October 16, 2026
Succession Planning by Family “Holdings” in Light of the Tax Reform
Succession Planning by Family “Holdings” in Light of the Tax Reform
Pedro Mainardi Kaminski; Nayara Regina Cavinato
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603348
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
Succession planning has gained increasing relevance in Brazil, with family “holdings” emerging as strategic instruments for asset organization and transfer, aiming for control and potential reduction of the tax burden. However, recent changes from the Tax Reform (Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and Complementary Law No. 227/2026) have imposed new challenges. The study aimed to analyze the viability of maintaining family “holdings” as a succession planning instrument in the face of the new national tax scenario, especially regarding the Tax on Transfer upon Death and Donation of Any Assets or Rights [ITCMD]. Using a qualitative approach and a case study method, a pre-existing family “holding” in Rio Grande do Sul, with assets valued at approximately R$ 4.1 million, was investigated. The corporate structure, quota distribution, and the impact of current and projected legislation on inheritance taxation were analyzed, with a quantitative projection of the ITCMD. The results indicated that, due to the progressive anticipation of quotas to descendants, the transfer upon death of ascendants resulted in a zero tax burden for heirs, even with the expansion of the tax base to market value and the possibility of increasing rates up to 8%. The succession planning generated estimated tax savings between R$ 82,000.00 and R$ 123,000.00. It was concluded that maintaining the family “holding” remains viable and tax-efficient, preserving advantages of asset organization and conflict reduction, although it requires monitoring future state regulations.
Keywords: ITCMD; Equity/ Property; Estate planning; Legal entity; Viability.
1. Introduction
Succession planning has been gaining increasing relevance in Brazil, driven by the complexity of the tax system and constant legislative changes. Culturally, there is a tendency to avoid discussions about death, which has historically resulted in a lack of planning for the succession of heritage, affecting those who remain (Rosa, 2023).
However, over the years, the organization of a strategic and formal succession procedure has become a matter of extreme importance for family businesses and wealth managers. The objective is to transfer and share assets efficiently and economically (Barufaldi et al., 2024).
Various instruments can be employed to outline the best succession strategy, including wills, inventories, lifetime gifts, and the establishment of family holdings (Rosa, 2023). Family holdings, configured as limited liability legal entities, are frequently used for succession planning, aiming to preserve and facilitate the transfer of property/equity to heirs (Mamede, 2023).
In this context, the transfer of social quotas of a family holding company in an inventory, whether judicial or extrajudicial, is subject to the incidence of the Tax on Transfer Mortis Cause and Donation of Any Assets or Rights (ITCMD). This state-level tax is provided for in Article 155 of the Federal Constitution (Brazil, 1988).
The relevance of ITCMD in the Brazilian federative arrangement has been growing. With the replacement of the Tax on Circulation of Goods and Services (ICMS) by the Tax on Goods and Services (IBS), ITCMD stands out as one of the few remaining taxes under exclusive state competence, which increases the revenue interest of subnational entities in property transfers (Albano, 2024).
Recently, the national tax landscape was profoundly altered by Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023, which modified the National Tax System, and by Complementary Law No. 227/2026, which complemented the normative framework. These legislations concluded the construction phase of the Tax Reform legal framework, inaugurating the practical implementation stage of the new system and directly impacting ITCMD (Albano, 2024; Peixoto, 2025).
The changes brought about by the Tax Reform impose new challenges and uncertainties regarding the efficiency of family holdings as succession planning structures. It thus becomes necessary to re-evaluate their viability in the current tax context, given the essential need to examine the impacts of the new legislation on the succession planning of Brazilian families holding companies with regard to ITCMD.
Thus, the objective of the present work is to analyze the viability of maintaining family “holdings” as an instrument of succession planning in view of the changes promoted by Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and Complementary Law No. 227/2026, especially regarding the Tax on Transmission causa mortis and Donation of Any Assets or Rights [ITCMD].
2. Material and Methods
The research adopted a qualitative nature, based on Chizzotti’s (2003) concept, which emphasizes the extraction of meanings from a specific context for scientific interpretation. To analyze the viability of maintaining family “holdings” in the face of legislative changes, the case study approach was employed, as advocated by Godoy (1995), aiming to deepen the understanding of the phenomenon in its real environment.
The unit of analysis consisted of a pre-existing family “holding company”, already constituted and in operation in the state of Rio Grande do Sul. The empirical object was selected for its representativeness and for the permissibility of deepening the understanding of the phenomenon under study, ensuring the usefulness of the case for research.
The research participants, in the context of data collection, included the family’s eldest daughter, holder of social shares in the family “holding company”. In addition to her, the other four legitimate successors, her siblings, and the ascending spouses, whose corporate participations were considered in the analysis, were also partners.
Data collection was carried out through the eldest daughter, who provided the necessary information about the corporate structure and the distribution of shares of the “holding company”. The legal entity’s assets consisted of eleven commercial rooms and three garage spaces, all located in a commercial gallery, valued at approximately R$ 4,100,000.00.
The practical reading of the data was structured in three stages: exploratory, systemic, and interpretive, following the methodology of Nisbet and Watt (1978). The exploratory phase defined the object of the research as the evaluation of the feasibility of the family “holding”. In the systemic stage, the data of the “holding” were obtained and organized, including the proportion of social quotas of ascendants and descendants.
The interpretive phase sought to project the impact of the Tax on Transmission Causa Mortis and Donation of Any Assets or Rights (ITCMD) on the family “holding” after legislative changes, evaluating its tax and succession viability. To this end, the data analysis involved the construction of scenarios.
Two real and two hypothetical scenarios were constructed to isolate normative and societal variables. Scenario 1 used the current legislative regime in Rio Grande do Sul (State Law no. 8.821/1989) as a benchmark. Scenario 2 projected the effects of the Tax Reform (Constitutional Amendment no. 132/2023 and Complementary Law no. 227/2026), including the valuation of quotas at market value and the possibility of increasing tax rates.
The hypothetical scenarios assumed that the entirety of the “holding” shares belonged to the two ascending spouses (50% for each), with no prior participation from the descendants. Hypothetical Scenario 1 applied the current regime, and Hypothetical Scenario 2 applied the regime projected by Complementary Law n. 227/2026. This construction aimed to measure, by contrast, the economic effect of the inheritance advances already made by the family.
The ITCMD calculation procedure followed a sequence of five steps. Firstly, the value of the shares held by the deceased partner was identified, obtained by multiplying the value of the legal entity’s equity by the respective percentage of corporate participation.
Next, the surviving spouse’s share, which is not subject to tax, was excluded. Subsequently, the remainder was divided among the heirs to determine the individual share. The fourth stage consisted of converting the individual share into UPF-RS (State Fiscal Standard Unit).
Finally, the tax rate corresponding to the bracket in which the individual share fell was applied, according to current and projected legislation. This procedure allowed for the measurement of the ITCMD’s tax impact on the causa mortis transfer of the shares of the ascending partners in each analyzed scenario.
3. Results and Discussion
The analysis of the results obtained through the case study allowed us to evaluate the viability of maintaining a family “holding” as an estate planning instrument, considering the current tax scenario and the projections arising from the Tax Reform. Initially, the legal framework for succession in Brazil was outlined, which, in the case of spouses married under the regime of universal community of property, provides for the 50% division of assets for the surviving spouse, not subject to ITCMD, and the division of the other half among descendant heirs (Peixoto, 2025). This understanding is fundamental to contextualizing the inheritance anticipation strategy and its tax impacts.
A family “holding”, although not a specific corporate type in the Brazilian legal system, is configured as a limited liability legal entity, frequently used to centralize the administration of assets and corporate participations. In the case studied, the “holding” is of a patrimonial and mixed nature, holding its own real estate assets and exploiting them through rental to third parties. Its constitution aims not only at tax optimization but also at asset organization and planned hereditary succession, seeking longevity and the preservation of family assets (Mamede, 2023).
In the succession plan, the “holding company” allows for the anticipation and organization of the intergenerational transfer of heritage, disciplining the participation and rights of heirs through the articles of association. This approach avoids the slowness, costs, and conflicts inherent in a judicial probate process, ensuring the integrity of the heritage, which remains under the ownership of the legal entity. The strategy aligns with the principle of business preservation and the pursuit of stability in family property relations (Gagliano and Pamplona Filho, 2023).
From a tax perspective, the family “holding” acts as a strategic instrument for tax rationalization, allowing the exploitation of assets under more advantageous taxation regimes and the distribution of income tax-exempt dividends (Albano, 2024). The transfer of social quotas, in many cases, can be more efficient than the direct transfer of assets, especially in terms of ITCMD and registration costs. This use does not contravene legislation, but rather takes advantage of legal alternatives for greater liquidity and predictability in Wealth Management (Coêlho, 2021).
The legislation for the Tax on Transmission Cause Mortis and Donation of Any Assets or Rights (ITCMD) is of state competence, according to article 155 of the Federal Constitution (Brazil, 1988). In Rio Grande do Sul, the ITCMD is regulated by State Law no. 8.821/1989, which already provides for the progressivity of rates based on the transmission value, converted into the State Fiscal Standard Unit (UPF-RS). The rate bands range from exemption up to 2,000 UPF-RS, passing through 3% to 5%, and reaching 6% for transmissions above 50,000 UPF-RS (Kfouri, 2018).
Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and Complementary Law No. 227/2026 brought significant changes to ITCMD. The Tax Reform made the progressivity of the tax mandatory, scaling taxation according to the value of the hereditary share, legacy, or donation. Although Rio Grande do Sul had already adopted progressivity since 2016, the new legislation reaffirms its constitutionality and opens space for debates on the expansion of the rate ceiling up to the limit of 8% established by the Federal Senate (Peixoto, 2025).
Complementary Law no. 227/2026 introduced structural changes to the legal regime of ITCMD, with direct repercussions for family “holdings”. The new territorial competence rule stands out, which for movable assets, securities, credits, and corporate shares, establishes competence at the domicile of the *de cujus* at the time of death. For the studied family, domiciled in Rio Grande do Sul, this rule reinforces legal certainty and predictability of the applicable taxation, eliminating the choice of forum for tax planning (Peixoto, 2025).
Another highly relevant change is the redefinition of the calculation basis for quotas of unlisted companies. Article 154, item II, of Complementary Law no. 227/2026, requires the calculation basis to be determined by a technically sound methodology, corresponding, at a minimum, to the net worth adjusted by the market value of assets and liabilities, plus the market value of goodwill. This represents an abandonment of the historical criterion based on book value, which was generally lower than the real value of the underlying assets (Peixoto, 2025).
For the “family holding” studied, whose assets consist of commercial real estate, this change is particularly sensitive, as real estate assets often show a lag between book value (close to acquisition cost) and market value, especially when acquired many years ago. With the new rule, the calculation base for ITCMD on the quotas will reflect the updated market value of the properties, potentially resulting in a significant increase in the tax burden, even without changes in the rates. However, the full effectiveness of this new methodology is subject to the constitutional principle of anteriority, with effects expected from 2027, after the adaptation of the state legislation of Rio Grande do Sul.
Impact Analysis: Actual Scenario
In the real scenario, the studied family “holding” has assets valued at approximately R$ 4,100,000.00, composed of eleven commercial rooms and three garage spaces. The current corporate structure shows that the ascending spouses hold 3.51% and 3.50% of the social quotas, respectively, while the five descendants hold larger percentages, with one of them (descendant 5) holding 14.79% due to compensation for an advance on inheritance.
When designing the succession of the Ascendant 1, holder of 3.51% of the shares, the value of the shares to be transferred is R$ 143,910.00. Of this amount, 50% (R$ 71,955.00) are reserved for the surviving spouse as marital property, not subject to ITCMD. The remaining inheritance (R$ 71,955.00) is equally divided among the five descendants, resulting in an individual share of R$ 14,391.00. Converting this value to UPF-RS, with the UPF-RS of 2026 at R$ 28.3264, the individual share corresponds to approximately 508 UPF-RS.
For Ascendant 2, holder of 3.50% of the shares, the amount to be transferred is R$ 143,500.00. After the exclusion of the moiety (R$ 71,750.00), the inheritance of R$ 71,750.00 is divided among the five descendants, resulting in an individual share of R$ 14,350.00. Converted to UPF-RS, this amount corresponds to approximately 506 UPF-RS. In both cases, the individual shares determined (508 UPF-RS and 506 UPF-RS) fall within the ITCMD exemption range provided for in Article 18 of State Law No. 8,821/1989, which covers shares up to 2,000 UPF-RS. Therefore, the *causa mortis* transfer of the shares from both ascendants results in zero tax burden for the heirs under the current regime.
Even when designing the scenario after the adaptation to Complementary Law no. 227/2026, with the expansion of the tax base to the market value of assets and a potential increase in rates up to 8%, the individual shares of ascendants would remain at modest levels. The amounts of R$ 14,391.00 and R$ 14,350.00, equivalent to approximately 508 and 506 UPF-RS, respectively, remain far below the taxable threshold of 2,000 UPF-RS. This indicates that these shares would hardly be reached by taxation, even with a legislative review of the exemption brackets.
The main tax vulnerability in the new regime does not lie in the *causa mortis* succession of ascendants, but in potential future donations of quotas among the partners themselves or in corporate reorganizations. In these hypotheses, the calculation base by market value of assets, plus goodwill, could generate a more significant tax impact. However, the studied family “holding” maintains its succession viability in the current scenario, requiring continuous monitoring of the state legislative adjustments planned for 2026 and 2027.
Impact Analysis: Hypothetical Scenario
To demonstrate the effectiveness of the succession planning adopted by the family, a hypothetical scenario was constructed in which the descendants would not have had prior participation in the corporate structure. In this case, the entirety of the “holding” shares would be distributed exclusively between the two ascending spouses, in the proportion of 50% for each, maintaining the same net worth of R$ 4,100,000.00.
Projecting the passing of Ascendant 1, holder of 50% of the shares, the value of the transferred shares would be R$ 2,050,000.00. After the 50% division for the surviving spouse (R$ 1,025,000.00), the inheritance of R$ 1,025,000.00 would be shared among the five descendants, resulting in an individual share of R$ 205,000.00. Converted to UPF-RS, this amount is equivalent to approximately 7,237 UPF-RS per heir.
In Hypothetical Scenario 1, under the current regime of State Law no. 8.821/1989, the share of 7,237 UPF-RS falls within the range of 5,001 to 20,000 UPF-RS, to which a rate of 4% corresponds. Applying this rate to the full value of the share, the ITCMD due by each heir would reach R$ 8,200.00. For the death of Ascendant 1, the total ITCMD would be R$ 41,000.00. The same reasoning applies to Ascendant 2, who also holds 50% of the shares, resulting in the same amount. Thus, the total accumulated ITCMD for both deaths would be R$ 82,000.00.
In Hypothetical Scenario 2, which projects the full effectiveness of Complementary Law no. 227/2026 and the possibility of increasing tax rates, a rate of 6% was considered. Maintaining the individual share of R$ 205,000.00, the ITCMD per heir would reach R$ 12,300.00. The total ITCMD for the death of each ascendant would be R$ 61,500.00, totaling R$ 123,000.00 for both. This 6% projection is a conservative estimate, as the share of 7,237 UPF-RS would still be below the R$ 50,000 UPF-RS bracket, which currently corresponds to the 6% rate in Rio Grande do Sul.
The comparison between the real case studied and the hypothetical scenarios unequivocally reveals the economic effectiveness of the succession planning implemented by the family. In the real case, the progressive anticipation of shares to the descendants, including the compensation for inheritance anticipation for Descendant 5, reduced the participation of the ascendants to low percentages of the share capital. This distribution resulted in individual shares below the ITCMD exemption range, making the *causa mortis* transfer entirely exempt under the current regime.
In contrast, in the hypothetical scenario, where the ascendants would hold 50% of the shares each, the total tax burden accumulated upon the death of both would reach R$ 82,000.00 under the current system (4% rate), potentially reaching R$ 123,000.00 with a 6% rate in the projected scenario. This difference quantifies the estimated tax savings between R$ 82,000.00 and R$ 123,000.00, depending on the applicable regulatory scenario. This result reinforces the viability and efficiency of the family “holding” as a lawful succession and tax planning strategy, in compliance with the principles of legality and freedom of initiative.
In summary interpretation, the research demonstrated that the family “holding”, in the studied case, remains a viable and tax-efficient instrument for succession planning, even in the face of changes promoted by the Tax Reform. The progressive anticipation of quotas to descendants was crucial for the *causa mortis* transmission from ascendants to result in a null tax burden, both in the current regime and in the projected scenario. In addition to tax benefits, the “holding” preserves advantages of asset organization, family governance, and reduction of intergenerational conflicts, purposes that remain relevant regardless of legislative changes. However, the viability of the structure requires continuous monitoring of future state regulations, especially regarding the review of exemption brackets and the effective implementation of market value assessment.
4. Conclusion
This study analyzed the feasibility of maintaining family holdings as an instrument for estate planning in light of the changes introduced by Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and Complementary Law No. 227/2026, especially regarding the Tax on Transfer causa mortis and Donation of Any Assets or Rights [ITCMD]. Through a case study of a pre-existing family holding in Rio Grande do Sul, with assets valued at approximately R$ 4.1 million, it was found that the strategy of progressive anticipation of quotas to descendants was crucial. It was identified that the causa mortis transfer of the ascendants’ quotas resulted in a zero tax burden for the heirs, as the individual shares calculated fell within the ITCMD exemption range, even with the projection of an expanded tax base to market value and the possibility of increased rates up to 8%. This approach generated estimated tax savings between R$ 82,000.00 and R$ 123,000.00, quantifying the efficiency of the adopted estate planning.
The study’s main contribution lies in demonstrating that the family holding company remains a viable and tax-efficient instrument for estate planning, while also preserving significant advantages in asset organization, family governance, and reduction of intergenerational conflicts. However, the structure’s viability is not static, as the full effectiveness of the new calculation base rules and the potential increase in tax rates by the Rio Grande do Sul legislator demand continuous monitoring and periodic reevaluation of the strategy. It was observed that the main future tax risk factor lies not in the structure itself, but in the possible revision of exemption thresholds and the requirement for market value assessment of shares in donations or corporate reorganizations. Therefore, it is suggested that a new impact study be conducted as soon as State Law no. 8,821/1989 is adapted to the provisions of Complementary Law no. 227/2026, in order to analyze the practical effects of future state regulations.
Bibliographic References
Albano, A. 2024. O impacto federativo da Reforma Tributária: a Emenda Constitucional nº 132/2023. Revista Carioca De Direito, 5(1), 67-84. Disponível em: https://revistacarioca.openjournalsolutions.com.br/index.php/rcd/article/view/154. Acesso em 29 mar. 2024.
Barufaldi, A.; Barufaldi, C.; Barufaldi, L. F. 2024. Estudos de Direito para Famílias Empresárias: homenagem aos 50 anos da Barufaldi Advogados. Livraria do Advogado. Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brasil.
Brasil. 1988. Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil, de 05 de outubro de 1988. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, 05 out. 1988.
Chizzotti, A. 2003. A pesquisa qualitativa em ciências humanas e sociais: evolução e desafios. Revista Portuguesa de Educação, vol. 16, núm. 2. Universidade do Minho Braga, Portugal. Disponível em: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=37416210. Acesso em: 27 fev. 2025.
Coêlho, S. C. N. 2021. Curso de Direito Tributário Brasileiro. 16ed. Forense, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Gagliano, P. S.; Pamplona Filho, R. 2023. Manual de Direito Civil. 7ed. SaraivaJur, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Godoy, A. S. 1995. Pesquisa Qualitativa: Tipos Fundamentais. Revista de Administração de Empresas. São Paulo, São Paulo, Brasil. Disponível em: www.scielo.br/pdf/rae/v35n3/a04v35n3.pdf. Acesso em: 27 fev. 2025.
Kfouri Jr., A. 2018. Curso de Direito Tributário. 4ed. Saraiva, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Mamede, G.; Mamede, E. C. 2023. Holding familiar e suas vantagens: planejamento jurídico e econômico do patrimônio e da sucessão familiar. 15ed. Atlas, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Nisbet, J.; Watt, J. 1978. Case Study. Readguide 26: Guides in Education Research. University of Nottingham School of Education, Reino Unido.
Peixoto, U. V. M. 2025. Holding Familiar e Planejamento Sucessório na Prática. 3ed. Cronus, Leme, SP, Brasil.
Rosa, C. P. da. 2023. Planejamentos sucessórios: teoria e prática. 2ed. JusPodivm, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Article originating from the Course Conclusion Work of the Specialization in Tax Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform