October 19, 2026
Use of medical forms: information quality, utility, and skill development
Use of Medical Forms: Information Quality, Utility, and Skill Development
Rafaela Mari Turra; Ana Paula Pereira dos Passos
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601336
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
The judicialization of health in Brazil, driven by the pursuit of the constitutional right to health and failures in public and private systems, requires consistent technical and legal criteria for judicial decisions. The perception of physicians from a Technical Support Unit of the Judiciary (NatJus) regarding the quality of patient health information, perceived usefulness, and the development of skills associated with the use of forms created by the Executive Committee on Health of the National Council of Justice (CNJ) was analyzed. A quantitative and descriptive approach was employed, with primary data collection through a questionnaire applied to nine physicians from a NatJus who used the forms. The results indicated that the medical forms were relevant for understanding clinical cases and for collaborative work among peers, promoting discussion and improvement of technical notes. High satisfaction was observed with the standardization and clarity of the forms, which streamlined the work of NatJus. However, limitations were identified in expanding knowledge in areas such as medical guidelines and public policies, and weaknesses in the instructions for completion. It was concluded that, despite the effectiveness of the forms in qualifying information and speeding up the process, their full integration requires greater engagement from the judiciary and improvement of instructions for assisting physicians, consolidating them as a pedagogical tool for judicial decisions in health.
Keywords: Right to health; Public health management; Clinical protocols; Judicial decision-making.
1. Introduction
The judicialization of health in Brazil represents a complex and multifaceted phenomenon, driven by the pursuit of the constitutional right to health and by failures in the provision of services in the public and private systems (Carvalho et al., 2020; Shulze and Neto, 2019). The growing judicial demand for access to medicines, procedures, and medical technologies has generated a significant impact on public policies and health management. Recent data, such as that from the e-NatJus platform, indicate that, in 2020-2022, the average cost per case was R$ 1,312.74, with a total saving of R$ 111.4 million for the Unified Health System (SUS), underscoring the importance of well-founded judicial decisions (Correia et al., 2025). This scenario requires legal operators to carefully analyze judicial actions in health, seeking more consistent technical and legal criteria (Neto, 2000).
The complexity of judicialization is aggravated by informational asymmetry and the need to establish robust technical and legal criteria for decision-making. The Judiciary, when intervening to correct deviations and omissions, must balance judicial activism with self-restraint, avoiding abuses and decisionism (Cleve, 2011; Streck, 2011). The influence of actors such as the pharmaceutical and medical equipment industry in the formulation of judicial demands requires critical analysis, which must be guided by evidence-based medicine and by clinical protocols and therapeutic guidelines, which have legal status (Law No. 12.401/2011) and are essential for rationalizing decisions (Campos Neto et al., 2018; Freitas et al., 2020). In this context, the National Council of Justice (CNJ) established the Technical Support Units of the Judiciary (NatJus), according to Resolution No. 479/2022, composed of professionals with expertise in health and public policies (CNJ, 2022). These units issue technical notes that support judicial decisions, and the standardization of information is crucial for the effectiveness of their work.
The CNJ’s initiative to develop standardized medical forms to qualify information in judicial proceedings represents a significant advancement. These forms aim to structure clinical data, facilitating case comprehension and action planning for the development of professionals’ competencies and skills (Pierre, 2007). The effectiveness of these tools is intrinsically linked to the concepts of organizational and situated learning, where knowledge is constructed through informal interactions and practical experiences (D’Arisbo et al., 2014; Gudolle et al., 2012). The continuous use of the forms, therefore, not only aids in information recording but also mobilizes and enhances physicians’ knowledge, developing essential skills for clinical analysis and the qualification of technical notes (Moraes and Borges-Andrade, 2010; Moura et al., 2019). The perception of usefulness and ease of use of these instruments is a determining factor for their acceptance and integration into professionals’ routines, directly influencing engagement and performance (Davis, 1989; Delone and Mclean, 2003). The relevance of the role played by NatJus physicians in qualifying health information and its direct impact on judicial decision-making justifies in-depth investigation of their perception of these instruments.
This study, therefore, is justified by the need to understand how the medical forms developed by the Executive Committee on Health of the CNJ contribute to improving the quality of health information and the development of skills of the professionals who use them, in a context of increasing judicialization. The general objective of this work is to analyze the perception of doctors from a Technical Support Unit of the Judiciary (NatJus) regarding the quality of patient health information, the perceived utility, and the development of skills associated with the use of the forms created by the Executive Committee on Health of the National Council of Justice (CNJ).
2. Material and Methods
This study adopted a quantitative, descriptive approach to investigate physicians’ perception of the use of forms. The research was based on the collection of primary data, carried out through the application of a closed questionnaire. This methodology allowed for the systematic analysis of variables and the identification of patterns in the responses, providing a structured view of the phenomenon studied, according to the principles of quantitative research (Martins and Theóphilo, 2009).
The study was conducted in a specific Technical Support Unit for the Judiciary (NatJus), linked to a Court of Justice in the state of Paraná, Brazil. This NatJus, according to Resolution No. 479/2022 of the National Council of Justice (CNJ, 2022), is composed of professionals with expertise in health and public policies, whose work is fundamental to support judicial decisions. Data collection occurred between January 14 and February 15, 2026, covering a period of approximately one month for obtaining the necessary information.
The target population consisted of 11 (eleven) physicians who were part of the selected NatJus team. The sample was defined as non-probabilistic by convenience, including physicians who used or had previously used the medical form of the Paranaense Health Committee in the preparation of technical notes for legal actions. To participate, professionals had to voluntarily agree to the research. Of the eleven eligible physicians, nine effectively participated in the study, while two were unwilling to collaborate, resulting in a response rate of 81.8%.
The data collection instrument was a closed questionnaire, structured in three distinct blocks, as detailed in Appendix A of the original work. The first block was dedicated to collecting sociodemographic and professional information from the participants. This segment included questions about the year of graduation in medicine, medical specialty, affiliation with the Court of Justice, experience with the CNJ medical forms, and time of practice in NatJus, as well as training in evidence-based medicine.
The second block of the questionnaire employed a scale adapted from Miles et al. (1986) and Jennings (2002), translated and validated by Butzke and Alberton (2017). This scale was designed to assess physicians’ perception of skill acquisition resulting from the use of forms for the judicialization of public health. Covering 13 questions, the scale explored three main factors: Problem Solving, Teamwork, and Professional Development. Responses were collected using a seven-point Likert scale, ranging from one (Helps little) to seven (Helps a lot).
The third part of the instrument was developed based on Ramos et al. (2013), with adaptations from Davis (1989) and Delone and Mclean (2003). Its purpose was to measure physicians’ perception of the qualification of the patient’s clinical data when using the standardized medical form by the CNJ Executive Health Committee in Paraná. This section contained 11 questions, distributed into three factors: Ease of use, Perceived usefulness, and Information quality. Similarly to the previous block, responses were recorded on a seven-point Likert scale, from one (Helps little) to seven (Helps a lot).
The complete structure of the questionnaire, including the blocks, evaluated factors, number of corresponding questions, and the theoretical bases of each scale, is presented in Table 1. This table synthesizes the organization of the instrument, facilitating the understanding of the investigated constructs and the origin of the methodological adaptations employed in the study, ensuring transparency about the construction of the tool.
Table 1. Questionnaire structure
|
Block |
Factors |
Issues |
Foundation |
|
Sociodemographic aspects |
Q1 to Q6 |
||
|
Learning from Medical Forms |
Problem Solving, Professional Training and Teamwork |
Q7 to Q19 |
Butzke and Alberton (2017) |
|
Medical forms as an instrument for improving technical notes |
Ease of use, Perceived Usefulness and Information Quality |
Q20 to Q30 |
Ramos et al. (2013) |
Source: Original survey data
The pre-test phase was conducted online, using the Google Forms platform, and disseminated via WhatsApp on January 14 and 15, 2026. Two volunteer physicians, who were not part of the main sample, participated in this stage. The objective was to verify the clarity and response time of the questionnaire. It was observed that the completion time was approximately 10 to 15 minutes, and two questions were revised to eliminate ambiguities and ensure greater understanding by future respondents, improving the quality of the collection.
The main data collection was initiated on January 16, 2026, and completed on February 15, 2026, also through an online questionnaire. To minimize response biases, such as the order effect or anchoring effect, the questions were presented in a randomized order, without following the organization by factors. This strategy aimed to ensure that participants responded to each item independently, without the influence of sequence or thematic grouping, contributing to the internal validity of the research.
To evaluate the internal consistency of the scales used in the questionnaire, Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient was applied, a widely recognized indicator for measuring the reliability of multi-item instruments (Bland and Altman, 1997). Cronbach’s Alpha values range from zero to one, with values closer to one indicating higher scale reliability. Values equal to or greater than 0.7 were adopted as acceptable, above 0.8 were considered good, and above 0.9 excellent (Martins and Theóphilo, 2009; Hair Jr. et al., 2007).
After collection, the raw data were tabulated and organized using Microsoft Excel® software. Data analysis was performed using descriptive statistics, which included calculating relative frequency, mean, and standard deviation for each item and factor of the scales. This approach allowed for the characterization of the participants’ profile and an objective description of their perceptions, without inferences about the population, aligning with the descriptive nature of the research.
The ethical procedures were rigorously observed, ensuring the protection of participants. The NatJus involved formalized their consent through a Term of Consent, authorizing the application of questionnaires and the use of data for academic purposes. The research ensured the anonymity of participants, not requesting personal information or any data that could identify them. All collected data were treated confidentially, aiming to preserve the safety and privacy of individuals, in accordance with ethical guidelines for research with human beings.
The methodological limitations of the study include the small population sample, composed of nine respondents out of a total of eleven eligible physicians. This characteristic may compromise the representativeness of the results and the ability to generalize to other contexts or NatJus. Furthermore, the homogeneity of the selected group, in terms of professional profile and experience, limited the feasibility of more complex data cross-referencing, allowing analyses only regarding belonging or not to the Judiciary Court staff, as explained in the final considerations.
3. Results and Discussion
This section presents the detailed research results, following a structure aimed at deepening the understanding of the findings and their implications. Initially, the sociodemographic profile of the respondents is described, providing context for subsequent analyses. Next, physicians’ perceptions regarding problem-solving, teamwork, professional training, ease of use, perceived usefulness, and information quality are analyzed, based on the obtained means and standard deviations. Subsequently, data cross-tabulation is performed to identify significant patterns and differences. Finally, the most relevant results are discussed in depth, proposing strategies and insights for decision-making within the scope of the Technical Support Unit of the Judiciary (NatJus).
Characterization of Respondents
The analysis of the sociodemographic profile of the participants is fundamental to contextualize the perceptions and experiences reported, as presented in Table 2. It is observed that the majority of physicians (66.7%) completed their medical degree between 1998 and 2007, indicating a group with consolidated professional experience. This longevity in the medical career suggests that the respondents possess a vast clinical background, which may influence their assessments of the complexity of judicial cases and the effectiveness of the forms. The experience accumulated over decades of clinical practice is a relevant factor, as physicians with longer practice tend to have a more critical and comprehensive view of work tools and processes, such as the medical forms of the Paranaense Health Committee. Professional maturity may, therefore, have contributed to a more balanced and well-founded evaluation of the instruments in question.
Table 2. Research Participants
|
Characteristic |
Option |
Frequency (Relative) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
1988 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
1992 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
1994 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
1998 |
2 (22,2%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
2001 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
2003 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
2005 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Year of graduation in medicine |
2007 |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
General surgery and pediatric surgery |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Occupational medicine and medical audit |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Pediatrics |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Family and Community Medicine |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Medical clinic, cardiology, forensic medicine and expertise |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Cardiology |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Pediatrics and intensive medicine |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Orthopedics |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Medical Specialty (if any) |
Psychiatry |
1 (11,1%) |
|
It belongs to the Court of Justice’s own framework |
Yes |
5 (55,6%) |
|
It belongs to the Court of Justice’s own framework |
No |
4 (44,4%) |
|
Used the medical forms of the CNJ’s Executive Committee for Health for public health lawsuits |
I used it for the preparation of a technical note |
8 (88,9%) |
|
Used the medical forms of the CNJ’s Executive Committee for Health for public health lawsuits |
I have never used |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Used the medical forms of the CNJ’s Executive Committee for Health for public health lawsuits |
I used it in another context |
0 (0%) |
|
Used the medical forms of the CNJ’s Executive Committee for Health for public health lawsuits |
I am unaware of the forms |
0 (0%) |
|
Experience in NatJus |
Does not work |
0 (0%) |
|
Experience in NatJus |
Works for less than 1 year |
1 (11,1%) |
|
Experience in NatJus |
Has been working for over 1 year |
8 (88,9%) |
|
Completed a course or training in evidence-based medicine |
Yes |
8 (88,9%) |
|
Completed a course or training in evidence-based medicine |
No |
1 (11,1%) |
Source: Original research results
The entirety of the respondents have medical specialization, with 36.36% having more than one specialty or subspecialty. The specialties of pediatrics and cardiology are repeated with equal frequency (22.2% each), denoting a diversity of areas of practice within NatJus. This multidisciplinarity is a crucial point, as the judicialization of health encompasses a varied range of clinical conditions, requiring specific knowledge in different fields of medicine. The presence of specialists in various areas, such as pediatrics, cardiology, occupational medicine, medical auditing, family and community medicine, internal medicine, forensic medicine, expertise, intensive care medicine, orthopedics, and psychiatry, reflects the complexity of judicial demands and the need for an integrated approach. The literature indicates that multidisciplinary teams tend to produce more robust and complete analyses, as different clinical and epidemiological perspectives are considered (Oliveira et al., 2015). The diversity of specialties, therefore, strengthens NatJus’s capacity to deal with the breadth of cases presented, although it may also generate challenges in standardizing understandings and technical communication.
Regarding the institutional link, the majority of respondents (55.6%) belong to the Judiciary’s own staff, while 44.4% do not. This distinction is relevant, as a formal link can influence the perception of job stability, engagement with internal policies, and familiarity with administrative procedures. Professionals with a direct link may feel more integrated into the judicial structure, which can translate into greater adherence to established tools and protocols. On the other hand, the presence of professionals without a direct link can bring a valuable external perspective, contributing experiences from other contexts and promoting a more critical view of internal practices. Almost all participants (88.9%) have worked at NatJus for over a year and have already used the Health Committee’s medical forms for legal actions. This data is fundamental, as it ensures that the sample is composed of experienced users of the forms, whose perceptions are based on real and continuous experiences. Practical experience with the tool is a prerequisite for an in-depth evaluation of its usefulness, ease of use, and impact on skill development.
Additionally, the dominant profile of the respondents (88.9%) has already completed some specific course or training in evidence-based medicine (EBM). This finding is of extreme importance, as EBM is a fundamental pillar for the qualification of health decisions, especially in the judicial context (Carvalho et al., 2024). EBM training enables physicians to critically evaluate scientific literature, integrate the best available evidence with clinical experience and patient values, resulting in more solid and justified recommendations. The high adherence to EBM among participants suggests that the NatJus in question values informed decision-making based on robust data, which is crucial for supporting the Judiciary in complex health matters. The absence of this training in only one respondent (11.1%) may indicate an area for continuous improvement, ensuring that all team members are aligned with best scientific practices. The integration of EBM with the use of standardized forms can, therefore, enhance the quality of technical notes and the consistency of judicial decisions.
Problem Solving
The physicians’ perception of how forms contribute to problem-solving is one of the central pillars of this study. The results indicate a strong appreciation for the forms’ ability to organize and condense clinical and therapeutic information, as evidenced by the high means of items 10 (6.44; SD = 0.73) and 9 (6.33; SD = 0.87). Item 10, which addresses the forms’ help in condensing and organizing information about treatments performed and the chronology of the clinical case, obtained the highest mean, suggesting that the standardization and structure of the forms are highly effective in optimizing information flow. This organization is crucial in a judicial context, where clarity and precision of data are imperative for making fair and informed decisions. The ability to synthesize a complex volume of clinical information into an accessible format is an undeniable practical benefit, aligning with the need for efficiency and objectivity in judicial processes (Moura et al., 2019).
Item 9, which refers to the support of forms in acquiring relevant information about the clinical history and therapies used, also presented a high average. This demonstrates that the forms not only organize existing data but also facilitate the identification and extraction of crucial information for understanding the case. The relevance of clinical and therapeutic history is unquestionable in medicine, and the standardized tool appears to optimize this process, allowing NatJus physicians to quickly access essential data for their analyses. This functionality is particularly valuable in an environment where time is a scarce resource and information accuracy can have significant consequences.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Chart of the percentage of Problem-solving items
On the other hand, items 7 and 11, both with a mean of 4.78 (SD = 2.64 and 1.86, respectively), presented the lowest means, indicating a more limited perception of the forms regarding the generation of new knowledge and the expansion of learning in broader areas, such as medical guidelines, public health policies, sanitary surveillance, and the pharmaceutical industry. Figure 1 illustrates this dispersion, with 33.33% of respondents indicating that the forms help in most cases for new knowledge, but a significant percentage (22.22% and 11.11%) perceive little help or help in few cases. This variation in responses suggests that, although the forms are efficient for organizing specific clinical case data, they may not be the most effective tool for promoting more comprehensive and contextualized learning.
This limitation can be attributed to the intrinsic nature of the forms, which are designed to collect standardized information focused on an individual case, rather than acting as platforms for continuing education or dissemination of knowledge in health policies. The literature on organizational learning (D’Arisbo et al., 2014; Gudolle et al., 2012) emphasizes that knowledge is constructed through informal interactions and individual experiences, and that learning at work occurs integrated into daily activities. Although forms facilitate the mobilization and redefinition of case-specific knowledge, they may not be the ideal vehicle for deepening the understanding of public health macro-themes. To fill this gap, it would be necessary to complement the use of forms with other strategies, such as case discussions, seminars, or access to databases and scientific publications that address health guidelines and policies more broadly. The need for improvement in this aspect is crucial for NatJus physicians to have a more holistic view of the health system and the implications of their technical notes.
Still regarding problem-solving, item 8, concerning the deepening of clinical and therapeutic content, obtained an average of 5.22 (SD = 1.86), with 55.56% of respondents indicating that the forms help a little above average and 33.33% that they help a lot. This suggests that, although the forms are useful for deepening clinical understanding, there is still room for improvement. The ability to identify problems related to SUS management and professional training (item 12, average of 5.00; SD = 2.24) also showed a disparate evaluation, with 44.44% understanding that the forms help a lot, but with significant percentages of responses at lower levels. This heterogeneity indicates that, for some doctors, the forms are a powerful tool for identifying bottlenecks in the healthcare system, while for others, this capacity still needs to be developed or improved. The practical implication is that the forms, although effective in organizing and condensing information, require educational and discussion complements to maximize their potential in generating new knowledge and identifying systemic problems. The integration of case discussions and the promotion of a collaborative learning environment can mitigate these limitations, transforming the forms into a catalyst for critical reflection and continuous improvement.
Professional Training
Regarding Professional Training, the results indicate that medical forms play a significant role, especially in the elaboration of technical notes, even when faced with incomplete clinical information. Although Table 9 is not explicitly presented in the provided material, the text describes its findings. Item 13, which addresses the assistance of forms in the elaboration of the technical note when faced with incomplete clinical information, obtained the highest average (5.89; SD = 1.05). This result is crucial, as it reflects the reality of judicial medical practice, where not all necessary information is always completely available. The ability of forms to guide the physician in structuring the technical note, even with partial data, demonstrates their utility as a tool for decision support and process standardization. Standardization, in this context, is vital to ensure the consistency and quality of technical notes, regardless of the initial completeness of the data (Moura et al., 2019).
Items 14, concerning assistance in reviewing and improving NatJus policies and practices, and 16, concerning the resolution of technical conflicts related to medical recommendations and judicial demands, presented equal averages of 5.56 (SD = 2.01). These findings suggest that the forms are not merely recording tools, but also instruments that foster critical reflection on existing practices and contribute to the resolution of ethical and technical dilemmas. The review of policies and practices is a continuous process in any healthcare organization, and the use of standardized forms can provide structured data to support this review. The ability to assist in resolving technical conflicts is particularly relevant in the judicial environment, where the interface between medicine and law frequently leads to impasses. The standardization of information through forms can thus reduce informational asymmetry and facilitate dialogue between healthcare professionals and the judiciary (Oliveira et al., 2015).
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Chart of the percentage of professional training items
The lowest average was observed in item 15 (4.89; SD = 2.09), which questions whether the forms increase the physician’s confidence in performing technical analyses independently. Figure 2 details this perception, showing that although 22.22% of participants understand that the forms greatly help increase confidence, there is considerable dispersion, with 33.33% indicating they help in most cases, 11.11% a little above average, and another 11.11% that they help little. This heterogeneity suggests that, for some physicians, the tool does not yet confer full autonomy or security for independent analyses. This result may be related to the complexity of the cases and the need for peer validation or in-depth knowledge in specific areas that the forms, by themselves, cannot provide. The literature on informal on-the-job learning (Antonello, 2007; Camillis and Antonello, 2010; Coelho and Mourão, 2011; Vieira et al., 2009) highlights that confidence and skill acquisition are often built through social interactions and reflection on practice, not just by using tools.
The practical implication of this finding is that, to maximize the potential of the forms in professional training and in increasing confidence, it is essential to complement their use with strategies that promote dialogue, case discussion, and psychosocial support. The creation of a collaborative learning environment, where doctors can share experiences and debate complex cases, can strengthen individual and collective confidence. Furthermore, continuous training in evidence-based medicine and the promotion of horizontal dialogue with the judiciary (Ircañaupa and Murillo, 2024) are fundamental for doctors to feel more secure in their technical analyses. The standardization of forms, while valuable, should be seen as part of a learning and professional development ecosystem that includes interaction, mentorship, and access to complementary educational resources.
Teamwork
The dimension of Teamwork is crucial for the effective functioning of a NatJus, and the research results, presented in Table 3, reveal a positive perception among physicians regarding the contribution of forms to collaboration and communication. All item means related to this dimension were above 5, indicating a strong appreciation for the role of forms in fostering joint work. Item 19, which addresses the increased ability to exchange and share qualified information among NatJus colleagues, obtained the highest average (6.00; SD = 1.94). This result underscores the importance of forms as catalysts for the exchange of knowledge and experiences among professionals. The standardization of information facilitates mutual understanding and case discussion, promoting an environment of collective learning and the construction of shared knowledge (Vogt and Bulgacov, 2019).
Table 3. Means and standard deviation of the Teamwork items
|
N |
Teamwork |
Mean |
Standard deviation |
|
17 |
They motivate collaborative work among NatJus members in the analysis of judicial demands in health. |
5,11 |
2,47 |
|
18 |
They increase the technical communication capacity among the doctors who are part of NatJus. |
5,67 |
1,41 |
|
19 |
They increase the ability to exchange and share qualified information among NatJus colleagues. |
6,00 |
1,94 |
Source: Original research results
Item 18, concerning the increase in technical communication capacity among NatJus physicians, also showed a high average (5.67; SD = 1.41). Effective technical communication is a pillar for collaboration in multidisciplinary teams, especially in complex contexts such as the judicialization of health. The forms, by structuring information in a standardized way, create a common language that facilitates understanding and discussion among peers, minimizing ambiguities and optimizing the analysis process. Clarity in communication is essential to avoid errors and ensure that technical notes are accurate and well-founded.
Item 17, which addresses the motivation for collaborative work in the analysis of judicial demands in health, obtained a mean of 5.11 (SD = 2.47). Figure 3 illustrates the percentage breakdown, showing that 44.44% of respondents consider that the forms greatly help motivate collaborative work, while 22.22% believe they help a little above average and another 22.22% that they help little. This dispersion, although still with a positive majority, suggests that, for some, motivation for collaboration may be influenced by factors other than the form itself, such as organizational culture or team dynamics. However, the predominance of positive responses indicates that the forms are perceived as a facilitator for case discussion and networking of professionals with different expertise.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Chart of the percentage of Teamwork items
The practical implication of these findings is that medical forms can be used as a strategic tool to strengthen teamwork and interprofessional collaboration at NatJus. By promoting the exchange of qualified information and technical communication, they contribute to the construction of more robust collective knowledge. To further optimize this potential, it is essential that NatJus management actively encourages case discussions, the exchange of experiences, and the creation of formal and informal spaces for collaboration. The more plural composition of NatJus, with the inclusion of health professionals beyond doctors, such as pharmacists and dentists, and from different specialties, can further enrich the debate and the quality of technical notes. Uncertainty in judicial health processes and the impact on public spending can be better addressed through digital tools and applications that allow continuous interaction among NatJus members, as suggested by Vogt and Bulgacov (2019). This technological approach, combined with the standardization of forms, can transform NatJus into a model of Knowledge Management and collective learning.
Ease of Use
Physicians’ perception of the ease of use of the forms is a determining factor for their acceptance and adoption, according to Davis’s (1989) Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). The results, presented in Table 4, show an extremely positive perception, with all items showing high averages, close to 7. Item 22, which states that using the medical form makes the preparation of the technical note faster, obtained the highest average (6.89; SD = 0.33). This finding is of great relevance, as speed is a highly valued attribute in high-demand work environments, such as NatJus. The ability to speed up the process of preparing technical notes not only optimizes professionals’ time but also contributes to the efficiency of the judicial system as a whole, reducing response time to health-related judicial demands.
Table 4. Means and standard deviation of the Usability items
|
N |
Ease of use |
Mean |
Standard deviation |
|
20 |
The medical forms are easy to be understood and used by NatJus. |
6,78 |
0,67 |
|
21 |
Using medical forms improves the quality of the technical note |
6,56 |
0,53 |
|
22 |
Using the medical form makes the technical note preparation faster |
6,89 |
0,33 |
Source: Original research results
Item 20, which addresses the ease of understanding and use of medical forms by NatJus, obtained an average of 6.78 (SD = 0.67). Figure 4 illustrates that the near unanimity of respondents (88.89%) understands that the forms help a lot, and 11.11% that they help a little above average. This perception of ease of use is an indication that the forms were well designed and are intuitive, which is fundamental for user adherence. Tools that are perceived as easy to use tend to be more accepted and utilized, as they reduce the entry barrier and the cognitive effort required for their operation (Davis, 1989). The standardization of the medical form and the adequacy of the required information contribute significantly to this ease, making the tool accessible and efficient.
Source: Original research results
Figure 4. Chart of the percentage of Usability items
Finally, item 21, which addresses the improvement of the technical note’s quality through the use of medical forms, showed an average of 6.56 (SD = 0.53). The majority of physicians (55.56%) believe that the form improves the quality of the technical note, while the other 44.44% believe it helps in most cases. This result reinforces the idea that ease of use is not an end in itself, but a means to achieve a greater objective: the improvement of the final product’s quality. Ease of use, therefore, acts as a facilitator for perceived usefulness, indirectly influencing the tool’s adoption. When a tool is easy to use and, at the same time, improves the quality of work, its acceptance and integration into professional routine are maximized.
The practical implication of these findings is that the high usability of medical forms is a strong point that should be capitalized on. The standardization and clarity of the forms are elements that directly contribute to the speed and quality of technical notes, aspects essential for NatJus. However, it is important that this ease of use is maintained and continuously improved, considering user feedback and technological evolutions. The integration of databases from different bodies, as proposed by CNJ’s (National Council of Justice, 2024) e-NatJus 4.0, can make the tool even more powerful, centralizing information and facilitating access. Usability, combined with perceived usefulness, is a pillar for professional engagement and for the effectiveness of forms as a pedagogical strategy for qualifying judicial decisions in health, as argued by Wang et al. (2023).
Perceived Usefulness
The perceived usefulness of medical forms is a critical aspect for their adoption and impact on the work of NatJus physicians. The results, presented in Table 5, reveal a mixed perception, with one item of high relevance and others with lower ratings, indicating areas for improvement. Item 24, which questions the relevance of the data requested in the medical form, obtained the highest average (6.56; SD = 1.33). This finding is extremely positive, as 88.89% of participants understand that the data is very relevant, and 11.11% that it is relevant in situations slightly below the average cases. This suggests that the forms are effective in collecting essential information for clinical analysis and judicial decision-making, without the inclusion of useless or redundant data. Data relevance is fundamental to information quality and to professionals’ confidence in the tool.
Table 5. Means and standard deviation of perceived Usefulness items
|
N |
Perceived usefulness |
Mean |
Standard deviation |
|
23 |
The instructions for filling out the form by the attending physician were complete |
4,44 |
2,24 |
|
24 |
The data requested in the medical form are relevant |
6,56 |
1,33 |
|
25 |
The Judges encourage the use of the medical form |
4,67 |
2,65 |
Source: Original research results
On the other hand, items 23 and 25 showed lower averages. Item 23, regarding the completeness of the instructions for filling out the form by the attending physician, obtained the lowest average (4.44; SD = 2.24). Figure 5 details this perception, showing a division of responses: 22.22% consider the instructions very complete, 22.22% complete in most cases, and 22.22% slightly below average. However, a significant percentage (22.22%) presents lower ratings, ranging from “almost never” (11.11%) to “few cases” (11.11%). This heterogeneity indicates a weakness in the filling instructions, which can compromise the quality of the data entered by the attending physicians and, consequently, the perceived usefulness of the form. Lack of clarity in the instructions can lead to errors, omissions, or misinterpretations, negatively impacting the accuracy of the technical notes.
Source: Original research results
Figure 5. Graph of the percentage of Perceived Utility items
Item 25, related to the judges’ stimulus for the use of the medical form, also presented a relatively low average (4.67; SD = 2.65). Figure 5 shows that 44.44% of respondents understand that judges stimulate a lot, but there is considerable dispersion, with 22.22% indicating that they stimulate a little below average and another 22.22% that they stimulate little. This lack of symmetry in the responses suggests that the judiciary’s engagement with the use of forms is not yet uniform or fully perceived by NatJus doctors. Judicial stimulus is crucial for the adoption and consistent use of forms, as it signals the importance of the tool and the valorization of standardized information. The absence of clear and consistent stimulus can demotivate professionals and compromise the effectiveness of the initiative.
The practical implications of these findings are multifaceted. Firstly, the need to improve the instructions for filling out the form is evident. This can be achieved through more detailed guides, specific training for attending physicians, and communication channels for clarifying doubts. Expanding the research to include the perception of attending physicians, who are the primary form fillers, would be fundamental to identify gaps and propose more effective improvements. Secondly, it is imperative to increase the judiciary’s engagement with the use of the forms. This can be done through awareness campaigns, joint workshops between judges and NatJus physicians, and the creation of formal feedback mechanisms that demonstrate the value of technical notes based on the forms. The standardization of forms, such as the Manchester Protocol or the SWALIS model (Carvalho et al., 2024), is essential to reduce judicial urgency and avoid distortions in the SUS. The difficulty or ease of using the forms is intrinsically linked to their perceived usefulness, and professional engagement can be encouraged by creating institutional workflows that incorporate these tools into the routine of judicial processes, rather than relegating their use exclusively to the judge’s initiative (Wang et al., 2023).
Information Quality
The quality of information is a fundamental pillar for judicial decision-making in healthcare, and the research results, presented in Table 6, indicate a generally high perception among NatJus physicians regarding the contribution of forms in this aspect. The highest values are concentrated in items 29, 27, and 30, suggesting that the information provided by the forms is perceived as valuable for the analysis and review of technical notes. Item 29, which addresses the understanding that more detailed information, linked to the professional’s experience, can improve the understanding of the requested treatment and the conclusion of the technical note, obtained the highest average (6.67; SD = 0.71). This is the highest percentage of the entire survey, with 77.78% indicating a high contribution. This result reinforces the role of forms not only as data collectors but as facilitators of a critical reflection process that integrates structured information with the professional’s tacit knowledge. The combination of detailed data and clinical experience is essential for producing high-quality technical notes that support complex judicial decisions.
Table 6. Means and standard deviation of the Information quality items
|
N |
Information quality |
Mean |
Standard deviation |
|
26 |
The Judges provide support in clarifying NatJus’ doubts about the content of the medical form |
5,44 |
2,19 |
|
27 |
I noticed an opportunity to change my view on the conclusion to be adopted in the technical note |
6,33 |
0,50 |
|
28 |
I noticed the existence of different views on the treatment to be prescribed to the patient |
5,56 |
2,19 |
|
29 |
I understood that the more detailed information related to my experience can improve the understanding of the requested treatment and the conclusion of the technical note |
6,67 |
0,71 |
|
30 |
I realized that my conclusion could have impacts that I hadn’t perceived, and, therefore, I altered my view in some technical notes |
6,11 |
0,93 |
Source: Original research results
Item 27, which refers to the opportunity to alter the view on the conclusion to be adopted in the technical note, obtained an average of 6.33 (SD = 0.50). Figure 6 shows that 66.67% of respondents indicate that the forms assist in most cases and 33.33% that they assist greatly, evidencing a strong contribution to technical reevaluation. This finding is crucial, as it demonstrates that the forms not only standardize but also promote flexibility and review capacity, allowing physicians to incorporate new perspectives and scientific evidence. The possibility of adjusting the conclusion of a technical note based on qualified information is an indicator of a dynamic and adaptive decision-making process, fundamental in a constantly evolving field such as health.
Source: Original research results
Figure 6. Chart of the percentage of Information Quality items
Item 30, which addresses the perception of impacts not previously considered in the conclusions and the consequent alteration of the vision in some technical notes, obtained an average of 6.11 (SD = 0.93). A significant 88.89% of respondents rate the forms with high levels of contribution, indicating their potential as an instrument for critical reflection and improvement of technical decisions within the scope of NatJus. This result suggests that the forms act as a feedback and learning mechanism, allowing physicians to identify gaps in their initial analyses and adjust their conclusions based on a deeper understanding. The ability to infer information and engage in questioning and analysis is an essential element for a complete and critical understanding (Ircañaupa and Murillo, 2024).
On the other hand, the lowest averages were observed in items 28 (M = 5.56; SD = 2.19), regarding the existence of different views on treatment, and 26 (M = 5.44; SD = 2.19), regarding the support of judges in clarifying doubts. Figure 6 shows that, in item 26, 55.56% of respondents understand that judges provide a lot of support, but there is a dispersion with 22.22% who help a little above average and 11.11% who help a little below average or little. This variability suggests that, although there is support, the dialogue between the judge and NatJus can be improved to strengthen this relationship in a more horizontal and less hierarchical manner. The existence of different views on treatment (item 28) also shows greater heterogeneity in responses, indicating that, although the forms contribute to the discussion, uniformity of understanding is still a challenge.
The practical implications of these findings are clear. The high quality of information provided by the forms is a valuable asset that should be continuously promoted and communicated. The capacity for review and improvement of technical notes, driven by the forms, should be encouraged through *feedback* processes and case discussions. To optimize judicial support and the management of divergent views, it is essential to strengthen interdisciplinary dialogue between NatJus and the judiciary. Effective communication, based on evidence-based medicine, is crucial for NatJus not to become a parallel system for health technology assessment (Oliveira, 2025). Promoting a collaborative environment and valuing technical expertise can transform the forms into an even more powerful tool for qualifying judicial decisions in health.
Data Crossing and Management Strategies
The data cross-tabulation, as presented in Table 7, offers valuable insights into the perception differences between physicians who are part of the Court’s own staff and those who are not. This comparative analysis is crucial for identifying how the institutional link may influence the evaluation of work tools and processes at NatJus. The results indicate that respondents not belonging to the Court’s staff present higher averages in most of the evaluated dimensions, suggesting a more positive perception of these aspects by these professionals.
Table 7. Groups that belong or do not belong to the Court and the scales
|
Group |
RFP |
SWOT |
TE |
SWOT |
UP |
IQ |
|
Does not belong to the Court’s record |
6,04 |
5,81 |
6,58 |
6,83 |
5,83 |
6,05 |
|
Belongs to the Court’s framework |
4,93 |
5,20 |
4,80 |
6,67 |
4,73 |
6,00 |
Source: Original research results
The greatest differences were observed in the dimensions of Teamwork (6.58 vs. 4.80) and Problem Solving (6.04 vs. 4.93). For physicians without a direct link to the Court, the contribution of the forms to collaborative work and problem-solving is significantly higher. This difference can be interpreted in several ways. External professionals may bring a fresher perspective, less influenced by the Court’s internal dynamics and bureaucracies, valuing more the structure and standardization that the forms offer to facilitate collaboration and case analysis. Furthermore, experience in different work contexts may have led these professionals to more readily recognize the benefits of tools that optimize interaction and the ability to solve complex problems. In contrast, physicians with a direct link may be more accustomed to internal processes and, therefore, may have different expectations or perceive the forms as an already integrated and expected part of their routine, without such a “revolutionary” impact on collaboration or problem-solving.
Relevant differences were also observed in Perceived Usefulness (5.83 vs. 4.73) and Professional Development (5.81 vs. 5.20). Physicians without direct affiliation perceive the forms as more useful and more contributory to their professional development. This perception may be linked to their search for tools that help them adapt to a new work environment (NatJus) or optimize their practices in a specific context (health litigation). Perceived usefulness, according to Davis (1989), is a key predictor of technology acceptance, and the greater valuation by external professionals may indicate that the forms fill a more evident gap in their practices or expectations. Regarding professional development, the novelty of the tool or its application in a specific judicial context may be seen as a more significant learning opportunity for those not directly involved in the Court’s structure.
On the other hand, the averages were quite close in Ease of Use (6.83 vs. 6.67) and Information Quality (6.05 vs. 6.00), indicating consensus between the groups on these aspects. This suggests that, regardless of institutional affiliation, the forms are universally perceived as easy to use and as tools that contribute to information quality. This uniformity is a strong point of the tool, as it indicates that its design and data structuring capabilities are effective for all users, regardless of their formal relationship with the Court. Ease of use and information quality are intrinsic attributes of the forms that transcend affiliation differences.
The managerial implications of these findings are significant. The more positive perception of professionals without direct ties regarding teamwork, problem-solving, usefulness, and professional training suggests that NatJus could benefit from a more plural and diversified composition. The inclusion of professionals with different experiences and perspectives can enrich the debate, foster case discussions, and promote the exchange of experiences and constant updates. Learning at NatJus, through the use of medical forms, proves relevant for problem-solving, acquiring skills on clinical case knowledge, and organizing appropriate treatment. Furthermore, the forms serve as a strategy to identify deficiencies in medical training and as a model to inspire national-level use.
To optimize the potential of the forms, NatJus must consider strategies that promote the integration and engagement of all its members, regardless of their affiliation. This may include mentoring programs, collaborative workshops, and the creation of digital platforms that facilitate interaction and knowledge sharing. Valuing the experience and perspective of external professionals can bring innovations and improvements to internal practices. The result of this is the enhancement of technical notes, with greater qualification of clinical information and different views on adequate treatment, also serving as an instrument for raising awareness about the impact of physicians on the healthcare system and as a strategy for balancing public spending. The lack of infrastructure, deficiencies in medical training, and the compromise of the judiciary are obstacles that need to be overcome for the full implementation of the forms, which are not just a viable alternative, but a pedagogical strategy for qualifying judicial decisions in health.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved by analyzing the perception of physicians from a Technical Support Unit of the Judiciary (NatJus) regarding the quality of patient health information, its perceived utility, and the development of skills associated with the use of forms created by the Executive Committee of Health of the National Council of Justice (CNJ). The forms proved effective in organizing and condensing clinical information, improving technical communication, and expediting the preparation of technical notes, contributing significantly to information quality and teamwork. However, their contribution to expanding knowledge in broader areas, such as medical guidelines and public policies, and to increasing confidence in independent technical analyses, still has room for improvement. The research also highlighted the need for greater engagement from the judiciary and case discussions to optimize the pedagogical potential of the tool.
The limitations of this study include the small population sample of only nine respondents, which restricts the generalization of the results. Furthermore, data cross-referencing was limited to the aspect of institutional affiliation. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the sample to include a larger number of NatJus physicians and, mainly, to extend the investigation to the attending physicians who fill out the forms. It is also recommended to include other health professionals, such as pharmacists and dentists, and from different specialties, for a more heterogeneous and comprehensive analysis. Such approaches will allow for a more complete understanding of the challenges and opportunities in qualifying judicial decisions in health.
Bibliographic References
Carvalho, A. L. B; Diniz, A. M. S; Batista, B. N. M; Barbosa, D. S; SILVA; E. R. R. A; Santos, O. A. N; NASCIMENTO, R. V. 2020. Determinantes da judicialização da saúde: uma análise bibliográfica. Cadernos Ibero-Americanos de Direito Sanitário. Disponível em: <https://www.cadernos.prodisa.fiocruz.br/index.php/cadernos/article/view/670/1405>. Acesso em 10/10/2025.
Correia, L.R; Paula, L.G.N de; Trenti, J.; Silva, B.D da. 2025. Impact evaluation of technical notes issued by NATJUS on healthcare judicialization. Einstein 23. Disponível em: <https://journal.einstein.br/wp-content/uploads/articles_xml/2317-6385-eins-23-eGS0766/2317-6385-eins-23-eGS0766.pdf>. Acesso em: 15
Shulze, C.J.; Neto, J.P.G. 2019. Direito à saúde: revista e ampliada. 2ed. Verbo, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in People Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform