October 19, 2026
Stakeholder Management improves predictability in interinstitutional educational programs
Stakeholder Management Improves Predictability in Interinstitutional Educational Programs
Rodnilson Luiz Ferreira; Enise Aragão dos Santos
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601386
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Stakeholder management has proven crucial for the predictability of deliveries in educational programs with multiple actors, given the dependence on alignment of expectations, cooperative governance, and consistent communication between instances. The objective was to evaluate the application of stakeholder management in the Program of Teaching Directorates, identifying priority stakeholders, levels of power, interest, and influence, and critical points of communication and governance, aiming to support engagement strategies. The research was characterized as applied, exploratory, and descriptive, employing a mixed method with a qualitative predominance, structured as a case study. Three in-person semi-structured interviews were conducted with key actors in the program’s governance, and the data were organized in a spreadsheet and analyzed by thematic content analysis, with comparative synthesis between respondents and construction of an adherence matrix between recommended practices and case evidence. The results indicated convergence in the identification of a core group of stakeholders, composed of a central body, regional directorates, school management, teachers, and external partners, in addition to differentiation between formal and informal influence. Recurring noise associated with parallel channels and undocumented changes was observed, causing delays and rework, and the treatment of divergences through technical mediation and escalation was noted. It was concluded that the program demonstrated intermediate maturity in stakeholder management, requiring greater standardization of official channels, recording of decisions, communication cadence, clarity of roles, and engagement monitoring to strengthen governance and reduce rework.
Keywords: Expectation alignment; Organizational communication; Institutional engagement; Project management; Collaborative governance.
1. Introduction
Stakeholder management, also known as stakeholder management, is a fundamental pillar for the success and predictability of projects and programs, especially in contexts involving multiple actors, divergent interests, and complex inter-institutional dependencies. The identification, analysis, and continuous engagement of these individuals, groups, or organizations that can affect or be affected by a project is crucial for the viability of deliverables (PMI, 2021). In educational initiatives, particularly those developed in collaboration with the public sector, the relevance of this management is accentuated, given that the results are intrinsically linked to the alignment of expectations, the effectiveness of cooperative governance, and the consistency of communication among the various involved instances, such as central, regional, and school bodies. The absence of a systematic approach can lead to misalignments, delays, and compromise the quality of deliverables.
The theoretical foundation of stakeholder management dates back to Freeman’s (1984) seminal work, which posits that organizational performance depends on the ability to recognize and balance the demands of groups relevant to strategy and sustainability. Mitchell, Agle, and Wood (1997) deepen this perspective by proposing a prominence model, in which the priority assigned to stakeholders varies according to their power, legitimacy, and urgency, factors that direct managerial attention and influence decisions. Within project management, Cleland (1999) and Bourne (2009) consolidated instruments for identification, categorization, and engagement planning, emphasizing the need for an adaptive process, with continuous monitoring and gradual adjustments. The power and interest matrix, associated with Mendelow (1981), exemplifies one of these tools, systematizing the prioritization of actors and the strategic direction of communication and relationship efforts. This logic aims to mitigate two recurring risks: underestimating stakeholders with high impact power or neglecting groups with high interest but low formal authority, who possess significant capacity for mobilization and informal influence.
The complexity of stakeholder management intensifies in the public sector and social policies, where the dimension of public value is added to traditional criteria (Bryson, 2004). In educational programs, this reality is notorious, as governmental norms and priorities coexist with rigid school routines, specific calendars, and operational restrictions. Research on program implementation (Durlak & DuPre, 2008; Fixsen et al., 2005) reiterates that the effectiveness of results critically depends on factors such as clear leadership, role definition, adequate technical support, and robust monitoring mechanisms. Even with a well-structured program content, the absence of effective coordination and persistent expectation misalignment can severely compromise execution. Communication, in this scenario, emerges as an essential transversal axis for coordinating decisions and sustaining engagement (PMI, 2021). However, the absence of clear communication governance, with cadence, official channels, and decision records, frequently results in noise, parallel messages, and divergent interpretations about scope, deadlines, and priorities, increasing the probability of delays and rework (Kerzner, 2017). Cascade communication, common in hierarchical structures, can also lead to loss of meaning and requires well-defined feedback and escalation mechanisms (Aaltonen, 2011).
It is within this context of challenges and interdependencies that the Teaching Directorates Program of the Education Partners Association, located in the state of São Paulo, is situated. Its operation depends on the articulation between multiple levels of governance and the adherence of actors with varied interests and capacities for influence. The justification for this study lies in its applied contribution to strengthening governance and inter-institutional collaboration in the program, through the systematization of evidence on the interests, influence, and engagement practices of stakeholders. In this sense, the present study aims to analyze the effectiveness of stakeholder management in the Teaching Directorates Program, focusing on the identification of key actors, the understanding of their levels of power, interest, and influence, and the elucidation of critical points of communication and governance. The purpose is to offer support for more robust engagement and communication strategies, which sustain the predictability and quality of the program’s deliverables.
2. Material and Methods
The research was characterized as applied, seeking to produce knowledge oriented towards the solution of a practical problem in the context of the Teaching Directorates Program. Regarding the objectives, the study was conducted with an exploratory and descriptive purpose, deepening the understanding of a specific organizational phenomenon and mapping relevant actors. A mixed method, with a qualitative predominance, was adopted to capture participants’ perceptions and experiences, while the quantitative dimension was employed descriptively to organize evidence into frequencies and response patterns, according to Gil (2019) and Vergara (2016).
The research was structured as a case study, an appropriate strategy for examining a contemporary phenomenon in depth within its real-world context. This approach allowed for a contextualized analysis of stakeholder management practices in the studied program. The results were conceived as evidence situated within the investigated case, without any claim of statistical generalization, but with the potential to produce learning and recommendations applicable to program management, in alignment with the logic of organizational research (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The study was developed in the context of the Teaching Directorates Program of the Education Partners Association, in interface with educational instances of the State of São Paulo. This institutional arrangement involved coordinated action between governance levels, such as program management and the Teaching Directorates, and execution levels, including schools and pedagogical teams. Such a scenario demanded continuous alignment of expectations, communication, and decision-making among multiple actors, characterizing a complex environment for stakeholder management.
Data collection was carried out in December 2026. The unit of analysis corresponded to the stakeholder management process in the program. This process was understood through the investigation of how stakeholders were identified and recognized, how power, interest, and influence were perceived, how engagement was planned and conducted, how communication flows and main noises occurred, and how divergences and conflicts were addressed within the scope of governance. This delimitation ensured coherence between the problem, the objective, and the methodological procedures (Vergara, 2016; Gil, 2019).
The scope of the study was delimited to practices and perceptions related to stakeholder management within the program, considering actors with direct participation in governance and delivery monitoring. The evidence was treated as contextualized to the case, not being oriented towards statistical generalization. The purpose was the production of in-depth understanding and recommendations applicable to the investigated reality, in alignment with the logic of applied studies in an organizational context (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The study population was composed of stakeholders directly related to the Teaching Directorate Program, encompassing actors involved in the governance and monitoring of its execution. The sampling was intentional, i.e., non-probabilistic, as participants were selected for their relevance to the study’s objective and their ability to provide qualified information on stakeholder management practices. This type of selection prioritized analytical depth and informational relevance over statistical representativeness (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The sample was composed of three key respondents, seeking to contemplate different governance perspectives. A program manager, representing the central level responsible for guidelines and coordination, and two educational leaders, representing the regional level with responsibilities for prioritization and institutional articulation, were included. This composition aimed to ensure minimal diversity of roles and analytical contrast between decision-making levels, as recommended by Vergara (2016). Inclusion criteria covered direct involvement in the program during the analyzed period, participation in decisions or institutional articulation, and availability for the interview.
To ensure the relevance of the collected data, exclusion criteria were established. Participants with no link to the program during the reference period, nor those with only indirect participation, without involvement in governance, communication, or monitoring routines, were not considered. In this way, we sought to ensure that the data reflected practical and relevant experiences for stakeholder management in the studied case, in coherence with the methodological guidelines of Gil (2019) and Vergara (2016).
The main data collection instrument was semi-structured interviews, conducted using a script structured in thematic blocks. The blocks addressed the respondent’s context and role, stakeholder identification, power, interest, and influence, engagement and relationship, communication and noise, governance and conflicts, and monitoring and improvements. The semi-structured interview was adopted because it allows for depth and flexibility to explore emerging themes without losing analytical focus, a characteristic highlighted by Vergara (2016) in field research with an interpretive emphasis.
The semi-structured interviews were conducted in person, at the premises of the Teaching Directorates linked to the participants, at previously scheduled times to reconcile the respondents’ availability with institutional routines. Each interview lasted approximately between 40 and 60 minutes, a time considered sufficient to explore the thematic blocks of the script in depth. The respondents were coded as E1, E2, and E3 to ensure anonymity and facilitate analytical traceability. The interview records were systematized in a spreadsheet database, organized by respondent and by question, allowing for subsequent treatment by categories and comparison between profiles (Gil, 2019).
The materials and sources of evidence were organized to allow the understanding of stakeholder management in the program’s context, based on empirical evidence. Complementarily, institutional documents of the program, such as meeting minutes, formal communications, and monitoring instruments, could be considered as a source of contextualization and interpretive support. However, the evidence was primarily based on the empirical material from the interviews, maintaining coherence with the scope of the collection carried out and with the delimitation of the analyzed dataset (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The data analysis was conducted systematically and coherently with the study’s objective, transforming interview records into interpretable evidence on the program’s stakeholder management. The analytical stage sought to organize, process, and interpret the data in a manner compatible with its qualitative nature and the research problem. In organizational research with multiple actors, clear analytical categories were defined, and traceability was maintained between the collected material and the inferences constructed.
The textual data from the interviews were treated by thematic content analysis, which involved a comprehensive reading of the material, identification of meaning units, and grouping into categories aligned with the stakeholder framework and the script structure. The categories used included the identification and emergence of stakeholders, power, interest, and influence, engagement strategies, communication flow and noise, governance, escalation and decision-making, conflicts and misalignment handling, and engagement monitoring and improvement proposals. This procedure aimed to identify recurring patterns, convergences, and divergences between profiles, especially between the central management level and the regional execution level.
Next, a comparative synthesis was carried out among the respondents, seeking to highlight points of consensus, differences in emphasis, and explanatory relationships between categories. The analytical contrast between the profiles aimed to strengthen the understanding of the phenomenon by exploring distinct positions in the program’s governance structure, thereby enhancing the study’s interpretive consistency. Furthermore, an adherence matrix was constructed between recommended stakeholder management practices and the evidence observed in the case, with the objective of evaluating the degree of alignment and identifying gaps.
The findings were organized to support applied project management products, such as case stakeholder mapping, the power and interest matrix, the identification of critical communication points, and guidelines for an engagement and communication plan. These products included channels, cadence, responsible parties, and key messages, focusing on managerial utility and the improvement of program governance.
The research was conducted with attention to the principles of ethics, confidentiality, and participant protection, considering that the interviews addressed perceptions of governance, communication, and influence in an institutional context that could involve sensitive information. According to Gil (2019) and Vergara (2016), research involving people requires care regarding voluntary participation, clarification of objectives, and preservation of respondents’ identity, ensuring transparency and diligence in the treatment and dissemination of data.
Respondents’ participation was voluntary, and they were informed about the study’s objective, the topics covered, the estimated time, and the academic use of the provided information. The right to not answer specific questions and to interrupt participation at any time, without prejudice, was assured. To reduce exposure, only information necessary for analytical contextualization was collected, such as position, tenure, and role in the program, avoiding non-essential personal data, in line with Gil (2019). Anonymity was guaranteed through participant coding (E1, E2, and E3), and the results were presented in an aggregated and interpretive manner, avoiding descriptions that could allow indirect identification of individuals (Vergara, 2016).
The interview records and the structured database were kept in a restricted-access digital repository, organized in spreadsheets and work files to ensure traceability and integrity during the analysis. After the study’s completion, the data were planned for maintenance only for the period necessary for academic and methodological audit purposes, with subsequent secure disposal, preserving confidentiality, as per the precautions recommended by Gil (2019) and Vergara (2016).
The study’s limitations were acknowledged in order to preserve the coherence between the adopted design and the interpretive scope of the results. Applied research structured as a case study produces contextualized evidence, useful for in-depth understanding and proposing improvements, but without any claim of statistical generalization. In organizational investigations, limitations related to the scope of the case, access to information, and participant profiles must be explicitly stated to ensure transparency and rigor (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The first limitation referred to the size and composition of the sample, which was intentional and restricted to three key respondents, including a program manager and two educational leaders. Although this selection was adequate to capture strategic and governance perceptions, it reduced the breadth of views on the program, especially from school-level stakeholders and central public sector bodies. Thus, the findings primarily reflected the central and regional governance perspective, and should be interpreted within this scope (Gil, 2019).
The second limitation was associated with the perceptual nature of the data, as the evidence was based on the interviewees’ reports and interpretations. This aspect could introduce memory biases, causality attribution, and distinct emphases according to the respondent’s institutional role. To mitigate this risk, we sought to organize the analysis by categories, compare convergences and divergences among interviewees, and maintain traceability between evidence and interpretations, in line with recommendations for analytical rigor discussed by Vergara (2016).
The third limitation related to the availability of documentary evidence in the Preliminary Results stage. Although institutional documents could strengthen the triangulation and detailing of the communication and governance flow, at this stage the study relied mainly on interviews. Thus, part of the findings remained dependent on field material, and the consolidation of the final work can be strengthened with the inclusion and documentary analysis, according to the logic of complementarity of sources indicated by Gil (2019).
Finally, it was recognized that the results represented an analytical generalization, not a statistical one, being valid as an in-depth understanding of the investigated case and as a basis for improvement propositions compatible with the program’s context. Thus, caution was recommended when directly transferring conclusions to other educational programs without considering differences in governance, institutional maturity, and local conditions, in line with Vergara’s (2016) guidelines for interpreting evidence in organizational studies.
3. Results and Discussion
The results and discussion that follow are based on evidence collected through three semi-structured interviews with key actors directly involved in the governance of the Teaching Directorate Program. The analysis sought to identify patterns, convergences, and divergences in perceptions of stakeholder management, according to the predefined thematic categories: stakeholder identification, power, interest and influence, engagement, communication, governance, conflicts, and monitoring. This approach allowed for an in-depth understanding of the inter-institutional dynamics and operational challenges faced by the program, aligning with the exploratory and descriptive nature of the case study (Gil, 2019; Vergara, 2016).
The characterization of respondents and their roles in the program governance revealed a complementary operational structure between the central and regional levels. Table 1, below, summarizes the profiles of the interviewees and their predominant responsibilities.
Table 1. Profile of respondents
|
Code |
Position |
Runtime |
Relationship with the program (synthesis) |
|
E1 |
Program Manager of Teaching Departments (Association) |
4 years |
Coordinates design and governance; monitors Income statements for the year (DRE) and schools. |
|
E2 |
Education Executive Board (DRE) |
2 years |
Sponsors execution in schools; prioritizes agenda; averages demands. |
|
EAC |
Education Executive Board (DRE) |
5 years |
Coordinates implementation; ensures local governance; articulates supervision and direction. |
Source: Original research results
The program manager (E1), operating at the central level, is responsible for strategic design, overall governance, and monitoring of the Teaching Directorates (DREs) and schools. Their 4 years of experience provide them with a comprehensive and strategic vision of guidelines and coordination. In contrast, the two teaching leaders (E2 and E3), with 2 and 5 years of experience, respectively, represent the regional level. Their responsibilities include sponsoring execution in schools, prioritizing the regional agenda, coordinating implementation, ensuring local governance, and liaising with school supervision and management. This division of responsibilities is crucial for the execution of inter-institutional programs, where coordination between different decision-making levels is a critical success factor (PMI, 2021). The observed complementarity between the design and scaling coordination at the central level and the agenda prioritization and execution coordination at the regional level is a finding that highlights the complexity and interdependence inherent in educational programs with multiple actors. Literature on collaborative governance, as discussed by Bryson (2004), emphasizes that clarity of roles and articulation between different spheres of decision-making are fundamental to the effectiveness of public policies and programs. The absence of such clarity can lead to overlapping responsibilities or gaps in execution, compromising the predictability of deliverables.
Regarding the identification of stakeholders, the interviewees demonstrated a notable convergence in pointing out a core group of essential actors for the program. As presented in Figure 1, the central body/Secretariat, DRE (directorate and technical teams), school management, teachers, and external partners were cited by all respondents (3/3) as main stakeholders.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Mentions by stakeholder group (n=3)
This unanimity in identifying these groups, as detailed in Table 2, suggests that the program has a consolidated understanding of its most directly involved and influential actors.
Table 2. Synthesis of cited stakeholders and associated evidence
|
Stakeholder group |
Mentions |
Evidence (synthesis) |
|
Central Body/Secretariat |
3/3 |
Define norms and priorities; influences agenda and criteria. |
|
Income statement for the year (DRE) (management/teams) |
3/3 |
Prioritizes regional agenda; articulates supervision, technical teams, and schools. |
|
School Management |
3/3 |
Enables local implementation; adjusts routines and operational conditions. |
|
Faculty |
3/3 |
Maintains adherence; influences the quality of pedagogical execution. |
|
External partners |
3/3 |
Supports training and technical support; contributes to follow-up. |
|
Association |
2/3 |
Coordinates governance; consolidates status and escalates impasses. |
|
Families/community |
1/3 |
Contributes to legitimacy; pressure for results varies by context. |
Source: Original research results
The predominance of these mentions reinforces the idea that the program operates in a complex inter-institutional arrangement, where alignment between the central body’s guidelines, the regional coordination of the DREs, and the schools’ implementation capacity is a sine qua non condition for the sustainability of routines and the success of deliveries. This perception is in line with Freeman’s (1984) definition of stakeholders, which describes them as any group or individual who can affect or be affected by the objectives of an organization. In the context of educational programs, the interdependence between these levels is even more pronounced, as the effectiveness of policies depends not only on central formulation but also on effective adaptation and execution at the regional and local levels (Durlak & DuPre, 2008). The constant presence of external partners in this core group of stakeholders also underscores the collaborative nature of the program, indicating that external technical and training support is vital for the continuity and quality of the monitoring of actions.
However, the analysis of mention frequency also revealed important nuances. The Association, the coordinating entity for governance, was cited by 2/3 of respondents, indicating a variation in its visibility. Although the Association is fundamental to consolidating the program’s status and escalating impasses, its perception is not uniform across all profiles. This variation may be a reflection of the operational design, where the Association may act more behind the scenes or during escalation moments, making its role less evident to those more exposed to regional or school execution. Such a finding is a governance alert, because if the entity responsible for coordination and escalation is not consistently perceived by all actors, there may be room for divergent interpretations about “who decides” and “who consolidates.” The literature on stakeholder management, such as Bryson (2004), suggests that clarity of roles and responsibilities is essential to avoid ambiguities and strengthen the legitimacy of decisions. The practical implication is the need to make the Association’s roles, formal channels, and responsibilities more explicit, through targeted communication and formalization of processes, to reduce variability in perception and ensure a common understanding of its central function.
Families/community, cited by only 1/3 of respondents, emerge as stakeholders of legitimacy, but with an influence perceived as contextual and variable. The fact that they are not universally cited suggests that, for some of the interviewees, the community is not fully integrated into the program’s operational cycle, or its influence manifests more indirectly, such as pressure for results or local demands. This result aligns with the theory of salience by Mitchell, Agle, and Wood (1997), who argue that the priority given to stakeholders varies according to their power, legitimacy, and urgency. Families and community, although legitimate, may not possess formal power or perceived urgency on a continuous basis, making them “latent” in the governance flow. The practical implication is that, although not at the center of daily operations, they can become critical in scenarios of conflict or changes in priorities, requiring engagement strategies that consider their mobilization capacity and their role in the program’s legitimacy. Creating feedback channels and including them in strategic communication moments can transform these latent stakeholders into active allies, strengthening the program’s support base.
The most critical data, however, is the absence of mentions of operational support (0/3). This indicates that activities such as registration, data, systematization, and formalization are not perceived as an explicit part of the stakeholder ecosystem. This gap is directly connected to the findings on unregistered noise and changes, as, when operational support is not recognized as relevant actors, the program tends to rely on individual efforts to document decisions and maintain traceability. The relevance of this group “grows with the demand for systems”, according to the evidence in Table 2, which points to a significant improvement opportunity: the institutionalization of support functions for registration and informational governance. Kerzner (2017) highlights that the documentation and registration of decisions are pillars for project management, preventing rework and increasing predictability. The absence of formal recognition of these actors can lead to an undervaluation of their contributions, resulting in failures in collecting and organizing essential data for monitoring and decision-making. The practical implication is the need to formalize and value the role of operational support, explicitly integrating them into the stakeholder mapping and defining their responsibilities regarding the program’s information management and documentation. This would not only reduce rework but also increase transparency and methodological auditability, as recommended by Gil (2019).
Regarding power, interest, and influence, the interviewees’ accounts allowed for a distinction between formal influence, associated with norms, position, and decision-making authority, and informal influence, linked to networks, technical legitimacy, and mobilization capacity. Table 3, below, summarizes the observed power/interest patterns and treatment strategies.
Table 3. Power/interest patterns and treatment strategies (synthesis)
|
Quadrant |
Example (typical) |
Observed Strategy |
|
High power / high interest |
Central body; Income statement for the year (DRE) in priority cycles |
Maintain continuous alignment; regular feedback; agreement on priorities. |
|
High power / low interest |
Instances with saturated schedule |
Connect to current priorities; reduce friction; deliver ‘quick wins’ and objective evidence. |
|
Low power / high interest |
Pedagogical actors engaged without decision-making autonomy |
Include in the construction of solutions; reinforce listening; translate decisions into school routine. |
|
Low power / low interest |
Peripheral actors in the current cycle |
Monitor change signals; trigger on demand; minimal sufficient communication. |
Source: Original research results
The central Organ and the DREs were consistently perceived as holders of greater formal power, which is expected in hierarchical governance structures. However, school management and technical leaderships were highlighted as crucial for the program’s adherence and continuity, evidencing the importance of informal influence. This distinction is fundamental for stakeholder management, as, according to Mitchell, Agle, and Wood (1997), a stakeholder’s salience is based not only on their formal power but also on their legitimacy and urgency. Mendelow’s (1981) power/interest matrix offers a framework for understanding how different combinations of these attributes should guide engagement strategies.
For “High power / high interest” stakeholders, such as the Central Body and the DREs in priority cycles, the observed strategy was to maintain continuous alignment, with regular feedback and agreement on priorities. This reflects the need to actively manage these groups, ensuring their expectations are aligned and their decisions are consistently incorporated. Lack of continuous engagement with these actors could lead to strategic misalignments and loss of crucial support for the program. The practice of explicit agreement on priorities is an effective measure to mitigate conflicts and ensure that central guidelines are understood and accepted at the execution levels, according to the literature on collaborative governance (Bryson, 2004).
In the “High power / low interest” quadrant, which includes instances with saturated agendas, the strategy was to connect the program to current priorities, reduce friction, and deliver “quick wins” with objective evidence. This group, although capable of influencing, may not have the time or attention to dedicate themselves fully to the program. The approach of focusing on rapid and tangible results, which align with their own objectives, is a way to maintain their support without overwhelming them. Durlak and DuPre (2008) highlight that agenda competition is a common challenge in inter-institutional programs, and the ability to demonstrate value quickly can be a differentiator in maintaining the engagement of powerful stakeholders with limited time.
For the “Low power / high interest” group, such as engaged pedagogical actors without decision-making autonomy, the strategy was to include them in the construction of solutions, reinforce listening, and translate decisions into school routines. This group, although it does not possess significant formal power, is crucial for the implementation and quality of pedagogical execution. Participatory engagement and the valuing of their perspectives increase adherence to and ownership of the program. Fixsen et al. (2005) emphasize that the successful implementation of programs strongly depends on the involvement and capacity of frontline professionals. Active listening and the translation of guidelines into local reality are essential to ensure that solutions are viable and sustainable.
Finally, for “Low power / low interest”, as peripheral actors in the current cycle, the strategy was to monitor for signals of change, trigger on demand, and maintain minimal sufficient communication. This group requires more passive management, focused on identifying potential shifts in their interest or power that might necessitate more active engagement in the future. This approach optimizes communication and engagement resources, directing them towards the most critical stakeholders at any given time, as recommended by Bourne (2009) for stakeholder management.
Communication and noise were identified as critical points in the program. Respondents described a predominantly cascading communication flow (central body/Association -> DRE -> schools), with focal points for coordination and feedback. Figure 2, below, summarizes the cited communication channels.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Communication Channels Cited
As illustrated in Figure 2, meetings, email, WhatsApp, and reports/spreadsheets were mentioned by all respondents (3/3), indicating that these are the predominant channels. The platform/system, on the other hand, was cited by only 1/3 of the interviewees, suggesting a punctual or less institutionalized use. The coexistence of multiple channels, both formal and informal, although it may seem flexible, introduces a significant risk of divergent messages and undocumented decisions. Kerzner (2017) warns that the lack of standardization in communication and recording channels can lead to misunderstandings, delays, and rework, compromising the predictability of deliveries. In interinstitutional educational programs, where cascade communication is common, the loss of meaning and misinterpretation of messages are recurring risks (Aaltonen, 2011). The absence of a clear official channel and formal recording rules formalizes informality, increasing dependence on individual efforts to maintain information coherence.
Regarding communication noise, the interviewees emphasized the use of parallel channels and the associated impacts, such as delays, rework, and misalignment. Figure 3, below, presents the frequency of mentions by type of noise.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Communication noise cited
According to Figure 3, parallel channels and impacts (delay/rework) were cited by all respondents (3/3), reinforcing the criticality of these issues. Unregistered changes were mentioned by 2/3, and scope ambiguities and divergent messages by 1/3. These findings corroborate the literature that points to communication failures as one of the main causes of conflicts and inefficiencies in complex projects (Eskerod & Jepsen, 2013). The proliferation of informal channels, such as WhatsApp, without a clear protocol for recording decisions, creates an environment where information can be fragmented and responsibilities diluted. The absence of formal records of decisions and changes hinders traceability and accountability, making it difficult to identify the origin of problems and assign responsibilities. The practical implication is the urgent need to standardize communication cadence, institute meeting minutes and decision trails to formalize agreements and changes, thereby reducing rework and protecting delivery predictability. This includes clearly defining which channel is official for each type of communication and requiring records for all relevant decisions.
Governance, divergences, and conflicts were initially addressed at a technical level, with attempts at mediation and negotiation, and, when necessary, escalation to higher instances. Table 4, below, summarizes the main misalignments and the observed treatment mechanisms.
Table 4. Synthesis of misalignments and treatment mechanisms (interviews)
|
Axis |
Recurrent examples |
Observed treatment |
|
Scope |
Interpretation of what is mandatory vs. recommended; local adaptations |
Reinforcement of criteria; explicit agreement; record in minutes/feedback. |
|
Deadlines |
Conflict with school calendar and regional agendas |
Rescheduling with milestones; early communication; prioritization by impact. |
|
Priorities/resources |
Competition of initiatives and restriction of pedagogical time |
Agenda protection; selection of few critical actions; alignment with management. |
|
Dissenting decision |
Conflict between Association, Income statement for the year (DRE) and school |
Technical mediation; escalation to a decision-making instance when necessary. |
Source: Original research results
Table 4 reveals a relevant pattern for project management in interinstitutional environments: conflicts are not mere punctual failures, but stem from ambiguities of expectations, structural constraints of the school context, and priority disputes between multiple agendas. The four axes presented (scope, deadlines, priorities/resources, and divergence decision) correspond to classic dimensions of governance and coordination, indicating that the program’s effectiveness depends less on “isolated technical solutions” and more on consistent mechanisms for agreement, communication, and escalation (PMI, 2021).
In the Scope axis, the recurrence of the interpretation of what is “mandatory versus recommended” suggests a typical problem in projects with multiple implementation levels: the translation of central guidelines into local routines generates variations and adaptations. Although these adaptations may be legitimate, they need to be governed. The observed approach – reinforcement of criteria, explicit agreement, and recording in minutes/feedback – points to an adequate response, as it transforms the dispute over interpretation into a verifiable agreement. From a management perspective, recording in minutes/feedback reduces the risk of parallel scope versions and increases change traceability, contributing to the reduction of rework and recurring conflicts. This finding reinforces the need to define clear adaptation limits and objective criteria for accepting adjustments, aligning with the recommendations of Durlak and DuPre (2008) on the importance of implementation fidelity.
In the Deadlines axis, the conflict with the school calendar and regional agendas highlights that the program’s deadlines compete with a rigid temporal structure and demand peaks inherent to the educational environment. The observed approach – replanning with milestones, early communication, and prioritization by impact – indicates maturity by recognizing contextual constraints and adjusting the plan based on milestones and criticality. In project management, this type of replanning is more effective when linked to minimum viable deliverables and realistic operational windows (Kerzner, 2017). Early communication is a critical factor, as it reduces the surprise effect and increases the probability of adherence, especially in a context of overload and multiple simultaneous demands. The ability to negotiate deadlines and adapt the schedule to local realities, without compromising central objectives, is an indicator of managerial flexibility.
On the Priorities/resources axis, the competition of initiatives and the restriction of pedagogical time show that the program operates in an environment of scarcity, where the attention and time of those involved are limited resources. The observed approach – agenda protection, selection of a few critical actions, and alignment with the administration – suggests a strategy of focus, reduction of dispersion, and an attempt to ensure local sponsorship. This point is central: when there are many initiatives in parallel, execution tends to fragment, and the selection of a few critical actions functions as a mechanism for reducing complexity and increasing feasibility. Furthermore, alignment with school administration indicates an understanding that, even with low formal power, local leadership directly influences time allocation and the sustainability of engagement (Fixsen et al., 2005). The ability to prioritize and focus efforts is crucial to avoid resource dilution and ensure that the most important actions receive the necessary attention.
Finally, the Decision axis in divergence explicitly states the political and authority dimension of the program: conflicts between the Association, DRE, and school require clear criteria on who decides what and when. The observed treatment – technical mediation and escalation – suggests a governance by levels, in which impasses should be resolved at the lowest possible level, but with a formal mechanism to escalate decisions when necessary. This pattern is consistent with good governance practices, as it avoids both paralysis (when no one decides) and arbitrary imposition (when decisions are made without legitimacy) (PMI, 2021). However, the recurrence of this axis also signals an opportunity for improvement: the more frequent the escalation, the greater the probability that roles, autonomy limits, and decision-making rules are not fully clear or sufficiently institutionalized. The formalization of these decision-making and escalation processes is vital to ensure agility and procedural justice in conflict resolution, strengthening trust among stakeholders.
Engagement monitoring and priority improvements were described by respondents through simple operational indicators, such as presence, punctuality, quality of deliverables, and responsibility in interactions. Effective practices were also mentioned, such as clear governance, objective feedback, and definition of a focal point per school. Table 5, below, consolidates a coherent set of governance and communication actions proposed to directly address the problems evidenced in the results.
Table 5. Priority improvements proposed by respondents (synthesis)
|
priority |
Objective (summary) |
|
Standardize official channel and registration |
Reduce parallel channels; record decisions and changes (minutes/log). |
|
Cadence and feedback |
Define fixed schedule of rites; short and objective feedback after each milestone. |
|
Clarity of roles and escalation |
Formalize responsibles and escalation criteria in divergences. |
|
Engagement monitoring |
Monitor presence, deliveries, and quality; signal early disengagement. |
Source: Original research results
In terms of project management, these improvements proposed by the respondents constitute a package of actions that strengthens the Stakeholders performance domain and also connects to the domains of Planning, Project Work, and Delivery, according to the PMBOK® Guide (PMI, 2021). The implementation of these measures aims to reduce ambiguity, increase traceability, and improve coordination between the different levels (Association, DRE, and schools).
The first priority, “Standardize official channel and record,” addresses the most critical risk identified in the interviews: the coexistence of multiple channels without a formal decision-making trail. The proposal to institute an “official channel” for decisions and changes, accompanied by simple tools such as standard minutes and a decision log, is fundamental. This reduces the probability of divergent interpretations regarding scope, deadlines, and responsibilities, as well as decreasing rework associated with undocumented changes. In practice, by transforming decisions into verifiable records, the program increases predictability and accountability, which is especially relevant in public and interinstitutional environments, where loss of meaning in cascading communication is frequent (Aaltonen, 2011). The formalization of decision recording is an essential practice for governance, ensuring that information is accessible and consistent for all stakeholders involved.
The second priority, “Cadence and feedback,” reinforces that the problem is not just “which channel to use,” but also “when and with what discipline alignments occur.” By proposing a fixed calendar of rites and short feedback sessions after milestones, respondents point to the need for coordination routines that stabilize expectations and reduce dependence on *ad hoc* alignments. In project management, cadence functions as a lightweight control mechanism: it creates regular synchronization points, allows for early deviation signaling, and reduces the escalation of conflicts due to accumulated pending issues (Kerzner, 2017). Furthermore, objective feedback acts as a minimal “communication contract,” decreasing the chance of parallel messages replacing formal guidance. The regularity and predictability of communications contribute to building trust and maintaining stakeholder engagement.
The third priority, “Clarity of roles and escalation,” indicates that some of the misalignments stem not only from communication failures but also from ambiguity of authority in decisions and conflicts. Formalizing responsible parties and escalation criteria strengthens program governance by defining who decides, who executes, who validates, and when an impasse should be escalated. This measure reduces the sense of arbitrariness, increases the perception of procedural fairness, and tends to accelerate conflict resolution on typical case issues (mandatory vs. recommended scope, deadlines, and prioritization). In project terms, this clarity brings the program closer to practices such as defining focal points and responsibilities, enhancing the efficiency of coordination among actors with different degrees of formal power and informal influence (PMI, 2021). The institutionalization of a clear escalation process is fundamental to avoid decision-making paralysis and ensure that problems are resolved efficiently and fairly.
Finally, the priority of “Engagement Monitoring” translates the need to control a critical success factor of the program: the sustained adherence of schools and teams, in a context of competing agendas and operational constraints. The indicators mentioned (presence, deliveries, quality, and responsiveness) are operational and simple, which is suitable for a viable tracking system. The managerial contribution here is twofold: (i) it creates early signals of declining engagement to allow intervention before implementation collapse; and (ii) it allows comparison of patterns between units, guiding differentiated support actions. By treating engagement as a monitorable variable, the program shifts stakeholder management from a reactive to a proactive stance (Bourne, 2009). The ability to anticipate problems and intervene proactively is a differentiator for program sustainability.
The analysis of stakeholder management in light of the PMBOK® Guide (7th edition) reveals that the program, despite having a core of recurring stakeholders and a predominantly cascading communication flow, still faces significant challenges. The coexistence of formal and informal channels, with associated noise from parallel messages, undocumented changes, and scope ambiguities, are critical points. The handling of divergences through technical mediation and escalation, along with engagement monitoring via simple operational indicators, are existing practices that require improvement.
In the Measurement Domain and Uncertainty Domain, engagement monitoring through simple metrics is useful for early signaling of adherence decline. However, uncertainty emerges especially from competing agendas, leadership turnover, and unrecorded priority changes, suggesting the value of lightweight control mechanisms, with minimal indicators, decision trails, and change management proportional to the context. The lack of a robust measurement system and the dependence on unrecorded information increase the program’s vulnerability to unforeseen events and hinder data-driven decision-making.
In the Team Domain and Delivery Domain, the continuity and quality of execution depend heavily on school-level actors and local technical leaders, even with less formal authority. This reinforces the need for engagement strategies focused on adherence and implementation capacity, in addition to communication oriented towards the school routine and academic calendar. The program’s effectiveness is intrinsically linked to the ability to mobilize and train the execution team, and communication must be adapted to resonate with their realities and needs.
In the Project Planning and Work Domain, the existence of a cadence of rituals, focal points, and feedback was indicated as an effective practice. At the same time, recurring issues point to gaps in the standardization of the official channel, lack of clear rules for decision and change registration and traceability, which increases rework and reduces predictability. The absence of formal communication planning and robust registration mechanisms compromises the program’s ability to learn from its experiences and replicate successes.
In the Stakeholders Domain, critical groups (central body, DRE, school management, teachers, and partners) were consistently identified, along with recognition of formal and informal influence. However, evidence suggests that identification and prioritization still depend on the point of contact and program cycle, with variation in the Association’s visibility and the absence of a single, updated record of stakeholders, roles, information needs, and specific strategies per profile. The lack of a centralized and dynamic stakeholder record prevents a holistic and proactive view of the influence and interest landscape, hindering the adaptation of engagement strategies over time.
Based on the evidence, a matrix of adherence between recommended practices and what was observed in the case was developed, in order to make explicit the priority gaps for program governance. Table 6, below, presents this matrix.
Table 6. Stakeholder Management Practices Adherence Matrix
|
Best practices |
Evidence in the case |
Adherence |
|
Stakeholder registration with roles, influence, and information needs |
Key stakeholders identified; distinction between formal and informal influence; visibility variation according to point of contact. |
Mean |
|
Engagement plan by profile (strategies, messages, responsible parties) |
Reported strategies for alignment and feedback, but without formalization by group and without standardized criteria for stakeholder escalation. |
Lower the average |
|
Official channel and decision track (minutes, log of decisions and changes) |
Coexistence of email, WhatsApp, meetings, and spreadsheets; noise from parallel channels and undocumented changes. |
Low |
|
Communication cadence and post-milestone feedback |
Rituals and feedback cited as effective; need for a fixed calendar and standardization. |
Mean |
|
Monitoring engagement with indicators and action triggers |
Use of presence, quality of deliveries and responsiveness; still without a single dashboard and without formal alert thresholds. |
Mean |
Source: Original research results
Table 6 shows that the program is in an intermediate maturity stage in stakeholder management. Although operational practices are in place, such as focal points, rituals, and feedback, the high dependence on individual efforts and the low standardization of records and communication governance increase variability between directorates and schools.
The recommended practice of “Stakeholder Register with roles, influence, and information needs” showed Medium adherence. Although central stakeholders are identified and there is a distinction between formal and informal influence, the variation in visibility according to the point of contact and the absence of a unified and updated register are gaps. Mitchell, Agle, and Wood (1997) and Bryson (2004) emphasize the importance of continuous and detailed mapping for effective management. The practical implication is the need to create and maintain a program Stakeholder Register, with periodic updates and indication of information needs by group, to ensure a comprehensive and dynamic view of the actors.
The “Engagement plan by profile (strategies, messages, responsible parties)” showed Low to medium adherence. Alignment and feedback strategies are reported, but without formalization by group and without standardized criteria for escalation by stakeholder. Bourne (2009) and Eskerod and Jepsen (2013) highlight that formalized engagement plans are crucial to avoid conflicts and ensure adherence. The recommendation is to formalize an Engagement Plan by profile, defining relationship objectives, key messages, responsible parties, and escalation criteria, adapting strategies to the characteristics of each stakeholder group.
The lowest adherence was observed in the practice of “Official Channel and Decision Trail (minutes, decision log, and changes)”. The coexistence of email, WhatsApp, meetings, and spreadsheets, along with noise from parallel channels and unregistered changes, is a critical problem. Kerzner (2017) and Aaltonen (2011) warn about the risks of fragmented communication. The implication is to establish an Official Channel for decisions and changes, with a standard Minutes and Decision and Change Log, reducing reliance on parallel messages and increasing traceability and accountability.
The “Communication Cadence and Post-Milestone Feedback” showed Medium adherence. Rituals and feedback are cited as effective, but there is a need for a fixed calendar and standardization. PMI (2021) emphasizes the importance of planned communication. The recommendation is to define a minimum cadence of rituals, with short feedback after milestones, including responsible parties and next steps, to ensure regular and predictable alignments.
Finally, the “Monitoring of engagement with indicators and action triggers” also had Medium adherence. There is use of presence indicators, quality of deliverables, and responsiveness, but still without a single dashboard and without formal alert thresholds. Bourne (2009) advocates for proactive stakeholder management. The proposal is to institute a simple engagement dashboard with minimum indicators and action triggers (for example, low presence or late deliverables), allowing for early and targeted intervention.
These measures, when implemented, preserve the flexibility necessary for the school context, but increase predictability and traceability, reducing rework and protecting the execution of the program’s deliverables. The study, therefore, contributes to the practice of project management in collaborative educational programs by demonstrating that systematic stakeholder management is a critical factor for reducing noise, aligning expectations, and sustaining the execution of deliverables. By transforming empirical evidence into structured recommendations, the work offers concrete subsidies for the improvement of governance and engagement in the Teaching Directorates Program, strengthening its capacity to generate consistent and sustainable results.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved by evaluating the application of stakeholder management in the Board of Education Program. The study identified key actors, understood their levels of power, interest, and influence, and elucidated critical communication and governance points. A clearly recognized core of stakeholders was found, composed of the central body, Regional Boards of Education, school management, teachers, and external partners, evidencing an interinstitutional arrangement that demands continuous coordination. The results also distinguished formal from informal influence and revealed recurring communication noise, associated with parallel channels and undocumented changes, which impact the predictability of deliverables. The analysis indicated that the program is in an intermediate stage of maturity in stakeholder management, requiring greater standardization of official channels, decision recording, communication cadence, role clarity, and engagement monitoring to strengthen governance and reduce rework.
However, this study has important limitations. The sample was restricted to three key respondents, which prioritized the perspectives of central and regional governance, limiting the breadth of views from other stakeholders, such as those at the school level. The perceptual nature of the data, based on reports, may introduce memory and causality attribution biases. Furthermore, the primary reliance on interviews, without delving into documentary evidence, may have influenced the findings. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the sample to include more actors from the school level and the public sector, as well as to incorporate documentary analysis for data triangulation. It is also recommended to conduct longitudinal studies to monitor the implementation of the proposed improvements and evaluate their impact on governance and delivery predictability, in addition to comparative research in other educational programs to verify the generalization of the results.
Bibliographic References
Aaltonen, K. 2011. Project stakeholder analysis as an environmental interpretation process. International Journal of Project Management, 29(2), 165-183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2010.02.001
Bourne, L. 2009. Stakeholder relationship management: A maturity model for organisational implementation. Gower Publishing.
Bryson, J. M. (2004). What to do when stakeholders matter: Stakeholder identification and analysis techniques. Public Management Review, 6(1), 21-53. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719030410001675722
Cleland, D. I. 1999. Project management: Strategic design and implementation (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Durlak, J. A., & DuPre, E. P. 2008. Implementation matters: A review of research on the influence of implementation on program outcomes and the factors affecting implementation. American Journal of Community Psychology, 41, 327-350. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10464-008-9165-0
Eskerod, P., & Jepsen, A. L. 2013. Project stakeholder management. Gower Publishing.
Fixsen, D. L., Naoom, S. F., Blase, K. A., Friedman, R. M., & Wallace, F. 2005. Implementation research: A synthesis of the literature. National Implementation Research Network, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. https://nirn.fpg.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/NIRN-MonographFull-01-2005.pdf
Freeman, R. E. 1984. Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman.
Gil, A. C. 2019. Métodos e técnicas de pesquisa social (7ª ed.). Atlas.
Kerzner, H. 2017. Project management: A systems approach to planning, scheduling, and controlling (12th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.
Mendelow, A. L. 1981. Environmental scanning—The impact of the stakeholder concept. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS 1981). Association for Information Systems. https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis1981/20/
Mitchell, R. K., Agle, B. R., & Wood, D. J. 1997. Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: Defining the principle of who and what really counts. Academy of Management Review, 22(4), 853–886. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1997.9711022105
Project Management Institute. 2021. A guide to the project management body of knowledge (PMBOK® Guide) (7th ed.) & The standard for project management. Project Management Institute.
Vergara, S. C. 2016. Projetos e relatórios de pesquisa em administração (16ª ed.). Atlas.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform