October 19, 2026
FEL-AWP-BIM Integration in Industrial Project Sequencing
Integration of Fel-awp-bim in the Sequencing of Industrial Projects
Ramon Barreto Amora; Carolina Rossi de Oliveira
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601359
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
The study addressed the challenges of productivity, costs, and deadlines in infrastructure projects, often caused by process fragmentation. It proposed and preliminarily validated an integration model between Front-End Loading (FEL), Advanced Work Packaging (AWP), and Building Information Modeling (BIM) to optimize sequencing. A simulated case study of the Morro do Moreno Tourist-Commercial Cable Car was conducted, using a comparative quasi-experimental design. In Scenario A (baseline), planning remained segmented, while in Scenario B (integration), the Path of Construction (PoC), hierarchical work package breakdown, and validation via 4D BIM simulation were established. Schedule Performance Index (SPI), Cost Performance Index (CPI), Information Quality (RFI), and constructability indicators were analyzed. The results showed a significant increase in predictability (SPI from 0.85 to 0.98) and cost efficiency (CPI from 0.90 to 1.00) in Scenario B. The 4D simulation allowed for the early detection and resolution of 12 space-time conflicts, reducing rework and improving adherence to sequencing. It was concluded that the FEL-AWP-BIM integration transformed planning into a production assurance process, offering a viable path to elevate execution maturity in capital projects.
Keywords: Virtual construction; Capital project management; Constraint management; Governance; Advanced planning.
1. Introduction
Large-scale capital projects, especially in the infrastructure sector, face recurring challenges of productivity, cost overruns, and schedule delays. Such failures are not solely attributed to technical complexity but to organizations’ inability to integrate processes, information, and agents throughout the project lifecycle. The literature shows that structural fragmentation between strategic planning, engineering, procurement, and execution is one of the main causes of performance loss in infrastructure projects (CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY INSTITUTE, 2015). This disarticulation prevents a holistic and coordinated view, resulting in rework and reduced predictability. Although Integration Management is essential to ensure coherence and alignment of objectives, its practical application is often superficial, limited to status reports, without a robust model that articulates methods, technologies, and decisions systemically (KPMG, 2020). This integration gap generates substantial value losses and increases the risks inherent in large-scale projects.
In this scenario, several methodologies and technologies seek greater discipline and predictability. Front-End Loading (FEL) is crucial for the progressive definition of scope and feasibility assessment in the initial phases, aiming to mitigate risks (MERROW, 2011). However, its effectiveness is limited when the transition to execution is not adequately structured. Advanced Work Packaging (AWP) proposes a construction-driven planning logic, structuring work into execution packages starting from the Path of Construction (PoC) to ensure input availability. Although it presents proven gains, late adoption or misalignment with the initial phases reduces its impact, and its implementation faces cultural and contractual barriers (CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY INSTITUTE; COAA, 2013; SINGH; WILLCOX, 2021). In parallel, Building Information Modeling (BIM) emerges as an integrating technology, offering a common data environment and enabling four-dimensional (4D) constructive simulations, which link the 3D model to the schedule to validate sequencing and detect conflicts (EASTMAN et al., 2018). Despite its potential to improve constructability, BIM’s effectiveness depends on factors such as interoperability and digital maturity, and its isolated use, without governance and integration with planning methodologies, limits its strategic value (MCGRAW HILL, 2020). Thus, the individual relevance of FEL, AWP, and BIM does not resolve fragmentation, requiring an approach that aligns methodologies, technologies, and organizational structures in a coherent governance model.
Given the persistence of fragmentation and the isolated application of promising methodologies and technologies, it becomes imperative to develop and validate models that promote systemic and continuous integration throughout the lifecycle of capital projects. This work is inserted in this context, addressing the need to overcome the limitations of traditional approaches to elevate execution maturity and predictability in complex ventures. The general objective of this study is to propose and validate an integration model between Front-End Loading (FEL), Advanced Work Packaging (AWP), and Building Information Modeling (BIM) to optimize the sequencing of infrastructure projects. To this end, a simulated case of the Morro do Moreno Tourist-Commercial Cable Car is used as the object of study, aiming to verify how the early and coordinated articulation of these three approaches contributes to the effective structuring of work packages and to the validation of executive sequencing through 4D simulation, increasing the predictability of costs and deadlines and transforming planning into a proactive production assurance process.
2. Material and Methods
This research was classified as applied, seeking to generate knowledge for practical application in the integration of processes in capital projects. Regarding its objectives, it was characterized as exploratory, by seeking initial evidence on the benefits of integration between Front-End Loading (FEL), Advanced Work Packaging (AWP), and Building Information Modeling (BIM). Additionally, it was explanatory, testing the causal relationship between integration and project indicator performance. The central technical procedure adopted was a simulated case study, with a comparative quasi-experimental design between distinct scenarios.
The object of study consisted of a simulated project for a tourist-commercial cable car, connecting Morro do Moreno to Morro da Marinha, located in the state of Espírito Santo. This undertaking included boarding and alighting stations, towers, cables, cabins, civil-electromechanical interfaces, access, and support services. The technical-managerial context was reconstructed from the researcher’s own artifacts, such as the Project Charter, Feasibility Study, and Project Execution Plan, which provided the factual basis for the simulation of the FEL-1, FEL-2, and FEL-3 phases, as well as the integrated application of AWP and BIM (3D and 4D).
The study’s scope was focused on planning and coordination, specifically on the planning and validation of sequencing, without encompassing the actual physical execution of the project. There was no population or sample in the statistical sense, as it was a simulated case study. The unit of analysis was the two comparative scenarios developed: Scenario A (baseline) and Scenario B (integrated model). The data selection criteria were based on the researcher’s authorial documentation, which provided the inputs for the construction and simulation of these scenarios, ensuring fidelity to the project’s technical-managerial context.
The sources and instruments used for data collection included various artifacts from the simulated case. Among them, the Project Charter, the Feasibility Study, the Project Execution Plan (PEP), the preliminary Project Breakdown Structure (WBS), the Cost Database, and the Risk Matrix stood out. Additionally, Gate checklists for the FEL-2 and FEL-3 phases were used, containing objective rubrics, a CWA-CWP-IWP decomposition matrix, a Constraint Log for recording restrictions, a Path of Construction (PoC) protocol, and evidence from the 4D BIM simulation, such as spatio-temporal conflict reports.
To validate the proposed model, the simulation was structured in two comparative scenarios. Scenario A, named Baseline, represented the traditional planning practice, characterized by segmentation by disciplines, without the structuring of work packages (AWP) or the use of 4D simulation for validation. In contrast, Scenario B, named Integrated Model, applied the integration between FEL, AWP, and BIM, establishing the Path of Construction (PoC), performing the hierarchical decomposition of Construction Work Areas (CWA) into Construction Work Packages (CWP) and Installation Work Packages (IWP), and carrying out the validation of the sequencing through 4D simulation.
The research operationalization occurred in four main stages. The FEL-1 and FEL-2 phases involved consolidating the justification, objectives, initial scope, stakeholders, assumptions, and constraints, based on the Project Charter and the Feasibility Study, culminating in the issuance of Gate FEL-2. Subsequently, in the FEL-3 phase, integrated with the WBS, the Path of Construction (PoC) was conducted to restructure the project into Construction Work Areas (CWAs). Examples of CWAs included the Morro do Moreno Station, the Marine Station, the Towers & Cables, and the Accesses/Infrastructure, organizing the scope constructively.
The hierarchical breakdown of CWAs into Engineering Work Packages (EWP), Procurement Work Packages (PWP), and Installation Work Packages (IWP) was performed, defining the predecessors, interfaces, and release rules for the IWPs. In Scenario B, operationalization considered an ongoing project, with packages in different states and active constraints classified by categories such as material, method, environment, labor, and machine. The Constraint Log was used as a governance mechanism to release work fronts, ensuring that readiness was met according to objective criteria before physical execution.
The 4D BIM simulation stage consisted of linking the schedule activities to the three-dimensional model, allowing for the verification of space-time conflicts, the analysis of logistical windows, and the identification of access and storage restrictions. This simulation was crucial for validating the logical sequencing and anticipating potential interferences. For consistency and traceability purposes, the analysis was conducted as a “snapshot” of the project on a specific cut-off date, April 8, 2026. This date corresponded to the last completed IWP and the IWP in progress at the study’s operational base, providing a temporal scope for the evaluation.
For the integrated model performance analysis, four main propositions were tested: P1 (Schedule), which evaluated the simulated Schedule Performance Index (SPI) elevation; P2 (Cost), which verified the simulated Cost Performance Index (CPI) improvement; P3 (Quality), which analyzed the reduction of requests for information (RFI) and the effectiveness in logging constraints (Constraint Log); and P4 (Constructability), which investigated the reduction of space-time conflicts detected in the 4D simulation. These indicators were fundamental to quantifying the benefits of the proposed integration.
The analytical treatment of the data involved synthesis into a comparative matrix between Scenario A and Scenario B, complemented by simple graphs and discussion. Quantitatively, the means of the performance indicators were compared, and where applicable, the effect size was indicated. Qualitatively, a thematic analysis of the barriers and enablers of integration was performed, in addition to *pattern matching* between the findings and propositions P1-P4. The validity and reliability of the results were reinforced by triangulation of artifacts and the 4D model, by the chain of evidence, and by the explicit statement of the study’s methodological assumptions and limitations.
The research ethical procedures were rigorously observed. The data used in the study were classified as non-sensitive, as they derived exclusively from the researcher’s authorial documentation, without involving personal information of individuals or confidential company data. All records generated during the research, including protocols, minutes of simulated meetings, evidence of the 4D simulation, and restriction logs, were kept in an organized and accessible manner. This practice ensured the traceability and integrity of the information used, allowing for academic auditing of procedures and results, in accordance with the ethical guidelines applicable to final course projects.
The research presented some methodological limitations inherent to its design. The simulation performed, although robust, did not replace the actual physical execution of the project, which restricted direct causal inference from the results. Performance indicators, such as SPI, CPI, and PPC, were used as *proxies* based on controlled estimates and hypotheses, rather than as Actual Values from a real project. The 4D model used was representative, with a level of detail compatible with planning decisions, which limited the granularity in detecting minor conflicts. However, the approach was considered adequate for the preliminary validation of the proposed conceptual model.
3. Results and Discussion
The results and discussion of this study provide significant evidence on the impact of the integration between Front-End Loading (FEL), Advanced Work Packaging (AWP), and Building Information Modeling (BIM) on the sequencing and performance of capital projects. The comparative analysis between Scenario A (traditional planning) and Scenario B (integrated model) revealed substantial improvements in key indicators of schedule, cost, information quality, and constructability, corroborating the initial research propositions.
The FEL governance and constraint management, central elements of Scenario B, were operationalized to connect project definition maturity to execution readiness. The FEL-2 and FEL-3 Gates, rather than being mere binary approval points, functioned as objective maturity filters, conditioning the advancement of definitions and preventing the transition of incomplete information to the execution phases. In the analyzed scope, the flexibility of Gate FEL-3 to remain partial/pending while engineering, procurement, and risk requirements are stabilized is a differentiator. This proactive approach strongly contrasts with the traditional model, where a lack of maturity in the initial phases frequently results in rework and delays in later stages, as pointed out by Merrow (2011), who emphasizes the critical importance of FEL for the success of megaprojects. Structured constraint management, consolidated in a Constraint Log with standardized classification by categories (material, method, environment, labor, and machine), allowed for visibility, traceability, and early treatment of impediments. This transformed Scenario B into a “constraint-managed” regime, where the absence of constraints is not presumed but actively managed to protect performance and enhance planning reliability. Project management literature, such as that from KPMG (2020), often highlights the superficiality with which integration is treated, reducing it to status reports. The present study, however, demonstrates that a robust model that articulates methodologies and technologies systemically, like the one proposed, can overcome this limitation, ensuring that work package release decisions are based on objective readiness criteria.
The structuring and decomposition of the scope through AWP and Path of Construction (PoC) represented a fundamental reconfiguration of planning in Scenario B. Instead of a discipline-driven (“push”) flow, planning became “construction-driven”, where the sequence of assembly and field execution defines the needs and deadlines for engineering and procurement. This inversion of the traditional logic broke down disciplinary fragmentation, adopting Construction Work Areas (CWAs) as primary management units. The hierarchical decomposition of CWAs into Construction Work Packages (CWP), Engineering Work Packages (EWP), Procurement Work Packages (PWP), and Installation Work Packages (IWP) ensured traceability between planning, readiness, and execution. Figure 1 of the original document, which represents the traditional schedule, illustrates the discipline-based chaining, where interdependencies with engineering and procurement are less visible, resulting in a “push” flow. In contrast, Figure 2 of the original document, showing the integrated schedule with work packages, highlights the reconfiguration of sequencing to be construction-driven, organized by packages and oriented towards the PoC. This change is crucial for constructability from the initial FEL-2 phases, as advocated by the Construction Industry Institute (CII) and Construction Owners Association of Alberta (COAA, 2013) in their AWP guidelines. Late adoption or misalignment of AWP with the initial phases, as observed in many projects, reduces its impact, but the integration proposed in this study mitigates this problem by incorporating AWP from FEL-3.
The decomposition of the project into CWAs, as illustrated in Figure 3 of the original document, acts as the “backbone” of AWP, concentrating construction packages and their respective engineering and procurement packages. This allows for readiness release to be applied systematically and audibly, ensuring that each work front is truly “ready-to-work”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 4. 4D planning by work packages
The operationalization of 4D planning by work packages, as presented in Figure 1 (originally Figure 4), demonstrates how executive sequencing transcends a mere list of isolated activities, coming to reflect deliverable fronts of execution, coherent with the PoC and conditioned by the AWP readiness criteria. This integrated visualization, often consolidated in analytical dashboards like Power BI, acts as a “control tower”, integrating planning information, work packages, and constraints in a single layer of analysis. This approach is fundamental for proactive decision-making, allowing project managers to identify bottlenecks and constraints before they impact physical execution. The ability to visualize the progress and readiness status of work packages in real-time, as demonstrated, is a significant advancement over traditional static schedules, which often fail to capture the complexity of interdependencies in capital projects (EASTMAN et al., 2018).
Source: Original research results
Figure 5. Supplier delivery tracking (PWP)
Complementarily, Figure 2 (originally Figure 5) illustrates the monitoring of supplier deliveries associated with work packages, reinforcing the integration between procurement and execution. This visualization is crucial to demonstrate that the release of work fronts depends not only on logical sequencing but also on the synchronization between engineering, supply, and field. The lack of synchronization between these areas is a common cause of delays and cost overruns in capital projects, according to the Construction Industry Institute (2015). By integrating the PWP (Procurement Work Package) directly into the AWP flow, the proposed model reduces the risk of premature release of activities without the necessary inputs, ensuring that materials and equipment are available at the right place and time. This minimizes waiting time, optimizes site logistics, and improves overall supply chain efficiency, a critical aspect for productivity in large-scale projects. Procurement management, when disconnected from construction planning, can generate significant additional costs due to inadequate storage, losses, or delivery delays, problems that the FEL-AWP-BIM integration seeks to proactively mitigate.
The comparative analysis of performance indicators between scenarios A and B, summarized in Table 1, quantifies the benefits of the proposed integration.
Table 1. Comparison of indicators
|
Indicator |
Scenario A (Traditional) |
Scenario B (Integrated) |
Observed Impact |
|
P1: Simulated SPI |
0.85 (latent delay) |
0.98 (adherence) |
Relative gain in predictability of approximately 15.3% (SPI: 0.85 → 0.98) |
|
P2: Simulated CPI |
0.90 (rework) |
1.00 (budgeted) |
Relative improvement in cost efficiency of approximately 11.1% (CPI: 0.90 ← 1.00), associated with the reduction of rework and waiting |
|
P3: RFI/Restrictions |
Higher incidence of RFI and restrictions treated reactively (baseline) |
Reduction and anticipation of constraint treatment (Constraint Log) |
Higher information quality and greater plan reliability, with removal/mitigation of restrictions before the release of IWPs (“constraint-managed”) |
|
P4: 4D Conflicts |
Not detected (high risk) |
12 detected/resolved |
Buildability gain |
Source: Original research results
The P1 proposition (Schedule) was validated with a relative gain in predictability of approximately 15.3% in the Schedule Performance Index (SPI), which rose from 0.85 in Scenario A (latent delay) to 0.98 in Scenario B (adherence). This result is particularly relevant, as an SPI below 1.00, as in Scenario A, indicates that the project is behind schedule, suggesting inefficiencies and potential unplanned shutdowns. The “latent delay” in Scenario A, although the schedule might have seemed logical in project management software, operated “blind” to the site’s geometric constraints and interdependencies not visible in traditional disciplinary planning. The improvement to 0.98 in Scenario B demonstrates that the FEL-AWP-BIM integration, by establishing the PoC, decomposing the scope into work packages, and validating sequencing via BIM 4D, allowed for more precise and proactive time management. This corroborates literature emphasizing the importance of robust and advanced planning for capital project performance (MERROW, 2011; CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY INSTITUTE, 2015). Merrow (2011) argues that the FEL phase, when well executed, is a significant predictor of success, and integration with AWP and BIM enhances this capability by extending planning maturity to execution. In practice, an SPI close to 1.00 means the project team can rely significantly more on the schedule, optimizing resource allocation, minimizing idle time for teams and equipment, and reducing the need for costly acceleration. The ability to anticipate and resolve space-time conflicts, such as those identified in the 4D simulation, translates into less rework in the field, greater operational safety, and a more predictable supply chain, directly impacting the organization’s ability to deliver projects on time to stakeholders.
The P2 (Cost) proposition was also validated, with a relative cost efficiency improvement of approximately 11.1% in the Cost Performance Index (CPI), which evolved from 0.90 (rework) in Scenario A to 1.00 (budgeted) in Scenario B. A CPI of 0.90 in Scenario A indicates that the project was spending more than planned for the work performed, a common symptom of rework, delays, and inefficiencies. Achieving a CPI of 1.00 in Scenario B demonstrates that the integrated model allowed the work to be executed within the planned budget, mainly due to the reduction of rework and waiting times. This improvement is directly linked to the greater predictability and constructability achieved in Scenario B. Literature, such as the McGraw Hill report (2020) on the value of BIM for infrastructure, highlights that the adoption of integrated technologies can lead to significant cost savings through process optimization and error reduction. The fragmentation of planning in Scenario A, without the structuring of work packages or 4D validation, resulted in additional costs arising from reactive decisions and the late discovery of problems. In contrast, the “constraint-managed” approach of Scenario B, by ensuring that work packages were released only when “ready to work,” avoided the premature mobilization of resources and the execution of activities with incomplete information, which are primary sources of waste and cost overruns. The practical implications of a CPI of 1.00 are vast: better budget control, lower risk of cost overruns, optimization of material and service procurement, and reduction of contractual claims and disputes. This allows organizations to allocate their financial resources more efficiently, freeing up capital for other investments and increasing project profitability.
Proposition P3 (Information Quality) was confirmed by the transition from a “higher incidence of RFIs and reactively handled constraints” in Scenario A to a “reduction and anticipation of treatment” in Scenario B. The effectiveness in registering constraints via the Constraint Log was a determining factor. In Scenario A, the lack of a structured mechanism to manage constraints resulted in a constant flow of RFIs, indicating information gaps and interface problems discovered only during execution. This generated interruptions, delays, and the need for reactive engineering. In Scenario B, the FEL-AWP-BIM integration, with its maturity Gates and the Constraint Log, ensured that information was matured and constraints were identified and mitigated proactively. This aligns with KPMG’s (2020) vision on the need for governance and objective alignment to overcome the superficiality of integration. The reduction of RFIs and proactive constraint management have direct implications for information quality and planning reliability. Fewer RFIs mean fewer interruptions in the field, less engineering time spent on emergency responses, and greater clarity for execution teams. The Constraint Log, by acting as a governance mechanism, ensures that work fronts are only released when they are “ready-to-work”, avoiding rework, unexpected stoppages, and consequently improving team productivity and morale. This translates into a safer and more efficient work environment, with less waste of resources and greater adherence to quality standards.
The P4 proposition (Constructability) was validated by the “reduction of spatio-temporal conflicts detected in the 4D simulation”, moving from “undetected (high risk)” in Scenario A to “12 detected/resolved” in Scenario B, resulting in a “constructability gain”. In Scenario A, the absence of 4D simulation meant that interface conflicts and site geometric constraints would only be discovered during physical execution, generating costly rework and delays. The 4D BIM simulation in Scenario B acted as proof of the PoC, allowing for the early detection and resolution of conflicts invisible in traditional Gantt charts.
Source: Original research results
Figure 10. 4D validation of the powertrain lifting sequence
As evidenced in Figure 3 (originally Figure 10), the 4D validation of the powertrain lifting sequence allowed for the adjustment of the fronts’ positioning before physical mobilization. This is a clear example of how 4D BIM technology, as described by Eastman et al. (2018), transforms planning from a static exercise into a dynamic, spatio-temporal validation. The ability to simulate complex operations, such as lifting heavy components, months before execution, allows for optimization of logistics, ensuring safety, and avoiding costly disruptions. The 4D simulation also revealed critical impact points, such as access and logistics conflicts, and interferences in lifting and crane reach. The optimization of the overlap between the structural assembly of the stations and the transport routes for heavy components, for example, avoided logistical blockages that would have forced work fronts to a standstill. Similarly, the simulation of the cable car tower installation, as per Figure 11 of the original document, demonstrated control over the reach of simultaneously operating cranes, ensuring the technical feasibility of the attack strategy. These virtual validations are crucial for constructability, as they allow value engineering to be applied proactively, significantly reducing the risk of rework and accidents in the field. The practical implications are immense: increased operational safety, optimized site layout, reduction of schedule delays due to physical collisions, and better coordination between engineering, procurement, and construction teams. The ability to “see” the project unfold in time and space before the first shovel of earth is moved is a competitive advantage that elevates execution maturity and project predictability.
The detailed analysis of financial and schedule performance, using Earned Value Management (EVM), reinforces the findings. Table 2 presents an example of a calculation sheet per package/activity, illustrating the logic of SPI and CPI in the comparison between scenarios.
Table 2. Example of EVM calculation (comparison between scenarios)
|
Scenario |
Package/Activity (example) |
Planned Value |
Earned Value |
AC Real |
schedule performance index (SPI) |
cost performance index |
|
The Traditional |
Civil works (example) |
BRL 200,000.00 |
BRL 180,000.00 |
BRL 210,000 |
0,90 |
0,86 |
|
Electrical installations (example) |
BRL 300,000.00 |
BRL 240,000 |
BRL 280,000 |
0,80 |
0,86 |
|
|
Mechanical assembly (example) |
BRL 500,000.00 |
BRL 430,000 |
BRL 454,444 |
0,86 |
0,95 |
|
|
Total for A |
BRL 1,000,000 |
BRL 850,000 |
BRL 944,444 |
0,85 |
0,90 |
|
|
B Integrated |
Civil works (example) |
BRL 200,000.00 |
BRL 200,000.00 |
BRL 200,000.00 |
1,00 |
1,00 |
|
Electrical installations (example) |
BRL 300,000.00 |
BRL 290,000 |
BRL 290,000 |
0,97 |
1,00 |
|
|
Mechanical assembly (example) |
BRL 500,000.00 |
BRL 490,000.00 |
BRL 490,000.00 |
0,98 |
1,00 |
|
|
TOTAL B |
BRL 1,000,000 |
BRL 980,000.00 |
BRL 980,000.00 |
0,98 |
1,00 |
Source: Original research results
In Scenario A (Traditional), civil works presented an SPI of 0.90 and CPI of 0.86, electrical installations SPI of 0.80 and CPI of 0.86, and mechanical assembly SPI of 0.86 and CPI of 0.95. The consolidated total for Scenario A was SPI=0.85 and CPI=0.90, reflecting latent delay and inefficiencies associated with the reactive discovery of constraints. The electromechanical package, with an SPI of 0.80, was the most affected, indicating that the lack of cleared fronts by civil works tends to paralyze assembly, a classic problem of disciplinary fragmentation. In contrast, in Scenario B (Integrated FEL-AWP-BIM), civil works achieved SPI=1.00 and CPI=1.00, electrical installations SPI=0.97 and CPI=1.00, and mechanical assembly SPI=0.98 and CPI=1.00. The consolidated total for Scenario B was SPI=0.98 and CPI=1.00, consistent with the logic of readiness-based release and active constraint management. These values, although simulated and based on controlled premises, demonstrate the causal mechanism of integration: each work package (IWP) is virtually validated and governed by readiness before being released to the field, reducing rework and waiting. The improvement in performance indicators is not just a reflection of the individual efficiency of each package, but of the synergy generated by integration, which allows for coordination between disciplines and anticipation of problems.
The FEL-AWP-BIM integration, therefore, transforms planning from an estimation exercise into a production assurance process. FEL governance, by acting as a risk mitigator, prevents the advancement of immature engineering into the field, making constraints visible, categorized, and traceable. AWP, in turn, restructures the schedule based on the assembly logic, ensuring workflow continuity and reducing the probability of rework. BIM 4D, as a validation tool, allows for the adjustment of logistical and lifting strategies months before physical mobilization, enhancing constructability and safety.
In summary, the FEL-AWP-BIM model has consolidated itself as a strategy capable of transforming the management of infrastructure projects, offering the transparency and predictability required by the contemporary market. The analysis, although based on a simulated case study, offers a practical and preliminarily validated roadmap for the application of integration in future ventures, mitigating sequencing failures and increasing the predictability of costs and deadlines. Methodological limitations, such as the simulated nature of the study and the use of performance indicators as proxies, have been explicitly stated and considered adequate for the preliminary validation of the conceptual model. It is recommended that future works apply this model in real execution environments to measure the impacts of unforeseen external variables, such as climatic variations and market fluctuations, in order to further strengthen the causal inference of the results.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved, as this study proposed and validated an integration model between Front-End Loading (FEL), Advanced Work Packaging (AWP), and Building Information Modeling (BIM) to optimize the sequencing of infrastructure projects. The model’s application in a simulated case of the Morro do Moreno Tourist-Commercial Cable Car demonstrated significant gains in schedule and cost predictability, with improvements in SPI and CPI indices, in addition to a notable increase in information quality and constructability. FEL governance, scope structuring via AWP, and BIM’s 4D validation acted synergistically to transform traditional planning into a proactive production assurance process, overcoming fragmentation and reactivity.
However, it is essential to acknowledge the inherent limitations of this work. The simulated nature of the study, while controlled to highlight the causal mechanism, does not replicate the complexity of real-world execution. Performance indicators, such as SPI and CPI, were used as proxies based on controlled estimates and hypotheses, and the 4D model, although representative, had a level of detail that limited the detection of minor conflicts. To strengthen causal inference and fully validate the model, it is recommended that future studies apply this integrated approach in real execution environments, measuring the impacts of unforeseen external variables, such as weather conditions and market fluctuations.
Bibliographic References
Construction Industry Institute (CII). 2015. Benchmarking & Metrics Report. CII, Austin.
Construction Industry Institute (CII); Construction Owners Association of Alberta (COAA). 2013. Advanced Work Packaging: From Project Definition through Site Execution. CII, Austin.
Eastman, C.; Teicholz, P.; Sacks, R.; Liston, K. 2018. BIM Handbook: A Guide to Building Information Modeling for Owners, Managers, Designers, Engineers, and Contractors. 3 ed. Wiley, New Jersey.
KPMG. 2020. Global Construction Survey 2020: Value of Resilience. KPMG, Londres.
McGraw Hill. 2020. The Business Value of BIM for Infrastructure (SmartMarket Report). McGraw Hill Construction, Bedford.
Merrow, E. 2011. Industrial Megaprojects: Concepts, Strategies, and Practices for Success. Wiley, New Jersey.
Singh, V.; Willcox, D. 2021. Barriers to Advanced Work Packaging implementation in construction projects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management 147(6).
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform