Strategy
People Management
June 14, 2024
Opportunity cost and leadership behaviors
The most effective decisions are made when a group of people is involved in a co-creation environment
A fundamental concept in economics and finance, called “opportunity cost”, is often misunderstood by common sense, meaning to take advantage of a unique offer or opportunity to acquire a certain product or service. On the contrary, opportunity cost basically implies a renunciation, that is, it involves a choice we make instead of another.

With this, understanding that an optimal choice, for example, results in the selection of the best option among other good choices, one ends up renouncing the other opportunities. A consumer who buys one good instead of another has incurred an opportunity cost, as they ended up losing the potential benefit of the forgone alternative when making the decision for the other good.
McRae (1970), in his article titled “Opportunity and incremental cost: an attempt at definition in systemic terms”, explains that the mechanism for measuring this cost is vague. In this sense, defining it as “the gains that could have been obtained if the available resource had been applied to another equally advantageous good, service, or productive capacity” may be an option.
Citing authors who address this nomenclature, McRae understands that one of the best definitions of opportunity cost is the following: “The cost of choosing one course of action over another can be expressed in terms of the opportunity that is lost or sacrificed by giving up the second alternative”. The author is emphatic in stating that, if the alternative is a project, this option will only be sacrificed if identical resources cannot be acquired, as opportunity cost involves a comparison between the chosen option and the one that was rejected.
Watts (2008) focuses on this “cost” at two points; first, when mentioning that opportunity cost is “simply another way of determining the true cost and total cost of any activity or action, considering the value of the second-best alternative that was negotiated or abandoned during the selection of the chosen alternative”; later, the author returns to the subject, stating that economists are not concerned with the expense or disbursement of something, but with the efficient use of resources, which means that this cost must be analyzed in light of what could have been obtained with the same expenditure of resources.
An example given by the author makes this “cost” debate clearer: if a person chooses to buy a R$10 whole wheat bread, what other products could they have bought with the same amount, such as an oat bread or tortillas, with their limited resources, if they had not decided to buy the whole wheat bread?
Let us then imagine that the decision involves something more complex, without an established monetary value, such as the resource of “time”. When a student decides to spend their entire Saturday at the beach or, conversely, studying for a test, there is a very real cost, even if no monetary value changes hands. In this specific case, the opportunity cost would be how each person determines daily how they will use the “limited resource of their time” (Watts, 2008).
Bringing these concepts to the area of people management, more precisely to the leaderships of organizations, how many project decisions are made daily, followed by several choices made to the detriment of others and which, in the short and medium term, one realizes that the cost of these choices was much higher than any benefit they may have initially brought? Furthermore, with the consideration of opportunity cost, there is a risk of realizing that, in the end, profit margins from processes may be achieved well below expectations regarding financial aspects and organizational climate, among others.

It is important to remember that the most effective decisions are made when a group of people is involved in a co-creation environment, where it is possible to offer and exchange ideas and calmly accept a colleague’s idea because it seems to be the best option at that moment. This environment of constant dialogues, clear, participatory, and transparent communication should be encouraged by leadership that truly listens to its team and truly believes that people can achieve better results and make more assertive decisions together.
When several parties in a working group are consulted, decisions are made collegially, bringing more clarity about the renunciations of choices. And these renunciations, in the context of people management, involve not only monetary aspects but also those related to emotions and behaviors.
Richard Barrett, a researcher and leadership expert, wrote a highly relevant book titled “Organization Driven by Values: Unleashing Human Potential for Performance and Profitability”. In the work, the author draws an analogy between a term from thermodynamics called “entropy” and organizations. He describes the “degree of dysfunction of an organization or any human group structure (community or nation) with the term “cultural entropy”, which would be generated by the selfish actions of leaders based on their fears – just as, in thermodynamics, entropy indicates the degree of disorder of a physical system.
These fears involve excessive caution, difficulty trusting others, risk aversion, environmental manipulation, authoritarianism, among others. Barrett states that the greater the cultural entropy, the lower the level of trust and cohesion of teams; he is emphatic in saying that, to gain trust, “leaders need to act with authenticity and live with integrity. They must show that they truly care about their employees and the common good” (Barrett, 2017).
Leaders need to change their discourse from “me” to “us”, from “what’s in it for me” to “what is best for the common good”, in addition to changing the vision from “being the best in the world” to “being the best for the world” (Barrett, 2017), fostering an environment of dialogue, exchange, and co-creation. Leaders will need to put the organization’s interests ahead of their own, as egocentric leaders can be one of the biggest inhibitors of a team’s sustainable results.
Returning to the concept of opportunity cost, it is verified that more assertive and higher quality decisions can be made when several actors are consulted, thus enabling diverse points of view and perspectives of financial, temporal, affective losses and expenses, among others to be duly weighed. Ethics, transparency, cohesive discourses and practices, as well as participatory leadership can, therefore, positively impact the opportunity costs involved in project decision-making.
Who wrote this column
Denise de Moura








