criteria for subsequent processes. For this purpose, a Project Opening Term was developed, which consolidated the objective, justification, scope, assumptions, constraints, deliverables, and main stakeholders of the process for utilizing the Lei do Bem (Law of Good). This document delimited the scope of the study and the project lifecycle, aligning with good project management practices (PMI, 2017) and the proof requirements of the Lei do Bem (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
From the Opening Term, the Risk Management Plan was structured, detailing the methodology, risk categories, functional responsibilities, probability and impact criteria, and monitoring logic. The risk categories were defined as technical (characterization of innovation and technological risk), documentary (evidence, versioning, and consistency), fiscal (eligible expenditures, calculation, and reconciliations), compliance (deadlines, regulatory adherence, and conformity), and organizational. Responsibilities were established by function (technical, fiscal/accounting, legal) and approval rules were set to increase the consistency of the technical-fiscal dossier (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The probability and impact criteria, risk appetite, and plan review cadence were defined to create a minimum governance applicable to the flow of the Law of Good. This step also established document traceability standards, such as version control and linking between deliverables and expenditures, ensuring that risk management was directly connected to the technical proof and fiscal consistency requirements of the claim (PMI, 2017; ABNT, 2018). This preventive approach, covering technical, documentary, fiscal, compliance, and organizational risks, was crucial, as the claim’s vulnerability stemmed not only from technological uncertainty but also from control, integration, and proof failures (MCTI, 2023; Souza and Martins, 2020).
The analytical structure of risks, as developed, demonstrated that the risks were distributed among different project dimensions and required integrated management. This graphical representation reinforced that planning was not just a formal step, but the basis for the governance of the proposed model. The adequate delimitation of the project favored greater coherence between the technical objectives, the supporting documentation, and the future consolidation of the technical-fiscal dossier, essential elements for the success of the claim under the Lei do Bem (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
Identification of Risks
The risk identification process was carried out by mapping the typical operational flow of the Lei do Bem, from the execution of R&D activities to the organization of technical evidence, the consolidation of information in FORMP&D, and the integration with tax calculation and ancillary obligations. This stage sought to recognize, in a structured manner, events that could compromise the project’s eligibility, the consistency of the technical-fiscal dossier, and the security of utilizing the incentive, in accordance with the logic of risk management proposed by the PMBOK (PMI, 2017).
Based on this mapping, a risk checklist was built that addressed fragilities related to the characterization of technological innovation, the proof of technological risk, the contemporaneity and consistency of evidence, the classification of eligible expenditures, the fulfillment of ancillary obligations, and the integration between technical and fiscal areas. The identified risks were recorded in a Risk Register, which included sequential numbering, objective description of the event, main cause, expected consequence, risk category, stage of the process in which it occurred, functional responsible, and sensitive point or related ancillary obligation (PMI, 2021).
The systematization of risks in the risk register ensured traceability between the identified risk and the moment in the flow when it could compromise the claim, favoring the prioritization and planning of responses. The identification of risks considered that vulnerabilities were not limited to the technical failure of the project. Even with technological merit, the fragility of the documentation, the absence of traceability controls, and inconsistencies between technical and fiscal information could partially or fully compromise the utilization of the benefit (Souza and Martins, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The main risks identified included inadequate characterization of technological innovation, absence of technological risk proof, non-contemporary technical evidence, lack of documentary version control, inconsistency between technical reports and fiscal documentation, inadequate classification of eligible expenditures, failure of traceability between deliverables and expenses, inconsistency in filling out the FORMP&D, non-compliance with regulatory deadlines, low integration between technical, fiscal, and legal areas, interpretive or normative change, and fragility in the final validation of the technical-fiscal dossier. These risks were categorized as technical, documentary, fiscal, compliance, and organizational, with impacts ranging from the project’s non-qualification to the total loss of the benefit or rework (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The analysis of risks by cause-and-effect relationships highlighted common structural factors and their potential impacts on the claim. Causes such as non-contemporary evidence, absence of version control, misalignment between the technical and fiscal areas, and insufficient final validation were identified as the main ones. These causes led to documentary fragility and low integration between areas, resulting in sub-causes such as expenditures not linked to the project, documents without technical backing, inconsistent FORMP&D, and inadequate classification of expenditures. The final effect was the compromise of the claim’s eligibility and fiscal security. The diagram reinforced the interdependence between the risks and showed that the absence of standardization, low functional integration, and fragility of internal controls underpinned different events, establishing the basis for subsequent qualitative analysis (PMI, 2017).
Qualitative Risk Analysis
The qualitative analysis of risks aimed to classify and prioritize the events identified in the Risk Register, considering their probability of occurrence and the potential impact on the project and the utilization of the Tax Incentive for Innovation (Lei do Bem). Qualitative three-level scales for probability and impact were adopted: low, medium, and high, applied in a standardized manner. Probability was estimated based on expected recurrence and process vulnerability, while impact considered its technical, documentary, fiscal, and organizational effects (PMI, 2017; ABNT, 2018).
The risk classification was presented in a probability x impact matrix, which visualized the concentration of risks in zones of higher or lower criticality, supporting the definition of treatment priorities. The most critical risks, with high probability and high impact, included inadequate characterization of technological innovation (R1), inconsistency between technical reports and fiscal documentation (R5), inconsistency in filling out the FORMP&D (R8), absence of proof of technological risk (R2), and failure of traceability between deliverables and expenses (R7). Risks such as non-contemporary technical evidence (R3) and low integration between areas (R10) presented medium/high impact, while the lack of documentary version control (R4) had low impact.
The prioritization of risks, organized in a criticality ranking, reinforced that the most relevant events were not exclusively concentrated in the technical dimension of innovation, but above all in the interface between technical merit, supporting documentation, and fiscal consistency. Documentary, fiscal, and compliance risks assumed a central position in the dynamics of using the Lei do Bem, as they could make the claim unfeasible even when the project, from a technological perspective, was consistent. This result aligned with the literature that points to the low integration between governance, documentation, and compliance as limiting factors for the incentive’s effectiveness (Souza and Martins, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
In this way, the qualitative analysis transformed the risk register into a prioritized basis for decision-making, guiding the focus of the following steps. By identifying which risks required priority treatment and which could remain under monitoring, this stage reduced the dispersion of managerial efforts and created an objective basis for quantitative analysis and response planning, reinforcing the preventive logic of risk management in the context of the Lei do Bem (PMI, 2017; ABNT, 2018).
Quantitative Risk Analysis
The quantitative analysis of risks aimed to estimate, in financial terms, the order of magnitude of the impacts associated with the critical risks previously prioritized in the qualitative analysis. In the context of this study, this quantification did not have a statistical or inferential purpose, but was used as a managerial decision-support tool, allowing the tangibilization of the potential economic consequences of documentary, fiscal, and governance failures associated with the enjoyment process of the Lei do Bem. The analysis focused on the events with the highest criticality, especially those with the potential to partially or fully compromise the fiscal benefit (PMI, 2021).
Quantitative scenarios were built based on realistic assumptions related to the total value of R&D expenditures, the expectation of tax benefit, and the estimated magnitude of losses arising from different adverse events. For example, a project with total R&D expenditure of R$ 1,500,000.00 and potential tax benefit of R$ 300,000.00, in the scenario of inadequate characterization of technological innovation (R1), resulted in a total loss of the benefit, estimated at R$ 300,000.00. The relevant divergence between technical documentation and expenditure calculation (R5) led to a partial disallowance of 30% of the benefit, with an estimated loss of R$ 90,000.00.
The inconsistency in filling out the FORMP&D (R8) resulted in an estimated additional internal cost of R$ 25,000.00 for technical-fiscal rework and documentary adjustment. The failure of traceability between deliverables and expenses (R7) led to a partial disallowance of 20% of the benefit, with an estimated loss of R$ 60,000.00. In contrast, the estimated cost for implementing preventive controls, such as a technical-fiscal checklist, an evidence repository, and an integrated validation routine, was R$ 18,000.00. These results reinforced that the process’s vulnerability lay not only in the execution of PD&I but also in the organization’s ability to convert innovative activity into technically robust and fiscally consistent documentation (MCTI, 2020; MCTI, 2023).
The plausibility of these quantitative scenarios was corroborated by documentary evidence from a real technical assessment by the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation. In a technical opinion of contestation, it was found that projects technically classifiable as R&D activities still received partial expenditure recommendation due to weaknesses in proof and linkage between materials, equipment, and the research developed. For example, in one project, the amount of R$ 33,826.75 for consumables was not accepted, and the full accelerated depreciation of R$ 3,326,997.20 was not recommended, due to a lack of clarity in the description and proof of exclusive use for R&D (MCTI, 2025).
This evidence reinforced the understanding that the recognition of the project’s technical merit, by itself, did not eliminate the risk of disallowance when documentary, fiscal, or traceability gaps persisted. The quantitative analysis showed that losses associated with proof failures were not restricted to hypothetical risk constructions but materialized in technically recognized projects. The comparison between potential losses and the estimated cost of implementing preventive controls highlighted a favorable relationship between prevention and avoided impact, justifying the investment in control and integration mechanisms (Kerzner, 2017; PMI, 2017).
Planning of Responses to Risks
The planning of responses to risks aimed to define, in a structured way, the necessary actions to address the prioritized risks in the previous stages, reducing their probability of occurrence, their potential impact, or both. In line with the PMBOK, this stage sought to select, for each critical risk, the most adequate response strategy among mitigate, avoid, transfer, or accept, according to its nature, criticality, and practical feasibility of implementation in the context of the Lei do Bem (PMI, 2017). Considering the profile of the identified risks, a predominance of mitigation strategies was observed, especially for events associated with weaknesses in governance, documentation, integration between areas, and process traceability.
The Risk Response Plan synthesized the adopted strategy and the main action planned for each critical risk identified. For inadequate characterization of technological innovation (R1), the strategy was to mitigate, with the action of reviewing the technical framework and standardizing the eligibility justification. The absence of proof of technological risk (R2) was mitigated by standardizing the registration of tests, hypotheses, and uncertainties. For non-contemporary technical evidence (R3), the response was to implement a continuous routine for recording and updating evidence. The lack of documentary version control (R4) was mitigated by the institution of formal versioning and standardization of documentary storage.
The inconsistency between technical reports and fiscal documentation (R5) was mitigated by performing cross-checking between the technical and fiscal areas. The inadequate classification of eligible expenditures (R6) was addressed by reviewing the eligibility criteria and fiscal-accounting reconciliation. The failure of traceability between deliverables and expenses (R7) was mitigated by linking expenditures to technical deliverables and supporting documents. The inconsistency in filling out the FORMP&D (R8) was mitigated by adopting a technical-fiscal checklist for review before submission. Non-compliance with regulatory deadlines (R9) was addressed with the strategy of avoidance, defining an internal schedule with review and monitoring milestones.
The low integration between technical, fiscal, and legal areas (R10) was mitigated by establishing cross-functional control points and alignment meetings. Interpretive or regulatory changes (R11) were accepted/monitored, with the action of monitoring regulatory updates and adjusting the dossier when necessary. Finally, the fragility in the final validation of the technical-fiscal dossier (R12) was mitigated by instituting a structured final review before submission. The planning of responses was guided by a predominantly preventive logic, focusing on mitigating the most critical risks through structured controls and validation routines, as most identified risks stemmed from procedural and documentary weaknesses (PMI, 2021; MCTI, 2023).
The planned responses were distributed throughout different moments of the project cycle, ranging from the initial technical framing phase to the final validation of the technical-fiscal dossier. The main triggers for activating these responses involved doubts regarding the project’s adherence to innovation criteria, absence of consistent technical evidence, discrepancies between technical documentation and fiscal assessment, traceability gaps, and approaching regulatory deadlines. This distribution reinforced that the treatment of risks, in the context of the Lei do Bem, depended on preventive and continuous action, and not just on documentary review at the end of the process.
The response plan also reinforced the need for cross-functional integration as a central element of mitigation. Several risks, especially those related to inconsistency between technical and fiscal information, expenditure traceability, and the completion of the R&D FORM, were not adequately addressed by a single area. The planned response sought to distribute responsibilities and create shared validation points, reducing the risk of process fragmentation and increasing the coherence of the technical-fiscal dossier. This result corroborates the perception that the effectiveness of the incentive depended not only on the quality of innovation but also on the organizational capacity to coordinate technical, fiscal, and regulatory knowledge (Souza and Martins, 2020; MCTI, 2020).
Implementation of Risk Responses
The implementation of risk responses corresponded to the stage where previously planned actions were converted into operational control and governance mechanisms applicable to the project flow. This implementation was not treated merely as the formal execution of measures defined in the plan, but as the practical incorporation of routines capable of reducing the probability of risks occurring and increasing the consistency of the process of leveraging the Lei do Bem. In accordance with the PMBOK, this stage sought to ensure that the responses ceased to be managerial intentions and began to produce concrete effects on the risk treatment of identified risks (PMI, 2021).
The main controls implemented for risk treatment included a technical-fiscal dossier checklist, aimed at verifying the consistency between technical and fiscal documentation and accessory obligations, generating a completed and validated checklist as evidence. A centralized repository with version control was established to ensure document traceability and file integrity, producing a version history and update records. A routine for contemporary registration of evidence ensured the continuous recording of R&D activities, generating dated and organized records.
The technical-fiscal cross-review was implemented to validate the alignment between technical deliverables and eligible expenditures, resulting in a reconciled review and version record. A traceability matrix between deliverables and expenses was created to link eligible expenditures to activities and deliverables, generating an updated traceability matrix. An internal regulatory milestones schedule was defined to avoid missing deadlines and prepare the claim, with evidence of monitoring and records. The final structured review of the dossier validated the technical, documentary, and fiscal integrity, generating a formal record of final validation. The monitoring of regulatory updates identified regulatory changes with potential impact, producing a record of regulatory update.
The implementation of the responses resulted in the creation of a set of controls distributed across different stages of the process, with a predominant focus on prevention, validation, and traceability. Most of the implemented controls were associated with the reduction of documentary and fiscal vulnerabilities, which proved consistent with the criticality profile revealed in the identification and qualitative analysis stages. Controls such as the technical-fiscal checklist, cross-departmental review, and the traceability matrix directly addressed the most relevant risks identified, demonstrating adherence between the response plan and its operational execution.
These controls were applied at different times in the project cycle, ranging from the execution of R&D activities to the final consolidation of the technical-fiscal dossier and the submission of the claim. Some of them assumed a continuous character, such as the repository with version control and the routine of contemporary evidence registration, while others focused on critical stages, such as the technical-fiscal cross-review, the final validation of the dossier, and the monitoring of regulatory milestones. This distribution reinforced that the implementation of the responses was not restricted to the punctual adoption of corrective measures, but corresponded to the incorporation of permanent mechanisms for prevention, validation, and traceability throughout the entire process.
The implemented controls were not restricted to a single functional area, but reinforced the interdependent nature of the Lei do Bem process. The presence of mechanisms that required interaction between technical, fiscal, compliance, and project management areas demonstrated that the implementation of responses was structured to reduce organizational fragmentation and increase the consistency of the claim as a whole. This finding aligns with studies that point to low integration between functions as one of the main vulnerability factors in the use of tax incentives for innovation (Souza and Martins, 2020; MCTI, 2023). Additionally, linking each control to generated evidence strengthened the auditability of the process and allowed for concrete demonstration that risk treatment was effectively put into practice, generating verifiable records (PMI, 2017; Kerzner, 2017).
Risk Monitoring
Risk monitoring constituted the final stage of the risk management cycle and aimed to ensure continuous tracking of identified events, updating their status, and verifying the effectiveness of the implemented responses throughout the process. In the context of this study, monitoring was structured as a periodic review mechanism of the risk register, allowing for the re-evaluation of probability and impact, verification of the permanence or reduction of exposure, and incorporation of emerging risks arising from internal or external changes to the project environment. In accordance with the PMBOK, this stage was conceived as an iterative process, aimed at maintaining project control and predictability throughout its entire lifecycle (PMI, 2021).
The risk monitoring dashboard synthesized the current status of events, the observed trend, and ongoing actions for their treatment. Risks such as inadequate characterization of technological innovation (R1), inconsistency between technical reports and fiscal documentation (R5), and low integration between technical, fiscal, and legal areas (R10) remained under treatment with a stable trend, requiring continuous review of the technical framework and cross-functional alignment meetings. Other risks, such as the absence of technological risk evidence (R2), non-contemporary technical evidence (R3), and failure of traceability between deliverables and expenses (R7), showed a downward trend due to actions for standardizing experimentation records, routine repository updates, and traceability matrix updates, respectively.
Risks such as the lack of documentary version control (R4), inadequate classification of eligible expenses (R6), and inconsistency in filling out the FORMP&D (R8) were monitored with a stable or decreasing trend, with actions such as implementing a formal documentary versioning routine, accounting-tax reconciliation, and applying a technical-tax checklist. Non-compliance with regulatory deadlines (R9) was monitored with a low trend, through internal schedule monitoring. Interpretive or normative changes (R11) were monitored with a variable trend, requiring regulatory monitoring, and fragility in the final validation of the technical-tax dossier (R12) was monitored with a decreasing trend, through structured final review.
The monitoring of risks was structured with a focus not only on the status but also on the evolution trend of each event, allowing an understanding of whether the risk was reduced, remained stable, or required greater managerial attention. In R&D projects linked to the Lei do Bem, this reading was particularly important, as documentary and fiscal risks were not automatically eliminated with the implementation of controls and demanded follow-up to confirm the effectiveness of the adopted responses (PMI, 2017; ABNT, 2018). Risks classified as under treatment concentrated on sensitive points of integration between technical documentation, proof of technological risk, and fiscal consistency, reinforcing the centrality of these factors in the success of the claim (MCTI, 2023).
The monitoring was not limited to the control function, but also acted as an organizational learning instrument. By associating the evolution of risks with the evidence produced and periodic reviews, the process allowed for the identification of fragility patterns, the improvement of mechanisms, and the strengthening of future cycles of planning and risk treatment. Monitoring consolidated itself as an essential step to sustain governance, close the risk management cycle, and reinforce the practical viability of the proposed model for the context of the Lei do Bem (Kerzner, 2017; PMI, 2017).
In summary, the systematic and integrated application of risk management, according to PMBOK guidelines and adapted to the requirements of the Lei do Bem (Law of Good), has proven to be an effective managerial tool for increasing predictability, strengthening regulatory compliance, and enhancing the governance of R&D claims. Risk management structured the incentivized innovation process more coherently and audibly, aligning technical objectives with documentary and fiscal requirements. The findings reinforced that the effectiveness of the Lei do Bem depended on the organizational capacity to structure, record, control, and prove innovation projects, integrating technical, documentary, fiscal, and organizational dimensions to qualify the use of the tax incentive.
4. Conclusion
The present study aimed to develop a risk management plan for Research, Development, and Innovation (RD&I) projects framed by the Lei do Bem, based on the guidelines of the PMBOK (6th edition). It was found that the systematic application of the seven risk management processes revealed significant governance weaknesses, particularly in technical documentation, traceability of eligible expenditures, and integration between the technical, tax, and legal areas. The construction and implementation of the risk management plan, with its predominantly preventive mitigation strategies, resulted in notable improvements in project structuring, predictability of results, and mitigation of fiscal and documentary risks. This structured approach strengthened the governance of innovation projects and qualified the interaction of companies with the instruments of Brazilian public policy promotion, demonstrating the capacity to convert technological uncertainty into a more coherent and auditable process.
The main contribution of this work lies in the development of a managerial model that integrates the technical, documentary, fiscal, and organizational dimensions, enhancing regulatory compliance and legal certainty in the use of the Lei do Bem (Law of Good). It was observed that the effectiveness of the tax incentive depends not only on technological merit but also on organizational maturity in structuring, registering, and proving innovation projects. However, the results stemmed from an analytical construction based on realistic scenarios, which restricts the empirical generalization of the findings. For future research, it is recommended to apply the risk management plan in real case studies, involving companies of different sizes and sectors, in order to empirically validate its effects on the reduction of disallowances, the mitigation of tax liabilities, and the improvement of governance in innovation projects.
Bibliographic References
Associação Brasileira de Normas Técnicas [ABNT]. 2018. NBR ISO 31000: Gestão de riscos – Diretrizes. ABNT, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Brasil. 2005. Lei nº 11.196, de 21 de novembro de 2005. Dispõe sobre incentivos à inovação e à pesquisa científica e tecnológica no ambiente produtivo. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 22 nov. 2005. Seção 1, p. 1.
Brasil. 2006. Decreto nº 5.798, de 7 de junho de 2006. Regulamenta os incentivos fiscais à inovação tecnológica de que tratam os arts. 17 a 26 da Lei nº 11.196, de 21 de novembro de 2005. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 8 jun. 2006. Seção 1, p. 2.
Calzolaio, Α.Ε.; Dathein, R. 2012. Política fiscal de incentivo à inovação: uma avaliação da Lei do Bem. Revista de Economia Contemporânea 16(2): 275-302.
Flick, U. 2009. Introdução à pesquisa qualitativa. 3ed. Artmed, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Guimarães, E.A. 2006. Políticas de inovação: financiamento e incentivos fiscais. Texto para Discussão. Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada [IPEA], Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Kerzner, H. 2017. Gestão de projetos: as melhores práticas. 3ed. Bookman, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Ministério da Ciência, Tecnologia e Inovação [MCTI]. 2020. Manual para utilização dos incentivos fiscais à inovação tecnológica – Lei do Bem. Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Ministério da Ciência, Tecnologia e Inovação [MCTI]. 2023. Relatório Anual da Lei do Bem – Consolidação das Informações. Disponível em: <https://www.gov.br/mcti/lei-do-bem>. Acesso em: 10 jan. 2026.
Ministério da Ciência, Tecnologia e Inovação [MCTI]. 2025. Parecer Técnico da Contestação n° 25.844/2025. Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Moreira Filho, J.R. 2013. Incentivos fiscais à inovação tecnológica: análise da Lei do Bem e seus efeitos sobre o investimento privado em P&D. Dissertação de Mestrado em Economia. Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development [OECD]. 2013. Frascati manual: guidelines for collecting and reporting data on research and experimental development. OECD Publishing, Paris, França.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development [OECD]. 2015. Innovation policies for inclusive growth. OECD Publishing, Paris, França.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development [OECD]. 2018. Oslo manual: guidelines for collecting, reporting and using data on innovation. 4ed. OECD Publishing, Paris, França.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2017. Um guia do conhecimento em gerenciamento de projetos – Guia PMBOK. 6ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2021. Um guia do conhecimento em gerenciamento de projetos – Guia PMBOK. 7ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Souza, D.L.; Martins, C.H. 2020. Barreiras à utilização dos incentivos fiscais à inovação no Brasil: uma análise à luz da Lei do Bem. Revista Brasileira de Gestão e Inovação 8(2): 45-62.
Yin, R.K. 2015. Estudo de caso: planejamento e métodos. 5ed. Bookman, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform