October 27, 2026
Sellers’ Perception of CRM and Sales Performance in a Software Company
Lauro Cesar de Campos Biazorlo; Vanilde de Castro
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601048
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
The digital transformation in the software sector has driven the adoption of customer relationship management (CRM) systems as an essential tool for commercial organization and managerial control. The introduction of CRM altered routines, redefined operational practices, and influenced salespeople’s perception of performance and autonomy. The study aimed to understand, through the perception of salespeople from a software company, the impacts of CRM implementation on commercial performance, considering the reduction in sales observed after its adoption. A quantitative approach was adopted, with the application of a structured Likert scale questionnaire to 47 salespeople, complemented by documentary analysis of commercial funnel indicators. The results indicated a positive evaluation of the implementation process, with emphasis on training, communication, and managerial support. In routine, an increase in activity registration and greater organization of opportunities were observed, although the perception of changes in daily operations was heterogeneous. In commercial performance, there was greater recognition of changes in closing than in sales volume. The autonomy dimension pointed to intensified monitoring and greater influence of the system on work evaluation, with less convergence regarding independence in negotiations. Documentary analysis revealed that the drop in conversion in 2025 was influenced by an atypical event in January; excluding this period, an improvement in funnel efficiency was observed, with an increase in conversion and the number of deals won, despite a reduction in the average ticket. The investigation contributed to the understanding of CRM’s effects in the commercial environment, highlighting differences between salespeople’s perception and operational indicators.
Keywords: Autonomy; Sales force; Sales funnel; Operational indicators; Digital transformation.
1. Introduction
Digital transformation has been redefining the business landscape, with the software sector at the forefront of this evolution, driving the pursuit of efficiency and competitiveness (Mattila, 2021). In this context, the adoption of customer relationship management (CRM) systems has become a central strategy for optimizing commercial processes and strengthening managerial control (Alavi, 2021). The global CRM market reflects this importance, with projections indicating substantial growth, exceeding eighty billion dollars by 2027 (Oliveira et al., 2025). Such systems are designed to centralize customer data, automate sales tasks, and enhance sales funnel management, aiming to improve organizational performance (Martinho et al., 2025). However, the mere implementation of advanced technology does not automatically guarantee the expected results, often generating challenges related to user adaptation and the redefinition of operational practices (Franck & Dampérat, 2022).
CRM, in its essence, is a strategic approach that restructures customer interaction and sales force management (Chatterjee et al., 2021). It optimizes the sales cycle through data collection and analysis, automation, and process standardization, seeking to improve commercial efficiency and performance (Khlif, 2021). Commercial performance is a complex concept, traditionally measured by sales volume, conversion rate, and average ticket size (Lima, 2019). However, the perception of salespeople, direct users of the system, is a critical factor that can diverge from quantitative data, influencing the acceptance and effectiveness of CRM in the work routine (Micallef et al., 2024; Giovannetti et al., 2022).
The introduction of CRM also reshapes the dynamics of autonomy and managerial control over the sales team. Salespeople, who previously had greater flexibility, now face intensified monitoring and standardization of workflows (Guenzi & Nijssen, 2021; Siegel et al., 2022). This change, while increasing predictability, raises questions about the perception of independence, as control systems can alter the sense of autonomy (Fujii, 2024). The tension between managerial control and salesperson autonomy is a central challenge in digitized commercial management, and its resolution directly impacts team motivation and engagement (Tienken et al., 2023; Jalo & Pirkkalainen, 2024). Organizational culture also influences how these changes are perceived and assimilated by professionals (Cao et al., 2025; Hasan et al., 2025).
In the specific scenario of a software company, the implementation of CRM is seen as a strategic step to optimize the sales funnel and opportunity management (Vásquez-Ruiz et al., 2024). However, the observation of a reduction in sales after the system’s adoption raises crucial questions about the real impacts of technology on commercial performance. This dissonance between theoretical potential and empirical results demands in-depth investigation of the salespeople’s experience. The drop in commercial volume can be influenced by factors such as resistance, inadequate training, bureaucratization of routine, or decreased autonomy (Peña et al., 2024). The analysis of the perception of professionals, the primary users of the system, is fundamental to unraveling the complexities of this relationship and identifying the causes of the variation in results (Mukhopadhyay et al., 2025; Nilashi et al., 2023).
The relevance of this study lies in filling a gap by confronting sellers’ perception with operational performance indicators, offering a holistic view of CRM effects in a real commercial environment. The investigation is justified by the need to understand the nuances of technological implementation and its non-linear developments, especially when initial results diverge from expectations. The detailed analysis of sellers’ experiences and sales funnel data allows for the identification of friction points and improvement opportunities, contributing to more effective management of future CRM implementations and the development of strategies that align technology with the needs and perceptions of the sales force. Thus, the objective of this work is to understand, through the perception of sellers from a software company, the impacts of CRM implementation on the organization’s commercial performance, considering the reduction in sales observed after its adoption and the changes in operational sales funnel indicators.
2. Material and Methods
The present research was characterized as applied, seeking to produce knowledge directed towards the understanding and possible improvement of a concrete situation experienced by a software company. This nature was chosen with the intention of generating empirical evidence capable of supporting managerial decisions related to the implementation of the customer relationship management (CRM) system and the performance of the sales team. According to Gil (2019), applied research aims to produce knowledge with the potential for practical use, bringing theory closer to organizational reality.
The methodological approach adopted was predominantly quantitative, justified by the need to measure perceptions through structured variables and to statistically analyze relationships between constructs defined in the data collection instrument. Creswell (2014) argues that quantitative research is appropriate when the researcher seeks to examine relationships between variables, test hypotheses, or identify patterns through numerically analyzed data, which aligned with the objectives of this study.
Regarding the specific objectives, the research assumed a descriptive and explanatory character. The descriptive dimension was related to the characterization of the sellers’ profile and the mapping of their perceptions about different aspects of the CRM system implementation. Hair et al. (2019) affirm that descriptive studies allow the identification of characteristics of a certain group, phenomenon, or situation, offering a structured overview of the investigated variables, which was essential for the present work.
The explanatory dimension was justified by the intention to analyze possible relationships between the investigated variables, seeking to understand how certain factors were associated with the perception of commercial performance. According to Hair et al. (2019), explanatory research contributes to broadening the understanding of interactions between variables and their implications in the organizational context, strengthening the analytical consistency of the study and allowing for a deeper understanding of the impacts of CRM.
The study was conducted in a single software company, located in Iracemápolis, São Paulo, Brazil, as indicated in the author’s affiliation. The unit of analysis consisted of the active salespeople of this organization, who are the direct users of the CRM system. Primary data collection, through a questionnaire, occurred over a specific two-day period, between April 13 and 14, 2026, while documentary analysis covered records prior to and after the CRM implementation.
The population of interest comprised all salespeople from the investigated software company. The sample consisted of 47 salespeople, who participated in the survey through a structured questionnaire. The participant selection criteria were defined by their role as salespeople in the company and their access to the CRM system, characterizing a convenience sample, without any claim of statistical representativeness for a broader universe.
The technical procedure adopted for primary data collection was the “survey”, carried out by applying a structured questionnaire to the salespeople. This choice was justified by the need to collect standardized data directly from the participants, enabling the measurement of perceptions, attitudes, and experiences related to the CRM implementation. Hair et al. (2019) highlight the suitability of the “survey” method for obtaining information from a specific group with a structured instrument, favoring statistical analysis.
The structured questionnaire was developed from a review of the academic literature on CRM, digital transformation in sales, commercial performance, and organizational change. It was composed of six distinct thematic blocks, each addressing a relevant aspect for the research objectives. The statements were constructed neutrally, avoiding interpretive directions, and organized on a five-point Likert scale, ranging from 1 (totally disagree) to 5 (totally agree).
Thematic blocks included the sociodemographic and professional profile of the respondents, allowing for sample characterization and enabling comparative analyses between different groups, as highlighted by Simões (2021) and Batista (2023). Another block detailed the usage profile and frequency of the CRM, considering that exposure and operational proficiency influence the experience reported by salespeople, as addressed by Sambento (2012) and Maria Filho (2020).
The evaluation of the CRM implementation process was addressed by items that examined planning, training, internal communication, and managerial monitoring, central elements for team adherence and the perception of implementation quality (Simões, 2021; Maria Filho, 2020). The impact on the work routine was investigated to understand the operational changes resulting from technological adoption, measuring the registration effort and changes in daily commercial activities (Protas, 2025; Sambento, 2012).
The measurement of the perception of commercial performance after the adoption of CRM addressed perceived changes in sales volume, closing dynamics, and results tracking from the salesperson’s perspective (Lima, 2019; Matielo, 2022). Finally, a specific block was dedicated to managerial autonomy and control, recognizing that CRM systems can alter monitoring patterns and evaluation criteria perceived by the sales team (Zanata, 2024; Sambento, 2012).
In parallel with the survey, document analysis was used as a complementary procedure, consisting of consulting internal company records. This technique allowed for the examination of already registered information, contributing to the contextualization of the investigated phenomenon and to the deepening of the interpretation of data collected by other techniques, as advocated by Marconi and Lakatos (2021), who emphasize the relevance of documentary sources for research.
The documentary analysis focused on the evaluation of internal company reports, commercial performance indicators, and operational records linked to the sales funnel. It included data on opportunity conversion rates, closed business volume, and stages of the commercial process before and after CRM implementation. The procedure aimed to empirically contextualize the research problem, allowing for the confrontation of salespersons’ perceptions with formal evidence of organizational performance.
Reading the documented workflows and historical indicators made it possible to identify changes in the commercial dynamics associated with the system’s adoption, contributing to a structured understanding of the sales reduction observed in the period after implementation. The data were compared by period and by type of sales process, separating scenarios with and without atypical events to avoid distortions in the indicators, also evaluating variations in the average ticket and conversion efficiency over time.
For the treatment and analysis of the quantitative data collected through the questionnaire, a statistical analysis of the responses was performed. Spearman correlation tests were applied, considering the ordinal nature of the scale used, to examine relationships between variables. Furthermore, comparisons were made between groups, especially between salespeople who worked at the company before the CRM implementation and those admitted later, using non-parametric tests suitable for the sample size. When pertinent, simple or multiple linear regression analyses were conducted to verify the association between independent variables and the dependent variable related to the perception of commercial performance.
The research was exempted from submission to the Research Ethics Committee (CEP), as it falls within the established guidelines for studies in Human and Social Sciences without direct participant identification and without exposure to risks. This exemption is provided for in Resolution No. 510, of April 7, 2016, of the National Health Council (CNS), and is formalized by filling out the Ethical Considerations Form (ECF), in accordance with the institutional guidelines applicable to the development of Final Course Projects (TCC).
3. Results and Discussion
The analysis of the research results, which combined data from a quantitative survey with salespeople and a documentary analysis of commercial indicators, offers a multifaceted understanding of the impacts of implementing a customer relationship management (CRM) system in a software company. The findings reveal both the perception of direct users and operational performance, allowing for a comparison between subjective perspectives and objective evidence. Initially, the sociodemographic and professional profile of the participants, although not presented in an explicit table in this section, showed a sample predominantly composed of professionals in the intermediate career stage (35 to 44 years old, 40.40%), with consolidated experience in software sales (40.40% with 1 to 3 years, 36.20% with 7 years or more) and high academic qualifications (46.80% with complete higher education, 27.70% with postgraduate studies). The majority (63.80%) were already working at the company before the CRM implementation, which is crucial for evaluating the perception of changes. This sample composition, with an experienced and well-educated sales force, suggests an ability to adapt and a solid foundation for understanding the nuances of the tool, but it may also indicate greater resistance to changes in established routines, as pointed out by Giovannetti et al. (2022) regarding salespeople’s resistance to customer-driven changes. The male predominance (70.20%) and the balance between types of roles (external sales, hybrid, and internal sales with 36.20%, 31.90%, and 31.90%, respectively) provide a robust panorama for interpreting perceptions, indicating that experiences with the CRM are shaped by different operational contexts within the same organization.
The usage profile and frequency of the CRM by salespeople, although not detailed in a specific table in this section, revealed intensive use of the system. The majority of participants (72.30%) access the CRM several times a day, with a daily time allocation concentrated between 1 and 2 hours (38.30%) and 30 minutes to 1 hour (29.80%). Furthermore, 42.60% state they always use the CRM in all stages of the sale, and 38.30% do so frequently. Familiarity with the system is predominantly moderate (51.10%) to high (29.80%), with a small portion (6.40%) indicating low familiarity. This data suggests that the CRM is deeply integrated into the company’s sales routine, acting as a central tool for managing daily activities. The high frequency of use and the time dedicated indicate that the system is not perceived as a marginal add-on, but rather as an essential component of the work journey. This integration is consistent with the literature that advocates for CRM as a pillar of digital transformation in sales, where exposure and operational mastery directly influence the salesperson’s experience (Sambento, 2012; Maria Filho, 2020). The low familiarity in a small portion of the sample, however, may signal the need for continuous training programs or individualized support to ensure that all team members achieve a level of proficiency that maximizes the system’s benefits, preventing a lack of mastery from becoming a bottleneck for individual and collective productivity. The literature on technology adoption in sales, as discussed by Jalo (2024), emphasizes that user resistance can be a significant obstacle, and the high familiarity observed in most respondents suggests that the company has managed to mitigate some of this initial resistance.
The evaluation of the CRM implementation process, whose data were collected through specific items in the questionnaire, showed a broadly positive perception from the salespeople. The average agreement with the statement “The CRM implementation was conducted in a structured manner” reached 4.17 (on a 5-point scale), with 83.00% of responses in the agreement categories (4-5). Similarly, adequate training to use the system obtained an average of 4.17, with 87.20% agreement. The communication of changes in commercial processes was perceived as clear (average of 4.30, 85.10% agreement), and managerial support during the adaptation period registered the highest average (4.32) and the highest agreement (91.50%). These results indicate that the company conducted the CRM implementation in an exemplary manner, aligned with best practices in project management and organizational change. The literature corroborates that a well-structured implementation process, with planning, training, effective internal communication, and managerial support, is fundamental for team adherence and the perception of implementation quality (Simões, 2021; Maria Filho, 2020; Tienken, 2023). The high agreement and low dispersion in responses for these items suggest that the company managed to create a supportive environment that facilitated the transition to the new system, minimizing initial adoption barriers and behavioral resistance that often accompany the introduction of new technologies, as warned by Jalo (2024). The absence of significant disagreement on these points shifts the focus of the discussion to the long-term operational and strategic effects of the CRM, rather than problems in the initial phase.
The impact of CRM on the daily work routine of salespeople was evaluated with averages ranging from 3.62 to 4.30. The item “The system contributes to the organization of my sales opportunities” obtained the highest average (4.30) and 80.90% agreement, indicating a strong perception of organizational benefit. However, the statement “The use of CRM altered my daily work routine” presented an average of 3.62 and greater dispersion (standard deviation of 1.23), with 55.30% agreement, but also 29.80% neutral responses and 14.90% disagreement. This suggests a heterogeneous adaptation to the new routine. The recognition that “The system requires detailed recording of commercial activities” (average of 3.94, 74.50% agreement) and that “The time dedicated to filling in information is relevant in my routine” (average of 3.87, 66.00% agreement) reinforces the idea that CRM increased formalization and administrative workload. These findings are in line with the literature that discusses how sales technologies simultaneously introduce operational demands and functional resources (Shin et al., 2024). While the system improves the organization and control of activities, it also requires greater recording effort, which can be perceived as an increase in bureaucracy, as highlighted by Mukhopadhyay (2025). The dispersion in responses about the alteration of the daily routine may be attributed to different working styles of salespeople or their individual ability to adapt to more structured processes. To mitigate negative perceptions, the company could focus on optimizing recording processes, perhaps through integrations with other tools or automation of repetitive tasks, ensuring that the time dedicated to CRM is perceived as an investment that generates value, and not just as an additional burden.
The perception of commercial performance after CRM adoption revealed more moderate means compared to the implementation and routine dimensions. The item “My commercial performance was impacted after CRM implementation” obtained a mean of 3.64, with 57.40% agreement, but a significant portion (31.90%) remained neutral. The perception of change in sales volume (“Sales volume changed after system adoption”) was the lowest, with a mean of 3.32 and greater dispersion (standard deviation of 1.16), showing 40.40% agreement, 34.00% neutrality, and 25.50% disagreement. On the other hand, the item “The sales closing process was altered with the use of CRM” obtained a mean of 3.62 and 59.60% agreement. This variability in responses suggests that the impacts of CRM on commercial performance are not perceived homogeneously by the team. Literature, such as Habel et al. (2025) and Franck and Dampérat (2022), indicates that commercial automation technologies do not guarantee a direct and immediate increase in sales, with their effects being conditioned by the quality of the funnel, the type of client, and the operational context. The dissociation between the perception of changes in the closing process and the limited perception of an increase in sales volume is a critical point. This may indicate that, although CRM has refined the final stages of the funnel, salespeople do not necessarily associate this improvement with a tangible increase in sales results. The presence of neutral and disagreeing responses in sales volume may reflect the complexity of isolating the impact of CRM from other market variables or commercial strategies, or even the need for a longer period for the benefits to materialize and be clearly perceived by salespeople.
In the dimension of managerial autonomy and control, the results indicated an intensification of monitoring and standardization of evaluation criteria. The item “The use of CRM increased the level of monitoring of commercial activities” obtained the highest average (4.30) and 83.00% agreement, while “The use of CRM influences how my work is evaluated” registered an average of 4.21 and 83.00% agreement. “The system made the performance evaluation criteria clearer” also showed high agreement (68.10%, average of 3.85). However, the statement “My autonomy to conduct negotiations was altered after implementation” obtained the lowest average (3.38) and the highest dispersion (standard deviation of 1.24), with 42.60% agreement, 36.20% neutrality, and 21.30% disagreement. These data corroborate the view of Fujii (2024) and Zanata (2024), who argue that sales control systems, such as CRM, expand the capacity for monitoring and directing activities, but can affect the salesperson’s perception of autonomy. The high agreement with increased monitoring and the system’s influence on work evaluation suggests that CRM is perceived as a managerial control tool, which can lead to greater clarity in performance criteria, but also a feeling of less independence. The coexistence of intermediate and dissenting responses regarding autonomy in negotiations highlights the challenge of balancing control and autonomy in digitized sales management, a central theme in the literature (Guenzi, 2021). While monitoring can bring gains in standardization and predictability, the company must be careful not to undermine the motivation and decision-making capacity of salespeople, which are crucial in dynamic commercial environments.
The cross-referencing of data with the sociodemographic and professional profile of the participants, whose dimension means were analyzed, revealed interesting patterns. Although not presented as a specific table in this section, the analysis indicated that younger salespeople (up to 24 years old) and with less experience (less than 1 year) showed the highest means in all dimensions (implementation, routine, performance, and autonomy). For example, the group up to 24 years old registered means of 4.75 for implementation, 4.25 for routine, 4.50 for performance, and 4.25 for autonomy. In contrast, the group aged 55 or older presented the lowest mean in performance (2.83). Professionals with postgraduate degrees tended to have lower means, especially in performance (3.26) and autonomy (3.65), while those with a complete high school education registered the highest means in all dimensions. These findings suggest that familiarity with digital technologies and an orientation towards innovation, often more present in younger and less experienced generations, positively influence the perception of CRM and its impact on performance, as pointed out by Silva et al. (2023). The greater adaptation of professionals with less work experience may be attributed to lower resistance to change and greater proximity to digital tools, while more experienced salespeople may have more ingrained routines and, therefore, a more critical perception of the changes imposed by the system. This heterogeneity in responses underscores the need for differentiated training and support strategies, adapted to the different profiles of the sales team, to ensure that CRM is perceived as a facilitator for everyone, and not just for a specific segment.
The associations between the dimensions, analyzed through Spearman correlation coefficients, revealed the degree of proximity between the investigated constructs. Table 1, which details these correlations, shows that all combinations presented positive values, indicating that the dimensions move in the same direction. The relationship between implementation and autonomy (0.584) and between routine and autonomy (0.578) stand out, suggesting that successful implementation and an organized work routine are strongly associated with the perception of autonomy. However, the most intense correlation was observed between performance and autonomy (0.664), which is a crucial finding. This implies that the greater the perceived autonomy of salespeople, the greater their perception of commercial performance. This strong link between autonomy and performance is a point of convergence with the literature discussing the motivation and engagement of the sales force in digitized environments (Guenzi, 2021). Perceived autonomy, even in a context of greater monitoring by the CRM, appears to be a key factor for salespeople to feel that the tool contributes to their results. On the other hand, the associations of lower magnitude, such as between routine and performance (0.435), indicate that, although the CRM organizes the routine, this organization does not always translate directly into a uniform perception of performance improvement. The variation in correlation coefficients reinforces the complexity of the interactions between the dimensions, suggesting that the mere adoption of a technology is not sufficient; how it is implemented and how it affects salespeople’s autonomy and control is determinant for the perception of success.
Table 1. Spearman correlations between dimensions
|
Dimension |
Implementation |
Routine |
Performance |
Autonomy |
|
Implementation |
0,434 |
0,479 |
0,584 |
|
|
Routine |
0,434 |
0,435 |
0,578 |
|
|
Performance |
0,479 |
0,435 |
0,664 |
|
|
Autonomy |
0,584 |
0,578 |
0,664 |
Source: Original research results
Figure 1 offers a visual synthesis of the net agreement levels of the evaluated items, organized by analytical dimension, allowing an overview of the intensity of positive responses.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Net agreement of questionnaire items by analytical dimension
In the implementation dimension, the highest net agreement values are concentrated in managerial follow-up (89.4%), structured implementation (83.0%), communicated changes (83.0%), and adequate training (80.8%). These results reinforce the team’s positive perception of the CRM adoption process management, indicating that the company invested in crucial elements for the tool’s acceptance. This high agreement in support and organization aspects is a differential, as the literature, such as Bin Hammad et al. (2024), highlights that failure to align strategy, leadership, and the operational team during the transition can lead to assimilation difficulties and resistance. The strong perception of managerial follow-up, in particular, suggests that leadership played an active and visible role, which is vital for change management.
In the routine dimension, the organization of opportunities reaches 78.8% net agreement, followed by detailed registration (63.9%) and filling time (57.5%). The item “altered daily routine” shows a lower value (40.4%), indicating less consensus on the overall impact on routine. This distribution reveals that, although CRM is effective in organizing and detailing activities, the perception of how it alters daily work is more varied. This can be interpreted as a heterogeneous adaptation, where some salespeople see the change as positive, while others may feel an increase in administrative burden or a loss of flexibility, as discussed by Protas (2025) and Sambento (2012) regarding registration effort and changes in daily commercial activities.
In the performance dimension, the net agreement values are notably lower compared to the other dimensions. The item “performance impacted” registers 46.8%, and “altered closing” 40.5%. The item “sales volume changed” presents the lowest value among all items, with only 14.9% net agreement. This low perception of direct impact on sales volume is a critical finding and contrasts with the common expectation that CRM would boost sales. Literature, such as Habel et al. (2025), suggests that commercial automation technologies do not guarantee a direct increase in sales, and their effects are conditioned by multiple factors. The discrepancy between the perception of an altered closing process and the absence of a clear impact on sales volume may indicate that, although the system optimizes pipeline management, the final results in terms of sales volume may be influenced by external variables or by a longer adaptation period for the benefits to translate into numbers.
Finally, in the autonomy and control dimension, monitoring increased (80.9%) and CRM-influenced evaluation (78.7%) show high net agreement, while “clearer criteria” registers 57.5%. Altered autonomy, however, is the item with the lowest net agreement (21.3%) in this dimension. These results reinforce the perception that CRM intensifies managerial control and standardizes evaluation criteria, which can be seen as positive for clarity, but also raises questions about the independence of salespeople. The low agreement on the alteration of autonomy suggests that the team has divided perceptions on how the system affects their negotiation freedom, a sensitive point in sales management, where the balance between control and autonomy is fundamental for motivation and performance (Zanata, 2024; Sambento, 2012).
In summary, the highest levels of net agreement are concentrated in the items related to the implementation process and managerial follow-up, indicating a robust acceptance of the initial process. The lowest levels appear in items related to direct sales variation and negotiation autonomy. This difference between the extremes points to greater operational adherence to the system and a lower perception of direct impact on commercial results and individual independence. The results reinforce the presence of more consistent responses in the aspects of control and organization of activities, but also highlight areas where the benefits of CRM are not yet uniformly perceived or where they generate tensions, such as in salesperson autonomy and sales volume.
The documentary results of the commercial funnel provide a crucial empirical perspective to complement the sellers’ insights. Table 2 presents the commercial conversion indicators, considering the “Base” and “New” processes, in two scenarios: with and without the inclusion of January 2025.
Table 2. Commercial conversion by process, year and comparison scenario
|
Scenario |
Year |
Sales Process |
Registered |
Earnings |
Conversion |
95% CI |
|
Full year |
2024 |
Foundation |
3688 |
2266 |
61,40% |
59,9%-63,0% |
|
Full year |
2024 |
New |
1143 |
391 |
34,20% |
31,5%-37,0% |
|
Full year |
2025 |
Foundation |
7528 |
2420 |
32,10% |
31,1%-33,2% |
|
Full year |
2025 |
New |
2609 |
588 |
22,50% |
21,0%-24,2% |
|
As of January/2025 |
2024 |
Foundation |
3688 |
2266 |
61,40% |
59,9%-63,0% |
|
As of January/2025 |
2024 |
New |
1143 |
391 |
34,20% |
31,5%-37,0% |
|
As of January/2025 |
2025 |
Foundation |
3615 |
2284 |
63,20% |
61,6%-64,7% |
|
As of January/2025 |
2025 |
New |
1391 |
559 |
40,20% |
37,6%-42,8% |
Source: Original research results
The annual analysis, including all months, reveals a significant reduction in conversion in 2025 for the Base process, dropping from 61.40% in 2024 to 32.10%, even with a substantial increase in the volume of registered opportunities (from 3,688 to 7,528). A similar situation is observed in the New process, with conversion decreasing from 34.20% to 22.50%, accompanied by an increase in registrations (from 1,143 to 2,609). This drop in conversion, despite the higher volume of opportunities, is a concerning finding that contrasts with the expectation of efficiency improvement that a CRM generally promises. Literature, such as Micallef et al. (2024), discusses that the introduction of digital technologies can generate tensions and does not always translate into immediate performance improvements, especially during transition periods. Figure 2a, which illustrates the operational evolution of the funnel, confirms this behavior by presenting an atypical peak in registrations in January 2025, exceeding 5,000 records, a value much higher than in other months.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Operational dynamics of the sales funnel with scale adjusted to avoid visual compression: a) registered opportunities per month, in full scale; b) registered opportunities from February to December; c) operational conversion from February to December, with January/2025 outside the scale; d) daily distribution of registrations in January 2025
The exclusion of the month of January 2025 drastically alters the interpretation of the data. In the Base process, conversion, instead of decreasing, increases from 61.40% in 2024 to 63.20% in 2025, with similar registration volumes (3,688 versus 3,615). For the New process, conversion also improves, going from 34.20% to 40.20%. Figure 2b shows greater stability in registrations between February and December, while Figure 2c presents a growth in operational conversion throughout 2025, with emphasis on the final months. Figure 2d details the behavior of January 2025, revealing a concentration of 82.7% of registrations on the 9th and 10th. This volume concentrated in a short time interval distorts the aggregated indicators, artificially raising the denominator of the conversion and, consequently, reducing the final percentage when the month is considered in the annual calculation. This finding is fundamental, as it demonstrates that an atypical and concentrated event can mask the real efficiency of the sales funnel. Kerr and Franco-Santos (2023) argue that the use of multiple metrics and different analytical breakdowns is essential for an accurate assessment of sales performance, and this study exemplifies this need by showing how segmented analysis reveals an improvement in efficiency that would not be visible in aggregated data. The practical implication is that companies should be cautious when interpreting aggregated indicators and seek to contextualize the data with specific events that may influence the metrics.
Table 3 complements the documentary analysis, presenting the comparison between 2024 and 2025 regarding business volume gained, financial values, and average tickets.
Table 3. Deals won and commercial value in the accounted cut of the funnel
|
Year |
Gained business |
Project value |
Recurring value |
Total sales |
Total average ticket |
Project average ticket |
Average recurring ticket |
|
2024 |
2.657 |
BRL 5,582,333.02 |
BRL 2,306,569.36 |
BRL 7,888,902.38 |
BRL 2,969.10 |
BRL 2,100.99 |
BRL 868.11 |
|
2025 |
3.008 |
BRL 5,948,106.90 |
BRL 2,503,318.28 |
BRL 8,451,425.18 |
BRL 2,809.65 |
BRL 1,977.43 |
BRL 832.22 |
Source: Original research results
The number of deals won grew from 2,657 in 2024 to 3,008 in 2025, and the total traded value increased from R$ 7,888,902.38 to R$ 8,451,425.18. This growth in volume and total value is a positive indicator of the company’s overall commercial performance. However, the total average ticket decreased from R$ 2,969.10 to R$ 2,809.65, with similar drops in the project ticket and the recurring ticket. This reduction in the average ticket, despite the increase in the volume of deals, suggests a shift in sales composition or pricing strategy. Figure 3 details the breakdown of the variation in value per registration for the full year and for the scenario without January 2025.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Variation decomposition of the value by registration in the full year and in the scenario without January/2025.
In Figure 3a, the value per registration decreased from R$ 1,784 in 2024 to R$ 980 in 2025. The decomposition shows a significant negative impact associated with conversion (-R$ 742), while the ticket effect shows a smaller variation (-R$ 62). This reinforces that the observed drop in value per registration for the full year is predominantly linked to lower efficiency in converting opportunities, and not so much to the reduction in the average sales value. However, when excluding January 2025 (Figure 3b), the value per registration increases from R$ 1,784 to R$ 1,810, with the conversion effect showing a positive contribution (+R$ 161), while the ticket effect maintains a negative sign (-R$ 135). This inversion in the conversion effect, from negative to positive, when the atypical month is removed, is robust evidence of the importance of data contextualization. The literature on sales management, such as Oliveira et al. (2025), emphasizes the need for segmented and contextualized analyses to understand the real dynamics of the sales funnel and the impacts of technologies like CRM. The company should therefore focus on strategies to optimize opportunity conversion, perhaps by refining lead qualification or improving the team’s negotiation skills, to maximize the value generated per registration. The reduction in the average ticket, even in the adjusted scenario, deserves attention, possibly indicating the need for upselling or cross-selling strategies, or a reassessment of the product/service portfolio.
The synthesis of the research results reveals a complex interaction between salespeople’s perception and the commercial funnel’s operational indicators after the CRM implementation. On one hand, the sales team perceived the implementation process as well-structured, with adequate training, clear communication, and strong managerial follow-up. This positive perception of the initial phase is a strong point, indicating that the company managed to establish a solid foundation for technology adoption, mitigating the initial resistance that frequently accompanies such changes (Simões, 2021; Maria Filho, 2020). The CRM is also seen as an enabler in organizing opportunities and in the detailed recording of activities, which aligns with the literature on the benefits of formalization and control that these systems provide (Protas, 2025; Sambento, 2012).
However, the perception of the direct impact on commercial performance, especially on sales volume, was more moderate and heterogeneous. The low agreement on the increase in sales volume, in contrast to the perception of changes in the closing process, suggests a dissociation between operational improvement and perceived financial results. This gap is crucial and is partially explained by the documentary analysis, which revealed a drop in conversion in 2025 when January, with its atypical event of massive and unqualified registrations, is included. When this period is excluded, the sales funnel efficiency, for both “Base” and “New” processes, actually improved, with an increase in conversion and the number of deals won. This finding underscores the importance of contextualized analyses and caution in interpreting aggregated data, as advocated by Kerr and Franco-Santos (2023). Salespeople’s perception of the drop in sales may, therefore, have been influenced by this initial distortion in the data, reinforcing the need for transparent communication about the adjusted indicators.
The dimension of autonomy and managerial control also presented important nuances. While CRM was clearly perceived as an instrument that increased activity monitoring and influenced work evaluation, the perception regarding the alteration of autonomy in negotiations was divided. This tension between control and autonomy is a known challenge in digitized sales management (Guenzi, 2021; Fujii, 2024). The company must seek a balance, ensuring that increased monitoring does not stifle the initiative and decision-making capacity of salespeople, which is vital for sales success. The positive correlation between autonomy and perceived performance reinforces that, even in a more controlled environment, the feeling of independence is an important motivational factor.
The differences in perceptions among sociodemographic groups, with younger and less experienced salespeople showing greater adaptability and positive perception of CRM, are also relevant. This suggests that the company may need more personalized training and support strategies to meet the needs of different salesperson profiles, ensuring that all team members can maximize the system’s benefits (Silva et al., 2023). The density of the results, by crossing subjective perceptions with objective data, allows for a deeper understanding of CRM impacts. Successful implementation in terms of process and organization does not automatically translate into a uniform perception of performance or autonomy improvement, and documentary analysis reveals that atypical events can mask real operational efficiency. The software company, therefore, must continue to refine its CRM management strategies, focusing not only on technical optimization but also on managing expectations and communicating adjusted results to the sales team, fostering an environment where the system is perceived as a true ally for commercial success.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved by understanding, through the perception of software company salespeople, the impacts of CRM implementation on commercial performance, considering the initial reduction in sales and changes in operational indicators. The research revealed that the implementation process was perceived as well-structured, with effective training and managerial follow-up. However, the perception of the direct impact on sales volume was heterogeneous and moderate. Document analysis, crucial for contextualization, showed that the apparent drop in conversion in 2025 was a distortion caused by an atypical event of massive and unqualified registrations in January. After adjusting the data, an improvement in funnel efficiency was observed, with an increase in conversion and the number of deals won, although the average ticket size decreased. Autonomy and managerial control were perceived as intensified, with negotiation autonomy showing divided perceptions but strongly correlated with performance.
Among the limitations of this study, the analysis restricted to a single software company and the limited number of respondents stand out, which may affect the generalization of the results. Furthermore, the reliance on the declared perception of salespeople and the difficulty in completely isolating the influence of external factors to CRM on commercial results represent inherent research challenges. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the sample to include diverse organizations, compare different levels of digital maturity, and deepen the statistical analysis. It is also recommended to conduct longitudinal studies to track the evolution of CRM effects on commercial performance over time, offering a more dynamic and comprehensive view of its impacts.
Bibliographic References
Alavi, S.; Habel, J. 2021. The human side of digital transformation in sales: review and future paths. Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management 41(2), 83-86.
Chatterjee, S.; Chaudhuri, R.; Galati, A.; Vrontis, D. 2021. Adoption of ubiquitous “CRM” for operational sustainability of the firms: Moderating role of technology
Franck, R.; Dampérat, M. 2022. Influence of sales force automation on salesperson performance: A study of interpersonal and intrapersonal mediators. Recherche et Applications en Marketing (English Edition) 37(3), 59-85.
Martinho, D.; Farinha, J.; Ribeiro, V. 2025. The Impact of Customer Relationship Management Systems on Business Performance of Portuguese SMEs. Sustainability 17(12), 5647.
Mattila, M.; Yrjölä, M.; Hautamäki, P. 2021. Digital transformation of business-to-business sales: What needs to be unlearned? Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management 41(2), 113-129.
Oliveira, F.; Belitski, M.; Perez-Vega, R. 2025. Sales digitization and sales process optimisation for firm performance: Evidence from European firms. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 217, 124172.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Sales Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform