October 26, 2026
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND OPTIMIZATION OF THE RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION PROCESS OF ORGANIZATIONS IN THE SUGAR-ENERGY SECTOR
Andressa Nicodemos Alves; Manoel Gonçales Filho
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202600556
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in recruitment and selection (R&S) has transformed the dynamics of the human resources area, promoting gains in efficiency, precision, and agility. The study aimed to identify the experiences of HR professionals regarding the application of AI in R&S, analyzing its benefits, challenges, and impacts on the organization, and verifying up to which stage of the selection process AI is relevant, in addition to proposing improvements based on the literature. The research, of an applied nature and qualitative approach, was developed through a case study in a large company in the sugarcane-energy sector, using semi-structured interviews with professionals directly involved in the process. The results showed that AI should be employed mainly in the talent screening and attraction stages, providing time savings, standardization of criteria, and greater alignment between the candidate’s profile and the organizational culture. However, from the interview and behavioral assessment phases onwards, human intervention proved essential to ensure ethical, empathetic, and contextualized decisions. The research contributed by highlighting the importance of balancing automation and human judgment, and proposed the periodic review of AI tools’ criteria, combining technological efficiency with ethical, inclusive, and strategic practices to strengthen organizational performance and candidate experience.
Keywords: Automation; People Management; Human Resources; Digital Transformation.
1. Introduction
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in the human resources (HR) area has intensified, with technologies assuming a central role in daily work activities. This growing proximity reflects the search for more practical and efficient solutions, redefining the dynamics of various sectors (Ribeiro, 2024).
In the context of recruitment and selection (R&S), AI has promoted a true revolution, automating repetitive and operational tasks, such as resume screening. This automation allows for more precise and concrete analyses, based on behavioral data and competencies (Garcia; Mendes, 2023). Benefits include cost reduction, better time utilization, and increased assertiveness in hiring (Appolinário et al., 2025).
The application of AI in R&S also contributes significantly to the reduction of human errors and unconscious biases, improving the alignment between the candidate’s profile and the organizational culture. In less digitized environments, resume screening can consume up to seventy percent of HR professionals’ time. AI, according to Sousa et al. (2019), facilitates communication with candidates, generates personalized feedback, and standardizes processes, making HR more strategic and data-driven.
Furthermore, the adoption of AI in selection processes empowers organizations to overcome limitations and biases, ensuring the selection of qualified talents. This encourages innovation and diversity, crucial factors for increasing competitive advantage in today’s market (Atanazio et al., 2021).
However, the implementation of AI in R&S is not without its challenges and ethical concerns. Issues such as data privacy, over-reliance on algorithms, and the possibility of dehumanization of the workplace are points that require attention (Garcia; Mendes, 2023; Martins, 2024). To mitigate these risks, it is essential for organizations to adopt governance practices, including constant audits, transparency in decision-making processes, and responsible technology use policies.
It is crucial that technology acts as a support to human judgment, and not as a substitute, especially in situations involving subjective aspects, such as motivation and performance evaluation. The balance between automation and human intervention is, therefore, an essential condition for AI to strengthen both organizational outcomes and the employee experience (Garcia; Mendes, 2023).
In this context, the problem arises of how artificial intelligence impacts and optimizes the recruitment and selection process in a specific organization in the sugar-energy sector, located in the State of São Paulo. There is a gap in understanding the experiences of HR professionals and in identifying up to which stage of the selection process AI’s performance is most relevant, ensuring ethical and effective use.
This work is justified by the growing adoption of AI tools in the organizational environment, which demands critical analyses of their practical and ethical implications, as well as the proposal of improvements that harmonize technology and human activity. Thus, the present study aims to identify the experiences of human resources professionals regarding the application of artificial intelligence in the recruitment and selection process, analyzing its benefits, challenges, and impacts on the organization, and to verify up to which stage of the selection process it is pertinent to maintain the performance of artificial intelligence.
2. Material and Methods
This research was characterized by its applied nature, seeking to generate knowledge for the solution of practical problems in organizational management (Gerhardt; Silveira, 2009). A qualitative approach was adopted, which allowed for an understanding of the perceptions, meanings, and interpretations attributed by human resources professionals to the use of artificial intelligence in recruitment and selection processes (Minayo, 2001).
Regarding the objectives, the study was classified as exploratory, as it provided greater familiarity with the investigated topic. It was also configured as bibliographic, by relying on theoretical references that substantiated the discussion, and explanatory, by seeking to understand the cause-and-effect relationships between technology and its impacts on people management practices (Gil, 2007).
The literature search was conducted in databases such as Google Scholar and Spell.Org, using keywords in Portuguese and English. The keywords used were: Artificial Intelligence, Recruitment and Selection, Human Resources, and Process Automation. This stage aimed at building the theoretical foundation for the study.
As a technical procedure, a case study was conducted in a large company in the sugar-energy sector, located in the state of São Paulo, Brazil. The investigated organization has approximately nine thousand employees in the country and is controlled by an international group of European origin.
The company’s Human Resources department, the focus of this research, is composed of forty-four professionals. Of these, twelve work directly in recruitment and selection processes. The company operates seven industrial units distributed in the northwest of São Paulo state, being a global leader in the production of sugar, ethanol, and renewable energy.
The study participants were twelve recruiters who work directly in the company’s recruitment and selection processes. The selection of these professionals was based on specific inclusion criteria: having a minimum of one year of experience in the R&S area and having participated in selection processes mediated by artificial intelligence technologies.
For data collection, semi-structured interviews were used, conducted in a private setting. The question guide was developed based on the main axes identified in the literature on artificial intelligence and recruitment and selection (R&S), as detailed in Appendix A of the original work.
The interviews had an average duration of 45 minutes and were conducted “online”, through the “Teams” platform. Notes were recorded with prior authorization from the participants. Data collection occurred between October and November 2025.
The profiles of the interviewees, which included information on education, role, and years of experience, were considered to contextualize the perceptions collected. The diversity of roles and experiences among the participants contributed to a comprehensive view on the subject.
The analysis of the obtained data was performed using the content analysis technique (Bardin, 2016). This method allowed for the identification of recurring patterns, categories, and meanings in the participants’ responses, providing an in-depth understanding of the reported experiences.
The analysis categories were defined by a hybrid process, which combined theoretical frameworks identified in the literature review with emerging evidence from the interviews. Initially, preliminary categories were established based on recurring axes in studies on AI in R&D, such as operational efficiency, biases, ethics, diversity, and humanization.
Subsequently, during the analysis of the speeches, these categories were refined and adjusted according to the recurrence and relevance of the themes identified in the reports. The recurrence of patterns in the reports was sought, identified when the speeches presented repetition of content and absence of new relevant elements.
The research ensured the anonymity and confidentiality of the interviewees and the information provided. Participation was voluntary, with participants fully informed about the study’s objectives through the Free and Informed Consent Form (TCLE), presented in Appendix B.
According to the sole paragraph of Article 1 of CNS Resolution no. 510, of April 2016, the work was exempted from registration and analysis by the Research Ethics Committee (CEP) and the National Commission for Ethics in Research (CONEP). This exemption was granted because it concerns an opinion survey with unidentified participants.
3. Results and Discussion
The research sought to identify the experiences of human resources professionals regarding the application of artificial intelligence in the recruitment and selection process, analyzing its benefits, challenges, and impacts on the organization. The interviews were structured based on a comprehensive literature review, allowing for an in-depth analysis of participants’ perceptions of technology, efficiency, biases, and ethics. The comparison between the practices observed in the company and the recommendations from the literature was fundamental to identify points of convergence and divergence, supporting the proposition of specific improvements for the R&S process of the studied organization, a large company in the sugar-energy sector.
Research participants highlighted the use of digital tools, such as “LinkedIn Recruiter”, for talent attraction and acquisition. This technology was perceived as a strategic ally in optimizing time, identifying profiles more aligned with vacancies, and standardizing evaluation criteria. This finding corroborates the findings of Sousa et al. (2019), which indicate that AI can reduce the time spent on resume screening by up to seventy percent, contributing to more agile and assertive decisions. By employing technology in these initial phases, the company aligns itself with best practices in the literature, seeking efficiency and reduction of operational costs.
The implementation of artificial intelligence tools required a period of adaptation and training by the HR team. Reports indicated initial resistance, along with the need to understand how algorithms and filters work to maximize the use of technology in daily operations. The company invested in internal training, which resulted in greater confidence from recruiters and the development of the department’s digital maturity. To sustain this evolution, it is proposed to periodically review the parameters of the AI tools, ensuring that the filters and search criteria remain updated and aligned with the real demands of the vacancies, avoiding undue exclusions and increasing the assertiveness of the results, as well as strengthening the team’s continuous training.
Regarding the stages of the selection process where AI demonstrates greater efficiency, most respondents pointed to resume screening and keyword-based profile searching. These activities, traditionally time-consuming for recruiters, have become faster and more consistent with the use of technology, especially in high-volume selection processes. This benefit is widely recognized in the literature, as by Appolinário et al. (2025), who emphasize the gain in agility and cost reduction as central advantages of automation in recruitment and selection (R&S). The company, therefore, capitalizes on these gains by automating the initial phases of the process.
However, participants emphasized that, from the interview and behavioral assessment phases onwards, human presence becomes indispensable to ensure ethical, empathetic, and contextualized decisions. This perception aligns with the argument by Garcia and Mendes (2023), who advocate that AI should act as support for human judgment, rather than a substitute for subjective discernment. The balance between technology and human sensitivity was identified as one of the greatest challenges, as it seeks to ensure agility without compromising the humanization of the selection process, reinforcing the need for AI to support more strategic decisions, identifying candidates with greater potential for future adherence and development.
The interviews showed that AI’s performance is more relevant in the initial stages of the selection process, such as resume screening and sourcing. In contrast, phases like interviews, behavioral analyses, and the final decision should remain under human judgment. Recruiters highlighted that, in these stages, subjective judgment, empathy, and contextual interpretation are crucial to avoid biased or dehumanized decisions. AI, therefore, is more effective as an operational and analytical support tool, rather than a substitute for human discernment in the decisive stages of R&S. To enhance this integration, it is suggested to establish an internal policy that clearly defines the limits of AI’s performance, ensuring that final hiring decisions are conducted by human evaluation.
Additionally, opportunities were identified to develop transition protocols between automated and in-person stages, ensuring consistency of criteria and preserving the ethics, impartiality, and humanization of decisions. The creation of diversity indicators and the implementation of such protocols can aid in the continuous monitoring of results, ensuring that technology acts inclusively and aligned with organizational values. This approach aims to enhance the social and cultural impact of selection processes, guided by principles of diversity and inclusion, as advocated by Atanazio et al. (2021).
When questioned about the role of AI in reducing prejudice and promoting diversity, participants presented a balanced view. They acknowledged that the technology can assist, provided it is configured appropriately, but warned that poorly defined parameters can reinforce existing biases. Atanazio et al. (2021) emphasize the importance of governance and constant monitoring for AI to be an ally in reducing prejudice, promoting greater diversity and Innovation. The proposed improvement includes the creation of diversity indicators for continuous monitoring, ensuring that the technology acts inclusively and aligned with organizational values.
Regarding the candidate experience, interviewees observed that automation reduced response time and standardized feedback, as highlighted by Sousa et al. (2019). However, initial contact became more impersonal. It is therefore recognized the importance of balancing efficiency and empathy, ensuring that technology does not compromise the humanization of the process. It is recommended to incorporate candidate satisfaction metrics and strategic human contact moments, in order to preserve the perception of welcome and empathy during the selection process, strengthening the relationship between the organization and potential talents.
Ethical issues were also a subject of reflection, with concerns about the risk of good candidates being discarded by overly rigid automatic filters and the possibility of the process becoming impersonal. This concern converges with the analyses by Martins et al. (2024), who warn about the risks of excessive reliance on algorithms and the dehumanization of the work environment. The interviewees reinforced the need to always maintain human judgment, ensuring that technology is an ally and not a substitute for the sensitivity of recruiters. The proposition in this regard is the creation of governance protocols that establish clear limits for the use of AI, ensuring human review in decisive stages of the selection process.
In general, the interviewed professionals highlighted clear benefits of AI, such as time savings, agility in mass selection processes, and greater standardization in profile analysis. The expectation is that, in the coming years, AI will assume an increasingly analytical role, allowing recruiters to focus on decision-making and human relationship stages. However, challenges were mentioned, such as dependence on technology and the risk of losing talent due to automated criteria. The improvement proposal is the definition of transparent parameterization criteria and the periodic review of AI tools, ensuring that the benefits of automation are maintained without compromising the diversity and quality of hires.
The research showed that the balanced use of AI represents not only a technological innovation but a cultural transformation in how people are managed. The results demonstrate that the future of recruitment depends on the integration between data and empathy, algorithms and experience, which reinforces the need to build organizational policies that prioritize both operational efficiency and respect for human individuality. The improvement proposals focus on AI governance, the review of algorithmic criteria, and the integration between technological decisions and human judgment, indicating that the organizational challenge lies in the management, monitoring, and alignment of technology with the organization’s ethical and strategic values.
4. Conclusion
The present study aimed to identify the experiences of human resources professionals regarding the application of artificial intelligence in recruitment and selection, analyzing its benefits, challenges, and impacts on the organization, and verifying up to which stage of the selection process AI is relevant. It was found that artificial intelligence was employed with greater efficiency in the initial stages of the process, such as resume screening and talent attraction, providing significant gains in time savings, standardization of criteria, and greater assertiveness in identifying profiles aligned with the organizational culture. However, it was observed that, from the interview and behavioral assessment phases onwards, human intervention proved indispensable to ensure ethical, empathetic, and contextualized decisions, avoiding the dehumanization of the process. The research contributed by highlighting the importance of balancing automation with human judgment, proposing periodic review of AI tools’ criteria and continuous training of the HR team, aiming to harmonize technological efficiency with ethical, inclusive, and strategic practices that strengthen organizational performance and candidate experience.
As a limitation, it should be noted that the study was conducted in a single company in the sugar-energy sector, which restricts the generalization of the results. For future studies, it is suggested to broaden the investigation to different sectors and analyze the use of AI in other stages of the people management cycle, such as retention and development, deepening the understanding of the role of technology in building a more strategic and human HR. The improvement proposals focus on AI governance, the definition of transparent parameterization criteria, and the creation of transition protocols between automated and in-person stages, ensuring coherence, transparency, and inclusion in recruitment decisions, in addition to incorporating candidate satisfaction metrics to preserve empathy during the selection process.
Bibliographic References
Appolinário, D. G.; Hedler, H. C.; Ferneda, E. 2025. Desafios do uso da inteligência artificial na gestão de recursos humanos: uma revisão sistemática. Boletim de Conjuntura (BOCA), [S.I.], v. 7, n. 3, p. 1–15. Disponível em: <https://revista.ioles.com.br/boca/index.php/revista/article/view/6979>. Acesso em: 25 set. 2025.
Atanazio, A.; Silva, L. R. O.; Formigoni, A.; Novais, R. A. B. de. 2021. A inteligência artificial transformando o RH do futuro: um estudo de caso sobre a tecnologia e a diversidade no mercado de trabalho. Refas – Revista Fatec Zona Sul, 7(4): 1-16.
Bardin, L. 2016. Análise de conteúdo. Edições 70, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Garcia, M. E. P. T.; Mendes, T. D. O. 2023. Transformações no recrutamento e seleção: um estudo sobre a inteligência artificial no processo seletivo. Revista de Gestão e Secretariado, 14(4). Disponível em: <https://ojs.revistagesec.org.br/secretariado/article/download/4665/3063/14988>. Acesso em: 13 set. 2025.
Gerhardt, T. E.; Silveira, D. T. 2009. Métodos de pesquisa. EAD Série Educação a Distância. Disponível em: <https://www.ufrgs.br/cursopgdr/downloadsSerie/derad005.pdf>. Acesso em: 13 set. 2025.
Gil, A. C. 2007. Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. 4. ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Martins, G. et al. 2024. Inteligência artificial e recursos humanos. Letra e Forma Editora, Curitiba, PR, Brasil. DOI: 10.29327/5435233.
Minayo, M. C. S. 2001. O desafio do conhecimento: pesquisa qualitativa em saúde. 8. ed. Hucitec, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Ribeiro, C. S. M. 2024. Inteligência artificial em recursos humanos: tendências e competências para o futuro. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Instituto Politécnico do Porto, Porto, Portugal. Disponível em: <https://www.proquest.com/openview/addff76ea4a03a9c8e96d2043edf409a/1?cbl=2026366&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar>. Acesso em: 25 set. 2025.
Sousa, S. P.; Passarelli, C. R.; Pugliesi, M. A. 2019. A inteligência artificial no recrutamento e seleção de pessoas: um estudo exploratório. Revista de Informação Contábil e Organizacional, São Paulo, v. 4, n. 1, p. 45-59, jan./jul. Disponível em: <https://ric.cps.sp.gov.br/bitstream/123456789/4968/1/A%20INTELIG%C3%8ANCIA%20ARTIFICIAL%20NO%20RECRUTAMENTO%20E%20SELE%C3%87%C3%83O%20DE…janeiro-julho%202019.pdf>. Acesso em: 25 set. 2025.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in People Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform