October 19, 2026
Consortium management of urban solid waste: case study of the Manuel Alves River Valley Landfill – TO
Consortium Management of Urban Solid Waste: Case Study of the Manuel Alves River Valley Sanitary Landfill – to
Tainan Pereira dos Santos Moreira; Márcia Rossi
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603473
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The management of urban solid waste (USW) in Brazil faces technical, institutional, and socioeconomic challenges, intensified by the demands of the National Solid Waste Policy and the New Sanitation Legal Framework. In this context, intermunicipal public consortia have emerged as a strategy to enable economies of scale and strengthen municipal management capacity. The study analyzed how the implementation of the Rio Manuel Alves Valley Consortiated Landfill contributes to the effectiveness of sustainable USW management in the municipalities belonging to the consortium, located in Tocantins. A descriptive-analytical case study design was adopted, based on secondary data and technical-regulatory documentation from 2019 to 2024. The analysis did not measure consolidated operational results, but rather the institutional and technical consistency of the model and its potential for effectiveness, structured around legal-institutional, environmental, economic-operational, governance, and social dimensions. The results indicated that the consortiated model showed adherence to current legal frameworks, with institutional formalization, integrated planning, and technical design of the landfill in accordance with environmental requirements, potentially contributing to overcoming inadequate waste disposal. However, limitations were identified in environmental education, integration with selective collection, and social inclusion. It was concluded that the implementation of the consortiated landfill represented a relevant advance in legal compliance and regional organization of USW management, but its sustainable effectiveness depends on the strengthening of complementary policies for governance, social participation, and long-term economic feasibility.
Keywords: Sanitary landfill; Consortia management; Environmental governance; Urban solid waste; Sustainability.
1. Introduction
The management of urban solid waste (USW) in Brazil remains one of the most complex challenges on the contemporary environmental and sanitary agenda, as it simultaneously involves technical, institutional, economic, and social requirements. The National Solid Waste Policy (PNRS), established by Law No. 12.305/2010, and the New Legal Framework for Sanitation, reinforced by Law No. 14.026/2020, have consolidated guidelines aimed at the elimination of dumps, the regionalization of services, and the adoption of environmentally appropriate solutions for the final disposal of waste. In this context, consortia management between municipalities has been presented as an alternative capable of enabling economies of scale, cost rationalization, and strengthening of state capacity, especially in territories marked by low revenue, spatial dispersion, and administrative limitations.
In the State of Tocantins, the creation of the Intermunicipal Consortium for Sustainable Development of the Vale do Rio Manuel Alves and the proposal to implement a joint sanitary landfill represent a relevant experience in the regionalization of urban solid waste management. This experience is particularly significant as it develops in a regional context where the final disposal of waste has historically occurred in a fragmented manner and, in many cases, environmentally inadequate, highlighting the need for collective solutions capable of overcoming the structural precariousness of local management.
From a theoretical point of view, intermunicipal public consortia can be understood as instruments of horizontal coordination that reduce capacity asymmetries between local governments and broaden the possibility of cooperation in complex public policies. From the perspective of environmental governance, the effectiveness of these arrangements is not exhausted by the formal existence of institutions, but depends on the ability to articulate rules, coordination, transparency, participation, and control mechanisms (Abrucio and Sano, 2013; Ostrom, 2010).
Sustainable waste management, on the other hand, presupposes integration between legal compliance, environmentally adequate infrastructure, economic-financial viability, social inclusion, and participatory governance (Wilson et al., 2015; UN-Habitat, 2010). From this perspective, the analysis of consortiated waste management should not be restricted to verifying the physical existence of a sanitary landfill, but should consider to what extent the adopted institutional and technical model creates real conditions to overcome environmental liabilities, strengthen municipal capacities, and structure a more sustainable regional management.
It is within this framework that the present study is situated. Although the literature recognizes the potential of public consortia as instruments of federal coordination, applied studies investigating their effectiveness in peripheral regional contexts with structural limitations are still scarce. The work does not aim to evaluate consolidated operational results of the undertaking, as it is still in the implementation and environmental licensing phase. The analytical focus, therefore, falls on the institutional and technical adherence of the consortium model and on its potential effectiveness as a regional strategy for sustainable management.
This work seeks to fill this gap by offering an empirical and multidimensional analysis of the capacity of a public consortium to structure sustainable solutions for the management of urban solid waste. Its main contribution consists of demonstrating that, although consortiated management represents a relevant institutional advance, its effectiveness depends on the integration between governance, social inclusion, and economic-financial viability, not being exhausted in the implementation of disposal infrastructure. Thus, this work aims to analyze how the implementation of the Consortiated Sanitary Landfill of the Vale do Rio Manuel Alves contributes to the effectiveness of sustainable urban solid waste management in the municipalities belonging to the consortium, located in the state of Tocantins.
2. Material and Methods
The present study adopted an applied case study research design, of a descriptive-analytical nature. This approach was selected to allow an in-depth analysis of the implementation of the Consorciado Landfill of the Vale do Rio Manuel Alves, located in the state of Tocantins, and its contribution to the sustainable management of urban solid waste in the municipalities belonging to the consortium. The research focused on the institutional and technical consistency of the model and its potential effectiveness, without measuring consolidated operational results, given that the project was in the implementation and environmental licensing phase.
The empirical basis of the research was composed exclusively of secondary data and technical-institutional documentation. The documents were produced between 2019 and 2024, a period that covers the structuring of the Intermunicipal Consortium for Sustainable Development Vale do Rio Manuel Alves and the elaboration of the main normative, technical, and planning instruments related to the implementation of the joint sanitary landfill. This temporal scope allowed us to follow the genesis of the arrangement and its regulatory bases.
The documentary selection observed three complementary analytical criteria. Firstly, the normative and institutional relevance of the documents for the management of urban solid waste was considered. Secondly, direct links between the documents and the process of constitution, planning, licensing, or implementation of the joint sanitary landfill were prioritized. Finally, the technical reliability of the sources was assessed, with a preference for official documents, environmental studies, planning instruments, and public databases.
The analyzed sources included federal and state legislations, technical standards from the Brazilian Association of Technical Standards (ABNT), planning documents, and technical reports. Among the specific documents, the Environmental Control Report and Environmental Control Plan (RCA/PCA) of the Sanitary Landfill (2024) and the Intermunicipal Integrated Solid Waste Management Plan (PIGIRS) (2019) stood out. Official data and academic literature on environmental governance and consortia management were also consulted.
The federal legislations examined comprised Law nº 12.305/2010 (National Solid Waste Policy), Decree nº 7.404/2010, Law nº 14.026/2020 (New Legal Framework for Sanitation), Law nº 11.445/2007 (Basic Sanitation), and Law nº 9.605/1998 (Environmental Crimes). MMA Ordinance nº 280/2020, which establishes the national Waste Transport Manifest (MTR), was also used. Demographic and socioeconomic data from the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE, 2022) and technical studies and regional diagnostics (2023-2024) complemented the documentary base.
The ABNT technical standards, such as NBR 10.004:2004 (classification of solid waste), NBR 13.895:1997 (groundwater monitoring wells), and NBR 13.896:1997 (non-hazardous waste landfills), were considered to evaluate technical compliance. Resolutions from the Tocantins State Environmental Council (COEMA/TO) No. 07 and No. 08, of 2005, and CONAMA Resolution No. 275, of 2001, on color standardization for selective collection, also integrated the documentary corpus.
The procedures for data collection and organization comprised three articulated stages. The first consisted of a targeted bibliographic review, focusing on environmental governance, public consortia, and sustainable management of urban solid waste. The second stage involved documentary survey, which included the consortium’s constitutive acts, intermunicipal plans, environmental studies, applicable regulations, and official statistical bases.
The third stage corresponded to the analytical systematization of the evidence, guided by four axes of operationalization of effectiveness. These axes were: (i) normative and institutional adherence; (ii) technical-operational and environmental consistency; (iii) economic-financial sustainability; and (iv) institutional governance and social participation. These axes guided the cross-sectional reading of the documentary corpus and functioned as categories for interpreting effectiveness.
The analysis plan was structured from a legal and institutional compliance matrix, complemented by thematic analytical frameworks. The objective was to identify evidence of adherence, fragility, potential, and limitation of the consortia model. The interpretation was reinforced by triangulation between normative documentation, technical studies, and specialized literature, seeking to provide greater analytical density to the study and avoid a merely descriptive reading of the examined material.
As a methodological limitation, the absence of primary data and consolidated operational indicators stands out. This limitation arose from the fact that the undertaking was still in the implementation and environmental licensing phase. However, this condition did not make the proposed analysis unfeasible, as the study’s objective was to examine the institutional and technical consistency of the model and its potential effectiveness, not to measure post-operation performance.
3. Results and Discussion
The preliminary research results show that the implementation of the Consortiated Landfill of the Vale do Rio Manuel Alves represents a significant effort in the regional reorganization of urban solid waste management. This undertaking is situated in a territory characterized by low population density, municipal dispersion, and institutional limitations typical of small municipalities, which historically resulted in fragmented and environmentally inadequate final disposal. The analysis indicates that the contribution of the consortiated model to the effectiveness of sustainable management is not limited to the provision of an environmentally adequate final disposal infrastructure, but lies in the combination of a robust institutional arrangement, integrated regional planning, regulatory compliance, and the capacity to overcome the fragmented logic that previously characterized waste management in the member municipalities.
In this sense, the findings were organized and discussed based on five interdependent analytical dimensions: legal-institutional, environmental, economic-operational, governance and participation, and social and public health. This expository structure, which unfolds the methodological axes for operationalizing effectiveness, allowed for an in-depth analysis of the consortia model. The adopted approach recognizes that the sustainability of waste management depends on a complex articulation between physical infrastructure, state capacity, intermunicipal cooperation, adequate financing, social participation and inclusion, as advocated by the literature on environmental governance and integrated waste management (Ostrom, 2010; Wilson et al., 2015).
Legal-institutional dimension
Documentary analysis demonstrated that the consorted arrangement is solidly supported by a coherent set of legal frameworks and institutional instruments, conferring legitimacy to the proposal for regionalization of urban solid waste management. The formalization of the consortium, the existence of intermunicipal planning, and the linkage of the undertaking to the guidelines of the National Solid Waste Policy (PNRS) and the New Legal Framework for Sanitation indicate that the model was conceived in accordance with the contemporary agenda of overcoming landfills and regional organization of public services, representing an unequivocal advance in the substitution of inadequate disposal for a technically controlled solution.
However, the normative adherence identified should not be interpreted as automatic synonym of full effectiveness. Although the documents reveal formal compliance with legal requirements in several points, they also expose gaps in the integration between final disposal, recycling, social inclusion, and environmental education. This suggests that, although the legal-institutional dimension is robust in structuring the model, its full effectiveness still depends on the development of complementary policies to achieve greater coherence with the expanded notion of integrated management provided for in the legislation, which requires prevention, recycling, and inclusion, in addition to final disposal.
The presence of an intermunicipal planning instrument, such as the Intermunicipal Plan for Integrated Solid Waste Management (PIGIRS), demonstrates regional articulation and adherence to the requirement for structured planning, which reinforces the consortium’s institutional legitimacy and favors coordination among municipalities. Furthermore, the reference to the use of the Waste Transport Manifest (MTR) and other management instruments expands the traceability and control of waste flow, strengthening documentary governance and accountability. These measures are consistent with modern control and management practices, increasing transparency and compliance in waste management.
The consortiated structuring of the final disposal solution is compatible with the regionalization guideline established by Law No. 14.026/2020, especially in contexts of low individual capacity of municipalities, which tends to increase scale and rationalize costs. However, the effectiveness of this regionalization depends on continuous cooperative governance. The documentation also links the undertaking to basic sanitation, according to Law No. 11.445/2007 and its updates, but universalization presupposes operational stability and continuity of service provision, which are not yet fully consolidated, maintaining adherence more institutional than empirical.
The project addresses the need to halt inadequate disposal practices, such as landfills, according to Law No. 9.605/1998, but full compliance depends on the effective closure and regularization of degraded areas, under the risk of persisting liabilities and legal risks. Finally, the documentation does not show a consolidated regional system for segregating and valuing recyclables, which compromises adherence to the logic of integrated management and increases dependence on final disposal. This reinforces that the undertaking, although representing a substantial advance, still carries the challenge of migrating from a solution centered on final disposal to an effectively integrated and sustainable model.
Institutional arrangement and territorial scope
The empirical basis records the creation of the Intermunicipal Consortium for Sustainable Development Vale do Rio Manuel Alves in 2019, with the purpose of executing public activities of common interest related to basic sanitation, adequate disposal of solid waste, and environmental improvement. The municipalities covered are Chapada da Natividade, Almas, Porto Alegre do Tocantins, Dianópolis, Novo Jardim, Rio da Conceição, Taipas do Tocantins, and Conceição do Tocantins. The development of the Intermunicipal Plan for Integrated Solid Waste Management (PIGIRS) functions as a structuring instrument for regional action, ensuring a coordinated approach to waste management challenges.
From a geographical point of view, the eight municipalities in the consortium are located in the southeastern portion of the State of Tocantins, in a region characterized by low demographic density and predominantly cerrado relief. In population terms, according to estimates by the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE, 2022), the municipalities have the following contingents: Dianópolis, with 17,739 inhabitants; Almas, with 6,499 inhabitants; Chapada da Natividade, with 3,117 inhabitants; Conceição do Tocantins, with 3,887 inhabitants; Novo Jardim, with 2,600 inhabitants; Porto Alegre do Tocantins, with 2,866 inhabitants; Taipas do Tocantins, with 2,056 inhabitants; and Rio da Conceição, with 1,895 inhabitants. The total population served by the consortium is approximately 40,127 inhabitants.
These numbers highlight the heterogeneity of scale among the consortium municipalities, with Dianópolis concentrating the largest share of the regional population. This distribution reinforces the argument that the regionalization of waste management constitutes a relevant strategy for small municipalities, which individually would have low capacity to sustain their own final disposal infrastructure. The formation of the consortium, in this context, already indicates institutional strengthening, as it signals capacity for horizontal coordination, sharing of responsibilities, and the construction of a common regional agenda, in line with the perspectives of Abrucio and Sano (2013) on federal cooperation.
More than an institutional fact, this territorial scope is analytically relevant because it demonstrates the attempt to overcome the fragmentation of the municipalized management of residuals in a region where, in isolation, municipalities tend to present low economic scale and limited technical capacity. At the same time, territorial amplitude imposes challenges. Regionalization expands the scale of the service, but also increases the complexity of administrative coordination, transport logistics, and the maintenance of political-institutional commitments over time. Thus, the consortium’s scope must be read simultaneously as a potentiality and as a pressure factor on the governance of the arrangement, requiring robust management mechanisms and continuous cooperation.
Environmental dimension
The analyzed documents indicate that the project was sized based on estimates of urban solid waste generation for the associated municipalities, considering the reference population of 2022, totaling 40,127 inhabitants. The estimated generation is approximately 29.29 tons per day, with a weighted regional average of 0.73 kg per inhabitant per day. For the purpose of projecting the useful life, the highest per capita generation observed among the municipalities, associated with Dianópolis, was adopted as a parameter, suggesting a conservative technical approach in sizing the system, aiming to ensure its long-term sustainability.
Regional gravimetric characterization showed the predominance of the organic fraction, with emphasis on food scraps, in addition to the expressive participation of recyclable materials, such as plastics and paper/cardboard. This data is particularly relevant because, although it justifies the need for environmentally adequate final disposal infrastructure, it also highlights the still uncaptured potential for reduction, segregation, and recycling. In other words, the composition of the waste reinforces both the need for a landfill and the limitation of a model that remains excessively focused on final disposal, without fully integrating the valorization chain.
The situation prior to the implementation of the undertaking was described as individualized and irregular disposal, with open-air dumps, without adequate environmental control systems. This diagnosis is central to the interpretation of the results, as it defines the starting point from which the identified effectiveness is in a stage of construction, not yet empirically consolidated. In comparative terms, the replacement of dumps with a technically structured landfill constitutes a substantive advance in the protection of soil, groundwater, air quality, and public health, mitigating the risks associated with inadequate disposal.
The undertaking was designed in an area of approximately 20 hectares, in a rural zone of Porto Alegre do Tocantins, described as having low interference on water resources and no overlap with Permanent Preservation Areas (PPAs) or conservation units. The locational selection demonstrates prior concern with environmental restrictions and licensing feasibility. The operational horizon was estimated until 2051, with a useful life of 27 years and the provision of five trenches, in addition to operational and effluent treatment structures. For leachate treatment, a modular Leachate Treatment Station (LTS) based on stabilization ponds is foreseen; for gases, horizontal and vertical drainage systems with individual flares; and for monitoring, four groundwater wells, with quarterly campaigns.
Geomembrane waterproofing is an essential element for controlling seepage and protecting soil and groundwater, representing a point of full compliance. However, the robustness of this control depends on executive quality, maintenance, and continuous inspection. The leachate treatment system, although technically coherent with the scale of the undertaking, was classified as partially met, as its effectiveness will depend on operational management and compliance with environmental standards, with risks of overload or operational failures. Similarly, gas drainage and management, with horizontal and vertical drains with flares, represents an advancement, but the initial system without forced extraction indicates an intermediate level of control, potentially limiting the efficiency of emission management throughout the operation.
Periodic environmental monitoring, carried out through monitoring wells and quarterly campaigns, strengthens preventive control and the capacity to detect potential impacts, but its effectiveness depends on institutional continuity and corrective response to deviations. The projected lifespan of 27 years suggests planning compatible with the regional stability of the solution, although it may be reduced if there is no input control, segregation, and integrated management. The replacement of open-air dumps represents a significant advance from an environmental and sanitary point of view, but the full benefit depends on the effective closure and recovery of previously degraded areas.
From an analytical point of view, the environmental dimension is one of the most robust aspects of the work. The documentation shows that the undertaking was conceived based on technical parameters compatible with the requirements of a regional sanitary landfill, which indicates real potential for mitigating historical liabilities associated with dumps. The existence of waterproofing systems, leachate treatment, gas drainage, and environmental monitoring demonstrates that the project surpasses, in structural terms, the logic of precarious disposal previously predominant, aligning with the guidelines of Wilson et al. (2015) on the importance of environmentally adequate final disposal.
However, the robustness of the technical design does not eliminate risks. A relevant part of the expected environmental results will depend on the quality of the implementation, the maintenance of the systems, the regularity of monitoring, and the institutional capacity for continuous operation. Thus, the model proves to be technically promising, but its future environmental effectiveness is still conditioned by the transition between design, licensing, and stable operation. This means that the most evident gain, at this stage, is the potential for a break with the previous degradation scenario, rather than empirical proof of consolidated environmental performance, requiring continuous vigilance and management to ensure long-term sustainability.
Economic-operational dimension
Although the economic-operational dimension appears in less detail in the documentation, there is sufficient evidence to support an interpretive analysis of the model’s feasibility. Data on population served, regional waste generation, centralization of final disposal, and charges associated with services indicate that the consortium seeks to structure a solution based on economies of scale, cost sharing, and rationalization of public investment. The single solution for multiple municipalities, classified as “Atende” (Serves), reduces the infeasibility of isolated solutions in small municipalities, but its benefit depends on the permanence of cooperation and the equitable distribution of costs.
In regions with low population density, the viability of municipalized landfills tends to be reduced, either due to high unit costs or the inability of each municipality to individually maintain adequate infrastructure, technical operation, and environmental control. In this context, the regionalization of final disposal functions as a strategy to compensate for local weaknesses. Concentrating the service in a single enterprise tends to reduce structural redundancies, favor integrated planning, and expand the possibility of cost sharing, which is a significant advance compared to the previous fragmented management.
Shared logistics, with regional centralization of final disposal, streamlines destination, but was classified as “Partially Meets” due to the increased importance of transportation costs and the need for efficient routes. Distances and territorial dispersion can pressure operational costs, requiring robust logistical planning. There is evidence of an attempt to institutionalize financing through service-linked fees, which strengthens the system’s maintenance capacity. However, the lack of financial detail prevents verification of collection sufficiency, classifying financial sustainability as “Partially Meets”.
Capacity planning, with a 27-year lifespan and annual projections, reinforces operational predictability and was classified as “Meets”. However, without selective collection and valorization of recyclables, pressure on capacity may increase, compromising the landfill’s longevity. The consortia structure and integrated planning aim to avoid the multiplication of small landfills and undersized structures, rationalizing public costs. This measure was classified as “Meets”, but the projected savings may be reduced by coordination failures and high logistical costs, highlighting the importance of continuous governance.
From the perspective of effectiveness, the economic-operational dimension suggests that the consortium model is plausible and institutionally coherent with the regional context, even without detailed financial data. The main gain identified is not the empirical demonstration of economic efficiency already achieved, but the existence of an arrangement designed to make it possible. In other words, the consortium seems to create more favorable structural conditions for financial sustainability than the previous fragmented management, although proof of this sustainability depends on future monitoring of actual transport, operation, cost-sharing, and maintenance costs, as discussed by Abrucio and Sano (2013).
This dimension thus reveals a conditioned potential effectiveness. There are relevant signs of economic rationality in the institutional design, but also inherent fragilities in regional arrangements in extensive and sparsely populated territories. Centralization is both a solution and a challenge: it reduces the infeasibility of isolated initiatives, but transfers part of the pressure to logistics and the stability of intermunicipal financing. Managing these challenges will be crucial for the long-term consolidation of the economic-operational sustainability of the joint sanitary landfill.
Governance dimension and participation
Document analysis shows that the governance of the consortium model presents a relatively consistent institutional core, supported by the formalization of the consortium, the existence of the PIGIRS, and the articulation between regional planning and infrastructure implementation. These elements indicate coordination capacity among municipal entities and signal that regionalized management is not being built in an improvised manner, but rather supported by formal cooperation instruments. Intermunicipal cooperation, formalized by the public consortium, demonstrates horizontal coordination capacity and shared responsibilities, being classified as “Meets Requirements”. However, cooperation needs to be politically sustained in the long term to guarantee its effectiveness.
Nevertheless, the governance dimension is not limited to the existence of formal institutions. For a consortium to produce lasting effectiveness, it is necessary that it sustains mechanisms of transparency, participation, administrative continuity, and social control, according to Ostrom’s perspective (2010). In this aspect, the documentation reveals important fragilities, especially in the field of environmental education, continued social participation, and the integration between institutional planning and population engagement. Regional planning, with the existence of PIGIRS, strengthens regional coherence and offers a basis for integrated decisions, being classified as “Meets Requirements”, but the plan, by itself, does not guarantee effective implementation.
The institutional articulation between consortium, planning, and licensing demonstrates alignment between instruments, but the documentation does not fully detail permanent governance routines, being classified as “Partially Meets,” with a risk of administrative and operational discontinuity. Environmental education, with punctual and non-continuous actions, was classified as “Does Not Fully Meet,” as the absence of a continuous program weakens the preventive and participatory dimension of management, limiting behavioral change and social adherence to integrated management. Social participation and control, with still incipient evidence, were classified as “Partially Meets,” as there is no robust demonstration of permanent and transparent participatory instances, which may compromise the social legitimacy and accountability of the arrangement.
In analytical terms, the model’s main strength lies in the existence of a minimally structured formal governance, anchored in the consortium, in the PIGIRS, and in the articulation between planning and licensing. This is the central evidence. The evaluation resulting from this evidence, however, indicates that the effectiveness of governance remains partial, because institutional robustness is not accompanied, with the same intensity, by continuous mechanisms for transparency, environmental education, and social participation. The analytical implication of this finding is relevant: the consortium arrangement demonstrates administrative coordination capacity, but has not yet fully converted this capacity into socially dense and legitimized governance.
In summary, the governance of the consortium model proves to be more structured on the formal level than on the relational and participatory level. This asymmetry suggests that the effectiveness of the arrangement, although institutionally viable, still depends on the consolidation of continuous mechanisms for social engagement and the institutionalization of transparency and control practices, without which governance tends to remain predominantly administrative, rather than truly collaborative. This asymmetry highlights that the consolidation of the model’s effectiveness depends less on the expansion of its formal structure and more on the institutionalization of continuous practices of engagement, transparency, and social co-responsibility. In contexts of low population density, such as the one analyzed, governance cannot be limited to administrative coordination, but must incorporate mechanisms that ensure social legitimacy and long-term political support.
Social dimension and public health
In the social dimension, the most consistent evidence is the potential reduction of health risks arising from the replacement of open-air dumps with an environmentally controlled structure, which was classified as “Meets”. This is a potentially significant result, as inadequate waste disposal is usually associated with the proliferation of vectors, environmental contamination, landscape degradation, and increased social vulnerability of surrounding populations. The change reduces exposure to vectors, contamination, and health liabilities typical of inadequate disposal, indicating significant progress compared to the previous scenario and contributing to public health.
On the other hand, the documentation indicates that the inclusion of waste pickers and integration with the recycling chain are not yet robustly structured. The incipient structuring for the inclusion of waste pickers was classified as “Does not fully meet,” as the absence of clearer integration with recycling and socio-productive inclusion limits the social dimension of sustainability. This reveals that the proposed transition is more consistent in the sanitary-environmental dimension than in the socioeconomic dimension of sustainable management, maintaining fragility in the articulation between environmental management and social justice.
Regional service to multiple municipalities contributes to territorial equity, expanding access to adequate disposal in municipalities with low individual capacity. This measure was classified as “Partially meets”, as distributive effectiveness depends on service continuity and balance between municipalities. The absence of continuity in education and behavioral change, with isolated actions, was classified as “Does not fully meet”, as environmental education has low potential to produce structural transformation, which reduces the capacity for prevention and segregation at the source.
The integrated reading of this dimension indicates that the consortia model produces important indirect social gains, especially by creating conditions for the reduction of regional health risks. However, its contribution to the social dimension of sustainability is still partial, because it remains underdeveloped regarding the inclusion of waste pickers, the valorization of recyclables, and the promotion of socio-environmental justice. This reinforces the idea that the effectiveness of the undertaking, although promising, is asymmetrical between the analyzed dimensions, according to the UN-Habitat (2010) approach on integrated and sustainable waste management.
The analysis thus shows that the social dimension of consorted management remains one of the main turning points for consolidating the model’s effectiveness. The absence of structured socio-productive inclusion mechanisms and waste valorization limits the arrangement’s capacity to move towards a circular economy logic, keeping it closer to a sanitary solution than a fully sustainable system from a socio-environmental perspective. The transition to an effectively sustainable system requires the incorporation of circular economy strategies capable of integrating proper disposal, waste valorization, and social inclusion in an integrated manner.
The preliminary results show that the analyzed consortia model has consistent potential to contribute to the effectiveness of sustainable urban solid waste management, mainly for four reasons: (i) it structures a regionalized institutional arrangement in a context of low municipal capacity; (ii) it shows relevant adherence to the main applicable legal frameworks; (iii) it projects infrastructure technically compatible with overcoming the scenario of landfills; and (iv) it creates more favorable conditions for cost rationalization and long-term planning. These findings confirm the literature that associates intermunicipal cooperative arrangements with the strengthening of state capacity in contexts of institutional and economic restriction (Abrucio and Sano, 2013; Ostrom, 2010).
At the same time, the analysis shows that the identified effectiveness is, at this stage, predominantly potential and not yet empirically proven in operational terms. The integrated reading of the five dimensions, guided by the four methodological axes adopted, shows a more robust model in the legal-institutional and environmental dimensions, intermediate in the economic-operational dimension, and more fragile in the dimensions of participatory and social governance. The main finding of the study, therefore, is not only that the consortium represents progress, but that this progress has unequal density among the components of sustainable management: it breaks with the precariousness of inadequate disposal, but still depends on the strengthening of participatory, social, and economic-financial instruments to consolidate itself as a full experience of effectiveness.
4. Conclusion
The study analyzed how the implementation of the Consorciado Landfill of the Vale do Rio Manuel Alves contributes to the effectiveness of sustainable urban solid waste management in the municipalities belonging to the consortium, located in Tocantins. It was found that the consortium model represented a significant advance in legal compliance and regional organization of MSW management. A solid adherence to current legal frameworks was identified, with institutional formalization and integrated planning, and a technical design of the sanitary landfill that meets environmental requirements. It was observed that this regionalized structuring creates favorable conditions for overcoming inadequate waste disposal, mitigating historical environmental liabilities, and promoting cost rationalization and long-term planning in a context of low municipal capacity. The main contribution lies in demonstrating that inter-municipal cooperative arrangements are effective instruments for strengthening state capacity and enabling environmentally sound solutions in regions with structural limitations.
However, the effectiveness of sustainable management has proven to be predominantly potential, not yet empirically proven in operational terms, as the venture is in the implementation and licensing phase, and the analysis was based on secondary data. Important limitations were identified in the dimensions of participatory and social governance, especially in the fragility of environmental education actions, the incipient integration with selective collection, and the socio-productive inclusion of waste pickers. Economic-financial sustainability, although plausible, lacks consolidated data for a complete evaluation. It is suggested that the full consolidation of the effectiveness of the consortia model will depend on the continuous strengthening of complementary policies for governance, social participation, and long-term economic feasibility, in addition to the incorporation of circular economy strategies. Future studies could monitor the operational results and the social and economic impacts after the landfill begins operation.
Bibliographic References
ABRUCIO, Fernando Luiz; SANO, Hironobu. Governança e gestão pública: desafios contemporâneos e propostas de agenda de pesquisa. Revista de Administração Pública, Rio de Janeiro, v. 47, n. 6, p. 1547-1564, 2013. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-76122013000600010.
CONSELHO NACIONAL DO MEIO AMBIENTE (CONAMA). Resolução n° 275, de 25 de abril de 2001. Dispõe sobre a padronização de cores para os diferentes tipos de resíduos na coleta seletiva. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 19 jun. 2001.
INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA E ESTATÍSTICA (IBGE). Estimativas populacionais dos municípios brasileiros. Rio de Janeiro: IBGE, 2022. Disponível em: https://www.ibge.gov.br/. Acesso em: 12 out. 2025.
OSTROM, Elinor. Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511807763.
UN-HABITAT. Solid waste management in the world’s cities: water and sanitation in the world’s cities 2010. London: Earthscan, 2010.
WILSON, David C.; RODIC, Ljiljana; SVIATSKY, Anne; WHITEMAN, Andrew; VILLALOBOS, P. Global waste management outlook. Nairobi: UNEP, 2015. Disponível em: https://www.unep.org/resources/report/global-waste-management-outlook. Acesso em: 12 out. 2025.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Compliance and ESG of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform