October 26, 2026
Improving Communication between Stakeholders in Sanitation Project Using BIM
Reinaldo Shoiti Yamashita; Aline Gisele Zanao Benatto
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603397
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The urgency imposed by the Legal Framework for Basic Sanitation (Brazil, 2020), which aims to universalize water and sewage treatment and distribution by 2033, makes the optimization of communication among stakeholders crucial for the speed and quality of projects. In this context, stakeholder management in a basic project for the expansion of a water treatment plant was analyzed, where Design Review meetings with 3D BIM were used as a tool to improve communication. The objective was to verify if the use of BIM in a retrofit project of a Water Treatment Plant (WTP) improved communication among stakeholders. The methodology employed a descriptive research, using a mixed-methods survey, both qualitative and quantitative. A questionnaire was sent to the project stakeholders. The results showed that all respondents perceived significant or partial improvements in communication, project understanding, early identification of delay risks, reduction of rework, and compatibility among the involved disciplines. It was concluded that 3D BIM and Design Review meetings are effective tools for improving communication and efficiency in sanitation projects, although the need for training and more frequent meetings was pointed out as opportunities for improvement.
Keywords: BIM 3D; Design Review; Water treatment plant; Stakeholders.
1. Introduction
The discussion on project management begins, which, according to the Project Management Institute (PMI, 2021), represents a temporary endeavor to create a unique product, service, or result, with a defined beginning and end. In the context of engineering, especially in the sanitation sector, a project arises from the need to solve problems, such as the construction of water or sewage treatment plants, or the expansion of distribution and collection networks. In this scenario, stakeholders are individuals or groups who can affect or be affected by the project, acting both internally and externally to the sanitation company (PMI, 2021).
The relevance of basic sanitation in Brazil is accentuated by the Legal Framework for Basic Sanitation (Brazil, 2020), which establishes ambitious goals for 2033: universalization of water treatment and distribution to 99% of the population and sewage collection and treatment for 90%. Data from the Instituto Trata Brasil (2024) reveal that, in 2021, more than 100 million Brazilians did not have access to sewage collection and treatment, and almost 35 million lacked potable water. Given this panorama and the limited timeframe, the execution of sanitation projects must be swift and of high quality, minimizing setbacks and risks.
To achieve the necessary efficiency and assertiveness in these projects, the adoption of innovative technologies is fundamental, such as Building Information Modeling (BIM). BIM is more than software; it is a socio-technical system that promotes transformations in the design, construction, and management processes of buildings (Sacks et al., 2021). This methodology allows for the creation of precise virtual models of buildings digitally, offering support in all project phases and improving analysis and control compared to conventional methods. BIM enables project development in less time, with faster elaboration, fewer errors, and higher quality, in addition to ensuring compatibility between the various disciplines involved, such as architecture, hydromechanical and electrical installations, and structure (De Sá, 2023).
Communication is an essential pillar for effective stakeholder engagement in any project. The Project Management Institute (PMI, 2021) highlights that communication planning is crucial for interaction among stakeholders. In this context, the use of BIM can significantly optimize communication, as collaborative work processes and efficient information exchange among project participants are enhanced by this methodology (Sacks et al., 2021). The three-dimensional visualization and data integration provided by BIM facilitate project understanding for all involved, reducing ambiguities and potential conflicts.
The complexity of sanitation projects and the urgency of their goals demand tools that promote collaboration and clarity. The application of Design Review meetings using 3D BIM emerges as a promising strategy to enhance communication and efficiency. This study is justified by the need to investigate the effectiveness of this approach in a practical context, contributing to the advancement of project management practices in the sanitation sector. Thus, the objective of this work is to verify whether the use of BIM in a water treatment plant retrofit project improves communication among stakeholders.
2. Material and Methods
The research was descriptive in nature, employing a mixed-methods survey with a qualitative and quantitative approach. The central objective was to verify the improvement in communication among stakeholders in a water treatment plant (ETA) expansion project through the use of Building Information Modeling (BIM). This study focused on the basic design phase, seeking to understand the perception of those involved regarding the effectiveness of Design Review meetings with 3D BIM.
The study was conducted at a basic sanitation company in the state of São Paulo, which invests in the expansion of its infrastructures to meet the goals of the Legal Framework for Basic Sanitation. The specific project analyzed consisted of the implementation of a Filter Washing Water Recovery System (SRAL) and a Sludge Treatment and Drying System at an existing Water Treatment Plant (WTP). This basic project began in January 2024.
For the development of the basic project, a specialized company was hired to integrate several disciplines, including structural, architectural, urban planning, hydraulic-mechanical, electrical, and instrumentation/control. The client assigned professionals to manage, analyze, and approve each specialty. The operation and maintenance areas of the sanitation company also participated in the analysis process.
The BIM Execution Plan (BEP) was an essential component of project management, outlining roles, responsibilities, and guidelines for BIM use, according to Sacks et al. (2021). The contract’s terms of reference specified the software to be used by discipline. For topography, earthworks, roads, and drainage, AutoCAD Civil 3D was used. For architecture, structures, and building services, Autodesk Revit was employed.
Linear works and earthmoving were also developed with AutoCAD Civil 3D. For localized works, Revit, Plant, and Openplant were used. Project compatibility was carried out with Autodesk Navisworks. Documentation management occurred through Autodesk’s ACC Docs platform, which functions as a Common Data Environment (CDE).
Traditionally, the designer used to send the project by discipline, and the contractor’s coordinator would forward it for individual analysis. Doubts were clarified in specific meetings between the designer and the analyst. In this pilot project, however, the federated BIM model, which integrates architecture, structure, and hydromechanics in a single 3D visualization environment, was forwarded. BIM 3D Design Review meetings were implemented as a new form of communication.
The Design Review meetings were held virtually, facilitating the participation of all stakeholders, including professionals from all disciplines of the design firm and the contracting company, as well as managers and operation and maintenance teams. In these meetings, issues were pointed out directly in the 3D BIM model. After review by the design firm, a new meeting was held to verify compliance with the points raised and discuss justifications, seeking consensus for approval.
The data collection instrument was a structured questionnaire, organized into three parts, totaling fifteen questions. The first part aimed to identify the respondents’ profile, with five questions. The second part addressed participants’ perception of the work method with Design Review meetings using 3D BIM, containing nine questions. The third part requested suggestions for improving the method, with one open-ended question.
The study population comprised 30 participants involved in the project. The questionnaire was sent by email on March 25, 2026. Of these, 22 respondents completed the questionnaire, constituting the research sample. The data collection period lasted two weeks, during which the questionnaire remained available for participants to submit their answers.
The collected data were treated confidentially and anonymously, with the guarantee that no participant or company would be identified in the final report. The data analysis was based on the 22 responses obtained, seeking to understand participants’ perceptions of Design Review meetings with 3D BIM and suggestions for improving the method. Advanced statistical techniques were not employed, but rather a descriptive analysis of the responses.
3. Results and Discussion
This section details the research findings, interpreting them in light of the objective to verify whether the use of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in a Water Treatment Plant (WTP) retrofit project improved communication among stakeholders. The results obtained through the Survey-type survey, with a mixed approach, revealed unanimous perceptions of improvement in communication and project efficiency. The analysis was structured to present the participants’ profile, their perceptions about the application of Design Review with 3D BIM, and suggestions for the continuous improvement of the methodology, according to the logic of the original study.
In the domain of stakeholder performance, the Project Management Institute (PMI, 2021) emphasizes that projects are intrinsically carried out by and for people, making communication a fundamental pillar for effective stakeholder engagement. The adoption of BIM, in this context, has shown to favor an interactive environment for agile information analysis and sharing, contributing significantly to the improvement of engineering projects and construction execution, as pointed out by Freire et al. (2023). This theoretical perspective is corroborated by the empirical data collected, which will be detailed below.
Respondent Profile
The study sample consisted of 22 professionals, representing a diversity of stakeholders involved in the WTP expansion project. Positions included analysts (23%), technical support (23%), management (18%), designers (14%), operation/maintenance (14%), environment (5%), and BIM coordination (5%). This heterogeneous composition is crucial as it minimizes biases from a single area of expertise and enriches the analytical robustness of the collected perceptions, as highlighted by Creswell and Creswell (2021). The multiplicity of roles reflects the inherent complexity of sanitation projects and the need for effective communication among different specialties.
The participants’ experience in the sanitation sector proved to be predominantly high, with 64% of respondents having worked for over 10 years. Another 14% had between 6 and 10 years of experience, and 14% between 2 and 5 years, while only 9% had less than 2 years. This data is significant as it indicates that the professionals possess in-depth knowledge of the sector’s processes, challenges, and particularities. Such expertise lends greater weight to their perceptions of communication difficulties and the improvements provided by the applied methodology, validating the relevance of their opinions in the study’s context.
Regarding the experience with BIM, including the Common Data Environment (CDE), the team demonstrated a good level of familiarity with the technology. Half of the respondents (50%) considered themselves advanced, 27% intermediate, and 23% basic. This distribution suggests that the team possessed the necessary technical capacity for the effective implementation and utilization of BIM in the basic design. User competence is a determining factor for the success of adopting new technologies, and the high percentage of advanced and intermediate professionals indicates a conducive environment for innovation.
Previous experience with the Design Review system was equally divided: 50% of respondents had previously worked with a similar system, while the other 50% were encountering this methodology for the first time. This data is relevant because it indicates that, for half of the sample, the application of Design Review with 3D BIM represented an innovative work experience. Despite this, the frequency of participation in Design Review meetings on the project showed considerable engagement, with 45% participating occasionally and 36% frequently, totaling 82% active participation.
Perception of the 3D BIM Design Review
Stakeholders’ perception of the effectiveness of Design Review meetings with 3D BIM was largely positive, with a high agreement rate across all assessed issues, and no disagreement responses. Understanding of the basic design improved significantly for 95% of respondents and partially for 5%, compared to traditional 2D drawings. This improvement in understanding is a direct indicator of 3D BIM’s ability to provide clearer and more intuitive project visualization, facilitating interpretation by all involved, regardless of their specialty.
The early identification of risks of delay in the technical reports of the basic project was also perceived as significantly improved by 77% of participants and partially by 23%. This ability to predict problems is crucial for project management, allowing for proactive interventions and minimizing negative impacts on the schedule. Better control and efficiency of the project schedule were observed by 68% of respondents as significantly improved and by 32% as partially, evidencing the effectiveness of the methodology in time and resource administration.
The multidisciplinary harmonization of the project was significantly facilitated for 86% of respondents and partially for 14%. This is one of the greatest advantages of BIM, which allows the integration of various disciplines (architecture, structure, hydromechanics, electrical) into a single federated model, identifying conflicts (clashes) before the execution phase. The reduction of rework in subsequent stages of the basic design was perceived as significant by 59% and partial by 41%, a finding that directly corroborates the literature on the benefits of BIM in process optimization.
The reduction in time needed to make critical technical decisions was pointed out as significant by 73% of participants and partial by 27%. The presence of all disciplines involved in Design Review meetings facilitated discussion and real-time resolution of multidisciplinary problems, unlike the traditional method. This agility in decision-making is fundamental in complex projects such as sanitation, where delays can have significant implications for cost and deadlines.
The earliest identification of clashes between disciplines was significantly enabled by the use of 3D BIM for 82% of respondents and partially for 18%. This resulted in a decrease in the need for future rework, a direct benefit of three-dimensional visualization and BIM’s interference detection capabilities. Sacks et al. (2021) highlight that federated BIM, used with tools like Navisworks, is essential for interference detection and the promotion of more assertive collaborative processes.
The facilitation of analyses, reviews, and approvals of the technical reports for the basic design of the various disciplines was perceived as significant by 82% of participants and partial by 18%. This result corroborates previous findings on improved project understanding, ease of reconciliation, and agility in decision-making. The integration of federated BIM and virtual Design Review meetings enabled more efficient and inclusive collaboration, involving everyone from designers to operations and maintenance teams, which is fundamental for the quality and sustainability of sanitation projects.
Communication between designers, coordination, contractor, and other stakeholders improved significantly for 86% of respondents and partially for 14%. The unanimous perception of all 22 participants regarding the improvement of communication is one of the most relevant findings of the study, confirming the main objective of the research. The PMI (2021) emphasizes communication as a pillar of stakeholder engagement, and the 3D visualization provided by BIM, combined with virtual meetings, optimized this process, allowing interested parties to provide real-time feedback.
Suggestions for Method Improvement
The open question about what could improve the work method with Design Review meetings using 3D BIM generated valuable insights, with respondents being able to choose more than one option. The most frequent suggestions, with 73% of the responses each, were the need for more courses and training in 3D BIM tools, the holding of more Design Review meetings among stakeholders before the submission of revisions to reduce rework, and the inclusion of meetings by discipline involved in the project, in addition to multidisciplinary meetings.
These suggestions indicate that, although BIM technology and the Design Review methodology have been well received and their benefits recognized, there is still a demand for greater training and for a deeper integration of the review process into the project schedule. The request for disciplinary meetings, even with the success of multidisciplinary meetings in holistically understanding the basic design, points to the need to deepen specific technical discussions that may not be fully addressed in broader meetings.
Other suggestions, although less frequent (5% each), included the importance of controlling notes and inaccuracies for meeting efficiency, the need to guide involved personnel from the beginning of the cycle for satisfactory modeling, better preparation of participants for meetings, and standardization of templates for superficial analysis automation, focusing on technical engineering aspects. These observations reinforce the importance of a robust BIM Execution Plan (BEP), as advocated by Sacks et al. (2021), which should encompass not only the definition of software and procedures but also a continuous training plan for the team.
The organization’s BIM maturity is a critical factor for the success of the implementation, and the demand for training and more frequent meetings points to the need to invest in the learning curve and the adaptation of internal processes. The standardization of models and rigorous control of inputs are crucial aspects for the efficiency and effectiveness of Design Review meetings, ensuring that the benefits of BIM are fully exploited. These points for improvement, although they do not diminish the positive impact observed, indicate paths to consolidate and expand the gains in efficiency and communication.
In summary, the research results demonstrated that the application of 3D BIM together with Design Review meetings in the retrofit project of the Water Treatment Plant (WTP) promoted significant improvements in communication among stakeholders, in project understanding, in early risk identification, in rework reduction, and in multidisciplinary coordination. The majority perception of the participants was that the methodology contributed to greater efficiency and assertiveness in project management, validating the premise that BIM technology is an effective tool for optimizing collaboration and information exchange in sanitation projects.
4. Conclusion
This study sought to verify whether the use of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in a Water Treatment Plant (WTP) retrofit project improved communication among stakeholders. It was found that the application of 3D BIM, along with Design Review meetings, promoted significant improvements in communication among interested parties, in the understanding of the basic design, and in the early identification of delay risks. A reduction in rework in subsequent stages, a notable facilitation in multidisciplinary coordination, and a decrease in the time required for critical technical decision-making were also observed. The ability to identify clash errors earlier was a relevant finding, corroborating the methodology’s effectiveness. The main contribution of this work lies in demonstrating that 3D BIM and Design Review meetings are effective tools for optimizing collaboration and information exchange in sanitation projects, promoting more efficient and assertive management, which is fundamental for the quality and sustainability of these infrastructures.
Despite the expressively positive results, the sample of 22 respondents, although representative of the pilot project, may be considered a limitation for broad generalizations, and the nature of the research, based on self-assessment of perceptions, may introduce a bias. As suggestions for improving the method, the need for continuous investments in training and courses in 3D BIM tools was identified, the holding of more Design Review meetings before the delivery of revisions to reduce rework, and the inclusion of meetings by discipline involved in the project, in addition to multidisciplinary ones. For future studies, the use of objective metrics is suggested, such as the number of clashes detected and resolved or the actual percentage reduction in rework, and a comparative study with the company’s database before and after the adoption of the method, in order to quantify the improvement in rework, approval time, and the quality of the basic project.
Bibliographic References
Brasil. 2020. Lei nº 14.026, de 15 de julho de 2020. Atualiza o marco legal do saneamento básico; e altera Lei nº 9.984, de 17 de julho de 2000. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, 16 jul. 2020. Seção 1, p. 1 a 5. Acesso em: 02. fev. 2025
Creswell, J. W.; Creswell, J. D. 2018. Research design: qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. 5. ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
De Sá, C.C. 2023. Análise da tecnologia BIM na elaboração de projetos arquitetônicos de engenharia habitacional. Revista Multi-Science Reserch (v.6n.1(2023): Janeiro – Junho). Disponível em: <https://msrreview.multivix.edu.br/index.php/msr/article/view/114> Acesso em: 02. fev. 2025
Freire, F. C.; Souza, L. A.; Eufrazio, E.P; Costa, H. G. 2023. Comunicação integrada na coordenação de projetos BIM par construção civil. In: XLIII Encontro Nacional de Engenharia de Produção, 2023, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brasil.
Instituto Trata Brasil [Trata Brasil]. 2024. Ranking do saneamento 2023-Release. Disponível em: <https://tratabrasil.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Press-release-ATUALIZADO-Ranking-do-Saneamento-2023-2.pdf>. Acesso em: 02 fev. 2025.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2021. Um Guia do Conhecimento em Gerenciamento de Projetos. 7ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Sacks, R.; Eastman, C.; Lee, G.; Teicholz, P. 2021; Manual de Bim: Um Guia de Modelagem da Informação da Construção para Arquitetos, Engenheiros, Gerentes, Construtores e Incorporadores. 3ed. Bookman, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform