October 20, 2026
The Impact of Feedback on Psychological Safety and Willingness to Make Mistakes
The Impact of Feedback on Psychological Safety and Willingness to Admit Mistakes
Wesley Andrews dos Reis Ferraz; Girlaynne Danusia Farias Pereira
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202602436
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
Psychological safety and feedback quality are fundamental elements for learning and innovation in contemporary organizations. The study analyzed the relationship between employees’ perception of feedback received from their managers and psychological safety to expose vulnerabilities. An applied research of a descriptive nature was conducted, with a mixed (quantitative-qualitative) approach, using a digital survey. The sample consisted of 28 employees from a financial institution in São Paulo, SP. The data collection instrument employed a 5-point Likert Scale and open-ended fields for qualitative reports. The results indicated a positive perception of feedback and psychological safety, with high averages for both. A moderate positive correlation (r = 0.595) was identified between the variables. It was found that the willingness to report errors was high, although moderate barriers persisted for disagreement in meetings. It was concluded that feedback acts as a relational practice that conditions team trust and communication openness, reducing reputational risks and favoring learning over self-image.
Keywords: Organizational Behavior; Organizational Communication; Feedback; People Management; Leadership.
1. Introduction
The contemporary organizational environment demands from teams not only operational efficiency but also continuous capacity for learning, adaptation, and innovation. In this context, psychological safety plays a central role, as it concerns the perception that the work environment is safe for interpersonal exposure. This allows people to express ideas, doubts, concerns, and mistakes without fear of embarrassment, punishment, or retaliation (Edmondson, 2019). In organizations marked by high complexity and interdependence, innovation depends precisely on this freedom to speak up, test hypotheses, revise decisions, and correct failures quickly. When fear guides interactions, knowledge tends to be retained, mistakes are hidden, and collective learning loses strength, compromising performance and value generation.
Leadership occupies a decisive position in shaping this climate, as a large part of the experiences of security or threat at work is mediated by how managers communicate with their teams. In this direction, Scott (2017) proposes the concept of Assertive Empathy, according to which leading requires combining genuine care for people with the courage to directly confront issues of performance, behavior, and development. From this perspective, feedback ceases to be just a corrective tool and becomes a relational practice that signals respect, clarity, and commitment to the growth of others. Thus, the way the leader offers feedback influences not only the quality of communication but also the team’s confidence to position themselves, disagree, ask questions, and admit mistakes without fear of humiliation.
However, the reception of feedback does not always occur in a simple or linear way. Stone and Heen (2014) argue that receiving feedback can trigger intense emotional reactions, especially when the content received threatens self-image or disrupts a person’s perception of themselves. The authors call this process identity triggers, meaning situations in which feedback is interpreted as a threat to personal value, competence, or professional legitimacy. In these cases, the individual tends to react defensively, shifting the focus from learning to self-protection. Thus, even if the feedback is intended for development, it can be perceived as judgment, which hinders listening, reduces openness to reflection, and weakens the learning potential present in the interaction.
From the perspective of behavioral change, Goldsmith (2007) highlights that successful trajectories often produce the illusion that the behaviors that yielded good results in the past will continue to be sufficient in new contexts. However, leading people in complex environments requires continuous review of habits, especially those that inhibit listening, openness to others, and willingness to learn. Leadership evolution, therefore, depends not only on technical competence but on the ability to recognize limitations, solicit feedback, sustain difficult conversations, and transform feedback into a permanent development practice. From this perspective, teams tend to feel more secure when they perceive that their leaders are also willing to review conduct, welcome contributions, and learn from their own mistakes.
The relevance of this discussion becomes even more evident in the face of the risk of organizational silence, a phenomenon in which collaborators stop communicating doubts, disagreements, concerns, or failures for fear of interpersonal and professional consequences. In environments where feedback is perceived as aggressive, punitive, or inaccurate, people tend to excessively filter their speech and prioritize self-preservation over collective contribution. This movement weakens innovation, reduces the circulation of relevant information, and hinders the early correction of problems.
Considering this scenario, investigating the relationship between feedback and psychological safety proves relevant to understanding how leadership practices can foster greater communication openness in teams. Thus, the following research question was formulated: what is the influence of the feedback style adopted by managers on employees’ willingness to express their doubts and admit mistakes in the workplace? Given the above, this study’s general objective was to analyze the relationship between employees’ perception of the feedback received from their managers and their psychological safety to express vulnerabilities, especially doubts and mistakes, in the workplace.
2. Material and Methods
To analyze the relationship between employees’ perception of feedback received from their managers and psychological safety to expose vulnerabilities, this study adopted a specific methodological approach. An applied research of a descriptive nature was conducted, whose primary objective is the description of the characteristics of a population or phenomenon, as well as the establishment of relationships between variables (Gil, 2022). This nature aligned with the proposal to investigate the perception of feedback and psychological safety in the workplace.
The research strategy was based on the mixed-methods research approach, combining quantitative and qualitative data. As argued by Creswell and Creswell (2021), this combination provides a more complete understanding of the research problem than the isolated use of only one of the approaches. Numerical data allowed for the identification of general trends and the strength of relationships between variables, while open-ended responses offered subjective depth, enriching the analysis of the phenomena studied.
The technical procedure used for data collection was the survey, characterized by obtaining information from a group of people about the investigated topic (Gil, 2022). The collection occurred through a structured questionnaire, applied in a digital environment via the Google Forms platform. This format ensured agility in administration and respondent anonymity, crucial elements for obtaining sensitive data on perceptions and experiences in the workplace.
The data collection instrument consisted of closed-ended questions, designed based on the 5-point Likert Scale, and open fields for qualitative reports. The Likert Scale, according to Malhotra (2019), is an effective tool for measuring attitudes and opinions, allowing the conversion of subjective perceptions into data suitable for statistical analysis. The questions were formulated to address the perception of feedback and psychological safety, aligning with the study’s objectives.
The study sample consisted of 28 collaborators working in a financial institution located in the city of São Paulo, SP. Participant selection was by convenience and accessibility, a non-probabilistic technique frequently used in exploratory studies in the organizational environment (Sampieri et al., 2013). This selection method allowed access to a group of individuals who fit the desired profile for the investigation, facilitating the execution of the research within the specific organizational context.
Regarding data processing, quantitative information was processed through descriptive statistics and correlation analysis. Descriptive statistics allowed for summarizing and organizing the data, while correlation analysis was used to verify the existence and strength of associations between the studied variables. Qualitative data, obtained from open-ended questions, were subjected to the content analysis technique, which, according to Bardin (2016), organizes the subjects’ discourse into thematic categories for grounded inferences.
Ethical considerations were rigorously observed throughout the entire research process. Respondent anonymity was ensured, guaranteeing that no personal information that could identify them was collected or disclosed. Before participation, collaborators were informed about the study’s objectives and the procedures involved through a Free and Informed Consent Form (TCLE), as detailed in Appendix A of the original work, reinforcing the voluntariness and confidentiality of the data.
3. Results and Discussion
The results obtained in this research were carefully presented and discussed, seeking to answer the study problem and integrate the quantitative data, the qualitative reports, and the theoretical foundation that underpinned the investigation. The analysis revealed significant perceptions of the collaborators regarding the feedback received from their managers and psychological safety in the workplace, as well as their willingness to expose vulnerabilities. The internal coherence of the findings with the proposed objectives was a central point, allowing for an in-depth understanding of the relational dynamics between leadership and team in the studied context.
Sample characterization
The research involved the participation of 28 valid respondents, whose sociodemographic profile offered an initial overview of the context in which the data were collected. A predominance of participants in the 36 to 45 age group was observed, representing 46.4% of the sample, closely followed by those between 26 and 35 years old, who totaled 42.9%. This age distribution suggests a sample composed of professionals with consolidated experience, which may influence the maturity of their perceptions regarding the work environment and leadership practices.
Regarding the tenure in the current organization, a significant concentration of professionals with longer institutional permanence was observed, with 71.4% of respondents reporting more than five years of affiliation with the company. This longevity in current employment is an indicator of stability and may be associated with greater familiarity with the organizational culture and feedback dynamics. As for the job level, respondents in administrative, analytical, or technical positions prevailed, representing 64.3% of the sample, while 32.1% held leadership, management, or coordination roles. In relation to the work model, there was a broad predominance of the hybrid format, with 96.4% of participants working under this regime.
The sample composition, characterized by a majority of individuals with relative professional maturity and consolidated insertion in their respective organizational contexts, could confer greater stability and depth to the perceptions expressed about leadership, feedback, and interpersonal climate. The length of stay in the organization, in particular, tends to significantly influence satisfaction and perceptions of the work climate, favoring evaluations more anchored in the accumulated experience of organizational processes and relationships (Teclaw et al., 2014). This stability is crucial for the validity of interpretations, as it minimizes the influence of superficial or short-term perceptions.
Perception of the feedback received
In the section of questions dedicated to the evaluation of feedback received from the direct manager, the results revealed a predominantly favorable perception by the collaborators. The “feedback” dimension obtained an overall average of 4.15 on a scale of 1 to 5, indicating a positive evaluation. When analyzing the specific items, the item related to the frequency of feedback presented an average of 3.82, while the items related to the focus on the development of the feedback and the perception of fairness and objectivity achieved averages of 4.32 in both cases.
These results suggested that managerial feedback is perceived less as a censorship mechanism and more as a guidance and development practice. The concentration of the highest scores on the attributes of fairness and focus on professional growth indicated that the respondents recognized the legitimacy and usefulness of the feedback received. This perception is consistent with the literature that points out that feedback, when offered with clarity, respect, and a genuine intention of development, strengthens trust and favors performance improvement, instead of generating a defensive reaction (Scott, 2017; Stone; Heen, 2014). The quality of the interaction, therefore, is a determining factor in the effectiveness of feedback.
The lowest average observed in the frequency variable, compared to other feedback attributes, indicated that although feedback is valued, it may not be sufficiently incorporated into management routine as a continuous and regular practice. Participants’ open-ended responses reinforced this interpretation, bringing qualitative elements that complement the numerical data. In the reports, characteristics such as objectivity, factual basis, and clarity were frequently associated with positive feedback experiences, highlighting the importance of these aspects for the constructive reception of the feedback.
In contrast, when the feedback was perceived as aggressive, unilateral, or devoid of concrete facts, participants reported significant negative impacts on motivation and engagement. Such findings suggested that the outcomes of feedback depend, to a large extent, on the quality of the interaction that sustains it, and not just on its existence. Poorly managed feedback can, therefore, undermine trust and openness, while well-constructed and frequent feedback can be a catalyst for development and psychological safety.
Psychological safety in the workplace
In the set of items intended for measuring psychological safety in the workplace, the results also showed to be high, indicating a general positive perception. The item written in the negative sense, “if I make a mistake on this team, I feel it would be used against me,” presented an average of 1.96. As this is an inverted assertion, this result suggests a low perception of punishment or instrumentalization of errors against the worker, which is a favorable indicator for psychological safety.
This finding corroborates the literature that describes psychological safety as the reduction of interpersonal fear at work, favoring the exposure of failures, doubts, and contributions without the fear of negative social consequences (Edmondson, 2019). The absence of a punitive environment for errors is a fundamental pillar for employees to feel comfortable experimenting and learning. The other items on the scale showed averages above 4.00, reinforcing the perception of a safe environment.
Specifically, the perception of safety for taking risks and suggesting ideas obtained an average of 4.11. Comfort in asking for help and the perception of mutual support reached an average of 4.29. The interpretation of this data indicated that participants tend to perceive their work context as relatively safe for interpersonal exposure. However, a finer reading revealed that the highest score was observed in comfort for asking for help, while the average related to safety for taking risks and suggesting ideas was slightly lower.
This subtle yet relevant difference suggested that the environment might be more permissive of legitimate dependency behaviors, such as asking for help, than of behaviors involving greater authorial exposure, such as innovating, questioning the status quo, or presenting ideas that might be controversial. Although there is a good general level of safety, the nuance indicates that there are still areas for improvement in fostering a culture of innovation and actively encouraging proposals that challenge the conventional, which is essential for continuous learning and organizational adaptation.
Willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements
This analysis block investigated employees’ willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements, presenting results that, although positive, were more moderate compared to the other dimensions. The immediate communication of already identified errors obtained an average of 4.29, indicating that participants feel comfortable reporting failures after they occur. However, the fear of asking something and appearing incompetent in front of the manager presented an average of 2.61, revealing a significant barrier.
The freedom to disagree or bring different viewpoints to meetings obtained an average of 3.93. These results suggested that participants were more comfortable communicating already identified errors than exposing themselves in situations that could be interpreted as a sign of cognitive insufficiency or confrontation. The fear of asking and appearing incompetent, as well as the freedom to disagree, reflected the permanence of subtle self-censorship mechanisms in the workplace.
This self-censorship aligns with literature demonstrating that many individuals avoid self-exposure to avoid being perceived as ignorant, incompetent, or disruptive, which favors organizational silence and the protection of professional image (Edmondson, 2019). The practical implication is that, even in an environment with generally good psychological safety, the culture may still not fully encourage proactivity in identifying problems or expressing divergent opinions, which can limit innovation and collaborative problem-solving.
Relationship between feedback, psychological safety, and willingness to expose errors
The correlational analysis performed indicated positive associations between the study’s central constructs, providing insights into the interconnection between feedback, psychological safety, and the willingness to expose vulnerabilities. The correlation between feedback and psychological safety was r = 0.595, a value suggesting a moderate positive association. This means that the more positive the perception of the feedback received, the greater the perception of psychological safety in the work environment.
Furthermore, the correlation between psychological safety and the willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements was r = 0.617, indicating a moderate to strong association. This result reinforces the idea that environments perceived as safer foster speaking up and vulnerability-assuming behaviors. Such a finding is convergent with the literature on psychological safety, which describes it as a central relational condition for individuals to feel empowered to speak up, ask for help, admit mistakes, and contribute without excessive fear of embarrassment or retaliation (Edmondson, 2019).
The weakest association was observed between feedback and the willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements, with a correlation coefficient of r = 0.361. This correlation, although positive, suggests that feedback did not act on open speech in an exclusively direct manner, but possibly through psychological safety. This implies that feedback, by itself, may not be sufficient to ensure the exposure of vulnerabilities if the environment is not perceived as psychologically safe. Psychological safety acts as a crucial mediator, transforming feedback into a more effective catalyst for communicational openness.
The integration of data allowed us to understand that fair and constructive feedback reduced the subjective cost of exposing vulnerabilities. This interpretation is supported by Stone and Heen (2014), who argue that the reception of feedback is mediated by triggers of truth, relationship, and identity. Feedback perceived as fairer, more specific, and fact-based tends to reduce defensiveness and foster greater openness to learning, as it minimizes the threat to an individual’s self-image and professional competence. The perception of fairness and objectivity in feedback, therefore, is a critical factor for its effectiveness.
From an interpretive point of view, the results were consistent with the hypothesis that learning-oriented feedback is associated with higher levels of psychological safety. This interpretation is coherent with the literature that understands psychological safety as a relational condition that favors the manifestation of doubts, concerns, and contributions in the workplace, especially when leadership builds relationships marked by respect, openness, and trust (Edmondson, 2019; Scott, 2017). The qualitative analysis reinforced this reading, highlighting the importance of leadership posture and relational trust.
The qualitative analysis, synthesized into thematic categories, revealed that “Leadership posture” is a determining factor. The perception that the manager’s attitude directly influences the safety to expose errors, especially when there is support, listening, and welcoming, was a central finding. Reports such as “when my superiors present their own errors” and “the manager also exposes doubts more frequently” illustrate how the leader’s vulnerability can shape the team’s behavior, creating an environment of “receptivity and cordiality”. This suggests that leadership that demonstrates humility and openness to its own mistakes inspires trust and reduces employees’ fear of doing the same.
The “Constructive Feedback” category highlighted the appreciation of clear, objective, and development-oriented feedback, based on facts and with practical direction. Expressions such as “it was very well structured,” “brought up occurrences and direction for the next steps,” and “exposed the areas for improvement” indicate that effective feedback is one that offers a path for enhancement, rather than focusing solely on failure. This approach, aligned with Scott’s (2017) Assertive Empathy, combines genuine care with the courage to confront performance issues, transforming feedback into a tool for growth.
“Relational trust” emerged as a fundamental pillar, highlighting the importance of the bond of trust and proximity to the manager as a condition for greater communication openness. Phrases such as “I have a trusting relationship with my manager” and “close daily contact greatly facilitates our alignment” underline that the quality of the interpersonal relationship with the leader is a prerequisite for employees to feel safe to expose their vulnerabilities. This proximity and trust create a space where communication flows more freely, reducing barriers to the exposure of doubts and errors.
The “Openness to dialogue” was another relevant category, indicating the presence of a receptive environment where there is encouragement to speak, question, and present divergent opinions. Reports such as “being explicitly encouraged to have this stance” and “divergent opinion will always be seen as important for evolution” demonstrate that, when leadership actively promotes dialogue and values different perspectives, the team feels safer to contribute. An “environment that is open to learning and mistakes” is perceived as a space for growth, not judgment.
On the other hand, the category “Reputational Concern” revealed the fear of judgment, of appearing incompetent, or of suffering negative consequences when exposing errors, doubts, and disagreements. Expressions such as “a somewhat aggressive manner,” “my manager didn’t pay attention,” and “in the end, he only said what he wanted” illustrate situations where feedback or managerial interaction generated fear. These accounts indicate that, even in environments with good overall psychological safety, the fear of damaging one’s self-image or professional reputation can inhibit open communication, corroborating Stone and Heen’s (2014) perspective on identity triggers.
Participants’ accounts showed that feedback practices perceived as respectful and objective tend to enhance trust in the manager, in line with Scott (2017), who argued that the combination of personal care and direct challenge strengthens more honest, productive, and trustworthy relationships in the workplace. This leadership approach, which balances empathy and assertiveness, is crucial for building an environment where feedback is seen as an opportunity for development, rather than a threat. The leader’s communication quality, therefore, is a determining factor for the team’s perception of safety and openness.
In contrast, when the return was experienced as a threat or aggressive communication, the reported movement was one of withdrawal and reduced spontaneity, which dialogues with Edmondson (2019), who argues that interpersonal fear compromises psychological safety and inhibits learning behaviors, transparency, and the exposure of failures. The perception that an error can be used against the employee or that a disagreement will be misinterpreted leads to self-censorship, weakening the team’s ability to innovate and solve problems collaboratively. Leadership plays a fundamental role in mitigating this fear, promoting an environment of trust and mutual respect.
In practice, the findings suggest that fair and development-oriented feedbacks are associated with high levels of psychological safety, which, in turn, encourage the communication of errors and doubts. The main contribution of this study was to highlight that feedback was not just a technical correction, but a relational practice that reduced the subjective cost of exposure. Although the environment was perceived as safe for requesting help and admitting operational errors, the persistence of symbolic barriers to public disagreement suggests that leadership should act not only in the absence of punishment, but in the active construction of the legitimacy of divergent speech.
Based on the findings, it was suggested to the organization the implementation of feedback literacy strategies for leadership, focusing on “Assertive Empathy”. The intention is to foster a culture where mistakes are no longer perceived solely as a reason for sanction but are treated as a strategic input for innovation. This approach aims to empower leaders to provide feedback constructively, promoting an environment where vulnerability is seen as an opportunity for learning and growth, not as a weakness. The ability to learn from mistakes and adapt to new contexts is fundamental to organizational success, as highlighted by Goldsmith (2007).
The results obtained showed internal coherence with the proposed objectives, indicating that the positive perception of feedback received from managers is associated with greater psychological safety and, consequently, a greater willingness of employees to expose vulnerabilities in the workplace. The moderate positive correlation between feedback and psychological safety, as well as between psychological safety and the willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements, reinforces the importance of the leader’s posture for communication openness. The practice of fair and fact-based feedback can reduce perceived reputational risks, favoring the employee prioritizing learning over self-image protection, which is essential for continuous development and innovation in teams.
4. Conclusion
This study analyzed the relationship between employees’ perception of feedback received from their managers and psychological safety to expose vulnerabilities in the workplace. A predominantly positive perception of both managerial feedback and psychological safety was found, with high means for both constructs. A moderate positive correlation (r = 0.595) was identified between feedback perception and psychological safety, and a moderate to strong association (r = 0.617) between psychological safety and the willingness to expose errors, doubts, and disagreements. It was observed that, although employees felt comfortable communicating already identified errors and asking for help, moderate barriers persisted for disagreement in meetings and the fear of appearing incompetent when asking questions. The qualitative analysis reinforced that leadership posture, constructive feedback, and relational trust are pillars for communication openness, while reputational fear inhibits exposure. The main contribution of this work lies in demonstrating that feedback acts as a relational practice that reduces the subjective cost of exposing vulnerabilities, encouraging learning over protecting self-image.
However, the study presented limitations due to the small sample size (28 respondents) and the exclusive focus on a single financial institution, which restricts the generalization of the results. Self-report bias and the predominance of senior professionals may also have influenced perceptions. For future studies, it is recommended to conduct longitudinal research and expand the sample to different sectors and work modalities, including the fully remote regime, in order to understand the influence of physical distance on psychological safety and feedback effectiveness. It is suggested that the organization implement feedback literacy strategies for leadership, focusing on “Assertive Empathy”, aiming to foster a culture where errors are perceived as strategic input for innovation and continuous learning.
Bibliographic References
BARDIN, L. Análise de conteúdo. São Paulo: Edições 70, 2016.
CRESWELL, J. W.; CRESWELL, J. D. Projeto de pesquisa: métodos qualitativo, quantitativo e misto. Porto Alegre: Penso, 2021.
EDMONDSON, Amy C. The fearless organization: creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, 2019.
GIL, A. C. Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. São Paulo: Atlas, 2022.
GOLDSMITH, Marshall; REITER, Mark. What got you here won’t get you there: how successful people become even more successful. New York: Hyperion, 2007.
MALHOTRA, N. K. Pesquisa de marketing: uma orientação aplicada. Porto Alegre: Bookman, 2019.
SAMPIERI, R. H. et al. Metodologia de pesquisa. Porto Alegre: Penso, 2013.
SCOTT, Kim. Empatia assertiva: como ser um líder incisivo sem perder a humanidade. Tradução de Cristina Yamagami. São Paulo: HSM, 2017.
STONE, Douglas; HEEN, Sheila. Obrigado pelo feedback: a ciência e a arte de receber bem o retorno de chefes, colegas, familiares e amigos. Tradução de Renata Guerra. Rio de Janeiro: Portfolio-Penguin, 2014.
TECLAW, R.; OSATUKE, K.; FISHMAN, J.; MOORE, S. C.; DYRENFORTH, S. Employee age and tenure within organizations: relationship to workplace satisfaction and workplace climate perceptions. The Health Care Manager, v. 33, n. 1, p. 4-19, 2014. DOI: 10.1097/01.HCM.0000440616.31891.2d.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in People Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform