October 26, 2026
Structuring of a “framework” for strategic management of research and development project portfolio
Paulo Lopes Barsanelli; Beatriz Garcia Altafin
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601304
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
In a scenario of increasing competitiveness and resource constraints, strategic management of the Research and Development (R&D) project portfolio is crucial for agribusiness companies. However, in organizational practice, an unstructured prioritization of R&D projects was observed, focused on short-term results and based on managerial judgments, with gaps in the formalization of multicriteria processes and in the integration between strategy and portfolio. Given this context, the objective was to develop a framework for evaluating and prioritizing R&D projects, aiming to strengthen strategic alignment and optimize resource allocation. The action-research methodology was adopted, involving the active participation of stakeholders and data collection through documentary analysis of institutional materials and semi-structured interviews with key professionals. The data were treated by qualitative content analysis, comparing current practices with the recommendations from the literature and the Project Management Institute (PMI). The results revealed that project prioritization was informally based on criteria such as strategic alignment and financial return, but lacked a formal and transparent methodology, with a tendency to favor short-term initiatives and qualitative assessment of risks and resources. Significant gaps were identified in relation to best practices. A multicriteria prioritization matrix was proposed, with eight weighted criteria (Strategic Alignment, Financial Return, Technical Feasibility, Risk and Complexity, Time Horizon, Synergy and Scalability, Partners and Ecosystem, and Resources and Required Effort), integrated into a decision flow with gates. The main contribution consisted of proposing a structured, transparent, and organizationally relevant methodology, capable of supporting strategic R&D investment decisions, promoting greater balance, traceability, and alignment of the project portfolio, and strengthening governance.
Keywords: Agribusiness; Strategic alignment; Governance; Multicriteria matrix; Action research.
1. Introduction
The contemporary business scenario is marked by intense competitiveness and the constant need for innovation, especially in high value-added sectors such as agribusiness. In this context, Research and Development (R&D) emerges as a fundamental strategic driver for value generation, sustaining competitive advantage, and ensuring organizational longevity (Cooper and Edgett, 2010). The technological complexity and resource constraints inherent in this sector require companies not only to invest in R&D, but to do so strategically and efficiently. Global data indicate that investment in R&D in agribusiness has been growing, driven by the demand for greater productivity, sustainability, and new solutions for food and environmental challenges (Souza et al., 2021). However, the success of these investments lies not only in the competent execution of individual projects, but crucially, in the ability to select and prioritize R&D initiatives that best align with the organization’s strategic objectives (Cooper et al., 2002). Failure to “choose the right projects” can lead to resource dispersion and underperformance in innovation, even if the projects are well managed (Cooper and Edgett, 2010).
The strategic management of the R&D portfolio constitutes the vital link between innovation initiatives and corporate strategy, ensuring that R&D investments contribute directly to business objectives (PMI, 2017a). The specialized literature emphasizes the need for formal portfolio management processes, which go beyond individual project management, to optimize resource allocation and maximize strategic return (Archer and Ghasemzadeh, 1999; Cooper et al., 2000). However, organizational practice frequently reveals significant gaps in this domain. There is a tendency to prioritize R&D projects in an unstructured manner, often focused on short-term results and based on subjective managerial judgments, without the formalization of multi-criteria processes (Oliveira et al., 2014). This approach lacks transparency and traceability, hindering effective integration between long-term strategy and the composition of the project portfolio (Bitman and Sharif, 2008; PMI, 2017a). The “front-end” of innovation, the initial phase of ideation and selection, is particularly vulnerable to poorly structured decisions, which can compromise the entire subsequent development cycle (Cooper et al., 2002; Oliveira and Rozenfeld, 2010).
The absence of integrated and systematically applied multicriteria models compromises analytical consistency and decision-making transparency, hindering the effective translation of organizational strategy into R&D investment choices (Cooper et al., 2000; Bitman and Sharif, 2008). Frequently, there is a dissociation between long-term strategic direction and project portfolio configuration, with a decision-making bias that favors short-term criteria, such as immediate financial return and operational urgencies, over exploratory and strategic initiatives (Cooper et al., 2000; PMI, 2017a). This imbalance reflects the challenge of organizational ambidexterity, which requires companies to explore new long-term opportunities (exploration) while optimizing existing competencies for short-term gains (exploitation), an essential condition for the sustainability of competitive advantage (March, 1991; Tushman and O’Reilly, 1996). The literature suggests that R&D project selection should consider, in addition to classic financial indicators such as Net Present Value (NPV) and Return on Investment (ROI), qualitative and strategic dimensions, such as strategic alignment, technical feasibility, risk and complexity, time horizon, synergy, scalability, and partnership potential (Cooper et al., 2000; Souza et al., 2021). The integration of these criteria into a robust governance system, with portfolio committees and decision “gates,” is crucial to reduce subjectivity and align the portfolio with strategy more effectively (PMI, 2017b; Archer and Ghasemzadeh, 1999).
Given this scenario, in which R&D portfolio management is recognized as strategic, but often lacks formalization, transparency, and balance between short- and long-term initiatives, the need arises for a model that systematically integrates organizational strategy with portfolio decisions. The absence of a structured methodology for evaluating and prioritizing R&D projects can result in suboptimal resource allocation, missed innovation opportunities, and misalignment with business objectives, compromising the company’s ability to remain competitive. Therefore, this work is justified by the urgency of providing agribusiness organizations with a robust approach to optimize their innovation investments. The objective is to develop a framework for evaluating and prioritizing Research and Development projects, aiming to strengthen strategic alignment and optimize resource allocation, promoting greater balance, traceability, and governance in the project portfolio.
2. Material and Methods
The present study adopted an action-research approach, characterized by the active participation of the researcher and the collaboration of *stakeholders* in the pursuit of practical improvements, in iterative cycles of planning, action, and reflection (Tripp, 2005). This qualitative methodology was selected for its ability to solve a real organizational problem, specifically the gap in the strategic management of Research and Development (R&D) projects, as identified in the introduction. Action research allowed for an in-depth investigation of existing practices and the joint construction of a solution aligned with the company’s reality, aiming to strengthen strategic alignment and optimize resource allocation (Gil, 2017).
The research was developed in the context of a multinational agribusiness company, focusing on its Research and Development department. This environment was chosen for presenting specific challenges in prioritizing R&D projects, as stated in the introduction, which demanded a structured solution. The study was conducted between January and February 2026, a period during which data collection and analysis activities were carried out. The unit of analysis focused on the R&D project portfolio management processes and practices of the organization, seeking to understand and improve how innovation initiatives were evaluated and selected.
For the primary data collection, the population of interest comprised professionals directly involved with the management and execution of R&D projects within the company. The sample for the semi-structured interviews consisted of three key professionals from the area, including members of the strategic committee, project managers, and R&D analysts. The selection criteria for these participants were based on their strategic relevance and tacit knowledge of the company’s current R&D portfolio management practices, ensuring they could elucidate the challenges and opportunities associated with the innovation project prioritization process.
Data collection was carried out through multiple sources of evidence, integrated throughout the action research cycle, as recommended by Tripp (2005) and Gil (2017). Initially, documentary analysis of internal organizational materials was performed. The documents explored included corporate presentations related to innovation committees, a sample of a previous project report, and the project monitoring dashboard. The committee presentations allowed for the identification of criteria for strategic discussion and decision-making, while the project report provided insights into the evaluation of specific initiatives. The monitoring dashboard offered a systemic view of the current portfolio, detailing recorded and monitored information.
Complementary to the documentary analysis, semi-structured interviews were conducted with the selected key professionals. The interview script, developed according to Bardin’s (2016) recommendations for qualitative instruments, was structured into fifteen questions distributed across five thematic blocks: Context and Experience; Criteria and Decision-Making; Strategic Alignment; Governance and Resources; and Perceptions and Improvements. The categories explored in the questions were derived from key criteria highlighted in the literature, ensuring comprehensive thematic coverage. The objective was to collect evidence on the practical use of each criterion and the R&D portfolio decision-making process within the company, capturing the tacit knowledge of the participants.
The research execution followed distinct steps for each data type. For documentary analysis, Bardin’s (2016) systematized approach was adopted, which comprised three phases: pre-analysis, with exploratory reading and delimitation of the documentary *corpus*; material exploration, for information selection, thematic categorization, and content classification; and results treatment, for synthesis and articulation with the interview findings. The interviews, in turn, were recorded via MS Teams and transcribed with the aid of MS Copilot, with manual review. Subsequently, a floating reading was performed for familiarization and inductive categorization of the criteria and practices mentioned by the interviewees.
The treatment and analysis of interview data employed the qualitative content analysis technique, as per Bardin (2016). After a floating reading, the selection of recording units and open coding was carried out, followed by thematic categorization of the codes. In the treatment phase, aggregation and frequency counting per code were performed, allowing the identification of the most relevant criteria and practices. Subsequently, a systematic comparison was made between the company’s current practices and the best practices recommended by the PMBOK guide and scientific literature. The triangulation of documentary sources and interviews strengthened the internal validity of the study, providing objective evidence to identify convergences and gaps.
Based on the in-depth analysis and data triangulation, a structured methodology for evaluating and prioritizing R&D projects was developed. This action phase resulted in the construction of a more robust portfolio *framework*, which defined objective criteria for ranking and filtering projects. A matrix was proposed for classifying prioritization criteria into five levels of adherence, encompassing eight essential dimensions: Strategic Alignment, Financial Return, Technical Feasibility, Risk and Complexity, Time Horizon, Synergy and Scalability, Partners and Ecosystem, and Resources and Required Effort. This matrix aimed to formalize existing practices and fill identified gaps, offering a transparent and comparable method for decision-making.
The final score, termed “Score”, for each evaluated project was calculated by the weighted sum of the grades assigned on a scale of one to five, multiplied by the respective weights proposed for each criterion. The formula used for this calculation was `Score = ∑(CkPk)`, where C represents the value assigned to criterion *k* and P the proposed weight for criterion *k*. This approach allowed projects to be classified into priority categories (high, medium, or low), formalizing the decision-making process. The proposed *framework* was structured into a flow of seven main stages, from project submission to formal closure, including decision *gates* for initial screening, eligibility assessment, and periodic portfolio review.
It is important to recognize the methodological limitations of this study. The research was conducted in a single organization, which restricts the generalization of the results to other organizational contexts or sectors. Although action research is intrinsically focused on a specific case, this characteristic prevents the direct extrapolation of conclusions. Additionally, the reduced number of interviewees, although strategic for in-depth qualitative data collection, may have influenced the breadth of perceptions captured about the prioritization process. The qualitative nature of the research, although essential for contextual understanding, does not allow for statistical inferences or broad quantifications.
3. Results and Discussion
The in-depth analysis of the collected data, through triangulation between documentary analysis and semi-structured interviews, revealed a complex panorama of Research and Development (R&D) project portfolio management in the studied organization. The results allowed for the identification of both consolidated practices and existing gaps in relation to the best practices recommended by specialized literature and the Project Management Institute (PMI).
The application of Bardin’s methodology (2016) for the documentary analysis of the company’s internal materials, as detailed in the Methods section, provided the first evidence regarding project prioritization criteria. The pre-analysis indicated that the project monitoring dashboard, corporate innovation committee presentations, and previous project reports contained relevant information on how projects were classified and evaluated. Specifically, the monitoring dashboard demonstrated project classification by strategic objective, priority level, and feasibility, with monthly updates. The innovation committee presentations, in turn, revealed a strong connection with the company’s strategic objectives, indicating that strategic alignment was already a valued criterion by leadership. Finally, the previous project report highlighted the application of technical criteria for feasibility, return, and risk in the prioritization of new technologies.
Table 1. Project evaluation criteria obtained from documentary evidence
|
Criterion |
Documentary evidence |
|
Strategic Alignment |
Committees and panels classify all projects by strategic axis. |
|
Financial return |
Spreadsheet with earning potential and efficiency reports. |
|
Technical feasibility |
Pilot, industrial and PoC tests. |
|
Complexity |
Classification (high/medium/low); technical and regulatory challenges. |
|
Urgency |
Projects related to climate, legislation, and other external factors. |
|
Scalability |
Replication in industry and between units. |
|
Partnership ecosystem |
“Startup”, university, suppliers, and partners. |
Source: Original research results
As presented in Table 1, the documentary analysis allowed the identification of seven main criteria that, although not formalized in a single model, guided project prioritization: strategic alignment, financial return, technical feasibility, complexity, urgency, scalability, and partnership ecosystem. The presence of these criteria in internal documents suggests an implicit recognition of their importance for R&D decision-making. However, the way these criteria were used was fragmented, distributed across different documents, and without formal integration into a unified methodology. This dispersion of information and the absence of a structured prioritization model represent a significant gap, as, emphasized by Cooper et al. (2000) and PMI (2017a), the lack of an integrated and systematic multicriteria model can lead to inconsistent, subjective, and less transparent portfolio decisions. Project portfolio management literature, since Archer and Ghasemzadeh (1999), has advocated for the need for frameworks that unify and formalize these criteria to ensure that R&D investment choices objectively reflect organizational strategy. The absence of a unified matrix, for example, increases the risk that isolated decisions are made without traceability or comparability, which can compromise portfolio governance (PMI, 2016). Furthermore, the documentary analysis revealed the absence of explicit criteria for aspects such as the quantification of risks and the consumption of resources and capacity, which, according to Cooper et al. (2002) and PMI (2017a), is fundamental for robust and realistic portfolio management. The non-formalization of these critical criteria can lead to suboptimal resource allocation and an unbalanced portfolio, with projects that, although individually promising, do not synergistically contribute to the company’s strategic objectives.
The content analysis of the semi-structured interviews, conducted with three key professionals in the R&D area, complemented and deepened the findings of the documentary analysis. Bardin’s (2016) methodology was employed to code and categorize the excerpts from the reports, allowing for the identification of portfolio management criteria and practices.
Table 2. Categorization and coding of interview excerpts related to project prioritization criteria and portfolio management practices
|
Category |
Code |
Paraphrase of Reports |
|
Criteria |
Strategic Alignment |
E1: Projects must adhere to the company’s strategic priorities. |
|
Criteria |
Strategic Alignment |
E2: The evaluation begins with the strategic direction defined by the company. |
|
Criteria |
Strategic Alignment |
E1: Key criteria include strategic alignment, expected return, and associated risk. |
|
Criteria |
Strategic Alignment |
E3: Priority linked to previously defined strategic pillars; proposals outside this scope do not advance. |
|
Criteria |
Market trends |
E3: Approval requires market reading — target customers, positioning, and commercial viability. |
|
Criteria |
Time horizon |
E3: There is greater pressure for short-term deliveries, although long-term initiatives are also evaluated. |
|
Criteria |
Leadership Direction |
E2: Many demands arise from leadership guidelines and market reading. |
|
Criteria |
Leadership Direction |
E1: The project agenda is usually guided by management and the board. |
|
Criteria |
Scalability |
E3: Projects need to be scalable in the B2B context, in addition to being economically attractive. |
|
Criteria |
Time horizon |
E2: The portfolio must balance short- and medium-term gains with long-term exploration. |
|
Criteria |
Financial return |
E1: Potential for financial return is a central criterion in the decision. |
|
Criteria |
Financial return |
E2: Estimates start from initial assumptions and are refined as the project matures. |
|
Criteria |
Financial return |
E1: Key criteria include strategic alignment, expected return, and associated risk. |
|
Criteria |
Financial return |
E3: Economic attractiveness compatible with the company’s standard (e.g., “payback” and profitability) is required. |
|
Criteria |
Technological risk |
E1: Key criteria include strategic alignment, expected return, and associated risk. |
|
Criteria |
Market trends |
E2: Part of the portfolio arises from market trends and signals. |
|
Criteria |
Time horizon |
E3: Initiatives with impact on the year’s result tend to gain priority. |
|
Challenges |
Periodic monitoring |
E1: It is necessary to periodically review the priority of projects. |
|
Challenges |
Decision by the board |
E2: Disagreements between leaders increase the subjectivity of decisions. |
|
Challenges |
Limited resources |
E2: Financial and team resources are limited, imposing choices. |
|
Challenges |
Communication and systemic view |
E3: Communication gaps and partial chain visibility hinder alignment. |
|
Forces |
Budget dedicated to innovation |
E2: There is a specific budget for innovation, which favors the portfolio. |
|
Forces |
Engaged leadership |
E2: Leadership commitment accelerates execution. |
|
Forces |
Project scope |
E1: The portfolio contemplates multiple fronts considered strategic. |
|
Forces |
Budget dedicated to innovation |
E3: Dedicated funds for innovation projects. |
|
Weaknesses |
Deficitary post mortem |
E2: Lack of robust post-project follow-up to capture value and lessons. |
|
Weaknesses |
Deficitary post mortem |
E3: Discontinued projects are recorded synthetically, with justification for cancellation. |
|
Weaknesses |
Time horizon |
E2: Excessive emphasis on the short term reduces focus and patience for long cycles. |
|
Governance |
Strategic Alignment |
E2: The targeting strategy is clearer today. |
|
Governance |
Decision by the board |
E2: Multifunctional forums support the decision, but the final deliberation rests with the board of directors. |
|
Improvements |
Systemic view |
A more structured arrangement is needed to clarify the next steps and the destination of each project. |
|
Improvements |
Unified tool |
E2: An integrated tool would reduce rework and information dispersion. |
|
Improvements |
AI and automation |
E2: AI technologies can reduce effort and accelerate R&D and management activities. |
|
Improvements |
Interdisciplinary communication |
E1: Widely disseminating results – including failures – strengthens collective learning. |
|
Improvements |
Unified tool |
E3: A dedicated management solution would make monitoring more agile and automatic. |
|
Improvements |
Governance and tool |
E2: Practicality depends on clear governance supported by an adequate tool. |
|
Desired methodology |
Formal matrix for prioritization |
E1: It is proposed to score and weigh criteria to rank projects by defined pillars. |
|
Desired methodology |
Review periodicity and reprioritization |
E1: Establish reassessment cadences from the beginning of the project. |
|
Desired methodology |
Formalization Gate |
E1: Define an explicit milestone for transforming an idea into a project before formal evaluation. |
|
Desired methodology |
Indicators and KPIs |
E3: Create simple indicators to monitor stage and performance, generating KPIs. |
|
Desired methodology |
Simple and applicable method |
E3: The method must be accessible and incorporated into the routine to avoid a drop in usage. |
|
Current practices |
Decision committees |
E2: Periodic committees review status and define directions. |
|
Current practices |
Absence of formal matrix |
E1: There is no established matrix; the current pipeline is more for tracking than for prioritization. |
|
Current practices |
Absence of formal matrix |
E2: In practice, prioritization has been more intuitive in leadership. |
|
Current practices |
Volatile directions |
E2: Frequent changes in direction require rapid adaptation and can affect long projects. |
|
Current practices |
Leadership defines priorities |
E1: Priorities are usually defined by management and the board. |
|
Current practices |
Annual prioritization |
E2: There are bimonthly meetings and annual review; closings happen on a case-by-case basis. |
|
Current practices |
R&D initiatives |
E2: Part of the demands arise from internal proposals from the R&D team. |
|
Current practices |
Decision committees |
E3: The flow foresees technical-functional committees and a strategic committee to guide continuity. |
|
Current practices |
Absence of formal matrix |
E3: Ideas remain in the pipeline until they meet criteria to become a project. |
|
Current practices |
Absence of formal matrix |
E3: Current management occurs in spreadsheets; a dedicated portfolio tool is missing. |
|
Current practices |
Annual prioritization |
E3: In the budget elaboration, the pipeline is reviewed to prioritize or de-prioritize initiatives. |
|
Current practices |
Strategic Alignment |
E3: Active initiatives must adhere to the strategic pillars defined for the year. |
|
Current practices |
Absence of formal matrix |
E2: Manual monitoring of projects via pipeline. |
|
Resources |
Decision by the board |
E2: Leadership decides whether the project will be prioritized and receive resources. |
|
Resources |
Dedicated budget |
E3: There is a cost center for innovation that covers people, services, and tests. |
Source: Original research results
Table 2 presents the categorization and coding of the reports, revealing a series of criteria, challenges, strengths, weaknesses, governance aspects, and desired improvements. The frequency of reports per category, as illustrated in Figure 1, indicated that the categories “Criteria” and “Current Practices” were the most addressed by the interviewees, confirming the relevance of the research focus.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Quantity of reports by category
Figure 2, in turn, details the quantity of reports per code, evidencing the five codes with the highest occurrence: “Strategic alignment”, “Temporal horizon”, “Financial return”, “Absence of formal matrix” and “Board decision”.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Number of reports by code
These high-frequency codes are particularly revealing. “Strategic Alignment” being the most cited code reinforces the convergence with the literature that positions it as the primary criterion for selecting R&D projects (PMI, 2017a; Cooper et al., 2002). Interviewees E1, E2, and E3 reiterated the importance of projects adhering to the company’s priorities and strategic direction, indicating that proposals outside this scope hardly advance. This finding is consistent with the view that portfolio management is the link connecting R&D initiatives to organizational strategy, ensuring that innovation investments directly contribute to business objectives (PMI, 2017a). The company, therefore, demonstrates a fundamental understanding of the importance of strategic alignment, using it as an initial filter for project selection, which is a practice recommended by Cooper (2002) for high-performing organizations.
“Financial return” and “Time horizon” also stood out, indicating a concern with economic feasibility and project return time. However, the analysis of the reports revealed a considerable emphasis on short-term deliveries and initiatives with impact on the year’s results, which, although understandable in a corporate environment, can generate a decision-making bias. Interviewee E3 mentioned the pressure for short-term deliveries, while E2 highlighted the need to balance short- and medium-term gains with long-term exploration. This tension between short and long term is a widely discussed challenge in the literature, especially in the context of organizational ambidexterity (March, 1991; Tushman & O’Reilly, 1996). Innovative companies need to balance the exploration of new long-term opportunities (disruptive innovation) with the exploitation of consolidated competencies for short-term gains (incremental innovation) to ensure the sustainability of competitive advantage. The PMI’s “Standard for Portfolio Management” (2017b) corroborates this view, emphasizing that a healthy portfolio must combine projects of different horizons and risk levels. The company’s current practice, with its inclination towards the short term, may therefore neglect strategic long-term initiatives that are crucial for disruptive innovation and maintaining future competitiveness. The practical implication is that the company may be missing out on transformative innovation opportunities by focusing excessively on immediate returns, which could compromise its long-term adaptability and growth in a dynamic sector like agribusiness.
The codes “Absence of formal matrix” and “Decision by the board” are particularly critical, as they point to the main identified gap: the lack of a structured and transparent methodology for project prioritization. Interviewees E1, E2, and E3 confirmed that no formal matrix is in place, that current management occurs in spreadsheets, and that prioritization has been more intuitive and centralized with leadership. The final decision on prioritization and resource allocation often falls to the board, which, while it may expedite some decisions, introduces subjectivity and divergence, as pointed out by E2. This practice directly contrasts with the recommendations of PMI (2017b) and authors such as Cooper et al. (2000) and Bitman and Sharif (2008), who advocate for the implementation of integrated and systematic multicriteria prioritization models, such as “scoring models” or “stage-gate frameworks”. The absence of a standardized multicriteria evaluation system means that the project “pipeline”, although useful for status tracking, does not function as an objective decision-making tool. This can lead to unbalanced portfolios, suboptimal resource allocation, and a lack of traceability in decisions, confirming the gap pointed out by the literature that, without structured methods, there is a higher risk of investing in projects misaligned with the strategy (Cooper et al., 2002; Cooper & Edgett, 2010). The practical implication is the difficulty in justifying decisions, the potential loss of value due to choices based on personal preferences, and the inability to learn and refine the prioritization process over time.
The triangulation of documentary data and interviews, consolidated in Table 3, allowed for a systematic comparison between the company’s current practices and the best practices recommended by the literature and the PMBOK guide.
Table 3. Current company practices, literature recommendations, and the relationship between them against prioritization criteria
|
Criterion |
Current company practice |
Literature recommendations |
Company-literature relationship |
|
Strategic Alignment |
Projects evaluated for alignment with strategic axes; out-of-scope proposals do not advance. |
Central criterion according to PMBOK (PMI, 2017a) and Cooper et al. (2002); the portfolio must reflect the organizational strategy. |
Aligned. Clear convergence between practice and theory. |
|
Financial Return |
High priority to projects with potential for financial gain; use of spreadsheets and estimates. |
Structured metrics such as NPV, ROI, and payback are recommended (Cooper et al., 2002). |
Partially aligned. Formal structuring is missing in the analyses. |
|
Technical Feasibility |
Evaluation by PoC, pilots and industrial tests; unfeasible projects are interrupted. |
Essential criterion to avoid investments in unfeasible projects (Serrão, 2024). |
Aligned. Consistent practice with the literature. |
|
Risk (Uncertainty) |
Considered qualitatively; without a formal scoring tool. |
Explicit and structured assessment recommended (Cooper et al., 2002; Serrão, 2024). |
Not aligned. Lacks formalization and objective metrics. |
|
Project Complexity |
Informal assessment by level of technical and regulatory difficulty. |
It should be considered to balance the portfolio (Cooper et al., 2002). |
Partially aligned. Lacks structuring and integration with risk. |
|
Time Horizon |
Emphasis on short-term deliveries; long-term projects have lower priority. |
A balance between short and long term is recommended (March, 1991; Tushman & O’Reilly, 1996; Cooper et al., 2002). |
There are gaps. Short-term bias compromises strategic balancing. |
|
Scalability and Synergy |
Valorization of replicable projects with synergy, but without formalization. |
Recommended criteria for adding value and avoiding duplication (Hsu et al., 2003; Souza et al., 2021; Serrão, 2024). |
Partially aligned. Formalization can strengthen prioritization. |
|
Partnerships and Ecosystem |
Projects with external partners are well regarded, especially in R&D. |
Open innovation expands innovation capacity and reduces risks (Chesbrough, 2003; Souza et al., 2021; Hsu et al., 2003). |
Contextually aligned. Formalization can reinforce coherence with the strategy. |
|
Resources and Effort Required |
Resources are limiting, but there is no structured criterion of effort. |
Recommended effort and capacity assessment (PMI, 2017a; Cooper et al., 2002; Souza et al., 2021). |
There are gaps. Explicit criteria and capacity analysis are missing. |
|
Prioritization Process |
Intuitive process, without a formal matrix; decisions centralized in leadership. |
Structured methods with weights and scoring are recommended (PMI, 2017a; PMI, 2021; Kumar, 2004; Bitman & Sharif, 2008; Cooper et al., 2002). |
There are gaps. Absence of a structured methodology compromises traceability and objectivity. |
Source: Original research results
Table 3 highlights both convergences and important gaps. Regarding Strategic Alignment, the company demonstrates a clear convergence with the literature. Projects are evaluated for alignment with strategic axes, and proposals outside this scope do not advance. This is a central criterion according to PMBOK (PMI, 2017a) and Cooper et al. (2002), who emphasize that the portfolio must reflect organizational strategy. The company’s practice of using strategic alignment as an initial filter is a good practice that ensures R&D investments are directed towards business objectives, maximizing generated value. The practical implication is that the company already has a solid foundation for strategic decision-making, which can be formalized and improved.
Regarding Financial Return, there is a partial alignment. The company prioritizes projects with financial gain potential, using spreadsheets and estimates. However, the literature (Cooper et al., 2002) recommends structured metrics such as Net Present Value (NPV), Return on Investment (ROI), and “payback”. The lack of formalization and standardization of these analyses in the company can lead to inconsistent and less objective evaluations. Although the potential for financial return is a central criterion, the absence of a formal structure for its evaluation can result in decisions based on less robust and comparable estimates. The practical implication is the need to incorporate more sophisticated tools and methodologies for financial analysis, ensuring that the added value of projects is maximized in a transparent and traceable manner.
The Technical Feasibility is a point of strong alignment. The evaluation through Proofs of Concept (PoC), pilot and industrial tests is a practice consistent with the literature, which considers technical feasibility essential to avoid investments in unfeasible projects (Serrão, 2024). Unfeasible projects are interrupted, demonstrating pragmatic and efficient management. This practice is crucial for mitigating technological risks and ensuring that resources are allocated to initiatives with a higher probability of technical success. The practical implication is that the company already has a robust process for validating technical feasibility, which is a positive differentiator and should be maintained and integrated into the new framework.
However, Project Risk (Uncertainty) and Project Complexity represent significant gaps. Although risk is considered qualitatively, there is no formal scoring tool. The literature (Cooper et al., 2002; Serrão, 2024) recommends an explicit and structured assessment of risk and complexity to balance the portfolio. The absence of objective metrics for risk and complexity can lead to decisions based on subjective perceptions, making it difficult to compare projects and proactively manage uncertainties. The practical implication is that the company runs the risk of undertaking projects with inadequate risk levels or underestimating complexity, which can lead to delays, budget overruns, and ultimately, project failure. Formalizing the assessment of risk and complexity, with the assignment of scores, would allow for more strategic and informed portfolio management.
The Time Horizon also presents gaps. There is an emphasis on short-term deliveries, with long-term projects having lower priority. This contrasts with the literature’s recommendation to seek a balance between short and long term to promote organizational ambidexterity (March, 1991; Tushman & O’Reilly, 1996; Cooper et al., 2002). The short-term bias can compromise the company’s ability to develop disruptive innovations and adapt to future market changes. The practical implication is that the company may be sacrificing long-term growth and innovation potential in favor of immediate gains, which may be unsustainable in an ever-evolving business environment. It is crucial that the proposed framework encourages an explicit balance between projects of different time horizons.
Scalability and Synergy are valued, especially replicable projects with synergy, but without formalization. The literature (Hsu et al., 2003; Souza et al., 2021; Serrão, 2024) recommends criteria for adding value and avoiding duplication. The formalization of these criteria can strengthen the prioritization of projects with greater potential for impact and scope, ensuring that the company maximizes innovation opportunities. The practical implication is that the formalization of these criteria can optimize resource allocation, directing them to projects that generate value on multiple fronts and business units, promoting a multiplier effect.
Regarding Partnerships and Ecosystem, projects with external partners are well regarded, especially in R&D. This is contextually aligned with the open innovation literature (Chesbrough, 2003; Souza et al., 2021; Hsu et al., 2003), which highlights how partnerships expand innovation capacity and reduce risks. The formalization of this criterion can reinforce coherence with the company’s open innovation strategy, encouraging the search for strategic collaborations that add value. The practical implication is that the company can leverage external knowledge and resources more systematically, accelerating the development of new technologies and mitigating risks associated with internal innovation.
Finally, Resources and Effort Required are recognized as limiting factors, but there is no structured effort criterion. The literature (PMI, 2017a; Cooper et al., 2002; Souza et al., 2021) recommends evaluating effort and capacity. The absence of an explicit effort criterion can lead to an overload of approved projects without guaranteed resources for all, resulting in delays and frustrations. The practical implication is the need to incorporate cost/effort metrics (such as investment estimates and personnel hours) and conduct periodic reviews of resource capacity to ensure that the selected portfolio is realistic and feasible.
The Prioritization Process as a whole is intuitive and without a formal matrix, with decisions centralized in leadership. This contrasts sharply with the recommendations of structured methods with weights and scoring (PMI, 2017a; PMI, 2021; Kumar, 2004; Bitman & Sharif, 2008; Cooper et al., 2002). The absence of a structured methodology compromises the traceability and objectivity of decisions, making the process vulnerable to biases and suboptimal decisions. The practical implication is the difficulty in justifying project choices, the lack of transparency, and the inability to consistently optimize the portfolio over time.
Based on this in-depth analysis and data triangulation, the action phase of the action research resulted in the development of a structured methodology for evaluating and prioritizing R&D projects. This methodology materializes in a more robust portfolio framework, which defines objective criteria for ranking and filtering projects. The central proposal is a matrix for classifying prioritization criteria into five levels of adherence, encompassing eight essential dimensions.
Table 4. Matrix for classifying projects regarding the level of adherence to the eight criteria established for prioritization
|
Criterion |
Level 1 (Very Low) |
Level 2 (Low) |
Level 3 (Intermediate) |
Level 4 (High) |
Level 5 (Very High) |
|
Strategic Alignment |
Unrelated to strategic objectives |
Weak relationship with secondary objectives |
Partial alignment with strategic objectives |
Clear alignment with main strategic objectives |
Direct alignment with central strategic priorities |
|
Financial Return |
No measurable financial return |
Uncertain or marginal financial return |
Moderate return based on reasonable assumptions |
Significant return with good foundation |
High financial return with strong impact on P&L |
|
Technical Feasibility |
Undominated technologies; high risk of failure |
Low technological maturity; requires development |
Known technology, but with relevant technical challenges |
Technology validated in a controlled environment (PoC) |
Mature and proven technology at industrial scale |
|
Risk and Complexity |
Extreme risk and high complexity of technical and regulatory |
High risk; multiple technical or operational uncertainties |
Moderate risk and complexity; mitigable with effort |
Identified risks and robust mitigation plans |
Low risk and complexity; high predictability |
|
Time Horizon |
Expected return in over 5 years |
Return in 3 to 5 years; predominant long term |
Return in 2 to 3 years; balance between short and long term |
Return within 2 years with relevant impact |
Return in less than 1 year with immediate impact |
|
Synergy and Scalability |
Without synergy or replicability |
Synergy limited to an area or unit |
Possible replication in some areas |
High synergy with other initiatives and units |
Fully scalable and with strong organizational synergy |
|
Partnerships and Ecosystem |
Isolated project, without external partners |
Minor partnerships |
Partnerships with the potential to add value |
Strategic partnerships with universities/startups |
Consolidated partnerships with high impact on open innovation |
|
Resources and Effort Required |
Requires resources beyond available capacity |
High effort with low cost-benefit ratio |
Effort compatible with expected return |
Good cost-benefit ratio; available resources |
Low effort with high return; efficient use of resources |
Source: Original research results
Table 4 presents the proposed classification matrix, which includes the eight criteria identified as crucial: Strategic Alignment, Financial Return, Technical Feasibility, Risk and Complexity, Time Horizon, Synergy and Scalability, Partners and Ecosystem, and Resources and Effort Required. Each criterion is detailed in five adherence levels, from “Very Low” (Level 1) to “Very High” (Level 5), with clear descriptions for each level. This matrix aims to formalize existing practices and fill identified gaps, offering a transparent and comparable method for decision-making. The formalization of these criteria and adherence levels is a fundamental step to reduce subjectivity and increase consistency in project evaluations, as advocated by Cooper et al. (2000) and Bitman and Sharif (2008). By standardizing the evaluation, the company can ensure that all projects are analyzed from the same perspective, facilitating the comparison and selection of those that best contribute to strategic objectives.
For each criterion, a weight was assigned, established from the proportion of recurrence and relevance observed in the internal documentation and interview reports, and adjusted based on the literature.
Table 5. Prioritization criteria and their calculated weights (documentary evaluation), proposal of weights to be used in the prioritization matrix and their respective justifications
|
Criteria |
Document Appraisal |
Proposal for Matrix |
Technical Justification |
|
Strategic Alignment |
27,4% |
25,0% |
Most important criterion for ensuring consistency with the strategy (Bitman & Sharif, 2008). |
|
Time Horizon |
18,2% |
10,0% |
Important to balance short and long term according to Cooper et al. (2002) and March (1991). |
|
Financial Return |
18,2% |
15,0% |
Relevant, but should not dominate the decision (Cooper et al., 2002). |
|
Resources and Effort Required |
18,2% |
10,0% |
Dedicated budget favors the reduction of its weight. |
|
Risk and Complexity |
4,5% |
10,0% |
Associated with the perspective of competitiveness and execution capability (Bitman & Sharif, 2008). |
|
Synergy and Scalability |
4,5% |
10,0% |
Related to the perspective of attractiveness and the generation of expanded value (Bitman & Sharif, 2008). |
|
Technical Feasibility |
4,5% |
15,0% |
Related to the reasonableness perspective used by Bitman & Sharif (2008). |
|
Partners and Ecosystem |
4,5% |
5,0% |
Aligned with the perspective of reasonableness by Bitman & Sharif (2008) and open innovation by Chesbrough (2003). |
Source: Original research results
Table 5 details the proposed weights for each criterion, along with their technical justifications based on the literature. Strategic Alignment received the highest weight (25%), which is consistent with the literature that considers it the most important criterion for ensuring portfolio coherence with organizational strategy (Bitman & Sharif, 2008). Financial Return and Technical Feasibility, both at 15%, reflect their importance, but without dominating the decision, as warned by Cooper et al. (2002). Temporal Horizon, Risk and Complexity, Synergy and Scalability, and Resources and Effort Required each received 10%, aiming to balance the short and long-term perspective, manage risks, and optimize resource allocation, according to March (1991) and Cooper et al. (2002). The Partners and Ecosystem criterion received the lowest weight (5%), but its inclusion is strategic for promoting open innovation (Chesbrough, 2003). A visual comparison of the weights calculated from the documentary evaluation and interviews with the proposed weights is presented in Figure 3.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Comparison of the weights of the criteria calculated with those proposed
Figure 3 graphically illustrates the shift in emphasis in prioritization. While the documentary review and interviews indicated a distribution of weights that, although valuing strategic alignment and financial return, did not assign the same weight to criteria such as risk and resources, the proposal seeks a more strategic balance. For example, the weight of “Financial Return” was adjusted downwards in the proposal (from 18.2% to 15%), and “Risk and Complexity” and “Resources and Effort Required” were increased (from 4.5% to 10%). This recalibration aims to mitigate short-term bias and the lack of formal consideration of risks and resources, which were identified as critical gaps. The practical implication of this weighting is that the company will now make portfolio decisions that not only seek strategic alignment and financial return but also explicitly consider inherent risks, project complexity, the balance between short and long term, and resource availability, resulting in a more robust, balanced, and sustainable portfolio.
The final score, or “Score”, for each evaluated project is calculated by summing the weighted scores assigned on a scale of one to five, multiplied by the respective weights proposed for each criterion, using the formula `Score = ∑(CkPk)`. This approach allows projects to be classified into priority categories (high, medium, or low), formalizing the decision-making process. The matrix does not replace managerial decision-making but provides an objective and traceable basis for prioritizing projects in the portfolio committee. Applying the matrix to hypothetical project examples, as in Table 6, demonstrates how the “Score” allows projects to be ranked in descending order of priority, offering clarity and objectivity to the decision-making process.
The proposed framework was structured in a seven-step flow, from project submission to formal closure, including decision “gates” for initial screening, eligibility assessment, and periodic portfolio review.
Source: Original research results
Figure 4. “Framework” for prioritizing innovation projects
Figure 4 illustrates the framework flow, which begins with the Project Input, where the description, demanding area, and objective are detailed. This initial stage ensures that all necessary information for the evaluation is available from the beginning, promoting clarity and communication, which were identified as challenges in Table 2.
Next, the project goes through Gate 0: Initial Screening, where the R&D department verifies if the proposal fits within the R&D scope or if it is a technical support/exploratory demand. This gate acts as an initial filter, preventing misaligned initiatives from consuming resources unnecessarily, a practice that contributes to portfolio efficiency and focus. Literature, such as Cooper et al. (2000), emphasizes the importance of “gates” for project screening and selection.
Projects that pass through Gate 0 are forwarded to Gate 1: Eligibility, where the innovation committee assesses strategic alignment, value hypothesis, initial technical feasibility, and minimum resource availability. This gate is crucial to ensure that only projects with internal sponsorship and validated value potential advance, reinforcing strategic alignment and feasibility, which are central criteria identified in Table 1 and Table 2. Eligibility assessment at this early stage is fundamental to avoid investment in projects that lack the necessary foundations for success, mitigating risks and optimizing resource allocation.
Eligible projects then proceed to Gate 2: Prioritization Matrix Application. In this stage, the Prioritization Matrix (Table 4) is applied, and each project’s “Score” is calculated. Based on this score, projects are classified into high priority (≥ 4.1), medium (3.1-4.0), or low (≤ 3.0) priority. This gate is the heart of the framework, formalizing the prioritization process that was previously intuitive and centralized in management, as revealed in Figure 2. The application of the multicriteria matrix and weighted scoring provide an objective and transparent basis for decision-making, reducing subjectivity and increasing traceability, in line with the recommendations of Archer and Ghasemzadeh (1999) and Cooper et al. (2000). Formal decision-making and R&D portfolio balancing occur at this stage, ensuring that the selected set of projects maximizes the company’s strategic and financial value.
After prioritization, high-priority projects move to Immediate Execution, while medium-priority ones enter the planning queue and low-priority ones remain under monitoring. This clear differentiation in project direction optimizes resource utilization and ensures that the most strategic and promising initiatives receive the necessary attention and investment.
Gate 3: Portfolio Review is a periodic stage where project priorities are re-evaluated. In this gate, the company can maintain, reprioritize, pause, or terminate projects, ensuring that the portfolio remains consistent with strategic pillars and adapts to changes in the business environment. Periodic review is a good practice of portfolio governance (PMI, 2016), which allows for flexibility and continuous learning, preventing portfolio rigidity and ensuring that resources are reallocated to higher-value initiatives.
Finally, the Formal Closure of the project includes the recording of lessons learned and value delivered. This stage is crucial for organizational learning and the continuous improvement of R&D processes, as highlighted by Nonaka and Takeuchi (1997). The lessons learned register, including failures, strengthens the culture of collective learning and informs future prioritization decisions, contributing to a virtuous cycle of innovation.
In summary, the proposed framework synthesizes and integrates recurring elements in the company’s portfolio management, formalizing criteria that were previously applied in a scattered and unstructured manner. By consolidating these criteria into a multicriteria matrix and a decision-making flow with defined “gates”, the proposal contributes to strengthening portfolio governance, by combining a transparent quantitative basis with the flexibility needed to deal with emerging factors from the operational and strategic environment. The proposed improvements for the R&D project prioritization methodology initially require the definition of minimal portfolio governance, followed by the formalization of criteria and decision-making “gates”. The methodology should be implemented incrementally, starting with pilot projects, until it becomes part of the organization’s decision-making routine, promoting strategic alignment, reduction of subjectivity, and continuous organizational learning (Kerzner, 2022; Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1997).
Although this study was conducted in a single organization, which restricts the generalization of the results to other organizational contexts or sectors, the depth of the action research allowed for a rich and contextual understanding of the challenges and the construction of a solution aligned with the company’s reality. The reduced number of interviewees, although strategic for the in-depth qualitative data collection, may have influenced the breadth of perceptions captured about the prioritization process. However, triangulation with documentary analysis strengthened the internal validity of the findings. The main contribution of the study lies in the proposition of a structured, transparent, and organizationally aligned methodology capable of supporting strategic R&D investment decisions and promoting greater balance, traceability, and alignment of the project portfolio.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved with the development of a robust framework for the evaluation and prioritization of Research and Development projects. This framework, which integrates a multicriteria matrix and a decision flow with defined gates, aims to strengthen strategic alignment and optimize resource allocation. By formalizing criteria such as strategic alignment, financial return, technical feasibility, risk, time horizon, synergy, partnerships, and resources, the proposed methodology promotes greater balance, traceability, and governance in the project portfolio. This systematic structuring reduces subjectivity in decisions, ensuring that R&D investments contribute directly to business objectives and the sustainability of the organization’s competitive advantage.
However, this study presents important limitations that should be considered. The research was conducted in a single organization, which restricts the generalization of the results to other organizational contexts or sectors, despite the depth of the action research. Furthermore, the reduced number of interviewees, although strategic for the in-depth qualitative data collection, may have influenced the breadth of perceptions captured about the prioritization process. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the application of the framework in different companies and sectors, allowing for comparisons and external validations of the proposed model. It is also recommended to explore the incorporation of more advanced quantitative methods, such as optimization techniques or scenario simulations, in order to refine resource allocation and decision-making. Additionally, it would be valuable to empirically evaluate the impacts of the framework on portfolio performance over time, validating its effectiveness in different scenarios.
Bibliographic References
Archer, N. P.; Ghasemzadeh, F. 1999. An integrated framework for project portfolio selection. International Journal of Project Management 17(4): 207-216.
Bardin, L. 2016. Análise de conteúdo. Edições 70, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Bitman, W. R.; Sharif, N. 2008. A conceptual framework for ranking R&D projects. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 55(2): 267–278.
Chesbrough, H. W. 2003. Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology. Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA, EUA.
Cooper, R. G.; Edgett, S. J. 2010. Developing a Product Innovation and Technology Strategy for Your Business. Research-Technology Management 53(3): 33–40.
Cooper, R. G.; Edgett, S. J.; Kleinschmidt, E. J. 2000. New problems, new solutions: making portfolio management more effective. Research-Technology Management 43(2): 18–33.
Cooper, R. G.; Edgett, S. J.; Kleinschmidt, E. J. 2002. Portfolio Management: Fundamental for New Product Success. Product Development Institute 1(1): 1–34.
Gil, A. C. 2022. Como Elaborar Projetos de Pesquisa. 7ed. Atlas, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil. Disponível em: https://app.minhabiblioteca.com.br/reader/books/9786559771653/. Acesso em: 03 nov. 2025.
Hsu, Y. G.; Tzeng, G. H.; Shyu, J. Z. 2003. Fuzzy multiple criteria selection of government-sponsored frontier technology R&D projects. R&D Management 33(5): 539–551.
Kerzner, H. 2014. Project Management Best Practices: Achieving Global Excellence. 3ª ed. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, EUA.
Kumar, S. S. 2004. AHP-based formal system for R&D project evaluation. Journal of Scientific & Industrial Research 63(11): 888-896.
March, J. G. 1991. Exploration and exploitation in organizational learning. Organization Science 2(1): 71–87.
Nonaka, I.; Takeuchi, H. 1997. Criação do Conhecimento na Empresa. Campus, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Oliveira, M. G.; Rozenfeld, H. 2010. Integrating technology roadmapping and portfolio management at the front-end of new product development. Technological Forecasting & Social Change 77(8): 1339–1354.
Oliveira, M. G.; Rozenfeld, H.; Phaal, R.; Probert, D. 2014. Decision making at the front end of innovation: the hidden influence of knowledge and decision criteria. R&D Management 45(2): 161-180.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2016. Governance of Portfolios, Programs, and Projects: A Practice Guide. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2017a. Um Guia do Conhecimento em Gerenciamento de Projetos. 6ª ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2017b. The Standard for Portfolio Management. 4ª ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Project Management Institute [PMI]. 2021. Um Guia do Conhecimento em Gerenciamento de Projetos (Guia PMBOK®). 7ª ed. Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, PA, EUA.
Serrão, S. M. 2024. Priorização de projetos: uma abordagem baseada em critérios estratégicos. Observatório de la Economía Latinoamericana 22(10).
Souza, D. G. B.; Santos, E. A.; Soma, N. Y.; Silva, C. E. S. 2021. MCDM-based R&D project selection: a systematic literature review. Sustainability 13(21): 11626.
Tripp, D. 2005. Pesquisa-ação: uma introdução metodológica. Educação e Pesquisa 31(3): 443-466.
Tushman, M. L.; O’Reilly, C. A. 1996. Ambidextrous organizations: managing evolutionary and revolutionary change. California Management Review 38(4): 8–30.
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Project Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform