October 16, 2026
Inclusive education and school management: challenges for the transposition of the legal ideal to practice
Inclusive Education and School Management: Challenges for Transposing the Legal Ideal to Practice
Paola Lira de Castro; Silvia Renata de Oliveira Santos
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603336
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The growing demand for inclusive education has driven transformations in contemporary schools, especially in private institutions, where school autonomy must align with national guidelines to realize the legal ideal in daily practice. The study analyzed inclusive education guidelines in institutional documents, seeking to identify the challenges of their implementation and offer subsidies for the manager’s decision-making in consolidating effective inclusive policies. A qualitative and applied approach was adopted, configured as a descriptive case study. The methodology was based on the documentary analysis of the Pedagogical Political Project (2019) and the School Regulations (2025) of a private institution. The results revealed that, despite the institution having a humanistic philosophy aligned with the inclusive paradigm, operational gaps persisted in the technical formalization of resources, such as Specialized Educational Support (AEE) and the Individualized Development Plan (PDI). It was concluded that the effective implementation of inclusion in school management demands the transposition of the democratic ideal into specific regulatory protocols, ensuring the articulation between specialized pedagogical support and teaching practice in the classroom.
Keywords: Pedagogical Accessibility; Content Analysis; Specialized Educational Service (AEE); Educational Law; Normative Instruments.
1. Introduction
The commitment to inclusive education has driven significant transformations in the organization of contemporary schools. This movement, although universal, acquires additional complexity in private institutions, where school autonomy needs to coexist harmoniously with national guidelines. The goal is to transpose what is established by legislation into a lived and effective reality in the school’s daily life.
The search for a school that not only integrates or aggregates, but effectively includes, requires institutions to be legally and pedagogically prepared. This means ensuring that all students have the right to attend school, receiving, when necessary, specialized support and access to adaptations that promote learning and retention. The success of this journey, however, is not limited to the individual effort of professionals; it intrinsically depends on the organization of the school as an institution (Mantoan, 2003).
In this scenario, planning assumes a crucial role, as it is what allows ideas to be materialized and the school reality to be transformed (Vasconcellos, 2014). Without structured support, the aspiration for a just education can be frustrated by bureaucratic barriers or by the absence of clear guidelines for daily action. Thus, the practical experience of teachers and school mediators reveals the need for an in-depth analysis of the norms that govern the institution.
The Law of Guidelines and Bases of National Education (LDB), Law nº 9.394/1996, constitutes the legal statute of greatest relevance for Brazilian education. It establishes the guidelines for the organization of teaching and articulates school education with the various formative processes present in society. The LDB (1996) broadens the understanding of education, not restricting it solely to educational institutions, but also encompassing the family, social interactions, workplaces, and civil organizations.
The Political Pedagogical Project (PPP) is a fundamental document, whose elaboration and execution are the responsibility of schools, according to Article 12, item I, of the LDB. According to Veiga (2013), the PPP is political due to its commitment to citizen formation and is pedagogical by defining educational actions, which must be in line with educational legislation. The commitment to school inclusion must, therefore, be explicitly present in the PPP and other institutional documents.
Inclusion, according to Mantoan (2003), transcends the mere act of receiving the student. It implies guaranteeing access to knowledge through specific supports, which must be formally registered in the institution’s documentation. This process seeks to overcome the existing barriers between the ideal and practice in the school context. Inclusion demands a profound restructuring of school conceptions, replacing exclusionary logics with practices that recognize that all students may, at some point, need specific supports to ensure their participation and learning (Mantoan, 2003).
It is crucial that the PPP and other institutional documents are aligned with a conception of education that values equity and promotes effective conditions for access, permanence, and learning for all. Libâneo (2004) highlights that the pedagogical project reflects the conception of society and human beings that the school adopts, serving as a reference for educational practices and decision-making. Thus, the PPP is considered the heart of the school, a living document that is continuously built and renewed through dialogue and practice (Libâneo, 2004).
The proposition of actions and pedagogical accessibility measures in the PPP is essential to ensure that all children have access to quality education, regardless of their special needs or individual differences (Brasil, 2001). Inclusion should not be limited to the physical presence of students, but should promote the necessary reflection and changes, reviewing conceptions and paradigms (Brasil, 2001). Although the investigated institution presents a humanist philosophy aligned with the inclusive paradigm, operational gaps persist regarding the technical formalization of resources, such as Specialized Educational Support (AEE) and the Individualized Development Plan (PDI).
In light of this context, the present research is justified by the need to deepen the understanding of how inclusive education guidelines are translated and implemented in institutional documents. The effective implementation of inclusion in school management requires the transposition of the democratic ideal into specific regulatory protocols, ensuring the articulation between specialized pedagogical support and teaching practice in the classroom. Thus, the research objective was to analyze the inclusive education guidelines in institutional documents, aiming to identify the challenges of their implementation and offer support for the manager’s decision-making in consolidating effectively inclusive policies.
2. Material and Methods
The research adopted a qualitative approach with a descriptive objective. It was based on an interpretive perspective, according to Lüdke and André (2013), who emphasize depth in data analysis over quantification. This methodological choice allowed for a detailed examination of the documents, seeking to recognize and characterize elements related to school inclusion.
The qualitative approach, according to Gatti and André (2011), proved adequate for exploring the dynamic field of the educational context. It favors the apprehension of perceptions, understandings, senses, and meanings attributed and manifested in relation to the object of study, which is established from social, cultural, historical, and political aspects.
The central methodological procedure was the case study, which, according to Yin (2015), favors in-depth investigation of phenomena in their real context. This type of study is particularly relevant for research developed in the educational field, allowing for a comprehensive understanding of the research object.
The institution investigated is a private school located in the city of Rio de Janeiro, with a long tradition in basic education. Founded in the early 20th century by educators linked to a foreign community, the school has consolidated itself as a recognized training space within the private education network.
Currently, the institution serves different segments of basic education and guides its pedagogical practice by institutional documents that express its principles, formative objectives, and educational guidelines. To preserve the confidentiality of the participating institution, its name was not mentioned in this study, in accordance with ethical precepts.
For data collection, document analysis was used as a technical methodological procedure. This choice was justified by the possibility of investigating documents that had not yet received specific analytical treatment, allowing the extraction of reliable and essential information for understanding the phenomenon studied (Gil, 2002).
The documentary analysis was carried out between November 2025 and March 2026. The documentary corpus consisted of the Political Pedagogical Project for the year 2019 and the School Regulations for the year 2025, both from the institution under investigation.
Additionally, legal and normative documents that guide inclusive education in the Brazilian context were analyzed, serving as a basis for confrontation with institutional documents. The selection of these documents aimed to ensure a comprehensive analysis of the guidelines and practices.
Access to institutional documents and data collection were formalized through the signing of the Term of Agreement and the Data Sharing Agreement. These terms were duly signed by the researcher and the legal representative of the participating institution.
In strict observance of Resolution No. 510/2016 of the National Health Council (CNS), the responsibility for the custody, confidentiality, and integrity of these signed instruments was delegated to the principal investigator for a minimum period of five years. This procedure ensured the necessary ethical support for the treatment of institutional information, in accordance with current academic guidelines.
The data analysis technique employed was content analysis, following Bardin’s (2016) guidelines. Ferreira and Loguecio (2014) highlight content analysis as an essential methodological path for interpretive research in education, due to its capacity to deepen the understanding of complex phenomena.
The analysis followed the phases proposed by Bardin (2016): pre-analysis, material exploration, and treatment of results and interpretation. In the pre-analysis stage, a floating reading of the institutional documents was carried out, especially of the Political Pedagogical Project and the School Regulations.
This initial reading aimed to identify relevant excerpts for the organization of the documentary corpus. In the material exploration phase, the data were systematized into Context Units, corresponding to the analytical dimensions related to inclusive education.
The Registration Units were understood as significant segments that express institutional conceptions, guidelines, and practices aimed at inclusion. Subsequently, in the stage of results treatment and interpretation, previously defined thematic categories were applied.
The thematic categories were established a priori, based on the research objectives and the legal and theoretical frameworks of inclusive education. They were organized into three main dimensions to guide the analysis of the documentary corpus.
The first category was the Normative and Identity Dimension, which investigated the conception of inclusion in the institutional mission, values, and vision. The alignment between the discourse of “integral formation” and the constitutional principles of democratic management and the right to education was analyzed.
The second category, Pedagogical and Curricular Dimension, analyzed the guidelines for curricular adaptations, diversified methodologies, and inclusive evaluation processes. It sought to confront institutional planning with the requirements for effective learning of Law nº 13.146/2015.
Finally, the Institutional Management and Support Dimension verified the operationalization of Specialized Educational Service (AEE), physical accessibility, and continuing education policies. This dimension sought to understand the forecast of resources required by Decree No. 7,611/2011.
The organization of data and the application of these categories allowed us to examine how guidelines related to inclusive education are expressed within the institutional scope. The analysis sought to understand the formalization of these orientations and their articulation with the legal context.
3. Results and Discussion
The documentary analysis of the Political Pedagogical Project (PPP) and the School Regulations of the investigated institution revealed the complexity of transposing the ideal of inclusive education into institutional practice. The PPP, a 35-page document, is organized into 18 main sections or chapters, distributed across thematic axes covering institutional identity, the pedagogical proposal, and the organization of educational work. This document outlines the philosophical and pedagogical foundations that guide the school’s actions, the curricular guidelines, teaching methodologies, and the conception of the student’s integral formation, reflecting a proactive and guiding approach.
In contrast, the School Regulation, with 53 pages, is structured into six chapters with sub-items, standardizing the legal, administrative, pedagogical, and disciplinary aspects of the institution. While the PPP expresses the vision and educational principles, the Regulation formalizes these guidelines into norms and procedures that regulate the school’s daily operations. This complementarity is essential, as the PPP establishes the “what” and “why” of inclusive education, and the Regulation should detail the “how,” ensuring the operationalization of policies.
The study identified five structuring axes in the PPP. The Referential Frameworks, which include Philosophy and Mission, define the institution’s worldview, its humanistic values, cultural integration, and the desired citizen profile. The Reality Diagnosis presents the institution’s history, the characterization of the school community, and the sociocultural context. The Curricular Proposal details the theoretical bases of teaching, the organization of knowledge areas, bilingualism, and methodologies for each segment, from Early Childhood Education to High School. The Learning Processes describe the conception of evaluation and the strategies for pedagogical intervention and recovery. Finally, the Transversal Projects list interdisciplinary activities, such as sustainability, social responsibility, and exchanges, which permeate all disciplines.
The School Regulation, in turn, details the preliminary provisions, identifying the institution, headquarters, units, and purposes of school education. The administrative organization defines the power structure and the competencies of the various bodies. The didactic-pedagogical organization establishes the school calendar, workload, enrollment regime, transfers, and class organization. The school and coexistence regime deals with conduct rules, rights and duties of the community, including disciplinary measures. The evaluation and promotion regimes detail the technical rules for approval, retention, class councils, and the system of grades or concepts. A specific chapter, Title VI, addresses School Inclusion, regulating the support for students with special educational needs, in accordance with current legislation.
The correlation between the institution’s documentary support and the legal framework for inclusion in the country was examined, and the results were organized into three distinct dimensions, allowing for a mapping of the distances between institutional protocols and the pedagogical paradigm established by legislation. This approach aimed to identify gaps and offer strategic subsidies for school management, seeking to understand how the inclusive philosophy translates, or not, into concrete and formalized actions in the documents that govern the school’s daily life.
Normative and Identity Dimension
In the normative and identity dimension, the documentary analysis revealed that the investigated institution establishes in its pedagogical proposal an identity based on the integral formation of the student, considering their multiple dimensions: intellectual, physical, emotional, social, and cultural, and on respect for differences. This approach is aligned with Hoffmann’s (2019) perspective, who argues about the need for diverse evaluative instruments to understand integral development, as each student manifests their knowledge in distinct ways. The school’s humanistic philosophy, therefore, demonstrates a commitment to the inclusive paradigm.
However, upon analyzing the School Regulations, especially in title VII, it was observed that the normative structure still maintains a centrality in achievement criteria that favor the verification of standardized school performance. This finding points to a conflict between the institutional organization and the provisions of the Brazilian Inclusion Law (Law No. 13.146/2015), which guarantees students with disabilities access to assessment instruments designed to meet their specific needs, overcoming rigid and standardized models. The lack of regulatory flexibility in assessment may compromise the effectiveness of inclusion.
For legal compliance to advance from intention to practice, Hoffmann’s (2019) contributions suggest a break from the testing culture. The author proposes a mediated assessment, in which error ceases to be a factor for regulatory exclusion and becomes a clue for pedagogical intervention. The formalization of a mediated assessment in the School Regulations would be crucial to ensure that the inclusive philosophy of the PPP materializes into assessment practices that truly support the learning and development of all students, especially those with special educational needs.
Pedagogical and Curricular Dimension
Regarding the pedagogical and curricular dimension, the PPP highlights curriculum development through Experience Units, especially in Early Childhood Education, aiming to respect students’ different paces. This perspective is in line with Cool (2004), who emphasizes the need for a flexible curriculum, capable of undergoing adjustments that allow everyone to participate in common activities. Such flexibility is fundamental to meet the diversity of needs and learning styles present in an inclusive classroom, promoting a more adaptive educational environment.
However, in the School Regulations, it was identified that, in the final grades, the curriculum assumes a more rigid and content-focused format, with no records of planned, organized, and structured experiences by the institution to ensure the integral development of students. This rigidity contrasts with the need for deep learning, which, according to Moran (2018), occurs through experiences, challenges, and projects. The absence of a diversified and flexible approach in the curriculum of the final grades can hinder the engagement and learning of young people immersed in digital culture and seeking practical meaning in what they study.
A critical point observed was the absence of explicit mention of the Individualized Development Plan (IDP) as an institutional registration instrument. Mendes (2012) argues that the IDP serves as an institutional pedagogical contract, recording the resources and methodologies that the school commits to offering so that students with disabilities can access the common curriculum. According to Decree No. 7.611/2011, full accessibility depends on individualized measures. Without the documentary formalization of the IDP, the respect for the learning pace, mentioned in the PPP, runs the risk of becoming a subjective action of the teaching staff, without institutionalized and systematic guarantee.
Dimension of Management and Institutional Support
In the dimension of management and institutional support, it was possible to identify that the management of inclusive education in the institution is articulated by support bodies, such as the Educational Guidance Service (SOE) and the Psychology Service, as provided for in Article 30 of the School Regulations. Grinspun’s (2011) reflections indicate that the function of educational guidance transcends individualized support, establishing itself as an instance of strategic mediation in the face of attitudinal barriers. This partnership with the teaching staff is fundamental for effectively inclusive education, promoting an environment of collaboration and mutual support.
Vasconcellos (2014) warns that planning is the axis that transforms intention into school reality, not being a bureaucratic act, but the anticipation of the group’s needs. The presence of these support services is a positive indication of the recognition of the importance of psychopedagogical support. However, the effectiveness of these services depends on their integration into robust and formalized institutional planning, which guarantees the continuity and systematicity of inclusive actions, preventing them from becoming isolated initiatives or dependent on individual efforts.
The analytical triangulation between institutional documents and the requirements of Decree No. 7.611/2011 revealed significant gaps in the operationalization of inclusion. Regarding Specialized Educational Support (AEE), although the PPP and the School Regulations mention pedagogical support and social inclusion, and the Decree requires a resource room and a specialist teacher, a lack of detail in the physical structure of the AEE was identified. This imprecision suggests that pedagogical support still requires investment from management to ensure the functionality of resource spaces, which prevents the full implementation of the AEE.
Regarding resources, while institutional documents foresee the provision of technologies and supplies, and the Decree requires assistive technology and accessible materials, a lack of specific technologies for disabilities was found. This omission of instrumental specificities transfers to the sphere of immediate decision-making what should be an institutional safeguard of accessibility. According to Coll, Palácios, and Marchesi (2004), the effectiveness of the inclusive process enables student autonomy, and the lack of this documentary record can weaken the permanence of the curricular adaptations offered, making them dependent on specific initiatives rather than institutionalized policies.
Regarding teacher training, the PPP mentions the constant updating of the teaching staff, and the Decree requires specific training in special education. However, the analysis revealed the absence of a specialized training plan in the School Regulations. This gap suggests that pedagogical management has not yet systematized Special Education as a transversal competence. For inclusion to transcend the sphere of physical integration, it is imperative that training be institutionalized and continuous, as argued by Glat and Pletsch (2012), ensuring that professionals are prepared to meet the diverse needs of students.
The researcher’s professional experience at the institution, acting as a tenured professor and school mediator, allowed for close observation of institutional dynamics. A growing movement of commitment from different professionals was evident in the search for more inclusive pedagogical practices and strategies to foster the participation of all students. However, a large part of the knowledge mobilized in this process has been sought through individual initiative by teachers, which reinforces the need for greater institutional encouragement in creating collective spaces for reflection on inclusive education, promoting the exchange of experiences and the joint construction of solutions.
As a main practical contribution to school management, this study highlights the need to instrumentally formalize the Individualized Development Plan (PDI) in the Regulations, ensuring that the curricular adaptations advocated by Coll (2004) are officially recorded and monitored. It is essential to foster the transition from purely normative assessment to a mediating practice, as proposed by Hoffmann (2019), where errors are used as pedagogical indicators for immediate replanning. Furthermore, it is crucial to ensure, in administrative organization, joint planning time between lead teachers and specialists, consolidating Vasconcellos’ (2014) vision that planning is the transformative axis of inclusive reality. These regulatory adjustments are essential for the right to education to materialize into a practice guaranteed by resources, protocols, and continuous training.
In summary, the research demonstrated that, although the institution possesses a humanistic philosophy and an ethical commitment to inclusion expressed in its Political Pedagogical Project, significant operational gaps persist in the School Regulations. These gaps are manifested in the lack of detail regarding the AEE infrastructure, the scarcity of specific assistive technologies, and the absence of a specialized training plan for teachers. The effective implementation of inclusive education in school management, therefore, demands the transposition of the democratic ideal into specific regulatory protocols, ensuring the articulation between specialized pedagogical support and classroom teaching practice, aligning discourse with concrete action.
4. Conclusion
The study sought to analyze the guidelines for inclusive education in institutional documents, aiming to identify the challenges of its implementation and offer subsidies for the manager’s decision-making in consolidating effectively inclusive policies. It was found that, although the institution has a humanistic philosophy and an ethical commitment to inclusion expressed in its Pedagogical Political Project, significant operational gaps persisted in the School Regulations. The absence of technical formalization of essential resources, such as the Individualized Development Plan (IDP) and the detailing of the infrastructure for Specialized Educational Attendance (SEA), was identified. Furthermore, a centrality in standardized evaluation criteria and a lack of specific assistive technologies were observed, in addition to the absence of an institutionalized plan for specialized training for teachers. The main practical contribution of this study lies in the proposal of normative adjustments aimed at transposing the democratic ideal into specific regulatory protocols, ensuring that the right to inclusive education is materialized in a practice guaranteed by resources, joint planning, and continuous training.
As a limitation of the research, the strictly documentary scope and the focus on a single institution stand out, which prevents the generalization of results. The absence of listening to the actors involved also leaves open the understanding of how norms are re-signified in the classroom environment. For future investigations, it is suggested to conduct case studies that cross the discourse of documents with the perception of managers, teachers, and those responsible, allowing a three-dimensional view of the effectiveness of inclusion policies. The implementation of inclusive education in school management demands the articulation between specialized pedagogical support and teaching practice in the classroom, consolidating the vision that planning is the transforming axis of inclusive reality.
Bibliographic References
BARDIN, L. Análise de conteúdo. São Paulo: Edições 70, 2016.
BRASIL. Decreto nº 7.611, de 17 de novembro de 2011. Dispõe sobre a educação especial e o atendimento educacional especializado. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 18 nov. 2011. Disponível em: http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/decreto/d7611.htm. Acesso em: 25 nov. 2025.
BRASIL. Lei nº 13.146, de 6 de julho de 2015. Institui a Lei Brasileira de Inclusão da Pessoa com Deficiência (Estatuto da Pessoa com Deficiência). Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 7 jul. 2015.
BRASIL. Lei nº 9.394, de 20 de dezembro de 1996. Estabelece as diretrizes e bases da educação nacional. Diário Oficial da União, Brasília, DF, 23 dez. 1996. Disponível em: http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/19394.htm. Acesso em: 11 nov. 2025.
BRASIL. Ministério da Educação. Diretrizes nacionais para a educação especial na educação básica. Brasília, DF: MEC/SEESP, 2001.
COLL, C.; PALACIOS, J.; MARCHESI, Á. Desenvolvimento psicológico e educação: transtornos de desenvolvimento e necessidades educativas especiais. 2. ed. Porto Alegre: Artmed, 2004. v. 3.
Cool, 2004 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
FERREIRA, M.; LOGUECIO, R. Q. A análise de conteúdo como estratégia de pesquisa interpretativa em educação em ciências. Revista Revelli – Educação, Linguagem e Literatura, v. 6, n. 2, p. 33-49, 2014. Disponível em: https://www.revista.ueg.br/index.php/revelli/article/view/3006. Acesso em: 10 abr. 2026.
GATTI, B. A.; ANDRÉ, M. E. D. A. A relevância dos métodos de pesquisa qualitativa em educação no Brasil. In: WELLER, W.; PFAFF, N. (orgs.). Metodologias da pesquisa qualitativa em educação: teoria e prática. 2. ed. Petrópolis: Vozes, 2011. p. 29-38.
Gil, 2002 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
GLAT, R.; PLETSCH, M. D. Estratégias de ensino-aprendizagem para alunos com necessidades educacionais especiais: o plano de desenvolvimento individualizado. Rio de Janeiro: EdUERJ, 2012.
GRINSPUN, M. P. S. Z. (org.). A orientação educacional: o trabalho do orientador, o trabalho da escola. 6. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Wak, 2011.
HOFFMANN, J. Avaliação mediadora: uma prática em construção da pré-escola à universidade. 41. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Mediação, 2019.
LIBÂNEO, J. C. A organização e a gestão da escola: teoria e prática. 5. ed. Goiânia: Alternativa, 2004.
LÜDKE, M.; ANDRÉ, M. E. D. A. Pesquisa em educação: abordagens qualitativas. 2. ed. Rio de Janeiro: E.P.U., 2013.
MANTOAN, M. T. E. Inclusão escolar: o que é? por quê? como fazer? São Paulo: Moderna, 2003.
Mendes, 2012 [Referência completa não encontrada no documento original]
MORAN, J. A educação que desejamos: novos fundamentos e práticas. 5. ed. Campinas: Papirus, 2018.
VASCONCELLOS, C. S. Planejamento: projeto de ensino-aprendizagem e projeto político-pedagógico. 24. ed. São Paulo: Libertad, 2014.
VEIGA, I. P. A. (org.). Projeto político-pedagógico da escola: uma construção coletiva. 15. ed. Campinas: Papirus, 2013.
YIN, R. K. Estudo de caso: planejamento e métodos. 5. ed. Porto Alegre: Bookman, 2015.
Article originating from the Course Conclusion Work of the Specialization in School Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform