April 22, 2026
Value Management in Sugarcane Ethanol Projects
Estevão Henrique Rodrigues De Souza; Gleison De Souza
Summary prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
The sugarcane-ethanol sector holds a strategic position in both the Brazilian and global scenarios, playing a fundamental role in the production of sugar, ethanol, and bioelectricity. Brazil consolidates itself as the largest global producer of sugarcane, responsible for over 20% of the world’s sugar production and approximately 50% of global exports of this product, which reinforces the importance of operational efficiency for food security and the agricultural trade balance (UNICA, 2023). Beyond its economic relevance, the national sugarcane-ethanol industry is a pioneer in the large-scale use of ethanol as a biofuel, representing one of the main sustainable alternatives for the transportation matrix, with a direct impact on reducing greenhouse gas emissions, in full alignment with global decarbonization goals (IEA, 2021). Bioelectricity generated from sugarcane bagasse complements the country’s renewable electricity matrix, highlighting Brazilian experience as a model for integration between agribusiness and clean energy. In this environment of high competitiveness and technical demands, project management emerges as a critical discipline to ensure that industrial interventions occur without compromising crop productivity.
Schedule management constitutes one of the central pillars of project administration and is essential for the success of predominantly predictive endeavors (PMI, 2017). This knowledge area aims to organize and structure all activities and work packages necessary to ensure that goals are met within determined deadlines. According to the guidelines established in the best practices guide for management, schedule control comprises fundamental processes such as defining activities, logical sequencing, estimating durations, and developing a solid basis for performance monitoring (PMI, 2021). The rigorous application of these practices improves predictability and mitigates uncertainties, especially in industrial environments characterized by severe time constraints and high technical complexity. Effective time management, supported by consolidated techniques such as the critical path method and earned value analysis, is decisive for delivering projects with quality and meeting stakeholder expectations (Kerzner, 2017).
In sugarcane-ethanol mills, schedule management faces significant challenges due to the intrinsic complexity of the production process, which combines continuous operations of milling, distillation, energy cogeneration, and storage. Such processes require precise coordination between mechanical, electrical, and automation specialties (Ferreira and Pires, 2019). The execution of maintenance and renovations is strongly limited to the off-season period, which defines fixed time windows for carrying out critical interventions. This temporal limitation increases pressure on meeting deadlines and on the efficient allocation of resources (Kerzner, 2017). Integration between planning, supervision, and execution is vital, as any schedule deviation can generate direct impacts on equipment availability and overall plant reliability for the subsequent harvest. Given this scenario, the application of Earned Value indicators, such as the Schedule Performance Index and the Cost Performance Index, allows for monitoring actual progress against the plan, identifying deviations early, and adopting timely corrective actions (PMI, 2021).
The concept of earned value management systematically integrates project scope, schedule, and cost, offering a quantitative approach that overcomes the limitations of traditional monitoring based solely on completion percentages (PMI, 2021). While the conventional method can be subjective, performance indicators provide reliable metrics for communication with managers and reinforce institutional governance. The Schedule Performance Index is an efficiency ratio that measures the degree of adherence to the original schedule; a result greater than 1.0 indicates that physical progress is ahead of schedule, while a value less than 1.0 signals delays. In parallel, the Cost Performance Index measures financial efficiency, comparing the value of work actually performed with the actual cost incurred (PMI, 2017). Trend analysis based on these indicators allows for predicting future performance and correcting anomalies during execution, ensuring that maintenance and renovations are completed with maximum operational efficiency. The objective of this study is to evaluate the application of these indicators in a heat exchanger implementation project, verifying whether the methodology adds greater predictability and agility to decision-making compared to the traditional method.
The methodology applied for the analysis was based on a case study conducted during the implementation of two shell-and-tube heat exchangers in a medium-sized industrial unit located in the interior of the state of São Paulo. The plant in question has an installed capacity for processing 2.6 million tons of sugarcane per harvest, with an average production of 3.8 million bags of VHP sugar and 145 million liters of ethanol (hydrated, anhydrous, and Grade B). The project was identified as a priority opportunity within the unit’s operational improvement program. The monitoring of activities occurred during the 2024/2025 off-season, initially using the unit’s conventional methodology, based on weekly updates of completion percentages, and subsequently applying the concepts of earned value management for evaluation and comparison of effectiveness.
For data collection, routine weekly progress meetings were held every Monday morning. In these meetings, the main bottlenecks observed in the previous week, points of attention, and critical activities for the subsequent week were discussed. This process was essential for obtaining complementary information that is not always included in formal documents. Additionally, a record of lessons learned throughout the project’s entire lifecycle was used, covering the conception, procurement, and planning stages, as per the recommendations of the project management guide (PMI, 2021). Planning and control data were processed with the aid of MS Project and Excel software, ensuring precision and accuracy in indicator calculations.
The survey of applied costs was carried out through the SAP integrated management system, where all material transactions, stock allocations, and labor contracts are recorded. This data was compiled in accordance with the schedule task references, allowing for the establishment of a baseline for planned value and its cross-referencing with actual cost and earned value. The unit adopts a strict change management policy, which requires documentary formalization of all physical, operational, and safety impacts arising from the project. This evaluation is conducted by a multidisciplinary team composed of professionals from the production, maintenance, conceptual engineering, and occupational safety areas. The synergy between these teams is fundamental for mitigating financial and temporal risks, especially in highly complex industrial environments (Silva, 2021).
The detailed schedule for the execution of activities covered a total period of 25 weeks, from the premise survey and conceptual design development to final testing and commissioning. The baseline was formalized through an S-curve, which is the corporate standard used for discussing physical progress in weekly meetings. However, it was observed that the unit’s common practice did not include the detailed specification of resources required for each stage, which can compromise the robustness of management in complex activities involving multiple professionals and equipment (PMI, 2017). To address this gap, schedule and cost performance indicators were experimentally applied throughout the execution, allowing for a deeper analysis of the variations between planned and actual performance.
The results obtained revealed that the project was delayed for most of its lifecycle. Detailed analysis of physical progress showed that between weeks 04 and 06, there was a slight deviation due to delays in the delivery of conceptual and isometric drawings required for assembly. This initial delay impacted the logical sequence of subsequent activities. Between weeks 07 and 09, the delay was extended by difficulties faced by the supply sector in negotiating the hiring of services and in acquiring steel materials, valves, and accessories. Only in week 10 was there a temporary alignment with the planned schedule, driven by the speed of the contracted supplier for manufacturing and by the progress in disassembly and interference removal activities in the field.
From week 11 onwards, the project again showed a sustained delay, mainly due to the existence of overlapping work in some service fronts. The group adopts a safety policy that requires complementary analyses when two or more teams operate on different floor levels in the same area, aiming to mitigate the risk of falling materials and tools (Silva, 2021). Although this practice is essential for accident prevention, it imposes restrictions on the execution pace. In week 15, an aggravation of the delay was observed due to a failure in the assembly planning, which did not foresee the need to rent a mobile elevating work platform for certain interventions at height. Furthermore, the need for partial replacement of the existing metal structure to support the new piping sections was identified, which was not included in the original scope.
Given the persistence of deviations, the unit management decided, in week 22, to increase the assembly team’s workforce. This decision was made late, as the schedule’s flexibility margin was only one week in relation to the final deadline for the off-season completion. In the final weeks, specifically between weeks 23 and 25, leak tests and commissioning were carried out. During this process, leaks were evident in some valve connections, requiring immediate rework. After the non-conformities were resolved, the new tests were approved and the technical delivery was formalized. Despite the setbacks, safety management was considered effective, as there were no registered accidents involving people or material damage, proving the efficiency of the established preventive measures (Silva, 2021).
The application of the Schedule Performance Index confirmed the perceptions gathered in the weekly meetings, but with superior quantitative precision. The indicator started the project at 1.00, but dropped to 0.75 in week 04, reflecting the delay in conceptual projects. There was a gradual recovery until it reached 1.00 again in week 10, followed by a new drop that stabilized around 0.92 and 0.95 during the most critical phase of assembly. In week 22, the index was 0.93, and only in week 25, with the completion of all pending issues, did the value return to 1.00. This oscillation shows that traditional monitoring by completion percentages often masks the severity of delays, while the Schedule Performance Index immediately highlights the loss of temporal efficiency.
Regarding costs, the Cost Performance Index showed initially favorable results, remaining above 1.00 until week 16. This indicated that the actual cost incurred was below the value added for the work performed. However, from week 17 onwards, the indicator began to decline, reaching 0.92 in week 22. This drop was the direct result of unforeseen additional costs, such as the emergency rental of the elevating platform and the increase in labor to accelerate assembly in the final stretch. The final project cost exceeded the initial budget by approximately 10%, a variation considered acceptable for medium-complexity interventions in an industrial environment, but which could have been mitigated if the indicators had been used for earlier proactive decisions.
The discussion of the results indicates that the detailing of field assembly activities was insufficient. Items such as disassembly of interferences, piping assembly, and system interconnection were treated as macro packages, which hindered the individualized management of critical subtasks. The guidance from the corporate engineering team suggests that work packages should have durations between 0.5 and 10 business days to allow for more assertive control. The lack of foresight regarding the lifting platform and the need for structural reinforcement highlight flaws in the conceptual development of the demand, which could have been identified through more rigorous technical inspections during the planning phase. The decision to increase the team only in week 22 demonstrates a reactive approach, confirming that the vision provided by the traditional monitoring method is limited (Kerzner, 2017).
The integration of the scope, schedule, and cost pillars through the earned value methodology contributes to greater visibility of project governance, providing robust information for managers and assisting in facing the challenges of the sugar-alcohol sector. The fixed off-season window does not allow for significant schedule extensions, making early trend detection a crucial competitive advantage. Experience has shown that, although the final cost was higher than expected and the schedule was extended by two weeks, the use of indicators allowed for a clear understanding of where the failures occurred, generating valuable lessons learned for future projects of a similar nature (Kerzner, 2018). It is recommended that the application of this methodology be expanded to all capital investment projects of the group, consolidating it as a strategic tool to increase operational reliability and efficiency.
It is concluded that the objective was achieved, as the application of Earned Value Analysis (EVA) indicators proved superior to the traditional schedule monitoring method, providing a quantitative and early view of schedule and cost deviations. The use of the Schedule Performance Index and the Cost Performance Index allowed for the identification that the main causes of delays and cost overruns were related to flaws in conceptual planning and resource estimation, such as the absence of lifting equipment and the need for unforeseen structural reinforcements. The study showed that reactive management, based solely on completion percentages, delays critical decision-making, while the earned value methodology offers the necessary predictability for interventions within restricted windows such as the sugar-alcohol off-season. The effectiveness of safety management and the absence of accidents reinforced the project’s operational feasibility, despite the technical challenges faced. Therefore, the systematic adoption of these indicators is recommended to elevate the level of governance and efficiency in the execution of complex industrial projects.
Bibliographic References:
Ferreira, T.S.; Pires, S.R.I. 2019. Gestão de manutenção em indústrias de processo: desafios e práticas em ambientes de alta complexidade. Gestão & Produção 26(3): 1-14.
International Energy Agency [IEA]. 2021. Renewables 2021: Analysis and forecast to 2026. IEA. Paris, França.
Kerzner, H. 2017. Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling, and Controlling. 12ed. Wiley, Hoboken.
Kerzner, H. 2018. Melhores práticas de gerenciamento de projetos: Alcançando excelência global. John Wiley & Sons.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2017. Um guia do conhecimento em gerenciamento de projetos. 6ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2021. Um guia do conhecimento em gerenciamento de projetos. 7ed. Project Management Institute, Pennsylvania, EUA.
Silva, R.A.L. 2021. Gerenciamento da Manutenção correlacionada à Eficiência da Segurança. Revista Científica e-Locução 1(20): 21-21.
Brazilian Sugarcane Industry Association [ÚNICA]. 2023. Annual Report 2023. UNICA. São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
Executive summary from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform