October 26, 2026
Role of leadership in ensuring psychological safety in the workplace
Ana Flávia Gimenes de Castro; Andreza Maria Luzia Baldo de Souza
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202600534
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
Psychological safety has emerged as a crucial element for promoting well-being, engagement, and performance in contemporary organizations marked by complexity and volatility. This work analyzed how leaders understand and apply practices related to psychological safety in their work teams. A descriptive public opinion survey with a mixed approach was adopted, using an anonymous online questionnaire applied to 78 leaders and managers, mostly from the communication and marketing areas. The main results revealed that most respondents were already familiar with the concept, considered its promotion essential to the leadership role, and associated it with stress reduction and illness. Leaders frequently declared practicing favorable behaviors, such as active listening, empathy, and constructive feedback. However, a significant portion had never received specific training in the area and felt only partially prepared for emotional issues. Cultural challenges were identified as the main barriers, such as the “fear culture,” punishment for errors, and inconsistency of senior leadership. It was concluded that psychological safety requires articulation between the development of leaders’ emotional competencies and the review of institutional practices that perpetuate fear and hierarchical rigidity.
Keywords: workplace well-being; organizational culture; active listening; People Management; emotional leadership.
1. Introduction
The contemporary organizational landscape is characterized by an accelerated pace of transformation, driven by technological, social, and economic advancements. In this dynamic and volatile scenario, the ability to adapt to innovations and maintain a healthy work environment have become crucial competitive differentiators. Promoting team well-being and engagement is fundamental for organizational success and sustainability.
In this context, psychological safety has emerged as a central concept. Originally described by Amy Edmondson, a professor at Harvard Business School, the term refers to the shared belief among team members that the work environment is safe for taking interpersonal risks (Edmondson, 2014). This implies the assurance that there will be no punishment or humiliation when expressing ideas, asking questions, admitting mistakes, or disagreeing with the status quo. Psychological safety transcends mere cordiality or respect, serving as the foundation for radical candor and continuous learning in organizations.
The construction of psychological safety, as proposed by Clark (2020), occurs progressively, through four interconnected dimensions. Initially, inclusion refers to the feeling of belonging and legitimate recognition within the collective. Next, learning allows the environment to admit questions, experiments, and errors as part of development, reducing the fear of judgment. Contribution safety emerges when collaborators feel confident to mobilize their skills and participate in decisions. Finally, in the challenge stage, the organizational climate encourages the expression of disagreements and the proposition of innovations, fueling continuous improvement.
The importance of leadership is undeniable in promoting these environments. The success of modern management is not limited to technical knowledge (Schein, 2004), but is intrinsically linked to the development of behavioral, relational, and emotional competencies, known as
interpersonal skills
(Goleman, 1998; Silva & Souza, 2023; Figueiredo, 2025). It is at this point that Emotional Intelligence, popularized by Daniel Goleman (1998), acts as a central mechanism for the construction of psychological safety.
The leader’s ability to recognize, understand, and manage their own emotions and those of others favors the construction of healthy interpersonal relationships, constructive conflict resolution, and the demonstration of empathy. These elements are essential for employees to feel truly welcomed, valued, and safe, which, in turn, positively impacts team performance and innovation.
The absence of psychological safety, on the other hand, carries significant consequences. Environments with low psychological safety foster defensive silence, where the fear of appearing incompetent, negative, or ignorant inhibits essential communication, resulting in the concealment of errors and the stagnation of innovation. This scenario negatively impacts organizational metrics, such as absenteeism, the
revenue
and productivity, besides increasing the incidence of mental illness among workers (Rocha et al., 2024).
Despite the recognition of the importance of psychological safety, a practical and theoretical gap persists. Many leaders, although they perceive the relevance of the topic and claim to practice favorable behaviors, such as active listening and constructive feedback, have not received specific formal training in the area. A significant portion feels only partially prepared to deal with complex emotional issues, relying more on intuition than on methodological support (Silva & Souza, 2023). Additionally, cultural barriers, such as the “fear culture,” punishment for errors, and inconsistency from senior leadership, emerge as significant obstacles to consolidating psychologically safe environments (Rocha et al., 2024).
Given these challenges and the increasing complexity of the work environment, it becomes fundamental to investigate how leadership understands and applies practices related to psychological safety. This understanding is crucial to support innovation and organizational sustainability, especially in dynamic sectors such as communication and marketing, where creativity and rapid adaptation are critical factors. In this regard, the present study aims to investigate how leadership understands and applies practices related to psychological safety in their work teams, with the purpose of offering subsidies for the improvement of training for new leaders and the creation of more innovative and safe environments.
2. Material and Methods
The present study was characterized as a descriptive public opinion survey, employing a mixed methodological approach that combined quantitative and qualitative elements. This methodological choice was guided by the need to obtain a comprehensive and up-to-date overview of leadership perceptions. The central objective was to investigate how leaders understand and apply practices related to psychological safety in their work teams, as outlined in the introduction.
The research unit of analysis consisted of leaders and managers active in different sectors, with an initial prioritization for the areas of communication and marketing. The sample was composed of 78 professionals who confirmed holding leadership or team management positions. Participant selection occurred through non-probabilistic sampling, using the convenience technique, known as “snowball sampling”, through dissemination on social networks and professional groups. This approach was justified by the exploratory nature of the study and by the time and resource limitations inherent in a Course Conclusion Work.
For data collection, an anonymous, structured online questionnaire was applied, developed on the Google Forms platform. The instrument was elaborated based on the specific objectives of the research and grounded in the scientific literature on psychological safety, according to the works of Edmondson (2014) and Rocha et al. (2024), which address the impact of psychological safety on leadership. The construction of the questionnaire aimed to capture the relevant dimensions of the phenomenon studied.
The questionnaire was structured in thematic blocks, covering the participants’ profile, such as tenure and main area, and the perception of psychological safety, including the level of knowledge and understanding of the concept. Additionally, the leadership practices adopted were investigated, measuring the frequency of behaviors that promote psychological safety, and the preparation and challenges perceived by leaders, through self-assessment and identification of barriers. The instrument contained closed-ended questions for quantitative analysis and open-ended questions for qualitative content analysis.
The questionnaire was disseminated through a link shared on professional social networks, such as LinkedIn and WhatsApp, and in specific sectoral groups. This procedure allowed us to reach a diverse number of leaders and managers. Data collection was conducted in a manner that ensured the complete preservation of the respondents’ identity, guaranteeing the anonymity and confidentiality of the information provided.
The obtained responses were processed in two distinct stages. Closed-ended questions were submitted to descriptive statistical analysis, using frequency and percentage tables. This procedure allowed us to map the profile of the sample and the distribution of perceptions and practices declared by the participants. The responses to open-ended questions, in turn, were analyzed using the Content Analysis technique, following the guidelines proposed by Bardin (2016), to identify emerging thematic categories.
The ethical procedures were rigorously observed, in accordance with CNS Resolution nº 510/2016, Article 1º, sole paragraph, item I, which regulates public opinion research with anonymous participants. No sensitive or identifiable information was collected, nor any intervention on the participants. The voluntariness of participation, anonymity, and the exclusive use of data for academic purposes were assured. The Consent agreement was presented in electronic format in the introductory text of the online form, clarifying the nature, objectives, risks, and benefits of the research.
The manifestation of free and informed consent by the participants was formalized by the voluntary act of filling out and submitting the questionnaire. This act occurred after reading the preliminary information in its entirety and acknowledging that participation was conscious and without any obligation. The integrity of the respondents’ identity was preserved at all stages of data collection and analysis, aligning with ethical guidelines for non-identified research.
3. Results and Discussion
This section details the results obtained in the research, which aimed to investigate the role of leadership in ensuring psychological safety in the workplace. The initial sample of the study comprised 88 respondents, of whom 78 professionals, representing 88.6% of the total, confirmed acting in leadership or team management positions. This composition of the valid sample (n=78) is crucial, as the data collected predominantly reflect the perspective of individuals with direct responsibility for people and processes. This approach aligns with the literature, such as Rocha et al. (2024), who highlight the direct influence of leaders’ behavior on the team’s climate of trust, openness, and learning, fundamental elements for psychological safety.
Regarding prior knowledge of the concept of psychological safety, it was observed that most participants were already familiar with the topic. Among the 78 respondents, 71.8% stated they had heard of psychological safety before the survey. A portion of 19.2% declared they did not know the concept, while 9% indicated they were unsure. This overview suggests that, although the term is not universally disseminated, it already has a considerable presence in the vocabulary of leaders, an indication of its growing relevance in the organizational context, especially considering that it is a concept consolidated in international literature in recent decades.
The open-ended responses deepened the understanding of the concept, revealing that, even among the less familiar, the practical interpretation approached Edmondson (2014) and Rocha et al. (2024)’s definition. Leaders described psychological safety as the ability to “not walk on eggshells,” to make mistakes without fear of punishment, to raise doubts, disagree, ask for help, and be welcomed as a human being, not just as a “productive resource.” They explicitly mentioned an “environment of respect, trust, and listening,” free from harassment, discrimination, and humiliation, where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities, not as shame. These perceptions converge with the literature, which understands psychological safety as a pillar for learning, innovation, and well-being, and with Silva & Souza (2023), who emphasize the role of leadership’s emotional competencies.
The perception of psychological safety as an integral part of the leadership role was widely confirmed by the results. When asked if promoting psychological safety is an attribution of leadership, 88.5% of participants answered “yes” and 11.5% stated “partially”, with no negative responses. This demonstrates that, for the group investigated, the responsibility of creating an environment where people can express themselves, make mistakes, and learn without fear is not a secondary task, but a central component of the leadership function. This view is in line with Rocha et al. (2024), who point to open and empathetic leadership styles as favoring psychological safety, and with Silva & Souza (2023), who highlight emotional intelligence as a strategic competence for sustaining relationships of trust and respect.
The expected benefits of a psychologically safe environment were also widely recognized by leadership, reinforcing the convergence between their perceptions and the literature. When indicating up to three benefits, 84.6% of respondents associated psychological safety with reduced stress and illness. Improved communication and collaboration were cited by 71.8%, and increased engagement and motivation by 70.5%. Although in smaller proportions, improved productivity (46.2%) and greater innovation and creativity (39.7%) were also considered relevant, indicating that, in the leaders’ imagination, psychological safety transcends individual well-being and positively impacts organizational performance.
These results align with the synthesis by Rocha et al. (2024), who describe psychological safety as a cross-cutting variable, capable of simultaneously influencing worker well-being, interaction quality, team performance, and the ability to generate creative solutions in complex contexts. The association of psychological safety with communication, engagement, and mental health, even if not always accompanied by formal training, indicates a mature perception of the topic by leadership. This perspective corroborates the view of Silva & Souza (2023), who argue that well-developed emotional capabilities can mitigate destructive conflicts, enhance cooperation, and strengthen trust within teams.
When analyzing the practices declared by the leadership, a repertoire was identified that aligns with the conduct promoting psychological safety described in the literature. Regarding the encouragement of active listening from the team, the majority of respondents declared practicing this conduct “frequently” or “always”, with minority percentages in “sometimes” or below. This pattern suggests a clear intention to foster an environment where employee voices are valued and heard, an essential pillar for building trust and mutual respect within teams.
The same trend was observed in encouraging the expression of opinions without fear, with most responses concentrated in the “frequently” and “always” categories, indicating the intention to create spaces for team members’ positioning. Regarding the recognition of errors as part of the learning process, the data revealed a robust combination of responses in the highest frequency categories. This suggests that, in the self-image of these leaders, failures are treated as opportunities for review and growth, rather than as reasons for reprimand. This set of practices is in line with Rocha et al. (2024), who identify behaviors that protect psychological safety, and with Silva & Souza (2023), who advocate for leadership capable of recognizing vulnerabilities and managing conflicts constructively, offering fact-based feedback.
Practices related to the management of sensitive and emotional topics also followed a positive direction. A large portion of respondents indicated that they frequently offer space for discussions of difficult or uncomfortable subjects, demonstrate empathy in the face of the team’s emotional situations, and promote feedback constructively and respectfully. These attitudes are fundamental to building an environment where employees feel safe to address sensitive issues, knowing they will be heard and supported. The consistency of these practices reinforces leadership’s commitment to creating a climate of openness and trust, essential for the well-being and development of teams.
From a theoretical point of view, these attitudes can be interpreted as a manifestation of socio-emotional competencies, especially empathy, emotional self-management, and social skills. Goleman (1998) describes these competencies as pillars of emotional intelligence, while Silva & Souza (2023) reinterpret them as strategic management tools. The encouragement of questioning established practices and presenting innovative ideas, although still facing some resistance, also appeared with significant percentages in the categories “frequently” and “always”. This suggests that a relevant portion of the interviewed leaders is willing to make room for creative risk, an aspect that Rocha et al. (2024) directly relate to the level of perceived psychological safety in teams.
However, when crossing the results on declared practices with the leadership development level, an important signal was observed. The majority of respondents, 52.6%, stated they had already participated in some training on emotional leadership, mental health, or psychological safety, while 47.4% reported never having undergone this type of training. This data indicates that the topic has already reached a significant portion of leaders, suggesting a greater dissemination of the agenda in organizations and a growing awareness of the importance of socio-emotional skills in People Management. However, the existence of almost half of the sample without formal training reveals a considerable gap.
This gap is evident in the discrepancy between the recognition of the topic’s relevance and its effective systematization in management development programs. The result points to an intermediate scenario, where there is progress in the offering and access to training, but this movement does not yet uniformly reach the entire sample of leaders. Therefore, training on the subject is not fully consolidated. This situation suggests that, although there is a positive perception and an intention to apply practices that promote psychological safety, the formal knowledge base and methodological tools may be insufficient for consistent and comprehensive action by all leaders.
In parallel, 65.4% of participants declared themselves to be “partially” prepared to deal with the team’s emotional issues, and only a smaller fraction considered themselves fully prepared. This combination highlights a significant gap between intention and systematic skills development. Silva & Souza (2023) emphasize that, in many organizations, leaders are compelled to face complex emotional issues without adequate theoretical and methodological support, relying more on intuition and prior experience. This can lead to overload and inconsistent responses. Rocha et al. (2024) warn about the risk of assigning all responsibility for psychological safety to middle management without structured training programs or cultural alignment.
Cultural challenges emerged as a significant explanatory axis for this tension. In open-ended responses about the main obstacles to promoting psychological safety, the theme of “fear culture” was recurrently mentioned. Leaders reported environments where mistakes are punished, disagreements are discouraged, there are explicit or veiled threats of dismissal, authoritarian styles prevail, and pressure for short-term results overrides well-being and learning. The fear of being judged as “weak” or “permissive” when practicing empathy, the difficulty in finding time for conversations beyond operational demands, the challenge of dealing with traumas from previous leadership, and the inconsistency between institutional discourse and daily practices were also reported. This scenario directly dialogues with the conclusions of Rocha et al. (2024), who identify punitive cultures, rigid hierarchies, and lack of institutional support as factors that undermine psychological safety.
The analysis of organizational culture and the influence of senior leadership reinforced this multilevel reading. Although 47.4% of respondents consider that their organizations’ culture values openness to dialogue and the expression of diverse ideas, 41% perceive this valuation only partially, and 11.5% state that it simply does not exist. Responses regarding senior leadership behavior revealed concrete examples of how decisions, stances, and management styles at higher hierarchical levels can either strengthen or sabotage the efforts of middle managers. Some accounts described environments where senior management invests in training and encourages listening, leading by example and fostering a safe climate. However, many others pointed to situations where management is centralizing, not very open to criticism, inconsistent between discourse and practice, or even hostile to error and vulnerability, generating fear, silencing, and distrust.
This ambivalence clearly illustrates the thesis of Rocha et al. (2024), who argue that psychological safety cannot be understood solely as an individual responsibility of the immediate leader. On the contrary, it is a phenomenon that is built or undone in the complex interaction between leadership at different levels, people management policies, and the institutional culture as a whole. The lack of alignment between these elements can create an environment where individual leaders’ efforts to promote psychological safety are constantly undermined by organizational practices and top management behaviors that perpetuate insecurity and distrust, hindering the consolidation of a truly safe environment.
On the other hand, the willingness of leaders to seek development points to a significant window of opportunity. When asked about their interest in receiving additional training or capacity building to promote psychological safety, 80.8% of respondents answered “yes”, and 14.1% answered “maybe”. This indicates that more than nine out of ten participants show interest or openness to deepen their knowledge and skills in this area. This significant demand suggests that there is a recognition of the need for improvement and an active desire to acquire the necessary tools to better perform their role in building psychologically safe environments.
This demand for development reinforces the reading of Silva & Souza (2023), who indicate that leaders not only need but also wish to improve their emotional competencies, provided they find the space and support for it within organizations. This means that the issue is not limited to a technical gap, but represents a concrete opportunity for companies and educational institutions to invest in continuous training programs. Such programs should articulate theory, practice, and critical reflection on the exercise of leadership, enabling leaders to transform intention into effective action and to deal with the emotional and cultural challenges of the work environment in a more structured and conscious way.
To deepen the understanding of the phenomena investigated, the open-ended responses were submitted to Content Analysis, according to Bardin (2016), resulting in the emergence of four main categories. The first category, “Understanding the concept of psychological safety”, revealed that leaders understand psychological safety as an environment where employees can express themselves freely, without fear of punishment, embarrassment, or retaliation. The concept was associated with trust, respect, welcoming, and the freedom to question, make mistakes, ask for help, and propose ideas safely. This perception suggests a consistent understanding of the topic, often built through practical experience rather than specific formal training.
The second category, “Effective practices from the leaders’ perspective,” highlighted active listening, constructive feedback, openness to dialogue, and consistency between leadership discourse and attitudes as the most effective practices for promoting psychological safety. The responses also underscored the importance of leaders who demonstrate vulnerability, acknowledge their limitations, and treat mistakes as part of the learning process. Together, these elements reinforce the idea that psychological safety depends less on isolated actions and more on consistent, everyday behaviors that build an environment of trust and mutual respect over time.
The third category, “Challenges for promoting the theme,” revealed that the promotion of psychological safety faces significant obstacles in the organizational environment. Participants reported that pressure for results, a punitive culture, and low openness to dialogue are important barriers. Difficulties in balancing the acceptance of the team’s emotional needs with the organization’s operational demands were also mentioned. Furthermore, the lack of specific preparation to deal with sensitive issues was pointed out as a relevant limitation for leadership performance, indicating the need for support and training to face these complexities.
Finally, the fourth category, “The influence of top leadership,” showed a consensus that psychological safety strongly depends on the positioning of the upper hierarchical levels. When top leadership adopts authoritarian, inconsistent, or unreceptive postures to dialogue, the efforts of middle management tend to lose strength. On the other hand, when management promotes consistency between discourse and practice, encourages listening, and values openness to divergent ideas, a more favorable context is created for building psychologically safe teams. This underscores the importance of cultural and managerial alignment at all levels for the effective implementation of psychological safety.
In summary, the research results reveal a multifaceted scenario, marked by three simultaneous movements. Firstly, there is a high level of awareness among the responding leaders about the importance of psychological safety, which is recognized as an intrinsic part of the leadership role. They consistently associate it with benefits for mental health, engagement, communication, and performance, and describe daily practices of listening, welcoming, and feedback that align with the recommendations of authors such as Edmondson (2014) and Rocha et al. (2024) on the role of leadership in strengthening this organizational climate.
Secondly, the research highlights a structural gap between this intention and the training offered. A significant portion of leaders have never undergone formal training in socio-emotional topics, despite being frequently called upon to deal with psychological distress, complex conflicts, past traumas, and performance pressures. This discrepancy between declared practice and the lack of structured training corroborates the analysis by Silva & Souza (2023), who argue that emotional intelligence in leadership should be treated as a competence to be continuously developed, with institutional and methodological support, and not as a merely “natural” attribute.
Third, the data demonstrate that these individual leadership efforts occur within institutional contexts that are not always favorable. A culture of fear, punishment for mistakes, lack of transparent communication, authoritarianism, and inconsistency between discourse and practice at higher management levels emerge as powerful barriers to building psychologically safe environments. At this point, the empirical findings align with the theoretical conclusions of Rocha et al. (2024), which indicate that without changes in organizational culture and the stance of senior leadership, the burden of promoting psychological safety falls disproportionately on middle managers, who, despite being engaged, operate under limiting structural conditions.
Thus, the study confirms the centrality of leadership in promoting psychological safety, but also demonstrates that this responsibility cannot be isolated to individuals. Drawing on the dialogue with Rocha et al. (2024) and Silva & Souza (2023), the research indicates that consolidating psychologically safe environments requires combined actions: intentional development of emotional competencies in leadership, review of management practices that reinforce fear and punishment, and genuine commitment from senior management to align discourse and behavior. Without this articulation, a disconnect persists between what leaders value and what organizations actually enable, hindering the creation of innovative and safe environments.
4. Conclusion
This study investigated how leaders understand and apply practices related to psychological safety in their work teams. It was found that most leaders and managers were already familiar with the concept, associating it with the freedom to express ideas, make mistakes without punishment, and be welcomed in an environment of respect and trust. The promotion of psychological safety was observed to be considered an essential leadership responsibility, consistently associated with reduced stress and illness, improved communication and collaboration, and increased team engagement and motivation. Leaders reported frequently practicing behaviors such as active listening, encouraging the expression of opinions, acknowledging mistakes as part of learning, demonstrating empathy, and providing constructive feedback, aligning with behaviors that promote a psychologically safe environment.
However, a significant training gap was identified, as a considerable portion of leaders have never received specific training in the area and feel only partially prepared to deal with complex emotional issues. The results revealed that the “culture of fear”, punishment for mistakes, and inconsistency from senior leadership emerge as substantial cultural barriers, undermining the individual efforts of middle managers. The contribution of this study lies in highlighting that the consolidation of psychological safety transcends individual responsibility, requiring combined actions that include the intentional development of emotional competencies in leadership, the review of management practices that perpetuate fear and punishment, and the genuine commitment of senior management to align discourse and behavior. Convenience sampling and the descriptive nature of the research constitute limitations, suggesting that future studies could explore the effectiveness of structured training programs and the impact of cultural interventions on promoting psychological safety in different organizational contexts.
Bibliographic References
Bardin, L. 2016. Análise de conteúdo. Edições 70, Lisboa, Portugal.
Clark, T.R. 2020. The 4 stages of psychological safety: defining the path to inclusion and innovation. Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Oakland, CA, USA.
Edmondson, A. 2014. A organização sem medo. Campus, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Figueiredo, R.M. 2025. Liderança, segurança psicológica e aprendizagem. Revista de Administração Contemporânea 29(2): xx-xx.
Goleman, D. 1998. Inteligência emocional. Objetiva, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Rocha, M.; [inserir os demais autores]. 2024. Impacto da liderança na segurança psicológica em organizações: scoping review. Revista de Ciências da Administração 14(3): 418-441.
Schein, E. 2004. Cultura organizacional e liderança. 3ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Silva, N.C.; Souza, M.H.R. de. 2023. A importância da inteligência emocional como um mecanismo estratégico de gestão nas organizações. Revista Ibero-Americana de Humanidades, Ciências e Educação 9(11): 3468-3490.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in People Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform