October 26, 2026
Motivators and differentials in the choice of credit cooperatives
Pablo Renan Alegre Arriaga; Lucineide Bispo dos Reis Luz
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601287
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Credit co-operativism has consolidated itself within the Brazilian financial system, offering competitive products and services and contributing to local development and financial inclusion. The study aimed to identify the main motivators and differentials that lead individuals to choose credit co-operatives over other financial institutions authorized by the Central Bank of Brazil. The methodology employed bibliographic research, combined with qualitative and quantitative approaches, through the application of a questionnaire via Google Forms, answered by 122 participants. The collected data revealed a profile of respondents with high education and financial maturity. The results indicated that factors such as reduced interest rates and fees, greater social impact, profit sharing, personalized service, and better NPS scores were among the main perceived advantages of credit co-operatives. However, barriers to their expansion were observed, including lack of knowledge about the co-operative model (69% of non-members), perception of lack of security (37%), and low institutional disclosure (39%). It was found that respondents, despite having some loyalty to traditional banks due to convenience, would be willing to migrate to institutions with reduced costs and operational fees, but did not do so due to a lack of knowledge about co-operative benefits. It was concluded that, despite consistent economic and social advantages compared to banks and fintechs, credit co-operatives require more effective communication and dissemination strategies to sustain their growth and overcome the challenge of lack of information.
Keywords: Local development; Participatory management; Financial inclusion; Customer satisfaction.
1. Introduction
The global financial landscape is marked by continuous transformations, driven by innovation and the demand for more accessible and equitable services. In this context, co-operative credit unions have consolidated themselves as a robust and relevant model (Paiva & Santos, 2009). Its origin dates back to the 19th century, with figures like Friedrich Wilhelm Raiffeisen in Germany, and in Brazil, the founding of the first credit cooperative in 1902, Sicredi Pioneira, under the leadership of Father Theodor Amstad (Paiva & Santos, 2009). The model expanded with the purpose of benefiting local communities, being recognized by the United Nations (UN) as a pillar for a sustainable future, designating 2025 as the International Year of Cooperatives. Currently, the Brazilian cooperative sector is significant, with more than twenty-five million members and assets exceeding one trillion reais (Organização das Cooperativas Brasileiras, 2025). Credit unions, specifically, represent more than twenty million members and assets exceeding nine hundred and eighty billion reais (Organização das Cooperativas Brasileiras, 2025).
The theoretical foundation of credit cooperativism is based on principles such as free and voluntary membership, democratic member control, and concern for community, according to the Rochdale principles of 1844 (Cunha et al., 2020). These pillars distinguish credit unions from other financial institutions, such as commercial banks and fintechs, whose primary objective is profit maximization for shareholders (Maia, 2022). In contrast, cooperatives aim for the mutual benefit of members and local development, resulting in notable competitive advantages. The pricing of products and services tends to be more advantageous, with reduced interest rates and fees. Empirical data show that annual interest rates in credit unions range between eighteen and twenty-two percent, significantly lower than the thirty-five to thirty-eight percent observed in large traditional banks (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023). The Basel Index, which measures solidity and risk absorption capacity, is often higher in cooperatives, indicating greater financial security (Arruda, 2020). Customer satisfaction, measured by the Net Promoter Score (NPS), is also consistently higher in cooperatives, exceeding seventy percent, compared to the average of approximately fifty-seven and a half percent in traditional banks (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023).
Despite these consistent economic and social advantages, the credit co-operative model faces significant challenges in its expansion and public recognition. The perception and level of knowledge about its operations and benefits are notable barriers. Research indicates that sixty-nine percent of non-members are unaware of how the co-operative model works. Additionally, the perception of a lack of security, cited by thirty-seven percent of individuals, and low institutional disclosure, mentioned by thirty-nine percent, contribute to hesitation in joining these institutions (Souza, 2024). Although consumers demonstrate a certain loyalty to traditional banks, often out of convenience, there is an openness to migrate to institutions that offer reduced costs and operational fees. However, this willingness does not materialize due to a lack of in-depth knowledge about the co-operative benefits. The profile of respondents in recent studies, often with high education and financial maturity, underscores that even an informed public may not be aware of the particularities and advantages of credit co-operatives, highlighting the need for more effective communication strategies (Cordeiro et al., 2023). Given this scenario of growing relevance and persistent information challenges, it becomes fundamental to understand the factors that motivate the choice for credit co-operatives. Thus, this study is justified by the need to provide subsidies for the development of effective communication strategies, aiming to overcome the barriers of lack of knowledge and sustain the sector’s growth. The objective of this work is to identify the main motivators and differentials that lead individuals to choose credit co-operatives over other financial institutions authorized by the Central Bank of Brazil.
2. Material and Methods
The research employed a mixed methodological approach, combining qualitative and quantitative elements for an in-depth understanding of the phenomenon studied. It was classified as a case study, focused on the analysis of information and data from a specific group, according to the perspective of Prodanov and Freitas (2013). This combination allowed for the exploration of both the numerical dimension of the data and the subjective and contextual aspects that influence the choice for credit unions. Bibliographical research was also a fundamental pillar, providing the necessary theoretical basis for the construction and interpretation of the findings.
The study was contextualized within the Brazilian financial system, encompassing operations of credit cooperatives, traditional commercial banks, and fintechs. The unit of analysis consisted of individuals from the general public, seeking to understand their motivators and differentiators in choosing financial institutions. Data collection occurred within a specific period, between December 15, 2025, and February 28, 2026, with no explicit geographical restriction for participants, aiming for a broad perspective on the topic.
The target population of the research was the general public, with no specific inclusion or exclusion criteria detailed in the TCC, beyond the ability to answer the questionnaire. The sample consisted of one hundred and twenty-two participants, who voluntarily answered the data collection instrument. Participant selection occurred by convenience, given the nature of the online questionnaire application, seeking to capture a diversity of perspectives on the central theme of the study.
The main data collection instrument was a structured questionnaire, administered through the Google Forms platform. This questionnaire was designed to gather information about the respondents’ profile, their financial behavior, and, primarily, the factors influencing the choice of credit cooperatives compared to other financial institutions. The use of Google Forms facilitated the efficient distribution and collection of responses, reaching a significant number of participants.
The questionnaire contained fifteen questions, as detailed in Annex 1 of the paper, addressing various dimensions relevant to the research objective. Questions were included about educational background, length of time with financial institutions, age group, and gender of the participants. Furthermore, the reasons for opening an account, motivations for joining or remaining with cooperatives, and the level of knowledge about the benefits and functioning of the cooperative model were explored.
Other questions on the instrument investigated participants’ perception of the service of their financial needs, the institutions that most move their resources, and the benefits considered in choosing an institution. It also sought to identify the reasons for the lack of knowledge of cooperative benefits and the means by which participants obtained information about credit unions. Finally, the questionnaire explored the benefits that would motivate the exchange of commercial banks for cooperatives and the reasons for non-association.
The research execution began with a comprehensive bibliographic review, which grounded the understanding of co-operative credit union and its differentials. Subsequently, the questionnaire was developed and applied via Google Forms, according to the established period from December 15, 2025, to February 28, 2026. After the collection period ended, the one hundred and twenty-two answered questionnaires were compiled and organized for the subsequent stages of data processing and analysis.
The qualitative analysis of the collected data sought a broad and in-depth interpretation of the participants’ perceptions and opinions. This process involved identifying key themes and patterns in the open-ended responses or choices that revealed subjective and contextual aspects, according to the approach of Fávero and Belfiore (2017). The objective was to understand the nuances behind the choices and the level of knowledge about credit cooperatives, enriching the quantitative analysis.
For the treatment of quantitative data, tools such as pivot tables were used, which allowed for the cross-referencing of information and the identification of numerical trends and patterns. The responses to each question on the form were quantified, enabling the creation of a structured database. This stage was crucial for descriptive statistical analysis, which provided a clear overview of the distribution of responses and participant profiles.
The integration of qualitative and quantitative approaches allowed for a robust analysis, correlating numerical data with participants’ perceptions and justifications. The theoretical foundation, combined with the researcher’s market knowledge, was used to interpret the obtained results. This mixed methodology ensured that the findings not only quantified the phenomena but also offered a contextualized understanding of the motivators and differentials in the choice of credit cooperatives.
3. Results and Discussion
The questionnaire, administered through the Google Forms platform to a general audience between December 15, 2025, and February 28, 2026, received 122 responses, providing a robust basis for analyzing the motivators and differentiators in choosing credit cooperatives. The data analysis revealed a profile of respondents with specific demographic and financial characteristics, which directly influence their perceptions and decisions in the financial market.
Initially, the research investigated the participants’ educational attainment, a crucial factor for understanding respondents’ level of discernment and critical analysis capacity regarding available financial options. As presented in Figure 1, the majority of participants have high educational attainment, with 53% holding postgraduate degrees and 41% having completed higher education, while only 6% have a high school education.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Level of schooling
This finding suggests that the sample is composed of individuals with a high level of education, which implies a greater probability that their financial decisions are based on rational and informed criteria, rather than mere emotional or superficial influences. High schooling may be correlated with greater financial literacy, allowing respondents to better understand the products, services, and business models of financial institutions, including credit unions. This characteristic of the sample is particularly relevant, as credit unions, with their participatory governance model and profit sharing, require a certain level of understanding for their differentials to be fully appreciated. Authors such as Marion (2021) and Dias et al. (2023) frequently associate educational level with the ability to assess financial complexities, which reinforces the validity of the perceptions collected in this study. The practical implications of this respondent profile are significant: credit unions, when directing their communication and marketing strategies, should consider the sophistication of their target audience, offering detailed and transparent information about their benefits and operations, rather than simplified approaches that might be more effective for audiences with lower schooling.
Next, the survey explored account tenure in financial institutions, an indicator of financial maturity and possible consumer loyalty. Figure 2 reveals that 76% of respondents have had an account for more than 6 years, with 4% having accounts for more than 10 years. Only 6% have had an account for up to 2 years, 6% between 2 and 4 years, and 8% between 4 and 6 years.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Account time in Financial Institution
This distribution indicates that the majority of participants have a consolidated financial history and, likely, a certain degree of inertia regarding switching institutions. The long relationship time with a financial institution can be a reflection of satisfaction, but also of convenience and the perception of high switching costs, such as the bureaucracy involved in opening a new account or transferring investments. This behavior is consistent with the literature on consumer loyalty in financial services, where convenience and familiarity often outweigh the active search for better conditions, unless there is a strong incentive to switch (Cordeiro et al., 2023). The predominance of respondents with more than six years of accounts in financial institutions suggests that credit unions face the challenge of attracting an already established audience, who may not be actively seeking alternatives. To overcome this barrier, credit unions need to not only communicate their differentials but also demonstrate added value that justifies the migration effort, such as significantly lower fees or superior service, as pointed out by Toffoli (2023). The practical implications lie in the need for credit unions to develop acquisition strategies that minimize the perceived effort in the transition and maximize the visibility of long-term benefits.
The age range of the participants was also analyzed, providing insights into different financial needs and priorities. According to Figure 3, most respondents are in the 32 to 40 age range (41%), followed by those over 50 years old (27%) and between 25 and 32 years old (25%). The 18 to 25 years and 36 to 50 years age ranges represent smaller portions, with 2% and 4%, respectively.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Age Range
This age profile suggests a predominantly adult and financially active sample, with responsibilities and needs that can range from wealth building to retirement planning. The concentration in more mature age groups (over 32 years old) indicates that respondents likely already have experience with more complex financial products and are in life stages that demand greater stability and financial planning. This finding aligns with studies demonstrating that the pursuit of security and profitability tends to increase with age and financial experience (Maia, 2022). The significant presence of individuals over 50 years old is also noteworthy, as this group may be more inclined to value institutional solidity and security, aspects that credit cooperatives, with their generally higher Basel Index, can offer (Arruda, 2020). Cooperatives should therefore adapt their product and service offerings to meet the specific needs of each age group, from credit lines for young entrepreneurs to investment and pension options for the more experienced, always emphasizing the security and participatory governance that characterize them.
Regarding gender, Figure 4 shows that 69% of respondents are women and 31% are men.
Source: Original research results
Figure 4. Gender
This female predominance in the sample may influence perceptions of service, security, and social impact, as studies indicate that women may have different financial priorities and behaviors compared to men (Marion, 2021). For example, some research suggests that women tend to value personalized service and security in financial transactions more. This characteristic of the sample should be considered in the interpretation of the results, as the identified preferences and motivators may partly reflect the priorities of a predominantly female audience. For cooperatives, this may mean the need to develop communication strategies and products that resonate with the concerns and values of this segment, such as financial education programs aimed at women or credit products with flexible conditions that meet their specific needs.
When investigating the reason for opening an account in financial institutions, Figure 5 reveals that 37% of respondents cite “Products and Services” as the main reason, followed by “Other” with 36%, “Customer Service” with 16%, and “Profit Sharing” and “Fees” both with 6%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 5. Reason for opening an account in a Financial Institution
The prevalence of “Products and Services” as the main motivator indicates that offering a complete and competitive portfolio is fundamental to attracting new clients. This includes everything from current and savings accounts to credit lines, investments, and insurance. The fact that “Other” represents such a high percentage (36%) suggests that there are diverse motivators not captured by the predefined categories, which may include recommendations, geographical proximity, or very specific needs. “Customer Service” (16%) also proves relevant, reinforcing the importance of quality in customer relationships, a differentiator often associated with credit unions (Toffoli, 2023). The low mention of “Profit Sharing” and “Fees” as initial reasons for opening an account (both 6%) may indicate an initial lack of awareness about these specific benefits of the co-operative model, which are frequently highlighted as its main competitive advantages (Moreira & Junges, 2019). This suggests that, although these benefits exist, they may not be the primary factor that leads an individual to open an account, but rather a factor for long-term retention or satisfaction. Therefore, co-operatives should focus on a competitive offering of products and services, while also educating the public about the unique benefits of co-operativism, such as profit sharing, which may become stronger motivators after membership.
The research also sought to identify the main reason that led participants to join and remain associated with a credit cooperative. Figure 6 shows that “The service and the facilities offered to the user” and “The economic benefits and advantages that the cooperative offers” are the main motivators, both with 37% and 35% respectively. “Involvement with the community and the social benefits derived” represents 14%, “Network of relationships provided by the association” 6%, and “The qualities of the cooperative in general” 4%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 6. Main reason that led them to associate
This result corroborates the literature that highlights personalized service and financial advantages as pillars of credit unionism. The service and facilities, which include proximity and humanization of the service, are frequently cited as a differential of cooperatives compared to large banks, which often prioritize scale over personalization (Toffoli, 2023). Economic benefits, such as lower interest rates and reduced fees, are a direct and tangible attraction, aligning with the findings of Silva and Cembramanel (2023) and Maia (2022) on the competitiveness of cooperatives. Community involvement and social benefits, although less cited as primary motivators, are still relevant (14%), reflecting the intrinsic social purpose of cooperatives, as advocated by Souza (2024) and Ribeiro & Menezes (2024). The low representation of “general cooperative qualities” (4%) and “relationship network” (6%) may indicate that these aspects are perceived as an integral part of the benefit package, but are not decisive factors in isolation. Cooperatives should continue to invest in service excellence and clear communication of their economic benefits, while reinforcing their role in local development and building relationship networks, which can generate long-term loyalty.
Regarding the fulfillment of financial services interests and needs, Figure 7 shows that 41% of respondents state that their needs are met “Almost always”, and 27% “Always meets”. Only 25% indicate “Sometimes”, 4% “Never meets” and 4% “Rarely”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 7. Service to the interests and needs of financial services
This data demonstrates a high level of general satisfaction with the fulfillment of financial needs, with 68% of respondents indicating that their needs are met “Almost always” or “Always met”. This result is consistent with the concept of Net Promoter Score (NPS) mentioned in the introduction, where credit unions often outperform traditional banks in customer satisfaction (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023). The perception that financial institutions, whether they are co-operative credit unions or banks, can meet customer demands is a critical factor for retention and building lasting relationships. The portion of respondents reporting “Sometimes”, “Never met” or “Rarely” met (33% in total) represents an opportunity for institutions to improve their services and identify gaps in service. For co-operative credit unions, maintaining and improving this high level of satisfaction is crucial to consolidate their market position and attract new members. This involves not only offering suitable products but also agility in problem-solving and proactivity in identifying new member needs.
When analyzing the financial institution that participants move the most, Figure 8 reveals that Itaú leads with 37%, closely followed by Digital Banks with 30%. Bradesco represents 11%, Banco do Brasil 10%, Caixa Econômica Federal 4%, and Santander 4%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 8. Financial Institution with the highest volume
This result highlights the strong presence of large traditional banks and the significant growth of digital banks in the Brazilian financial landscape. Itaú’s leadership and the expressive participation of digital banks demonstrate the intense competition that credit cooperatives face. While traditional banks benefit from their capillarity and brand recognition, digital banks attract customers with the promise of agility, technological innovation, and often reduced costs (Santos, 2023). The low representation of credit cooperatives in this regard, although not explicitly shown in the figure, can be inferred from the predominance of other institutions. This reinforces the need for cooperatives to intensify their marketing and communication strategies to increase their visibility and attract a larger share of the public that moves its resources in other institutions. Competition with digital banks, in particular, requires cooperatives to invest in technology and digitalization, without losing the essence of personalized service and social purpose that distinguishes them (Orsatto & Silva, 2022).
The benefits considered in choosing a financial institution were investigated in Figure 9. “Reduced operational fees” are the most relevant factor, with 43% of mentions, followed by “Quality of service” with 24%. Other factors include “Market Representation” (14%), “Investment return rate” (10%), “Branch location” (4%), “Number of branches” (4%), and “Waiting time for service” (4%).
Source: Original research results
Figure 9. What are the benefits considered in the choice of a financial institution
The primacy of “Reduced operational fees” as a selection criterion highlights consumers’ sensitivity to the cost of financial services. This finding is crucial for credit unions, which often offer more competitive rates compared to traditional banks, as highlighted by Silva and Cembramanel (2023) and Moreira & Junges (2019). “Quality of service” in second place (24%) reinforces the importance of humanized and efficient service, a strong point for cooperatives. “Market Representativeness” (14%) may reflect the search for solid and recognized institutions, while “Investment return rate” (10%) indicates that profitability is an important factor for a portion of respondents. The low relevance of “Branch location”, “Number of branches”, and “Waiting time for service” (all at 4%) may be a reflection of the increasing digitalization of financial services, where physical presence becomes less critical for many consumers. Cooperatives should capitalize on their competitive advantage in terms of costs and quality of service, communicating these benefits clearly and consistently. Furthermore, they should continue to invest in digital platforms to complement their physical network, meeting the expectations of an increasingly digitized audience.
One of the most critical findings for the growth of credit co-operativism is the level of knowledge of the respondents about this model. Figure 10 reveals that 41% of participants “Know and understand how a credit co-operative works”, which is a considerable percentage, but not the majority. However, 35% “Have heard of it, but do not know how it works”, and 14% “Do not know and have never heard of it”. Only 10% “Know, but only credit co-operatives for individuals”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 10. Level of knowledge about credit cooperatives
This data indicates a significant knowledge gap regarding the co-operative credit union model, despite a considerable portion of respondents having some familiarity. The sum of those who are unaware or have superficial knowledge (35% + 14% = 49%) represents almost half of the sample, which is a substantial barrier to adoption. This lack of awareness is one of the main challenges for the expansion of credit unions, as pointed out in the abstract of the work and by authors such as Souza (2024), who highlight low institutional disclosure as an impediment. The lack of understanding about how co-operative credit unions operate, which fundamentally differ from commercial banks due to their non-profit purpose and democratic management, prevents potential members from fully realizing their benefits. The practical implications are clear: co-operative credit unions need to invest heavily in financial education and awareness campaigns that simply and accessibly explain what a co-operative credit union is, how it works, and what its differentiators are. This strategy must go beyond mere advertising, seeking to engage the public in a learning process that demystifies the model and builds trust.
Complementing the previous finding, Figure 11 details respondents’ knowledge about the specific benefits of joining a credit union. The results show that 37% “Have no knowledge of the benefits”, while 30% “Know about reduced interest rates and low financing costs”. Other less known benefits include “Profit sharing” (13%), “Below-market operational fees and annual charges” (12%), and “Personalized service” (8%).
Source: Original research results
Figure 11. Knowledge about the benefits of joining a credit cooperative
The high percentage of respondents who are unaware of the benefits (37%) reinforces the need for more effective education and communication campaigns. It is concerning that, even among those with some knowledge of cooperatives, many still do not know the concrete advantages of joining. However, the recognition of “reduced interest rates and low financing costs” by 30% of participants is a positive point, as this is one of the most tangible and attractive differentiators of cooperatives, as evidenced by Moreira and Junges (2019) and Silva and Cembramanel (2023). The low perception of “Participation in results” (13%) and “Operational fees and annual dues below market rates” (12%) indicates that these benefits, although economically relevant, are not being effectively communicated. “Personalized service” (8%), despite being a strong point of cooperatives, is not widely recognized as a specific benefit. Practical implications suggest that cooperatives should not only publicize the existence of their benefits but also quantify and exemplify them, showing how they translate into real savings for members. Communication should be directed to highlight the most valued financial benefits, such as interest rates and fees, and, in parallel, educate about participation in results as a unique differentiator of the model.
The reasons for the lack of knowledge about the benefits of credit cooperatives were investigated in Figure 12. The “Lack of announcements, advertising, disclosure of cooperatives” is the main reason, with 39% of mentions, followed by “Lack of interest” with 34%. The “Difficulty in finding information” accounts for 14%, and “Lack of time” for 13%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 12. Reasons for unawareness of benefits
This result is a clear warning for credit unions. “Lack of disclosure” (39%) is an external barrier that can be overcome with investments in marketing and institutional communication. The perception of “low institutional disclosure” had already been mentioned in the work’s summary as one of the obstacles to expansion. In contrast, “Lack of interest” (34%) is an internal barrier, which can be influenced by initial unfamiliarity with the model and consumer inertia in seeking new financial options. “Difficulty in finding information” (14%) and “Lack of time” (13%) also contribute to the scenario of unawareness. These findings corroborate the need for more robust and targeted communication strategies, which not only inform but also awaken public interest. The literature on financial services marketing (Cordeiro et al., 2023) emphasizes that visibility and accessibility of information are crucial for consumer decision-making. Cooperatives should, therefore, not only increase their presence in traditional and digital media channels but also simplify how information is presented, making it easily understandable and relevant to the daily lives of potential members.
To understand how respondents obtained information about the benefits of cooperatives, Figure 13 questioned the means of knowledge. “Cooperative employees” and “Internet and social media” are the most cited means, both with 41% of mentions. “Newspapers and/or television ads” represent 11%, and “Contact with other members” 6%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 13. Means of knowing the benefits
The equivalence between “Cooperative Employees” and “Internet and social media” as main sources of information is a significant finding. This demonstrates that, despite increasing digitalization, human contact and personalized service remain crucial for disseminating information about credit unions. Employees play a vital role as brand ambassadors, capable of clearly and reliably explaining the benefits and the cooperative model. This aspect aligns with the valuation of “Personalized Service” (Toffoli, 2023) and “Participatory Management” (Vieira, 2023) as cooperative differentiators. In parallel, the strong influence of “Internet and social media” (41%) highlights the importance of a robust and strategic digital presence. Cooperatives need to optimize their online channels, ensuring that information is easily accessible, up-to-date, and engaging, leveraging the potential of social media to reach a broader and younger audience (Cordeiro et al., 2023). The low relevance of “Newspapers and/or television ads” (11%) and “Contact with other members” (6%) suggests that traditional media may have limited reach for this specific audience, and that word-of-mouth, while important, is not the primary source of initial information. The practical implications indicate that cooperatives should invest in training and development of their employees to be effective in communicating benefits, and simultaneously, develop a comprehensive digital strategy that includes informative websites, active social media profiles, and relevant content that educates and attracts potential members.
The research also explored what benefits would motivate respondents to switch from commercial banks to credit unions. Figure 14 reveals that “Reduced operational fees and interest rates” is the main motivator, with 39% of mentions. Next, “Ease of membership and less bureaucracy” (24%), “Profit sharing” (21%), and “Personalized service” (16%) appear.
Source: Original research results
Figure 14. Benefits that would lead to replacing commercial banks with credit unions
This finding is fundamental for credit unions, as it identifies leverage points to attract customers from traditional banks. The predominance of “Lower operational fees and interest rates” (39%) as a migration factor confirms consumers’ sensitivity to the cost of financial services and the competitive advantage of credit unions in this regard (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023; Moreira & Junges, 2019). “Ease of membership and less bureaucracy” (24%) indicates that simplifying adhesion processes can be a strong attraction, especially for an audience that values agility and convenience. “Participation in results” (21%) is a unique differentiator of the cooperative model, offering a direct financial return to members, distinguishing it from the profit maximization model of banks for shareholders (Maia, 2022). “Personalized service” (16%), although less cited as a migration factor, is still relevant and reinforces the perception of a more human and closer service. The practical implications are clear: credit unions should focus their acquisition campaigns on explicitly communicating their lower fees and interest rates, simplify their adhesion processes, and highlight participation in results as a tangible financial benefit. Furthermore, they should continue to improve personalized service, as it contributes to member satisfaction and loyalty, even if it is not the main trigger for the initial change.
Finally, the research investigated the reasons for not associating with a credit union, a crucial aspect for understanding entry barriers. Figure 15 shows that “Lack of knowledge” is the most cited reason, with 69% of mentions. In second place, “Lack of security and trust” appears with 37%. “Difficulty in finding branches” accounts for 10%, and “Lack of quality in services provided” for 9%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 15. Reasons for not joining a credit union
This is, perhaps, the most impactful finding of the study. The overwhelming majority of respondents who do not associate with credit unions do so due to “Lack of knowledge” (69%). This result corroborates the perception of “lack of knowledge of the cooperative model” and “low institutional disclosure” mentioned in the work’s abstract and by Souza (2024). The lack of information prevents potential members from understanding the benefits and functioning of cooperatives, creating an insurmountable barrier. “Lack of security and trust” (37%) is the second most relevant reason, which may be a direct consequence of this lack of knowledge. When the public does not understand the model, they may perceive it as less secure or less regulated than traditional banks, even though credit unions have higher Basel ratios and are regulated by the Central Bank (Arruda, 2020). This perception of insecurity is a “market fallacy,” as the TCC text itself points out, but it needs to be actively combated. “Difficulty in finding branches” (10%) and “Lack of quality in services provided” (9%) are less significant, but still indicate areas for improvement. The practical implications are urgent: cooperatives need to launch massive education and awareness campaigns that not only explain the model but also reinforce its solidity, security, and regulation. It is fundamental to demystify the idea that cooperatives are less secure and to build an image of trust through transparent communication and testimonials from satisfied members. Increasing visibility and accessibility, both physical and digital, is also essential to overcome these barriers and allow more people to consider credit unionism as a viable and advantageous alternative.
The integrated analysis of the field research results with the theoretical literature allows for an in-depth understanding of the motivators and differentials of credit cooperatives. The profile of the respondents, characterized by high education and financial maturity, indicates that the public is capable of discerning and valuing the more sophisticated aspects of the cooperativist model, such as profit sharing and democratic management. However, the persistent “Lack of knowledge” about the model and its benefits, coupled with “Lack of security and trust”, emerges as the main barrier to the adhesion and expansion of cooperatives. This scenario contrasts with the economic and social advantages that cooperatives offer, such as “Reduced operational fees and interest rates” and “Personalized service”, which are recognized as strong motivators for switching financial institutions.
The reviewed literature, including works by Paiva & Santos (2009), Cunha et al. (2020), Moreira & Junges (2019), and Souza (2024), consistently points to the differentials of cooperatives in terms of credit pricing, social impact, and local development. The research results confirm that these attributes are valued by consumers, but the perception of these benefits is overshadowed by a lack of information. The comparison with traditional banks and fintechs, as discussed by Vieira (2023) and Santos (2023), reveals that cooperatives have a more horizontal governance model and a purpose that prioritizes the member and the community, in contrast to profit maximization for shareholders. This distinction, although theoretically attractive, does not translate into greater adherence due to low visibility and perceived risk.
The practical implications are multifaceted. Firstly, credit unions must intensify their communication and marketing strategies, focusing not only on product promotion but on educating about the cooperative model itself. This includes explaining participatory governance, the distribution of surplus earnings, and social impact, using clear and accessible language for the general public. Secondly, it is crucial to combat the perception of lack of security and trust, highlighting regulation by the Central Bank of Brazil and financial soundness indicators, such as the Basel Ratio, which often surpass those of commercial banks (Arruda, 2020). Testimonials from members and successful local development cases can be powerful tools for building this trust.
Additionally, cooperatives must capitalize on the most effective information channels identified in the research: their own employees and digital platforms. Investing in employee training so they become true consultants and ambassadors of cooperativism is essential. In parallel, a robust digital strategy, with an active presence on social media and quality informative content, can reach a broader and younger audience, which seeks agility and convenience. Ease of association and reduction of bureaucracy should also be prioritized, as these are factors that would motivate the migration of customers from commercial banks. By simplifying membership processes and offering a fluid digital experience, cooperatives can reduce the perceived switching costs for consumers.
In summary, the results of this study reinforce that credit cooperatives have significant growth potential in the Brazilian financial system, driven by their competitive advantages in terms of costs, service, and social purpose. However, for this potential to be fully realized, it is imperative that they overcome the barriers of lack of awareness and perception of insecurity. This requires a coordinated and strategic effort in education, communication, and continuous improvement of the member experience, ensuring that the benefits of cooperativism are widely understood and valued by the public.
The questionnaire, administered through the Google Forms platform to a general audience between December 15, 2025, and February 28, 2026, received 122 responses, providing a robust basis for analyzing the motivators and differentiators in choosing credit cooperatives. The data analysis revealed a profile of respondents with specific demographic and financial characteristics, which directly influence their perceptions and decisions in the financial market.
Initially, the research investigated the participants’ educational attainment, a crucial factor for understanding respondents’ level of discernment and critical analysis capacity regarding available financial options. As presented in Figure 1, the majority of participants have high educational attainment, with 53% holding postgraduate degrees and 41% having completed higher education, while only 6% have a high school education.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Level of schooling
This finding suggests that the sample is composed of individuals with a high level of education, which implies a greater probability that their financial decisions are based on rational and informed criteria, rather than mere emotional or superficial influences. High educational attainment may be correlated with greater financial literacy, enabling respondents to better understand the products, services, and business models of financial institutions, including credit unions. This characteristic of the sample is particularly relevant, as credit unions, with their participatory governance model and profit sharing, require a certain level of understanding for their differentials to be fully appreciated. Authors such as Marion (2021) and Dias et al. (2023) frequently associate educational level with the capacity to evaluate financial complexities, which reinforces the validity of the perceptions collected in this study. The practical implications of this respondent profile are significant: credit unions, when directing their communication and marketing strategies, should consider the sophistication of their target audience, offering detailed and transparent information about their benefits and operations, rather than simplified approaches that might be more effective for audiences with lower educational attainment. Communication must be strategic, using channels and languages that resonate with an audience that already has a good understanding of financial concepts, focusing on the differentiation of the co-operative model compared to traditional banks and fintechs, and highlighting the solidity and sustainability that arise from its structure.
Next, the survey explored account tenure in financial institutions, an indicator of financial maturity and possible consumer loyalty. Figure 2 reveals that 76% of respondents have had an account for more than 6 years, with 4% having accounts for more than 10 years. Only 6% have had an account for up to 2 years, 6% between 2 and 4 years, and 8% between 4 and 6 years.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Account time in Financial Institution
This distribution indicates that the majority of participants have a consolidated financial history and, likely, a certain degree of inertia regarding switching institutions. The long relationship time with a financial institution can be a reflection of satisfaction, but also of convenience and the perception of high switching costs, such as the bureaucracy involved in opening a new account or transferring investments. This behavior is consistent with the literature on consumer loyalty in financial services, where convenience and familiarity often outweigh the active search for better conditions, unless there is a strong incentive to switch (Cordeiro et al., 2023). The predominance of respondents with more than six years of accounts in financial institutions suggests that credit unions face the challenge of attracting an already established audience, who may not be actively seeking alternatives. To overcome this barrier, credit unions must not only communicate their differentials but also demonstrate added value that justifies the migration effort, such as significantly lower fees or superior service, as pointed out by Toffoli (2023). The practical implications lie in the need for credit unions to develop acquisition strategies that minimize the perceived effort in the transition and maximize the visibility of long-term benefits. This may include offering attractive welcome packages, simplifying service portability processes, and creating digital tools that facilitate migration, reducing friction and time spent by the consumer.
The age range of the participants was also analyzed, providing insights into different financial needs and priorities. According to Figure 3, most respondents are in the 32 to 40 age range (41%), followed by those over 50 years old (27%) and between 25 and 32 years old (25%). The 18 to 25 years and 36 to 50 years age ranges represent smaller portions, with 2% and 4%, respectively.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Age Range
This age profile suggests a predominantly adult and financially active sample, with responsibilities and needs that can range from wealth building to retirement planning. The concentration in more mature age groups (over 32 years old) indicates that respondents likely already have experience with more complex financial products and are in life stages that demand greater stability and financial planning. This finding aligns with studies demonstrating that the pursuit of security and profitability tends to increase with age and financial experience (Maia, 2022). The significant presence of individuals over 50 years old is also noteworthy, as this group may be more inclined to value institutional solidity and security, aspects that credit cooperatives, with their generally higher Basel Index, can offer (Arruda, 2020). Cooperatives should therefore adapt their product and service offerings to meet the specific needs of each age group, from credit lines for young entrepreneurs to investment and pension options for the more experienced, always emphasizing the security and participatory governance that characterize them. Audience segmentation by age group allows cooperatives to create more relevant financial products and services, such as credit lines for real estate acquisition for the 32 to 40-year-old audience, or low-risk pension and investment plans for the over-50 audience, communicating the benefits in a personalized way.
Regarding gender, Figure 4 shows that 69% of respondents are women and 31% are men.
Source: Original research results
Figure 4. Gender
This female predominance in the sample may influence perceptions of service, security, and social impact, as studies indicate that women may have different financial priorities and behaviors compared to men (Marion, 2021). For example, some research suggests that women tend to value personalized service and security in financial transactions more, in addition to being more likely to engage in activities that promote social and community well-being. This characteristic of the sample should be considered in the interpretation of the results, as the identified preferences and motivators may partly reflect the priorities of a predominantly female audience. For cooperatives, this may mean the need to develop communication strategies and products that resonate with the concerns and values of this segment, such as financial education programs for women, credit products with flexible conditions that meet their specific needs, or the promotion of social impact initiatives that engage them. Understanding gender nuances in financial behavior can optimize the effectiveness of marketing campaigns and the relevance of the products offered.
When investigating the reason for opening an account in financial institutions, Figure 5 reveals that 37% of respondents cite “Products and Services” as the main reason, followed by “Other” with 36%, “Customer Service” with 16%, and “Profit Sharing” and “Fees” both with 6%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 5. Reason for opening an account in a Financial Institution
The prevalence of “Products and Services” as the main motivator indicates that offering a complete and competitive portfolio is fundamental to attracting new clients. This includes everything from current and savings accounts to credit lines, investments, and insurance. The fact that “Other” represents such a high percentage (36%) suggests that there are diverse motivators not captured by the predefined categories, which may include recommendations, geographical proximity, or very specific needs. “Customer Service” (16%) also proves relevant, reinforcing the importance of quality in customer relationships, a differentiator often associated with credit unions (Toffoli, 2023). The low mention of “Profit Sharing” and “Fees” as initial reasons for opening an account (both 6%) may indicate an initial lack of awareness about these specific benefits of the co-operative model, which are frequently highlighted as its main competitive advantages (Moreira & Junges, 2019). This suggests that, although these benefits exist, they may not be the primary factor that leads an individual to open an account, but rather a factor for long-term retention or satisfaction. Therefore, co-operatives should focus on a competitive offering of products and services, while also educating the public about the unique benefits of co-operativism, such as profit sharing, which can become stronger motivators after joining. Further investigation into what constitutes the “Other” category could reveal valuable insights for attraction strategies, while communication of long-term benefits should be integrated into the new member onboarding process.
The research also sought to identify the main reason that led participants to join and remain associated with a credit cooperative. Figure 6 shows that “The service and the facilities offered to the user” and “The economic benefits and advantages that the cooperative offers” are the main motivators, both with 37% and 35% respectively. “Involvement with the community and the social benefits derived” represents 14%, “Network of relationships provided by the association” 6%, and “The qualities of the cooperative in general” 4%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 6. Main reason that led them to associate
This result corroborates the literature that highlights personalized service and financial advantages as pillars of credit unionism. The service and facilities, which include proximity and humanization of the service, are frequently cited as a differential of cooperatives compared to large banks, which often prioritize scale over personalization (Toffoli, 2023). Economic benefits, such as lower interest rates and reduced fees, are a direct and tangible attraction, aligning with the findings of Silva and Cembramanel (2023) and Maia (2022) on the competitiveness of cooperatives. Community involvement and social benefits, although less cited as primary motivators, are still relevant (14%), reflecting the intrinsic social purpose of cooperatives, as advocated by Souza (2024) and Ribeiro & Menezes (2024). The low representation of “general cooperative qualities” (4%) and “relationship network” (6%) may indicate that these aspects are perceived as an integral part of the benefit package, but are not decisive factors in isolation. Cooperatives should continue to invest in service excellence and clear communication of their economic benefits, while reinforcing their role in local development and relationship network building, which can generate long-term loyalty. Promoting community events and disseminating the social impact of cooperatives can strengthen the bond with members and attract new members who value these aspects.
Regarding the fulfillment of financial services interests and needs, Figure 7 shows that 41% of respondents state that their needs are met “Almost always”, and 27% “Always meets”. Only 25% indicate “Sometimes”, 4% “Never meets” and 4% “Rarely”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 7. Service to the interests and needs of financial services
This data demonstrates a high level of general satisfaction with the fulfillment of financial needs, with 68% of respondents indicating that their needs are met “Almost always” or “Always met”. This result is consistent with the concept of Net Promoter Score (NPS) mentioned in the introduction, where credit unions often outperform traditional banks in customer satisfaction (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023). The perception that financial institutions, whether credit unions or banks, can meet customer demands is a critical factor for retention and building lasting relationships. The portion of respondents reporting “Sometimes”, “Never met” or “Rarely” (33% in total) represents an opportunity for institutions to improve their services and identify gaps in service. For credit unions, maintaining and improving this high level of satisfaction is crucial to consolidate their market position and attract new members. This involves not only offering suitable products but also agility in problem-solving and proactivity in identifying new member needs. The implementation of continuous feedback systems and personalized service based on the member’s history and preferences can further elevate satisfaction levels.
When analyzing the financial institution that participants move the most, Figure 8 reveals that Itaú leads with 37%, closely followed by Digital Banks with 30%. Bradesco represents 11%, Banco do Brasil 10%, Caixa Econômica Federal 4%, and Santander 4%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 8. Financial Institution with the highest volume
This result highlights the strong presence of large traditional banks and the significant growth of digital banks in the Brazilian financial landscape. Itaú’s leadership and the expressive participation of digital banks demonstrate the intense competition that credit cooperatives face. While traditional banks benefit from their capillarity and brand recognition, digital banks attract customers with the promise of agility, technological innovation, and often reduced costs (Santos, 2023). The low representation of credit cooperatives in this regard, although not explicitly shown in the figure, can be inferred from the predominance of other institutions. This reinforces the need for cooperatives to intensify their marketing and communication strategies to increase their visibility and attract a larger share of the public that moves its resources in other institutions. Competition with digital banks, in particular, requires cooperatives to invest in technology and digitalization, without losing the essence of personalized service and social purpose that distinguishes them (Orsatto & Silva, 2022). The creation of intuitive applications, efficient internet banking platforms, and the offering of competitive digital services are essential to compete in this scenario.
The benefits considered in choosing a financial institution were investigated in Figure 9. “Reduced operational fees” are the most relevant factor, with 43% of mentions, followed by “Quality of service” with 24%. Other factors include “Market Representation” (14%), “Investment return rate” (10%), “Branch location” (4%), “Number of branches” (4%), and “Waiting time for service” (4%).
Source: Original research results
Figure 9. What are the benefits considered in the choice of a financial institution
The primacy of “Reduced operational fees” as a selection criterion highlights consumers’ sensitivity to the cost of financial services. This finding is crucial for credit unions, which often offer more competitive rates compared to traditional banks, as highlighted by Silva and Cembramanel (2023) and Moreira & Junges (2019). “Quality of service” in second place (24%) reinforces the importance of humanized and efficient service, a strong point for credit unions. “Market representativeness” (14%) may reflect the search for solid and recognized institutions, while “Investment return rate” (10%) indicates that profitability is an important factor for a portion of respondents. The low relevance of “Branch location”, “Number of branches”, and “Waiting time for service” (all at 4%) may be a reflection of the growing digitalization of financial services, where physical presence becomes less critical for many consumers. Credit unions should capitalize on their competitive advantage in terms of costs and quality of service, communicating these benefits clearly and consistently. Furthermore, they should continue to invest in digital platforms to complement their physical network, meeting the expectations of an increasingly digitized audience. Transparency in fees and explicit comparison with competitors can be effective strategies.
One of the most critical findings for the growth of credit co-operativism is the level of knowledge of the respondents about this model. Figure 10 reveals that 41% of participants “Know and understand how a credit co-operative works”, which is a considerable percentage, but not the majority. However, 35% “Have heard of it, but do not know how it works”, and 14% “Do not know and have never heard of it”. Only 10% “Know, but only credit co-operatives for individuals”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 10. Level of knowledge about credit cooperatives
This data indicates a significant knowledge gap regarding the cooperative model, despite a considerable portion of respondents having some familiarity. The sum of those who are unaware or have superficial knowledge (35% + 14% = 49%) represents almost half of the sample, which is a substantial barrier to adoption. This lack of awareness is one of the main challenges for the expansion of credit unions, as pointed out in the abstract of the work and by authors such as Souza (2024), who highlight low institutional disclosure as an impediment. The lack of understanding about how cooperatives operate, which fundamentally differ from commercial banks due to their non-profit purpose and democratic management, prevents potential members from fully realizing their benefits. The practical implications are clear: credit unions need to invest heavily in financial education and awareness campaigns that simply and accessibly explain what credit unionism is, how it works, and what its differentiators are. This strategy must go beyond mere advertising, seeking to engage the public in a learning process that demystifies the model and builds trust. Creating educational content in various formats (videos, infographics, podcasts) and partnering with educational institutions can be effective in disseminating this knowledge.
Complementing the previous finding, Figure 11 details respondents’ knowledge about the specific benefits of joining a credit union. The results show that 37% “Have no knowledge of the benefits”, while 30% “Know about reduced interest rates and low financing costs”. Other less known benefits include “Profit sharing” (13%), “Below-market operational fees and annual charges” (12%), and “Personalized service” (8%).
Source: Original research results
Figure 11. Knowledge about the benefits of joining a credit cooperative
The high percentage of respondents who are unaware of the benefits (37%) reinforces the need for more effective education and communication campaigns. It is concerning that, even among those with some knowledge of cooperatives, many still do not know the concrete advantages of joining. However, the recognition of “reduced interest rates and low financing costs” by 30% of participants is a positive point, as this is one of the most tangible and attractive differentiators of cooperatives, as evidenced by Moreira and Junges (2019) and Silva and Cembramanel (2023). The low perception of “Participation in results” (13%) and “Operational fees and annual dues below market rates” (12%) indicates that these benefits, although economically relevant, are not being effectively communicated. “Personalized service” (8%), despite being a strong point of cooperatives, is not widely recognized as a specific benefit. Practical implications suggest that cooperatives should not only publicize the existence of their benefits but also quantify and exemplify them, showing how they translate into real savings for members. Communication should be directed to highlight the most valued financial benefits, such as interest rates and fees, and, in parallel, educate about participation in results as a unique differentiator of the model.
The reasons for the lack of knowledge about the benefits of credit cooperatives were investigated in Figure 12. The “Lack of announcements, advertising, disclosure of cooperatives” is the main reason, with 39% of mentions, followed by “Lack of interest” with 34%. The “Difficulty in finding information” accounts for 14%, and “Lack of time” for 13%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 12. Reasons for unawareness of benefits
This result is a clear warning for credit unions. “Lack of disclosure” (39%) is an external barrier that can be overcome with investments in marketing and institutional communication. The perception of “low institutional disclosure” had already been mentioned in the work’s summary as one of the obstacles to expansion. In contrast, “Lack of interest” (34%) is an internal barrier, which can be influenced by initial unfamiliarity with the model and consumer inertia in seeking new financial options. “Difficulty in finding information” (14%) and “Lack of time” (13%) also contribute to the scenario of unawareness. These findings corroborate the need for more robust and targeted communication strategies, which not only inform but also awaken public interest. The literature on financial services marketing (Cordeiro et al., 2023) emphasizes that visibility and accessibility of information are crucial for consumer decision-making. Cooperatives should, therefore, not only increase their presence in traditional and digital media channels but also simplify how information is presented, making it easily understandable and relevant to the daily lives of potential members.
To understand how respondents obtained information about the benefits of cooperatives, Figure 13 questioned the means of knowledge. “Cooperative employees” and “Internet and social media” are the most cited means, both with 41% of mentions. “Newspapers and/or television ads” represent 11%, and “Contact with other members” 6%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 13. Means of knowing the benefits
The equivalence between “Cooperative Employees” and “Internet and social media” as main sources of information is a significant finding. This demonstrates that, despite increasing digitalization, human contact and personalized service remain crucial for disseminating information about credit unions. Employees play a vital role as brand ambassadors, capable of clearly and reliably explaining the benefits and the cooperative model. This aspect aligns with the valuation of “Personalized Service” (Toffoli, 2023) and “Participatory Management” (Vieira, 2023) as cooperative differentiators. In parallel, the strong influence of “Internet and social media” (41%) highlights the importance of a robust and strategic digital presence. Cooperatives need to optimize their online channels, ensuring that information is easily accessible, up-to-date, and engaging, leveraging the potential of social media to reach a broader and younger audience (Cordeiro et al., 2023). The low relevance of “Newspapers and/or television ads” (11%) and “Contact with other members” (6%) suggests that traditional media may have limited reach for this specific audience, and that word-of-mouth, while important, is not the primary source of initial information. The practical implications indicate that cooperatives should invest in training and development of their employees to be effective in communicating benefits, and simultaneously, develop a comprehensive digital strategy that includes informative websites, active social media profiles, and relevant content that educates and attracts potential members.
The research also explored what benefits would motivate respondents to switch from commercial banks to credit unions. Figure 14 reveals that “Reduced operational fees and interest rates” is the main motivator, with 39% of mentions. Next, “Ease of membership and less bureaucracy” (24%), “Profit sharing” (21%), and “Personalized service” (16%) appear.
Source: Original research results
Figure 14. Benefits that would lead to replacing commercial banks with credit unions
This finding is fundamental for credit unions, as it identifies leverage points to attract customers from traditional banks. The predominance of “Lower operational fees and interest rates” (39%) as a migration factor confirms consumers’ sensitivity to the cost of financial services and the competitive advantage of credit unions in this regard (Silva and Cembramanel, 2023; Moreira & Junges, 2019). “Ease of membership and less bureaucracy” (24%) indicates that simplifying adhesion processes can be a strong attraction, especially for an audience that values agility and convenience. “Participation in results” (21%) is a unique differentiator of the cooperative model, offering a direct financial return to members, distinguishing it from the profit maximization model of banks for shareholders (Maia, 2022). “Personalized service” (16%), although less cited as a migration factor, is still relevant and reinforces the perception of a more human and closer service. The practical implications are clear: credit unions should focus their acquisition campaigns on explicitly communicating their lower fees and interest rates, simplify their adhesion processes, and highlight participation in results as a tangible financial benefit. Furthermore, they should continue to improve personalized service, as it contributes to member satisfaction and loyalty, even if it is not the main trigger for the initial change.
Finally, the research investigated the reasons for not associating with a credit union, a crucial aspect for understanding entry barriers. Figure 15 shows that “Lack of knowledge” is the most cited reason, with 69% of mentions. In second place, “Lack of security and trust” appears with 37%. “Difficulty in finding branches” accounts for 10%, and “Lack of quality in services provided” for 9%.
Source: Original research results
Figure 15. Reasons for not joining a credit union
This is, perhaps, the most impactful finding of the study. The overwhelming majority of respondents who do not associate with credit unions do so due to “Lack of knowledge” (69%). This result corroborates the perception of “lack of knowledge of the cooperative model” and “low institutional disclosure” mentioned in the work’s abstract and by Souza (2024). The lack of information prevents potential members from understanding the benefits and functioning of cooperatives, creating an insurmountable barrier. “Lack of security and trust” (37%) is the second most relevant reason, which may be a direct consequence of this lack of knowledge. When the public does not understand the model, they may perceive it as less secure or less regulated than traditional banks, even though credit unions have higher Basel ratios and are regulated by the Central Bank (Arruda, 2020). This perception of insecurity is a “market fallacy,” as the TCC text itself points out, but it needs to be actively combated. “Difficulty in finding branches” (10%) and “Lack of quality in services provided” (9%) are less significant, but still indicate areas for improvement. The practical implications are urgent: cooperatives need to launch massive education and awareness campaigns that not only explain the model but also reinforce its solidity, security, and regulation. It is fundamental to demystify the idea that cooperatives are less secure and to build an image of trust through transparent communication and testimonials from satisfied members. Increasing visibility and accessibility, both physical and digital, is also essential to overcome these barriers and allow more people to consider credit unionism as a viable and advantageous alternative.
The integrated analysis of the field research results with the theoretical literature allows for an in-depth understanding of the motivators and differentials of credit cooperatives. The profile of the respondents, characterized by high education and financial maturity, indicates that the public is capable of discerning and valuing the more sophisticated aspects of the cooperativist model, such as profit sharing and democratic management. However, the persistent “Lack of knowledge” about the model and its benefits, coupled with “Lack of security and trust”, emerges as the main barrier to the adhesion and expansion of cooperatives. This scenario contrasts with the economic and social advantages that cooperatives offer, such as “Reduced operational fees and interest rates” and “Personalized service”, which are recognized as strong motivators for switching financial institutions.
The reviewed literature, including works by Paiva & Santos (2009), Cunha et al. (2020), Moreira & Junges (2019), and Souza (2024), consistently points to the differentials of cooperatives in terms of credit pricing, social impact, and local development. The research results confirm that these attributes are valued by consumers, but the perception of these benefits is overshadowed by a lack of information. The comparison with traditional banks and fintechs, as discussed by Vieira (2023) and Santos (2023), reveals that cooperatives have a more horizontal governance model and a purpose that prioritizes the member and the community, in contrast to profit maximization for shareholders. This distinction, although theoretically attractive, does not translate into greater adherence due to low visibility and perceived risk.
The practical implications are multifaceted. Firstly, credit unions must intensify their communication and marketing strategies, focusing not only on product promotion but on educating about the cooperative model itself. This includes explaining participatory governance, the distribution of surplus earnings, and social impact, using clear and accessible language for the general public. Secondly, it is crucial to combat the perception of lack of security and trust, highlighting regulation by the Central Bank of Brazil and financial soundness indicators, such as the Basel Ratio, which often surpass those of commercial banks (Arruda, 2020). Testimonials from members and successful local development cases can be powerful tools for building this trust.
Additionally, cooperatives must capitalize on the most effective information channels identified in the research: their own employees and digital platforms. Investing in employee training so they become true consultants and ambassadors of cooperativism is essential. In parallel, a robust digital strategy, with an active presence on social media and quality informative content, can reach a broader and younger audience, which seeks agility and convenience. Ease of association and reduction of bureaucracy should also be prioritized, as these are factors that would motivate the migration of customers from commercial banks. By simplifying membership processes and offering a fluid digital experience, cooperatives can reduce the perceived switching costs for consumers.
In summary, the results of this study reinforce that credit cooperatives have significant growth potential in the Brazilian financial system, driven by their competitive advantages in terms of costs, service, and social purpose. However, for this potential to be fully realized, it is imperative that they overcome the barriers of lack of awareness and perception of insecurity. This requires a coordinated and strategic effort in education, communication, and continuous improvement of the member experience, ensuring that the benefits of cooperativism are widely understood and valued by the public.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved, identifying the main motivators and differentials that lead individuals to choose credit unions over other financial institutions. The research revealed that economic benefits, such as reduced operational fees and interest rates, and the quality of personalized service are the factors most valued by members. The cooperative model, with its democratic management and focus on local development, demonstrates significant growth potential. However, the study showed that the main barrier to joining is the lack of knowledge about how cooperatives work and their benefits, followed by the perception of a lack of security and trust. This information gap prevents potential members from fully understanding the competitive advantages and the solidity of the sector.
This study, although robust in its findings, presents limitations inherent to its methodology, such as the sample size of 122 respondents and the application via Google Forms, which may introduce selection biases and limit geographical representativeness. For future studies, it is suggested to conduct research with larger and more regionally diverse samples, focusing on communication and financial education strategies that demystify co-operative credit unions. It would be valuable to investigate the effectiveness of targeted campaigns for specific audiences and deepen the understanding of “lack of interest” and the perception of security, using qualitative methodologies. Additionally, exploring the impact of digitalization on attracting new members and overcoming knowledge barriers can offer crucial insights for the sector’s advancement.
Bibliographic References
CUNHA, V. C. da; ATTADIA GALLI, L. C. do L.; PRATES, G. A.; SAVI, A. F.; SANTANA, E. A. Cooperativismo de crédito: uma alternativa para o desenvolvimento econômico e social. Revista Científica Multidisciplinar Núcleo do Conhecimento, v. 4, n. 10, p. 1–20, 2020. Disponível em: https://www.nucleodoconhecimento.com.br/administracao/cooperativismo-de-credito.
MAIA, L. L. Eficiencia e ciclo de vida das cooperativas de crédito: uma abordagem econômica. Repositório Institucional da UFMG, 2022.
PAIVA, Benedito Geovani Martins de; SANTOS, Neusa Maria Bastos Fernandes dos. Um estudo do cooperativismo de crédito no Brasil. Revista da Universidade Vale do Rio Verde, v. 15, n. 2, 2017. Disponível em: http://dx.doi.org/10.5892/ruvrd.v15i2.4277.
SILVA,
SISTEMA OCB. Anuário do Cooperativismo Brasileiro 2025. Brasília: Organização das Cooperativas Brasileiras, 2025. Disponível em: https://www.somoscooperativismo.coop.br/anuario.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Economics, Investments and Banking of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform