October 19, 2026
Cost management in small and medium-sized construction projects with ERP systems support
Cost Management in Small and Medium-Sized Construction Projects with ERP Systems Support
Rafael de Oliveira Moreira; Leticia Faleiro
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601332
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Strategic cost management plays a relevant role in improving the financial performance of construction companies, especially in small and medium-sized organizations, which frequently face significant structural and operational limitations. The study aimed to analyze professionals’ perceptions of how the use of ERP systems influences financial performance and process management in construction companies, seeking to understand the importance attributed to these tools for the control and planning of projects. It was characterized as an applied research, with a quali-quantitative approach, using descriptive objectives and a field research procedure. Data were collected through a structured questionnaire, specifically designed for the study and applied to eight professionals working in construction companies in the state of São Paulo. Data analysis was performed using descriptive statistics and content analysis, confronting the findings with scientific literature to identify convergences and divergences. The results indicated that the use of ERP systems contributed significantly to greater cost control, information integration, and improved decision-making. However, the existence of challenges related to implementation and user training was observed, as well as the perception that poorly elaborated budgets are the main factor for not achieving financial goals. It was concluded that the adoption of ERP systems can substantially assist in improving the financial and operational efficiency of companies, strengthening their competitiveness in the construction sector. The research contributed empirical evidence on professionals’ perceptions, reinforcing the importance of adequate management practices and investments in training for the successful implementation of these technologies.
Keywords: Civil construction; Financial control; Financial performance; Operational efficiency; Budget.
1. Introduction
The construction industry is a fundamental pillar for economic and social development. However, this sector is intrinsically marked by operational complexity, reduced financial margins, and exposure to economic risks. In this scenario, strategic cost management emerges as a critical component for the sustainability and competitiveness of organizations, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises, with structural and operational limitations (Martins, 2018; Rezende and Lunkes, 2020). The absence of detailed planning and inadequate cost control are pointed out as primary factors for delays and financial losses in projects (Martins, 2018). Additionally, the limited adoption of technological tools and the lack of performance indicators compromise these companies’ ability to react strategically to economic dynamics (Rezende and Lunkes, 2020).
Strategic cost management transcends mere expense accounting, integrating planning, execution, and continuous monitoring of spending to support decision-making and optimize financial performance. In this context, Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems play a transformative role. They integrate financial, operational, and supply information into a single database, promoting greater control, traceability, and managerial reliability (Mainardes, 2014; Laudon, 2014). In the civil construction sector, the implementation of ERP systems can result in significant productivity gains, improved process quality, and cost reduction, conferring competitive advantages. The Project Management Institute (2021) emphasizes that information integration is a pillar for effective project control, essential in preventing budget deviations and in the continuous improvement of financial performance.
Budgeting is a crucial step in project planning, responsible for the detailed estimation of costs necessary for the project’s execution. The correct elaboration of cost compositions, which represent the analytical breakdown of each service into inputs such as materials, labor, and equipment, is fundamental for the reliability of the final project cost and for subsequent financial control (Mattos, 2019; Tisaka, 2011). ERP systems can expedite and improve the accuracy of budgeting, using regional price databases and standardized productivities. Furthermore, the application of tools such as the ABC Curve, based on the Pareto principle, allows for the classification of inputs according to their financial relevance, prioritizing the control of items with the greatest impact and contributing to the rationalization of resources and improvement of inventory management (Mattos, 2019; Martins, 2018). The automation provided by ERP systems in the elaboration and visualization of the ABC Curve consolidates cost compositions, making the process more agile and assertive.
The importance of strategic cost management and the adoption of integrated systems is corroborated by recent empirical research. Studies (Mendes and Montibeler, 2022; Souza, Silva and Pilz, 2023) demonstrate that small and medium-sized enterprises that implement strategic cost management and use control systems achieve better operational and financial results. However, the perception regarding the use of ERP systems in SMEs in the civil construction sector still lacks in-depth investigation. Evidence collected from industry professionals indicates that poorly elaborated budgets are the main factor for not achieving financial goals, being pointed out by more than 66% of respondents. This underscores the need for tools that improve budgetary accuracy. In parallel, the main difficulty in using ERP systems lies not in the technology, but in team integration and adherence to the tools, as indicated by more than 55% of participants, pointing to organizational and training challenges (Souza and Zwicker, 2000; Davenport, 1998).
Given the economic and social relevance of the construction sector, the challenges faced by SMEs in cost management, and the gap in the literature regarding professionals’ perceptions of ERP system usage in this segment, this study is justified by the need to provide empirical evidence that can guide managers and professionals. The general objective of this research is to analyze professionals’ perceptions of how the use of ERP systems influences financial performance and process management in construction companies, seeking to understand the importance attributed to these tools for project control and planning.
2. Material and Methods
This research was characterized as a study of an applied nature, seeking to generate practical knowledge for solving specific problems in the context of cost management in civil construction companies. A quali-quantitative approach was adopted, which allowed for the exploration of both measurable aspects and subjective perceptions of the professionals involved. The study’s objectives were descriptive, aiming to detail the characteristics of a given phenomenon, and the research procedure employed was a field study, with data collection directly in the environment of interest. This methodological combination was essential for a comprehensive understanding of the topic.
The nature of the collected data was mixed, integrating quantitative and qualitative information for a more robust analysis. Quantitative data covered measurable variables, such as participants’ age, professional experience duration, and frequency of ERP systems usage. On the other hand, qualitative data focused on respondents’ perceptions, opinions, and experiences regarding the use of these tools in the construction sector. According to Minayo (2014), the qualitative approach is crucial for uncovering subjective aspects, while the quantitative approach offers objective measurement, allowing for a complete view of the investigated phenomenon.
The obtained dataset was structured and predominantly descriptive in nature, facilitating the application of simple statistical analyses, such as the calculation of frequencies and percentages. This organization also supported the qualitative interpretation of participants’ perceptions, enriching the study’s understanding. The variables included nominal categories, such as the area of professional practice, which have no intrinsic ordering, and ordinal variables, which present a level of hierarchy or gradation, such as levels of experience or the degree of use of ERP systems. This diversity of variables allowed for a multifaceted analysis.
The study was conducted in the context of small and medium-sized construction companies, focusing on organizations located in the state of São Paulo. The unit of analysis consisted of professionals working in these construction companies who had direct interface with financial information and project management. Although the research covered the state of São Paulo, the geographical concentration of participants in companies from the city of São Paulo was an identified limitation. The data collection period was not explicitly detailed, but the research was conducted for a final course project dated 2025, indicating its completion in prior years.
The study’s target population comprised professionals working in small and medium-sized construction companies in the state of São Paulo. The sample was selected by convenience, prioritizing accessibility and participant availability for the research. Initially, ten individuals were contacted, resulting in eight respondents, which represented an 80% response rate. Participants were engineers, managers, and administrative professionals, all with practical experience in civil construction and direct involvement in the financial control of projects, ensuring relevant insights for the study’s objective.
The main data collection instrument was a structured questionnaire, developed specifically for this research. Its elaboration was based on a literature review on strategic cost management and ERP systems, with a foundation in studies by Rezende and Lunkes (2020), Mendes and Montibeler (2022), and Souza, Silva, and Pilz (2023). The questionnaire consisted of closed and semi-open questions, organized into three distinct thematic blocks, aiming to cover the essential aspects for achieving the proposed objectives. This structure allowed for standardized and comprehensive data collection.
The first block of the questionnaire focused on the participants’ profile, collecting information such as age, years of professional experience, type of work they are involved in, and area of expertise. The second block addressed the perception of management systems and ERP, investigating the importance attributed to these tools and their use in budgeting. The third and final block explored challenges and financial performance, including difficulties in ERP implementation and use, financial goals, and the factors impacting the failure to achieve results. This division allowed for a detailed analysis of the different dimensions of the research problem.
The questionnaire application occurred through an electronic form, available on the Google Forms platform and sent to participants via WhatsApp. This method ensured ease of access and remote completion, optimizing the collection process. Before application, all participants received and signed a Free and Informed Consent Term (TCLE), which ensured anonymity, confidentiality of the information provided, and exclusive use of the data for academic purposes. These ethical procedures were fundamental to ensuring the integrity and reliability of the research.
The research execution began with an in-depth literature search to substantiate the importance of using ERP systems in controlling and improving construction processes. Subsequently, a structured questionnaire was developed, aligned with the study objectives and the literature review. After ethical approval and participant consent, the questionnaire was administered. The collected data were then organized and tabulated, proceeding to the analysis phase. This sequence of steps ensured the systematicity and methodological rigor necessary for the development of the work.
The collected data were organized and tabulated using tools such as Microsoft Excel and Google Forms itself, which facilitated the structuring of the responses. The initial analysis was performed using simple descriptive statistics, employing frequency and percentage calculations to characterize the participants’ profile and their perceptions. Furthermore, a comparative analysis of the responses was conducted, seeking to identify patterns and trends. The approach also included content analysis, as mentioned in the TCC abstract, to interpret the qualitative and subjective information obtained.
After the descriptive and comparative analysis, the results were confronted with the existing scientific literature on strategic cost management and ERP systems. This confrontation aimed to identify convergences and divergences between the practices observed in the market and the theoretical references, enriching the discussion of the findings. The analytical structure adopted allowed not only to describe the collected data but also to establish relationships between the profile of the respondents, the level of use of technological tools, and the impacts on cost management, contributing directly to the achievement of the research objectives.
The study acknowledged some methodological limitations that may influence the generalization of the results. The main one was the small sample size, composed of only eight respondents, which restricts the representativeness of the findings. Additionally, the geographical concentration of participants in companies located in the city of São Paulo limits the scope of the results to other regions. The use of an electronic questionnaire, although efficient for collection, may have limited the depth of the responses, preventing a more detailed exploration of the participants’ perceptions. These limitations were considered in the interpretation of the results.
3. Results and Discussion
The results and discussion of this study emerge from an in-depth analysis of the perceptions of professionals working in small and medium-sized construction companies in the state of São Paulo, regarding cost management and the role of ERP systems. The research, of a quali-quantitative and descriptive nature, sought to elucidate how these technological tools influence financial and operational performance, as well as the challenges inherent in their adoption. The sample, although reduced to eight respondents from a universe of ten contacted, presented a return rate of 80%, conferring validity to the collected perceptions, especially considering the practical experience and direct involvement of these professionals with the financial control of construction projects.
The characterization of the participants’ profile revealed a group with professional maturity and significant experience in the civil construction sector. The age variable, as illustrated in Figure 1, showed a distribution ranging from 23 to 44 years, with a notable concentration in age groups that suggest both familiarity with new technologies and consolidated market experience. The presence of professionals of varied ages indicates that perceptions about technology are not restricted to a single generational group but reflect a broader view of the sector. This age diversity can influence the acceptance and adaptation to new tools, such as ERP systems, where younger professionals may demonstrate greater ease and openness to innovation, while more experienced ones may bring a critical perspective on the applicability and real benefits of these solutions in the practical context of civil construction.
Source: Original survey data
Figure 1. Age of participants
The professional experience of the respondents in civil construction is another crucial factor for the robustness of the findings. More than half of the interviewees have more than five years of experience, with a significant portion exceeding ten years, according to the collected data. This practical experience is fundamental, as the participants are engineers, managers, and administrative professionals with direct interface with financial information and project management. The depth of their experience lends greater weight to their perceptions of the effectiveness and challenges of ERP systems, aligning with Kerzner’s (2017) perspective, which emphasizes the importance of practical knowledge for managing complex projects. Their work on different types of projects, predominantly residential projects, and in areas such as planning and cost control, reinforces the relevance of their contributions to understanding cost management in the small and medium-sized construction companies segment. The concentration of professionals in the planning area, for example, is particularly pertinent, given that planning is the initial and crucial step for elaborating budgets and schedules, directly impacting financial control and strategic decision-making.
The general perception of the importance of management systems and ERP for the control and improvement of construction processes is widely positive among respondents. This finding corroborates the literature that highlights the fundamental role of ERP systems in integrating information and optimizing management processes (Mainardes, 2014). In the civil construction sector, where operational complexity and reduced margins are a constant, the ability to integrate financial, operational, and supply data into a single database, promoting greater control and traceability, is seen as a competitive advantage (Laudon, 2014). The research showed a significant convergence of responses regarding the importance of these tools for contract control, process organization, and improvement of financial monitoring, which reinforces the view of Rezende and Lunkes (2020) on the enhancement of controlling through integrated systems.
Specifically regarding contract management, the research revealed that the majority of respondents recognize the importance of a management system for contract control, with 55.6% of participants indicating this perception positively, as presented in Figure 2. This data is a strong indicator that information integration and process automation, inherent characteristics of ERP systems, are valued in the context of contract administration. Contractual management in civil construction is intrinsically complex, involving multiple suppliers, deadlines, costs, and specifications. The absence of a robust system can lead to inconsistencies, delays, and disputes, negatively impacting the project’s financial performance. The Project Management Institute (PMI, 2021) reiterates that effective project control depends on information integration, with contract management being an essential pillar for preventing budget deviations. Therefore, professionals’ perception aligns with the literature in recognizing that ERP acts as a facilitator for process standardization, error reduction, and improved communication among involved parties, crucial elements for efficiency and reliability in contract administration.
Source: Original survey data
Figure 2. Opinion related to contract management
The use of ERP systems in budgeting was another point of analysis, and the results point to a mixed scenario, but with a consensus on the challenges of lack of automation. Although not all respondents use ERP specifically for budgeting, those who do highlight benefits such as the creation of the ABC Curve for data analysis and decision-making, and greater ease in reviewing cost compositions and budgets. Budgeting is a critical stage in construction planning, requiring detailed and accurate cost estimates (Mattos, 2019). Manual preparation of cost compositions, as often occurs without ERP support, is prone to errors, outdated price and productivity databases, and lack of agility in revisions. Tisaka (2011) emphasizes that the correct preparation of unit compositions is fundamental to the reliability of the final cost. ERP systems, by integrating regional databases of prices, productivities, and service compositions, automate and standardize this process, minimizing errors and providing greater security and agility. The ability to perform comparative scenario analyses, such as the ABC Curve, allows for the identification of items with the greatest financial impact and optimization of resource allocation, as advocated by Martins (2018) and Formoso (2001). The absence of an ERP in this process can lead to “poorly made” budgets, a problem that proved central to the companies’ financial difficulties.
Indeed, the issue of challenges and financial performance revealed a particularly expressive finding: 66.7% of respondents pointed to “poorly made budget” as the main reason for not achieving financial goals, as evidenced in Figure 3. This result is alarming and underscores the critical importance of robust budgetary planning in the civil construction sector. The failure to prepare budgets is not just a technical error, but a strategic gap that compromises the financial viability of the entire undertaking. Martins (2018) and Rezende and Lunkes (2020) already warned that the lack of detailed planning and inadequate cost control are the main causes of delays and financial losses in construction projects. The perception of the interviewed professionals corroborates this literature, indicating that, in practice, budgetary inaccuracy is a significant bottleneck.
Source: Original survey data
Figure 3. Major challenges related to financial goals
Deepening the discussion on the “poorly made budget”, it is crucial to understand its ramifications. An inadequate budget can lead to an underestimation of costs, resulting in projects that exceed the initially planned amount, or an overestimation, which can make the construction company’s proposal less competitive. Furthermore, imprecise budgets hinder cost control during the execution of the work, as there is no solid basis for comparing the planned with the actual. This prevents early identification of deviations and the taking of corrective actions, culminating in financial losses and compromised profitability. The use of ERP systems, in this context, offers a robust solution. By integrating project data, standardized cost compositions, and updated price databases, the ERP automates and standardizes the budgeting process, drastically reducing the margin of human error. Davenport (1998) and Laudon and Laudon (2016) emphasize that integrated management systems promote greater accuracy and consistency in information, minimizing errors arising from manual processes and improving decision-making. The practical implication is that companies must invest not only in the ERP tool but also in the training of their budget estimators and in the standardization of their own internal processes for cost estimation and composition, ensuring that the system is fed with quality data and used strategically.
The other factors pointed out as challenges for not meeting financial goals, such as “poorly executed projects or executions without projects”, “management without process standards” and “lack of a contract management system”, although relevant, were cited by a smaller portion of respondents (11.1% each). This suggests that, although these problems exist and contribute to financial difficulties, “poor budgeting” is perceived as the primary and most impactful bottleneck. However, it is important to note that all these factors are interconnected. A well-made budget is the basis for efficient project execution and contract management. The absence of process standardization, in turn, can lead to inconsistencies in both budgeting and execution. The integration provided by ERP systems acts in mitigating all these challenges, by providing a unified platform for planning, execution, and control, ensuring that information flows consistently between the different stages and areas of the company.
Despite the evident benefits, the research also explored the difficulties in implementing and using ERP tools. The most prominent result, with 55.6% of the responses, was “team integration and adherence to the tool”, as illustrated in Figure 4. This finding is crucial, as it shifts the focus from challenges from a purely technological perspective to an organizational and human dimension. It is not just about acquiring software, but about promoting cultural change and adapting the organization’s internal processes for the tool to be effectively used. Souza and Zwicker (2000) already highlighted that the implementation of ERP systems involves significant changes in internal processes and that user resistance and difficulty in adaptation are critical factors for the success or failure of these tools.
Source: Original survey data
Figure 4. Main difficulty for using ERP tools
The “team integration and tool adherence” encompasses a series of practical issues. Resistance to change by employees, lack of understanding about the benefits of the new system, absence of adequate training, and difficulty in abandoning old work methods are common obstacles. Furthermore, the company’s internal processes can be “complex and not aligned with the company’s internal rules,” as mentioned in one of the answer options, which requires restructuring and standardization before or during the ERP implementation. Davenport (1998) argues that ERP systems demand a review of business processes, and many companies face difficulties when there is no adequate preparation or training for users. The practical implication of this finding is that construction companies seeking to implement or optimize the use of ERP systems must invest heavily in change management, continuous training programs, and clear communication of the benefits and the need for adaptation. Leadership must be engaged in promoting a culture of collaboration and innovation, ensuring that the team understands the value of the tool and feels empowered to use it fully. Without this holistic approach, the potential of ERP systems to improve cost management and financial performance may be underutilized.
In summary, the research results reinforce the premise that ERP systems are indispensable strategic tools for cost management in small and medium-sized construction projects. They promote information integration, process automation, and data standardization, crucial elements for more precise budget control and more assertive decision-making. The ability to elaborate detailed cost compositions, manage material requisitions, control cost appropriation, post invoices, and project cash flow in an integrated and automated manner provides companies with a significant competitive advantage. However, the study also highlights that the mere adoption of technology is not enough. The challenges lie mainly in the human and organizational dimension, with “poorly done budgeting” and “team integration and tool adherence” emerging as the main obstacles. Overcoming these challenges requires a commitment to change management, investment in professional training, and continuous review of internal processes, ensuring that technology acts as a catalyst for efficiency and not just another underutilized tool. The research, therefore, contributes empirical evidence that can guide managers and professionals in the sector to maximize the benefits of ERP systems, paving the way for superior financial and operational performance.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved by analyzing professionals’ perception of the influence of ERP systems on financial performance and process management in construction companies. The research demonstrated that these tools are crucial for controlling and planning works, promoting information integration, process automation, and data standardization. The results showed that the adoption of ERP systems can mitigate problems such as “poor budgeting,” identified as the main factor for not achieving financial goals. The general perception is that ERP is a competitive differentiator, optimizing contract management, budgeting, and cost control, although its effectiveness depends on team integration and adherence to the tool.
However, this study presents important limitations. The sample was restricted to a small number of respondents and geographically concentrated in companies from São Paulo, which may affect the generalization of the findings. Furthermore, data collection via electronic questionnaire limited the depth of perceptions. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the sample to include different regions and company sizes, as well as to use complementary methods, such as in-depth interviews or case studies, to explore nuances not captured. It is also recommended to conduct comparative analyses between companies that use and do not use ERP systems, in order to quantify the impacts of these tools on financial and operational performance, consolidating the understanding of their strategic relevance.
Bibliographic References
DAVENPORT, Thomas H. Putting the enterprise into the enterprise system. Harvard Business Review, Boston, v. 76, n. 4, p. 121–131, 1998.
FORMOSO, Carlos T. Lean Construction: princípios e práticas. Porto Alegre: UFRGS, 2001.
KERZNER, Harold. Gestão de projetos: as melhores práticas. 3. ed. Porto Alegre: Bookman, 2017.
LAUDON, Kenneth C.; LAUDON, Jane P. Sistemas de informação gerenciais. 11. ed. São Paulo: Pearson, 2014.
MAINARDES, Christiane Wagner; KRAINER, Jefferson Augusto. Análise dos impactos da utilização do ERP nos processos organizacionais de empresas de construção civil. Revista Engenharia de Construção Civil, Curitiba, v. 1, n. 1, p. 78-95, 2014. Disponível em: Acessar artigo. Acesso em: 8 abr. 2026.
MARTINS, Eliseu. Contabilidade de custos. 11. ed. São Paulo: Atlas, 2018.
MATTOS, Aldo Dórea. Como preparar orçamentos de obras. São Paulo: PINI, 2019.
Mendes, R. C., & Elias Montibeler, E. (2022). GESTÃO ESTRATÉGICA DE CUSTOS: UM ESTUDO SOBRE SUA APLICAÇAO E UTILIZAÇÃO EM MICRO E PEQUENAS EMPRESAS DO SETOR DE SERVIÇOS. ABCustos, 17(1), 56-79. https://doi.org/10.47179/abcustos.v17i1.619
MINAYO, Maria Cecília de Souza. O desafio do conhecimento: pesquisa qualitativa em saúde. 14. ed. São Paulo: Hucitec, 2014.
PROJECT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE. Guia PMBOK®: Um guia para o conjunto de conhecimentos em gerenciamento de projetos. 7. ed. Newtown Square: PMI, 2021
REZENDE, Denis Alcides; LUNKES, Rogério João. Controladoria e gestão estratégica. São Paulo: Atlas, 2020.
SOUZA, Cesar Alexandre de; ZWICKER, Ronaldo. Sistemas ERP: conceitos, ciclos de vida e estudos de caso comparados. In: SOUZA, Cesar Alexandre de; SACCOL, Amarolinda Zanela (org.). Sistemas ERP no Brasil. São Paulo: Atlas, 2000.
Souza, Silva e Pilz, 2023 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
TISAKA, Maçahico. Orçamento na construção civil: consultoria, projeto e execução. São Paulo: PINI, 2011.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Finance and Controllership of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform