October 20, 2026
Knowledge and references to access management positions in SME-SP: analysis of competition items
Knowledge and References for Accessing Management Positions in Sme-sp: Analysis of Contest Items
Vanessa de Mello Borges; Tatiana Giselle Guimarães Lopes
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603521
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
This study analyzed the framework of references and knowledge present in the items of public examinations for management positions in the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo (SME-SP) in the decade from 2015 to 2024. The objective was to identify the knowledge and references mobilized as selection criteria, as well as the expectations regarding the professional profile of the managers selected for coordination, direction, and supervision. The methodology employed content analysis of the examination items, categorizing them by enunciative context, knowledge in education and school management, and references in education and school management. The research highlighted a core of educational concerns common to different areas of school management, associated with the “critical discourse of school management”, the “discourse of diversity, equity, and inclusion”, and the institutional productions of SME-SP itself. The predominance of the theoretical-academic repertoire over the practical challenges of school management was observed. The Secretariat sought to select managers with a pedagogical leadership profile, capable of supporting teaching, assessment, and learning processes. The discursive orientation and the core of knowledge remained unchanged, even with changes in government. The results contribute to the understanding of discursive disputes in the educational arena.
Keywords: Content analysis; City of São Paulo; Public tender; Public education; School management.
1. Introduction
In Brazil, public examinations based on tests or tests and titles have become a mandatory requirement for filling public positions and jobs since the Federal Constitution of 1988. The Law of Directives and Bases of National Education (Law No. 9,394/1996) reinforced this obligation for the entry of education professionals into public basic education systems. Thus, public examinations are legally vested with the prerogative of verifying the necessary competencies and aptitudes for acting in public school service, also encompassing professionals in the management area, such as coordinators, principals, and school supervisors (Brazil, 1988; 1996).
In the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo (SME-SP), the access competition for management positions constitutes an internal selection process. It is aimed at permanent staff members of the teaching staff of the Prefecture, aiming for career progression, allowing network teachers to assume the roles of Pedagogical Coordinators, School Directors, and School Supervisors. To participate, a minimum of three years of service in the role is generally required, in addition to a full degree in Pedagogy or postgraduate studies in Education. The selection stages typically include an objective test, a discursive test, and an evaluation of titles that consider the candidates’ academic background and professional experience (São Paulo [City], 2007).
Academic literature understands school management as a field permeated by tensions between different discourses. One of these discourses is that of efficient school management, which conceives of the school principal as a manager focused on process control and the measurement of results through standardized external tests. This perspective values partnerships with private companies and third-sector organizations, as well as indicators such as the Basic Education Development Index (Ideb). It also emphasizes the adequacy of the pedagogical project to the curricular prescriptions of the National Common Curricular Base (BNCC), the conformity of teaching plans, and the regulation of teaching work based on data and evidence (Gatti, 2012; Brooke; Cunha, Faleiros, 2011; Ribeiro, 2023; Paro, 1986; Nascimento, 2024).
In contrast, the critical discourse of school management emphasizes the specificity of the educational institution, distinguishing it from a company. It prioritizes democratic management, participatory institutional self-assessment, and the social quality of education. In this paradigm, the manager coordinates the collective effort for the formation of citizens, criticizing the technical nature of administration and the naturalization of administrative rationality. Topics such as school autonomy, participatory construction of the Political Pedagogical Project (PPP), and institutional self-assessment are central (Arroyo, 1997; Félix, 1984; Paro, 1986; Camargo, 2006; Veiga, 2001; Vasconcellos, 1991; Freitas, 2003; Sordi; Ludke, 2009; Silva; Gallego, 2019). More recently, from the 2000s onwards, the discourse of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) has gained relevance, addressing themes such as Special Education, Youth and Adult Education (EJA), Anti-racist Education, and Education for Sexual and Gender Diversity, which stand out in the academic and institutional literature on school management (Prieto, 2010; Di Pierro, 2003; Carreira, 2013; Vianna; Carvalho, 2020).
The interactions and dialogues between these different discursive perspectives (Ribeiro, 2023) result in the reconfiguration of conceptual, procedural, and attitudinal knowledge (Coll, 1996) in the field of school management. This multiplicity of knowledge and the polyphony of sources (Ribeiro, 2023) are textually manifested in various documents in the educational and school management areas, including academic manuals, institutional documents from management bodies, media texts, and, notably, items from competitive examinations.
Given the complexity and multiple dimensions involved in school management in the largest education network in Brazil, and considering the researcher’s professional insertion in the network, which provided prior knowledge for the design of this study, it becomes relevant to investigate how knowledge and references are mobilized in selection processes. Thus, this study is justified by the need to understand the selection criteria and the expected professional profile for managers. The objective is to analyze the items of public examinations held by SME-SP (2015–2024) for school management positions – pedagogical coordination, direction, and supervision – in order to identify the knowledge and references mobilized as selection criteria, as well as the expectations regarding the professional profile of those selected.
2. Material and Methods
This research was characterized as a qualitative study, with a methodological approach based on content analysis. The central objective was to analyze the items of public examinations for school management positions in the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo (SME-SP), held between 2015 and 2024. It sought to identify the knowledge and references mobilized as selection criteria, as well as the expectations regarding the professional profile of the managers selected for the positions of pedagogical coordination, direction, and supervision.
For the constitution of the empirical object, a collection of items from public tenders for the management area in the municipal education network of São Paulo was carried out. The contests for pedagogical coordination, direction, and supervision that occurred in the decade from 2015 to 2024 and were publicly available on internet portals were included. The defined unit of analysis was the public tender item, understood as a specific textual genre that assesses knowledge and capabilities.
The systematic treatment of textual data, composed of the contest items, was based on Content Analysis, according to the assumptions of Bardin (2011) and Franco (2003). This technique was used to develop a set of methodological procedures and instruments that would allow the emergence of meanings not evident in a superficial reading of the material (Bardin, 2011). According to Franco (2013), Content Analysis made it possible to systematically inventory, differentiate, classify, categorize, regroup, and compare the manifest contents of the messages.
The operationalization of the analysis was structured into three main axes. The first axis, named “enunciative context of the item”, aimed to delimit the production markers of the contest exam, such as the year of realization, the position in dispute, and the examining board responsible. This axis provided essential contextual information for understanding the items.
The second axis of analysis focused on “knowledge in education and school management”. Through it, we sought to map the different types of knowledge examined in the contest items. This stage allowed us to identify the programmatic content, the general themes, and the specific content addressed in the questions.
The third axis, titled “references in education and school management”, aimed to identify and quantify the sources cited in the items that composed the research corpus. Academic, institutional, and legal sources were considered, in addition to the cited voice or enunciator, to understand the theoretical and normative basis of the issues.
To organize and systematize the collected data, a set of specific descriptors was used, which were detailed in a methodological table. Each descriptor functioned as a textual variable, or unit of record, aiding in the objective description of the research object. This organization allowed the conversion of the original “document-corpus” into a “spreadsheet-corpus”.
The transformation of the material into a textual database enabled the performance of operations for specification, categorization, scaling, and cross-referencing of descriptors. This methodological approach aimed to capture the textual evidence necessary to infer the descriptive traits of the knowledge framework on school management required by SME-SP from candidates for coordination, management, and supervision positions.
The analyzed contests were conducted by the Foundation for the Entrance Examination of the São Paulo State University (VUNESP). In the period from 2015 to 2024, competitions were held for Director (in 2015), Supervisor (in 2015), and Coordinator (in 2019). The collection resulted in a corpus of 189 written examination items, with 63 items for each position, composed of multiple-choice and constructed-response questions.
Additionally, a subcorpus was constituted with the citations present in the items, totaling 185 sources and references. This subcorpus was organized for the analysis of cited sources, including the type of social actor, the specification of voices and references, as well as shared references and emblematic citations. The treatment and analysis of the data proceeded from the general analysis of the items to the detailed analysis of the cited sources.
The methodological design thus sought to understand the expectations of the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo regarding the professional profile of municipal teaching managers. The analysis focused on the knowledge and references that the institution considered essential for access to school management positions, without delving into the empirical results or findings of the research.
3. Results and Discussion
The analysis of items from public service entrance examinations for management positions at the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo (SME-SP), conducted between 2015 and 2024, revealed a consistent panorama of valued knowledge and references. The examinations for Director (2015), Supervisor (2015), and Coordinator (2019) were conducted by the Fundação VUNESP, establishing a standard in selection. The research corpus comprised 189 test items, with 63 for each position, the majority in multiple-choice format and a smaller portion of essay questions. This dataset allowed for an in-depth investigation into the selection criteria and the professional profile sought by the network.
Regarding the type of programmatic content examined, a clear predominance of the theoretical-academic repertoire was observed, to the detriment of the practical challenges of school management. The data indicated that “academic or theoretical content” represented 15% for Coordinator, 18% for Director, and 22% for Supervisor. In contrast, “professional assignments” had a residual occurrence, ranging from 1% to 2% in the competitions. “Laws and regulations” and “institutional content” occupied an intermediate position. This distribution suggests that SME-SP prioritizes the conceptual and theoretical basis of candidates, relegating direct practical experience in the school’s daily routine to a secondary plane, which may generate a mismatch between the required training and the actual demands of the role.
The research identified that all general themes were shared by the contests for the three management positions, demonstrating a core of common educational concerns. The most prominent themes were “approach”, “management”, “curriculum”, “evaluation”, and “legislation”. However, there were differences in thematic preference for each position. For Coordinator, the theme “Curriculum” was the most recurrent, with 14 occurrences. In the contest for Director, the theme “Management” prevailed, with 13 occurrences. For Supervisor, “Approach” was the most outstanding theme, with 15 occurrences. These distinctions reflect the specificities of each role within the municipal school management structure.
Regarding specific themes, the analysis revealed a shared thematic core that signals central concerns and challenges of the educational network. Themes such as “learning assessment” and “institutional assessment” were recurrent, linked to the general theme of “assessment”. In the “approach” category, “emancipatory pedagogy”, “reflective teacher”, and “democracy and human rights” stood out. Under the rubric of “inclusion”, themes such as “special education”, “learning difficulties”, and “youth and adult education” were prominent. The “Law of Directives and Bases of National Education – LDB”, “anti-racist legislation”, and “full-time education legislation”, in addition to “curriculum theory” and “teacher training”, also proved relevant. This thematic breadth indicates a search for managers with a multifaceted understanding of educational challenges.
The centrality of the topic “learning assessment” in the three competitions is notable, reinforcing the expectation of a pedagogical leadership profile. This focus indicates that SME-SP seeks managers capable of supporting teaching, assessment, and learning processes, with special attention to the teacher’s evaluative performance and student development. For the Coordinator position, “learning assessment” and “city curriculum” stood out specifically. In the competition for Director, the most relevant themes were “learning assessment” and “school management”. For Supervisor, the most recurrent topics were “school supervision” and “learning assessment”, underscoring the importance of the pedagogical dimension in all spheres of management.
Regarding the type of source cited in the items, the predominance of “academic source” was evident in all three positions, indicating that the competitions value authors linked to universities and research institutions. This preference for theoretical works is a striking feature of the selection process. Comparatively, the academic source was even more predominant in the competition for Supervisor, with 40 occurrences, suggesting a professional ethos of technical leadership for supervisors in the municipal education network. Institutional and legal sources, although present, had fewer occurrences, reinforcing the priority given to theoretical-academic knowledge.
The analysis of the voices cited in the items revealed a relative dispersion, but also a common core of recurring authors and institutions. The “Secretaria Municipal de Educação de São Paulo – SME/SP” emerged as the main institutional source, followed by “BRASIL (Federal Republic)” and “Prefeitura do Município de São Paulo – PMSP” as legal sources. Among the most prominent academic sources, Paulo Freire, Fernando Hernandez, José Gimeno Sacristán, and Maurice Tardif stood out. The centrality of SME-SP as a bibliographic reference in the competitions demonstrates the interest in selecting candidates familiar with the institutional productions of the network itself, aligning the manager’s profile with internal guidelines and documents.
A common core of shared references was identified, composed of Federal Law no. 9.394/1996, the “Law of Directives and Bases of National Education – LDB”, the book “Pedagogy of Autonomy” by Paulo Freire (2011), “Transgression and Change in Education” by Fernando Hernandez (1998), “Indicators of Quality of Early Childhood Education in São Paulo” by SME-SP (2016), and “Teaching Knowledge and Professional Training” by Maurice Tardif (2002). These fundamental references permeate the selection processes for all positions, establishing a common theoretical and legal basis for future managers. The LDB, for example, was used to examine the non-selective nature of evaluation in Early Childhood Education and the age range of compulsory education.
Although there is a common core, each position mobilizes its own collection of specialized references. For the position of Coordinator, the LDB and the book “Organization and management of the school” by José Carlos Libâneo (2015) had prominence. In the competition for Director, the most recurrent references were the institutional publication of SME-SP “Interdisciplinary Dialogues on the Path to Authorship” (2015) and the book “Evaluation of school learning” by Cipriano Carlos Luckesi (2005). For the position of Supervisor, the work “Pedagogical Supervision” by Mary Rangel (2001) was the most frequently cited. This specialization of references reflects the specific demands of each function, although all are connected to the theoretical-critical framework of education.
The concrete textual manifestation of these references in the test items illustrates the intertwining of knowledge and sources. For example, items based on Paulo Freire (2011) addressed the educator’s commitment to the critical consciousness of the learner and the ethical responsibility of the school manager, emphasizing the concept of “thinking correctly” as a dialogical construction. Similarly, the institutional reference “Indicators of quality of Early Childhood Education in São Paulo” (SME-SP, 2016) was used to question participatory institutional self-assessment and the dimensions of educational management, demonstrating how the Secretariat’s own publications guide the assessment of candidates’ knowledge.
In summary, the knowledge and references present in the items of the SME-SP competitions are predominantly linked to the “critical discourse of school management” and the “discourse of diversity, equity, and inclusion”, as outlined in the introduction. This is manifested in the valorization of themes such as emancipatory pedagogy, reflective teacher, democracy and human rights, learning and institutional assessment, special education, learning difficulties, and Youth and Adult Education. Authors such as Paulo Freire, Fernando Hernandez, José Gimeno Sacristán, and Maurice Tardif, along with educational legislation and institutional publications from SME-SP, are pillars of this framework. The Secretariat thus seeks to select managers with a profile of pedagogical leadership, capable of supporting teaching, assessment, and learning processes, with the supervisor acting as a technical-scientific reference in the network. It is relevant to note that this discursive orientation and the common core of knowledge and references remained unchanged, even in the face of government changes in the Prefecture of São Paulo during the analyzed period.
4. Conclusion
This study analyzed the items of public service examinations for management positions in the Municipal Secretariat of Education of São Paulo (SME-SP) in the decade from 2015 to 2024, with the purpose of identifying the knowledge and references mobilized as selection criteria and the expectations regarding the professional profile of managers. A predominance of a theoretical-academic repertoire was observed in the examinations for coordinator, director, and supervisor, to the detriment of the practical aspects of school management. A common core of educational concerns was observed, manifested in themes such as learning assessment, emancipatory pedagogy, reflective teacher, democracy and human rights, and inclusion, which align with the “critical discourse of school management” and the “discourse of diversity, equity, and inclusion”. The centrality of learning assessment reinforced the search for a profile of pedagogical leadership, capable of supporting teaching and learning processes, with the supervisor acting as a technical-scientific reference. The institutional publications of SME-SP itself, along with authors such as Paulo Freire, Fernando Hernandez, José Gimeno Sacristán, and Maurice Tardif, constituted the main sources of reference. It is relevant to note that this discursive orientation and the core of knowledge and references remained unchanged, even in the face of government changes during the analyzed period.
The main contribution of this work lies in the elucidation of the selection criteria and the professional profile sought by the largest municipal education network in Brazil, offering an in-depth understanding of the discursive disputes present in the educational arena. The results indicate that the SME-SP seeks managers with a solid theoretical foundation and alignment with progressive educational perspectives. For future studies, it is suggested that this investigation serve as a basis for analyzing competition items in other public education networks in Brazil, in order to broaden the understanding of the knowledge and references valued in the selection processes for school management positions in different contexts.
Bibliographic References
Arroyo, M.G. 1997. Da escola carente à escola possível. Loyola, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Bardin, L. 2011. Análise de conteúdo. Edições 70, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Brasil. 1988. Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil. Senado, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Brasil. 1996. Lei de diretrizes e bases da educação nacional. Presidência da República, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Brooke, N.; Cunha, M.A.; Faleiros, M. 2011. A avaliação externa como instrumento da gestão educacional nos estados: relatório final. Fundação Vitor Civita, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Camargo, R.B. 2006. Problematização da qualidade em pesquisa de custo-aluno-ano em escolas de educação básica. INEP, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Carreira, D. 2013. Indicadores da qualidade na educação: relações raciais na escola. Ação Educativa, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Cool, C. 1996. Psicologia e currículo: uma aproximação psicopedagógica à elaboração do currículo escolar. 4ed. Ática, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Di Pierro, M.C. 2003. Seis anos de educação de jovens e adultos no Brasil. Ação Educativa, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Felix, M.F. 1984. Administração escolar: um problema educativo ou empresarial? análise da proposta do estado capitalista brasileiro para a burocratização do sistema escolar. Cortez/Autores Associados.
Franco, M.L.P.B. 2003. Análise de conteúdo. Liber Livro, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Freire, 2011 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Freitas, L.C. 2003. Avaliação de escolas e universidades. Komedi, Campinas, SP, Brasil.
Gatti, B.A. 2012. Políticas de avaliação em larga escala e a questão da inovação educacional. Série-Estudos 33: 29-37.
Hernandez, 1998 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Libâneo, 2015 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Luckesi, 2005 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Nascimento, I.S. 2024. Gestão da educação: a coordenação do trabalho coletivo na escola. Contexto, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Paro, V.H. 1986. Administração escolar: introdução crítica. Cortez, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Prieto, R.G. 2010. Atendimento escolar de alunos com necessidades educacionais especiais: análise das ações dos centros de formação e acompanhamento à inclusão (Cefai). Feusp/Fapesp, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Rangel, 2001 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Ribeiro, R.M. 2023. Discursos sobre avaliações de larga escala em revistas pedagógicas: análise da polifonia midiática. USP, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Silva, V.B.; Gallego, R. 2019. Projeto politico pedagógico. Pecege, Piracicaba, SP, Brasil.
SME-SP, 2015 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
SME-SP, 2016 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Sordi, M.R.L.; Ludke, M. 2009. Da avaliação da aprendizagem à avaliação institucional: aprendizagens necessárias. Avaliação 14(2): 253-266.
São Paulo (Cidade). 2007. Lei nº 14.660, de 26 de dezembro de 2007. Diário Oficial da Cidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Tardif, 2002 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
Vasconcellos, C.S. 1991. Projeto educativo: elementos metodológicos para a elaboração do projeto educativo. Libertad, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Veiga, I.P.A. 2001. As dimensões do projeto político-pedagógico. 4ed. Papirus, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Vianna, C.; Carvalho, M. 2020. Gênero e educação: 20 anos construindo o conhecimento. Bookwire, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in School Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform