October 26, 2026
Improvement of the Failure Investigation Process through Project Management and Reliability Engineering
Mauricio Gomes Maciel Junior; Fabiano José Stocco De Campos
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601225
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
The oil and gas sector, characterized by its operational complexity, demands high reliability in well completion equipment. This work aimed to develop and implement a structured model for investigating failures in these operations, seeking to reduce response time and improve the quality of technical reports. The research, of an applied nature, used a case study with an action-research approach, conducted in Macaé-RJ. Initially, the existing process was mapped, identifying gaps such as the lack of standardization and the high response time. Subsequently, an improvement project was conducted based on project management practices and the application of the Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) and 5 Whys methodologies for root cause identification. The implementation, which occurred in December 2025, included the standardization of reports, team training, and reorganization of the investigative workflow. The results demonstrated a significant reduction in the average failure analysis time, which decreased from approximately 30 to 7 days, representing a reduction of about 77% in response time. An improvement was also observed in the quality of technical reports and customer satisfaction, in addition to the elimination of recurring failures. It was concluded that the integration of failure analysis tools and project management practices contributed substantially to operational reliability and the efficiency of investigative processes.
Keywords: Root cause; Operational reliability; Project management; Process improvement; Offshore operations.
1. Introduction
With the increasing competitiveness in the industrial sector and the pressure for greater operational efficiency, companies have been striving to improve their productive and managerial processes. In this context, being able to detect problems, understand their causes, and implement effective improvements becomes a strategic differential, especially in areas with high technological complexity. According to Slack, Chambers, and Johnston (2009), well-functioning operations management is crucial for companies to align their processes with market needs, always offering quality and reliability, in addition to keeping operational costs low.
This is even more crucial in the oil and gas sector, where operations are carried out under severe conditions, with high pressures, elevated temperatures, and in highly corrosive environments. Because of these characteristics, the probability of equipment and system failures increases significantly, making it essential to implement good reliability engineering practices. Silva and Almeida (2018) state that operational reliability is essential to ensure the continuity of operations, minimize safety risks, and avoid financial losses due to unplanned shutdowns.
In this context, failure investigation processes become essential in organizations, as they go beyond simply pointing out the immediate causes of a problem and delve into the root causes that generate failures. By employing structured analytical methodologies, such as Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) and the 5 Whys technique, it is possible to address issues systematically, which leads to a reduction in the repetition of failures and continuous improvement of processes within the organization. As Paladini (2012) points out, the quality and efficiency of processes are closely linked to the ability to perform critical analysis and implement improvements based on reliable data.
Integrating project management practices with process improvement has been an effective strategy to provide more control, organization, and predictability in the actions taken. According to the Project Management Institute (PMI, 2021), the use of structured project management methodologies enables the planning of activities, the definition of responsibilities, and the monitoring of results, which helps to achieve objectives more efficiently.
Despite the importance of failure analysis tools and good practices in project management, it is common to find organizations that still have difficulties in standardizing their investigation processes. Frequently, the lack of well-defined methodologies, the lack of integration between the involved areas, and the absence of clear workflows lead to slow processes, rework, and low quality of technical reports. This shows that there is a deficiency in creating more efficient and organized models to improve failure investigation, reducing response time and increasing confidence in the analyses performed.
It is therefore crucial to investigate and suggest improvements in the failure analysis process, especially in activities as critical as well completion in the oil and gas sector. Integrating reliability engineering tools with project management practices can lead to much better organizational performance, resulting in greater efficiency, lower costs, and higher customer satisfaction. The optimization of these processes contributes directly to operational safety and the reduction of financial impacts, fundamental elements for the sustainability and competitiveness of companies operating in this segment.
In this way, this work aims to create and apply a systematic model for the investigation of failures in well completion operations, seeking to reduce the investigation response time and improve the quality of technical reports, which will result in greater operational reliability and efficiency in industrial processes.
2. Material and Methods
This study was characterized as an applied research, aiming at the proposition of practical improvements in an existing organizational process, with a focus on obtaining direct answers to problems found in the industrial sector. The methodology adopted was mixed, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches, as it included a detailed description of the processes and the measurement of performance indicators. The research strategy employed was a case study with an action-research approach, according to the guidelines of Yin (2005) and Thiollent (2011), which allowed for an in-depth analysis of the phenomenon in its real context and direct intervention for the implementation and evaluation of improvements. The research was conducted in the city of Macaé – RJ, a relevant hub for the oil and gas industry in Brazil.
To theoretically ground the study, a systematic literature review was initially conducted. The investigations were carried out in academic databases such as Google Scholar, Scopus, and SciELO. The terms “failure analysis”, “failure investigation”, “operational reliability”, “project management”, “fault tree analysis (FTA)”, and “root cause analysis” were used as descriptors. Articles published in the last 15 years that addressed the industrial context and practical studies with failure analysis tools were included. Duplicate articles, theoretical ones without practical application, or without full text were excluded, resulting in 17 relevant references to support the research, following the methodological guidelines of Yin (2005) and Thiollent (2011).
In the empirical stage, several techniques were employed for data collection. A documentary analysis was performed, which included the review of technical reports on previous failures, non-conformity records, and investigation histories. Additionally, structured interviews were conducted with specialists from the engineering, quality, and operations areas, seeking to obtain qualified opinions on the investigative process. Complementarily, direct observation was applied, monitoring investigation activities in real-time in the work environment, for a thorough understanding of the process dynamics, according to the case study approach (Yin, 2005).
Based on the collected information, the current failure investigation process was mapped using process modeling techniques. This diagnostic step enabled the identification of relevant gaps in the existing process, such as the lack of standardization, the long response time, and the absence of a structured methodology for root cause identification. These initial findings highlighted the need for a structured continuous improvement model (Paladini, 2012).
Based on the initial diagnosis, an improvement project was developed for the investigative process, structured according to the best practices of project management described in the PMBOK (PMI, 2021). The project was conducted systematically, covering the phases of initiation, planning, execution, and monitoring and control. This structuring aimed to ensure superior organization of activities, clear definition of responsibilities, and monitoring of results throughout its implementation.
In the project initiation phase, the scope was defined with a focus on reducing failure analysis time and improving the quality of technical reports. The main stakeholders were identified, including the engineering team, the quality department, operations, and the end customer. In the planning phase, improvement strategies were established, which included the selection of failure analysis methodologies, standardization of technical reports, definition of performance indicators, and planning of training for the involved team. Success criteria were also established, such as average analysis time and report delivery delay rate.
The project execution phase occurred in December 2025, when the planned actions were implemented. This included the application of the Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) methodologies and the 5 Whys technique for failure investigation, the standardization of analysis reports, and the conducting of training sessions with the technical team. Additionally, an improvement was implemented in the investigation workflow, allowing analyses to begin before the physical return of equipment to the workshop, which optimized response time.
In the monitoring and controlling phase, the previously defined performance indicators were tracked, such as average analysis time, investigation start time, quantity of recurring non-conformities, and customer acceptance. This stage was fundamental to evaluate the effectiveness of the implemented improvements and make adjustments when necessary. The adopted approach allowed for the integration of concepts from quality management, reliability engineering, and project management, providing a systemic view of the investigative process and contributing to the continuous improvement of operations (Slack, Chambers, and Johnston, 2009).
For the data analysis, the Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) methodology and the 5 Whys technique were used, which served for a logical analysis of failures and for discovering the root causes of problems, respectively. Structured brainstorming sessions were also employed to deepen the understanding of failures and define corrective actions. The definition and monitoring of performance indicators (KPIs) were essential to measure process evolution and control implemented improvements (Slack, Chambers and Johnston, 2009).
The organization of the collected and analyzed data was carried out through the standardization of technical reports, which allowed for a more consistent presentation of results and a more uniform analysis of failures. This standardization was crucial for the traceability of information and for the construction of an organizational knowledge base, according to the principles of quality management (Paladini, 2012).
3. Results and Discussion
This section details the results obtained from the implementation of the structured model for the investigation of failures in well completion operations, as well as the discussion on the significance of these findings in the context of operational reliability and process efficiency. The results demonstrate a significant transformation in the investigative process, which moved from a reactive and unstandardized approach to a proactive and systematic model, aligned with the objectives of reducing response time and improving the quality of technical reports.
Initially, the process of investigating failures in the organization presented predominantly reactive characteristics, with a notable absence of standardization in its stages. The dependence on the physical return of equipment to the workshop for the analysis to begin generated an average waiting time of approximately two weeks, considerably delaying the response to non-conformities. This operational gap compromised the agility and effectiveness of investigations, directly impacting the company’s ability to resolve problems in a timely manner.
The previous operational flow was initiated by the receipt of a non-conformity reported by the client, but without the formal opening of an investigation. Tests were defined in informal brainstorming meetings, lacking methodological standardization and structured recording of decisions. The engineering team was responsible for preparing technical reports, but the absence of clear definition of responsibilities between the engineering, quality, workshop, and operations areas resulted in conflicts and difficulties in deadline management.
The main bottlenecks identified were concentrated in the engineering area, due to the lack of a structured and standardized investigation flow. The quality area, although responsible for deadline control, did not have governance over the investigative process, which frequently led to delays. Additionally, the high rework rate, resulting from incomplete, inconsistent, or client-unaccepted analyses, highlighted the absence of a structured approach to root cause identification, as illustrated in the old process
.
As a consequence of these inefficiencies, the average time for failure analysis was approximately 30 days, with an 83% delay rate in the delivery of technical reports. This situation resulted in low reliability of the analyses performed and negatively impacted customer satisfaction. The need for a continuous improvement model was evident, as pointed out by Paladini (2012), who highlights the importance of critical analysis and the implementation of improvements based on reliable data for the quality and efficiency of processes.
Problem Analysis and Root Cause Identification
Based on the initial diagnosis, a structured failure analysis was performed using the Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) methodology, complemented by the 5 Whys technique. The initial FTA analysis showed that the failures were not restricted to individual components but were related to the system as a whole. Causes identified included inadequacy of materials for the environment, absence of clear design criteria, and failures in application validation, indicating a complexity that required a systemic view.
During the initial implementation phase, FTA was applied more in isolation, focusing on specific components. However, the need for rework led to the evolution of the analysis to a systemic approach, which considered the equipment’s behavior within the operational environment. This change was fundamental to identifying the real causes of recurring failures, providing a deeper understanding of the problems and allowing for the proposal of more effective corrective actions, as illustrated in the fault tree diagram.
.
The application of the 5 Whys technique was crucial to deepen the causes pointed out by the FTA, reaching the root of the investigated problems. A representative case involved the failure in the sealing of an equipment in the well, where the sequence of questions revealed that the root cause was linked to a design flaw, and not just an operational or execution failure. The investigation demonstrated that the sealing material was not adequate for the environment, the operational environment had not been correctly considered in the design, and there was no structured process for failure analysis and design feedback.
This approach allowed the identification of organizational problems that would not be evident in superficial analyses, such as the lack of standardized procedures or communication failures between teams. The ease of use and application of the 5 Whys enabled the participation of different levels of the organization in the investigation, fostering team involvement and establishing a culture of continuous improvement (Ohno, 1997; Imai, 2012). The combination of FTA with the 5 Whys resulted in a powerful and complementary approach, merging logical analysis and detailed root cause investigation (PMI, 2021).
Project Improvement Structuring (PMBOK Approach)
The improvement of the investigative process was conducted as a structured project, based on the project management practices described in the PMBOK (PMI, 2021). In the initiation phase, the project’s main objectives were to reduce failure analysis time, increase investigation quality, and eliminate failure recurrence. The main stakeholders involved were the quality team, responsible for process management, the engineering team, in charge of technical analysis, and the end customer.
In the planning phase, improvement strategies were defined, which included the standardization of the investigative process, the clear definition of responsibilities by area, the implementation of the FTA and 5 Whys methodologies, the creation of a standardized report model, and the definition of performance indicators. The project’s success criteria were established based on indicators such as average analysis time and the delay rate in report delivery, aiming to ensure the measurement of the effectiveness of the actions.
The execution phase occurred over approximately two months, involving a multidisciplinary team composed of three quality professionals and two engineers. The main actions implemented included defining a new investigation flow, immediate opening of investigations, team training in FTA, standardization of reports, and integration between areas. During this phase, rework was necessary in the FTA structure, migrating from a punctual analysis to a systemic approach, which reinforced the importance of adaptability in projects (Kerzner, 2017).
New Investigative Process (TO BE)
With the implementation of improvements, the failure investigation process was restructured to present a more efficient and standardized flow, as illustrated in the new process
. One of the main changes was the elimination of the lag time for the start of the investigation, allowing analyses to be initiated immediately after the failure occurred, without the need to wait for the physical return of the equipment to the workshop. This anticipation significantly optimized the process’s response time.
The new workflow established clear responsibilities: the quality team became responsible for the immediate opening of the investigation, while the engineering team assumed responsibility for the technical analysis. The operations and workshop areas began to act as technical support, ensuring more effective collaboration. This restructuring, based on the principles of lean management (Womack; Jones, 2004), aimed to eliminate waste and improve operational flows, resulting in greater agility and reliability in the results obtained.
Quantitative Results and Operational Impact
The evaluation of quantitative data demonstrated a considerable improvement in the performance of the investigative process. The average time for failure analysis was drastically reduced from approximately 30 days to 7 days, representing a decrease of about 77% in the investigative process response time. This significant reduction is a direct indicator of the effectiveness of the implemented actions and the importance of structured methodologies in process optimization, as illustrated in the comparison of the average analysis time
.
In addition to the reduction in response time, a substantial decrease in the delay rate for technical report delivery was observed. Before implementation, the delay rate was high, but with the new model, there was a considerable decrease, indicating stricter process control and more effective deadline management, as evidenced by the delay rate
. The elimination of recurring failures, which went from 15 open non-conformities to zero, and the reduction of costs associated with contractual fines were other significant quantitative gains.
Qualitative Results
Beyond quantitative indicators, relevant qualitative gains were observed. There was a significant improvement in the technical quality of the reports, which became clearer and more consistent in their analyses. The reduction in rework was notable, as investigations became more detailed and well-founded, decreasing the need for revisions and corrections. The integration between the involved areas was also enhanced, promoting a more collaborative and efficient work environment.
From the client’s perspective, there was explicit recognition of the improvement in the quality of investigations. The reports began to present a higher level of detail, methodological consistency, and professionalism, which contributed to strengthening confidence in the organization’s technical capacity. This positive client perception is crucial for the company’s competitiveness, especially in a sector as demanding as oil and gas (Kotler and Keller, 2012).
Impact of Standardization of Technical Reports
The standardization of technical reports represented one of the greatest innovations in the investigative process. Before the intervention, each report was prepared in a unique way, making it difficult to compare cases and track information. With standardization, a single format began to be used, with clear steps for describing the event, analyzing the cause, evidence, and action plan. This uniformity is fundamental to ensuring that processes are carried out with the same quality and consistency (Paladini, 2012).
The standardization of reports contributed directly to the reduction of rework, as the documents began to better meet the needs of clients and technical requirements. Well-defined processes generally have less variation and are more productive (Werkema, 2012). Furthermore, the improvement in internal and external communication was evident, as the standardized reports made analyses more accessible to all areas of the organization and clearer to clients (Slack, Chambers and Johnston, 2009).
The creation of a standardized reporting model also favored the construction of an organizational knowledge base. Valuable information for future investigations can be stored and reused, which is essential for organizational learning and continuous process improvement (Imai, 2012). This systematic approach strengthens the organization’s ability to learn from its failures and continuously improve its operations.
Reduction of Rework and Improvement of Operational Efficiency
The reduction in rework was one of the main benefits observed with the adoption of the new failure investigation model. The lack of a well-defined methodology in the previous process frequently resulted in incomplete or inconsistent analyses, leading to rejections by the client or requests for revisions. Thanks to the application of the FTA and 5 Whys tools, the analyses became more detailed and well-founded, significantly reducing the need for rework, which is a clear sign of quality improvement (Werkema, 2012).
Operational efficiency was improved through a more optimized workflow and faster analyses. The removal of unnecessary steps and the new organization of the process contributed to a more agile workflow. This transformation reflects the principles of lean production, which aims at the elimination of waste to increase efficiency (Womack and Jones, 2004). The ability to start analyses before the physical return of equipment was a crucial factor for this optimization.
The engineering team’s productivity also increased, as the team began to work in a more organized and structured manner. The clear definition of roles and the use of standardized methodologies aided in the management of available time and resources. Effective organization of activities is fundamental to the success of projects and processes, ensuring better organizational performance (Kerzner, 2017). This improvement in productivity contributed to the delivery of more consistent results in less time.
The reduction in rework had a positive impact on operational costs, reducing the need for overtime and technical rework. This demonstrates the relevance of using quality tools for the management of industrial processes, contributing to the reduction of expenses and the increase of the company’s profitability (Paladini, 2012). Process optimization, therefore, not only improved quality but also generated tangible financial benefits.
Integration between Areas and Improvement of Organizational Communication
The new research model promoted a more efficient integration between the areas of engineering, quality, operations, and workshop. In the previous process, the absence of structured communication between teams generated conflicts, delays, and inconsistent analyses. The reorganization of the workflow and the clear definition of roles and responsibilities allowed for much greater alignment between the areas, which is crucial for the efficiency of operations and the competitiveness of companies (Slack, Chambers, and Johnston, 2009).
Internal and external communication flowed more effectively thanks to the use of visual resources, such as FTA diagrams, and standardized reports. These elements made it easier to understand problems and their origins, accelerating and improving the quality of decisions. Effective communication is one of the pillars of project management (PMI, 2021), and its improvement contributed to a collaborative environment that stimulates knowledge sharing and continuous process improvement (Kerzner, 2017).
Sustainability of Improvements and Culture of Continuous Improvement
The implemented innovations were sustained by the institutionalization of new practices in the investigative process. The standardization of processes, team training, and constant monitoring of performance indicators were essential for the achieved results to be maintained over time. For continuous improvement to be more than a fleeting initiative, it is fundamental that it be integrated into the organization’s culture (Imai, 2012).
The established performance indicators made it possible to monitor the evolution of the process and identify new opportunities for improvement. This continuous monitoring is crucial to ensure the success of projects and processes within organizations, allowing for decision-making and adjustment of implemented strategies (PMI, 2021). Building an organizational culture focused on failure analysis and problem prevention, rather than a reactive strategy, resulted in fewer repeated failures and greater reliability in operations (Paladini, 2012).
The consolidation of improvements showed that the systematic implementation of management methodologies and tools is capable of producing sustainable and replicable results in various industrial contexts. This approach reinforces the relevance of innovation in process management to improve efficiency, reduce costs, and strengthen the competitiveness of organizations in the oil and gas sector (Kerzner, 2017). The results obtained demonstrate that the integration of failure analysis tools with project management practices contributes substantially to operational reliability and the efficiency of investigative processes.
4. Conclusion
The study aimed to create and apply a systematic model for the investigation of failures in well completion operations, seeking to reduce response time and improve the quality of technical reports, which would result in greater operational reliability and efficiency in industrial processes. It was verified that the previous investigative process was reactive and non-standardized, with an average analysis time of approximately 30 days and a high incidence of rework. The implementation of a structured model, based on the integration of Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) and 5 Whys methodologies with project management practices, resulted in significant gains. A reduction of about 77% in the average failure analysis time was observed, which decreased to 7 days, in addition to the elimination of failure recurrence and a substantial improvement in the quality and consistency of technical reports. This proactive and standardized approach contributed significantly to operational reliability and the efficiency of investigative processes, strengthening customer satisfaction and the organization’s ability to learn from failures.
However, it is important to consider that the research was conducted in a single organizational context, which may limit the generalization of the results to other companies or industry sectors. Additionally, the post-implementation monitoring period was relatively short, making it impossible to assess the long-term sustainability of the improvements. For future studies, it is recommended to apply the model in different operational scenarios and integrate complementary failure analysis tools, such as FMEA, as well as statistical failure analysis. It is also suggested to expand the use of performance indicators and digital management systems to promote greater automation and traceability of the investigative process.
Bibliographic References
KERZNER, H. 2017. Gestão de projetos: as melhores práticas. 3. ed. Porto Alegre: Bookman.
Kotler e Keller, 2012 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
PALADINI, E. P. 2012. Gestão da Qualidade: teoria e prática. São Paulo: Atlas.
PMI – PROJECT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE. 2021. A guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK Guide). 7 ed. Newtown Square.
SILVA, C. A.; ALMEIDA, R. F. 2018. Gestão da qualidade e confiabilidade em sistemas de produção offshore. Rio de Janeiro: Interciência.
SLACK, N.; CHAMBERS, S.; JOHNSTON, R. 2009. Administração da produção. São Paulo: Atlas.
THIOLLENT, M. 2011. Metodologia da pesquisa-ação. São Paulo: Cortez.
WERKEMA, C. 2012. Ferramentas estatísticas básicas para o gerenciamento de processos. Belo Horizonte: Werkema.
WOMACK, J. P.; JONES, D. T. 2004. A mentalidade enxuta nas empresas: elimine o desperdício e crie riqueza. Rio de Janeiro: Campus.
YIN, R. K. 2005. Estudo de caso: planejamento e métodos. Porto Alegre: Bookman.
ΙΜΑΙ, Μ. 2012. Kaizen: a estratégia para o sucesso competitivo. São Paulo: IMAM.
ΟΗΝΟ, Τ. 1997. O sistema Toyota de produção: além da produção em larga escala. Porto Alegre: Bookman.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform