October 19, 2026
Working capital dynamics in the health sector: a study using the Fleuriet Model between 2020 and 2024
Working Capital Dynamics in the Health Sector: A Study Using the Fleuriet Model Between 2020 and 2024
Ronaldo Pereira Dias Junior; Marco Antônio Alves de Souza Junior
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601399
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Working capital management plays a crucial role in sustaining operations and maintaining company liquidity, being indispensable in the healthcare sector due to constant liquidity pressure. The study analyzed the dynamics of working capital in three Brazilian healthcare companies between 2020 and 2024. The objective was to understand the behavior of key financial indicators and their implications for liquidity. For this purpose, a quantitative and descriptive approach was adopted, reclassifying accounting statements according to Fleuriet’s Dynamic Model. The methodology allowed for an integrated analysis of Net Working Capital (NWC), Investment Needs in Working Capital (INWC), and Treasury Balance (TB). The results showed relevant differences in the companies’ financial structure. Company A demonstrated high self-financing capacity, with positive NWC, negative INWC, and positive TB, indicating solidity. Company C exhibited structural robustness, with significantly positive NWC and TB, and INWC oscillating between positive and negative. In contrast, Company B presented greater variability in indicators, with a punctual negative NWC in 2021 and the occurrence of the Scissor Effect between 2022 and 2023, although with subsequent recovery. It was concluded that working capital management is directly associated with the operational structure and that Fleuriet’s Model proved to be an effective tool for capturing the particularities of short-term financial dynamics in the healthcare sector, reinforcing the importance of individualized analyses.
Keywords: Financial analysis; Business performance; Capital structure; Financial management; Liquidity.
1. Introduction
Working capital management is a strategic component for operational sustainability and maintaining company liquidity, having been recognized since historical commercial practices as vital for financial success (Brigham and Ehrhardt, 2016). In a modern business context, working capital often represents a substantial portion of total assets, and its ineffective management can lead to serious financial problems and even insolvency (Assaf Neto and Silva, 2011). In Brazil, the healthcare sector, characterized by its complexity and high capital intensity, has faced significant pressures in the period from 2020 to 2024. The COVID-19 pandemic, in particular, generated an environment of uncertainty that impacted the predictability of cash flows and demand for services, making efficient working capital management a critical factor for operational resilience and continuity (Carvalho, 2020). Working capital, which comprises current assets and liabilities, is essential for financing a company’s operating cycle, from the acquisition of inputs to the receipt of sales (Assaf Neto and Silva, 2011; Gitman, 2004). However, the static analysis of Net Working Capital (NWC) – the difference between current assets and liabilities – although providing an initial indication of financial slack, often fails to capture the temporal dynamics of cash flows, potentially masking liquidity risks (Brigham and Ehrhardt, 2016).
For a deep understanding of short-term financial dynamics, the Dynamic Model of Fleuriet (Fleuriet and Zeidan, 2015) reclassifies accounting statements, distinguishing operational from financial components. This model integrates Net Working Capital (NWC), Working Capital Requirement (WCR), and Treasury Balance (TB). The WCR quantifies the resources permanently invested in operations, being positive when there is demand for operational financing and negative when operations generate resources. The TB reflects the company’s immediate financial position, positive indicating sufficient resources to meet short-term obligations and negative pointing to dependence on short-term financing, increasing insolvency risk (Ambrozini et al., 2014). The interaction of these indicators is crucial for identifying the “Scissors Effect”, an imbalance where the growth of WCR exceeds that of NWC, compressing TB and signaling structural fragility (Fleuriet and Zeidan, 2015). The classification of financial profiles, based on the signs of NWC, WCR, and TB (Silva, 2023), allows for an accurate assessment of financial health. The application of this model is relevant in the Brazilian healthcare sector between 2020 and 2024, a period of intense economic pressures. Although studies point to solidity in parts of the sector (Rossi, 2022), others reveal significant heterogeneity in working capital performance among companies, even with similar sectoral characteristics (Silva, 2023; Morel, 2019). This variability highlights the inadequacy of aggregate analyses and the need for individualized investigations.
Given the strategic importance of working capital management for business resilience, the complexity and sensitivity of the healthcare sector to economic fluctuations, and the need for an analysis that goes beyond static indicators to capture real financial dynamics, this study is justified by the pursuit of an in-depth understanding of working capital behavior during a period of significant uncertainties. The application of the Fleuriet Dynamic Model offers a robust analytical lens to unveil the particularities of financing structure and liquidity. Thus, the present work aims to analyze the dynamics of working capital in three Brazilian healthcare companies between 2020 and 2024, seeking to understand the behavior of key financial indicators – Net Working Capital (NWC), Working Capital Requirement (WCR), and Treasury Balance (TB) – and their implications for the liquidity and financial structure of these organizations.
2. Material and Methods
This study was characterized as an exploratory and descriptive research, adopting a quantitative approach to analyze the dynamics of working capital. Descriptive research, according to Gil (2008), has the primary objective of describing the characteristics of a given population or phenomenon, or establishing relationships between variables. In this context, we sought to analyze the behavior of the main working capital indicators in healthcare companies in Brazil, providing an in-depth understanding of their financial and liquidity structures. The exploratory nature allowed for the identification and comprehension of factors influencing working capital management during a period of uncertainty.
The investigation was conducted in the Brazilian health sector, a segment of high complexity and capital intensity, focusing on the period between the years 2020 and 2024. This temporal interval was strategically selected as it represents a moment of significant transformations and uncertainties, notably the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, which exerted strong pressure on the liquidity and financial management of companies. The unit of analysis consisted of individual companies, allowing for a detailed evaluation of the particularities of each organization within the specific sectoral and macroeconomic context. The study sought to capture the real financial dynamics.
For the analysis, three publicly traded companies operating in the Brazilian healthcare sector were selected, whose shares are traded on B3 – Brasil, Bolsa, Balcão. The sample selection was intentional and justified by the relevance of these organizations in the sector, both in terms of size and representativeness, and by the availability and reliability of their publicly disclosed financial information. The companies, herein referred to as Company A, Company B, and Company C, were chosen to allow for a comparative analysis of different management models and operational structures within the same segment, contributing to a comprehensive view of working capital dynamics.
The financial data necessary for the research were obtained from the accounting statements published by the selected companies. Specifically, the Consolidated Balance Sheets and the Income Statements were collected. The primary source for collecting these documents was the Assaf Institute, a recognized portal that gathers and makes available financial information from various Brazilian companies listed on the B3. The use of publicly available and audited data ensured the reliability and consistency of the information used in the analysis, which are fundamental for the application of Fleuriet’s Dynamic Model.
The first stage of the methodological execution involved the reclassification of companies’ accounting statements, following the assumptions of Fleuriet’s Dynamic Model (Fleuriet and Zeidan, 2015). This approach differs from traditional analysis by distinguishing the operational from the financial components of the balance sheet, categorizing accounts into cyclical (linked to the operational cycle, such as inventory and receivables) and erratic (financial, such as cash and loans). Such reclassification is fundamental for a more precise understanding of the dynamics between the operational and financial cycles, allowing for a clearer and more consistent identification of the sources and uses of funds.
After reclassification, the main indicators of the Fleuriet Dynamic Model were calculated: Net Working Capital (NWC), Working Capital Requirement (WCR), and Treasury Balance (TB). The NWC, which represents the difference between Current Assets and Current Liabilities, was calculated according to equation (1) presented in the TCC. The WCR, which reflects the balance of operational cyclical accounts, was determined by equation (2). Finally, the TB, which indicates the company’s immediate financial position, was determined by equation (3). Table 1 illustrates the structure of the reclassified Balance sheet according to the model.
Table 1. Balance Sheet by the Fleuriet Model
|
Current Asset |
Current Liabilities |
|
CURRENT ASSETS – FINANCIAL (ERRATIC) |
CURRENT LIABILITIES – FINANCIAL (ERRATIC) |
|
Availability |
Loans and Financing |
|
Financial Applications |
|
|
CURRENT ASSET – OPERATIONAL (CYCLICAL) |
CURRENT LIABILITIES – OPERATIONAL (CYCLICAL) |
|
Accounts Receivable |
Social and Labor Obligations |
|
Stocks |
Suppliers |
|
Other Current Assets |
Tax Obligations |
|
Other Short-Term Liabilities |
Source: Original research results
The interpretation of the CCL, NIG, and ST indicators was performed in an integrated manner to assess the financing structure and short-term liquidity of companies. A positive CCL indicates financial slack, while a negative one signals liquidity restriction (Assaf Neto, 2020). The NIG expresses the need for resources to sustain operational activity, being positive when there is demand for financing and negative when operations generate resources (Fleuriet and Zeidan, 2015). The ST, in turn, reflects the company’s ability to honor short-term obligations. The joint analysis allowed for the identification of the “Scissors Effect”, an imbalance where the growth of NIG exceeds that of CCL, compressing ST and signaling structural fragility (Ambrozini et al., 2014).
For a more comprehensive assessment of financial health, companies were classified into different liquidity and risk profiles, based on the combination of signals from the CCL, NIG, and ST indicators. This classification follows the approach proposed by Fleuriet et al. (1978), adapted by Marques and Braga (1995), and discussed by Silva (2023). The profiles range from “Excellent” (CCL+, NIG-, ST+) to “High Risk” (CCL-, NIG+, ST+), allowing for the identification of each company’s financial position in relation to its self-financing capacity and dependence on short-term resources. This categorization provided a clear overview of working capital dynamics.
It is important to recognize the methodological limitations of this study. Firstly, the sample restricted to three companies does not allow for the generalization of results to the entire Brazilian healthcare sector. The conclusions are specific to the organizations analyzed and should not be extrapolated. Secondly, the time frame from 2020 to 2024 coincides with a period of strong macroeconomic disruption, influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic. This situation makes it difficult to distinguish between structural trends inherent in working capital management and conjunctural effects arising from an atypical economic environment, which requires caution in interpreting the findings.
3. Results and Discussion
The in-depth analysis of the Net Working Capital (NWC), Working Capital Requirement (WCR), and Treasury Balance (TB) indicators, according to the Fleuriet Dynamic Model, revealed distinct patterns in the working capital management of the three Brazilian healthcare sector companies between 2020 and 2024. These findings not only provide a detailed overview of each organization’s financial health but also allow for a robust discussion on theoretical and practical implications in a context of macroeconomic uncertainties.
Company A, a health insurance provider with national reach and a vertically integrated business model, demonstrated a consistently favorable financial structure throughout the entire period analyzed. Net Working Capital (NWC) remained positive and showed a notable growth trajectory, evolving from R$ 1,381,478 in 2020 to R$ 5,820,097 in 2024, as detailed in Table 2. This growth, with a more significant advance starting in 2022, is a strong indication that the company possesses permanent resources in sufficient volume to finance not only its permanent assets but also to generate a substantial surplus for working capital. From Assaf Neto’s (2020) perspective, positive and growing NWC reflects a robust financing structure, where the company does not excessively rely on short-term sources to sustain its operations, granting it greater financial autonomy and resilience to external shocks.
Table 2. Dynamic analysis indicators (in thousands of reais) of Company A in the period from 2020 to 2024
|
Identifier |
2024 |
2023 |
2022 |
2021 |
2020 |
|
CCL |
5.820.097 |
1.988.904 |
457.377 |
133.739 |
1.381.478 |
|
NIG |
(2.003.435) |
(2.904.778) |
(2.415.771) |
(1.220.291) |
(1.052.939) |
|
ST |
7.823.532 |
4.893.682 |
2.873.148 |
1.354.030 |
2.434.417 |
Source: Original research results
Company A’s Need for Working Capital (NWC) was consistently negative in all analyzed years, ranging from (R$ 1,052,939) in 2020 to (R$ 2,003,435) in 2024. This behavior is one of Company A’s most striking aspects, as it signals that its financial cycle is favorable, meaning that operational liabilities are due before payments are received. This implies that the company’s own operations generate sufficient internal resources to finance its working capital needs, rather than demanding additional capital. Fleuriet and Zeidan (2015) explain that negative NWC can result from a business model that allows for advance payments or from strong bargaining power with suppliers, extending payment terms. In Company A’s case, its role as a health insurance operator, which typically receives monthly fees from its beneficiaries before making payments to service providers, corroborates this explanation. This operational characteristic gives Company A a significant competitive advantage, reducing pressure on its treasury and the need to seek external financing for working capital.
The combination of a positive CCL and a consistently negative NIG resulted in an equally positive and growing Treasury Balance (ST), increasing from R$ 2,434,417 in 2020 to R$ 7,823,532 in 2024, as illustrated in Figure 1. This scenario indicates an extremely comfortable liquidity position, where the company has immediate financial resources in significant volume, exceeding its short-term obligations without compromising the financing of its operational cycle. Ambrozini et al. (2014) highlight that a robust ST is a sign of low exposure to financial risks and a high capacity to honor commitments, in addition to allowing the company to seize investment opportunities or face unforeseen events without difficulties. Company A, therefore, fits into Type 1 (Excellent) classification of the Fleuriet Model, characterized by financial solidity, low risk, and a remarkable self-financing capacity, which positions it advantageously in the health sector.
Source: Original research results
Figure 1. Financial indicators of Company A according to the Fleuriet Model
The analysis of Company A’s operational accounts reveals that the consistently negative NIG behavior is associated with the predominance of operational liabilities over operational assets. Accounts such as social and labor obligations, tax obligations, and other short-term liabilities have shown growth over the years, notably the increase in “other short-term liabilities,” which rose from R$ 387,443 in 2020 to R$ 2,463,097 in 2024. In contrast, operational assets, such as receivables and inventories, maintained more moderate growth, not keeping pace with the expansion of operational obligations. This dynamic suggests efficient management of payment and receipt terms, where the company can postpone its disbursements while maintaining control over its operational assets. The growth of CCL, in turn, occurred in parallel with the expansion of financial current assets, especially financial investments, which increased from R$ 2,334,120 to R$ 8,177,622. This movement reflects a strategy of maintaining resources in highly liquid assets, contributing to the increase in overall liquidity and ST, but without being directly linked to the operational dynamics of working capital. Company A thus demonstrates financial management that prioritizes liquidity and security, aligning with Gitman’s (2004) recommendations for companies seeking to minimize insolvency risks.
Company B, operating in the diagnostic medicine segment, showed more heterogeneous behavior in its working capital indicators, reflecting greater sensitivity to variations in the operational cycle and the economic environment. Company B’s NWC was positive in most years, with the exception of 2021, when it reached a negative value of (R$ 82,134), according to Table 3. This transient imbalance between current assets and liabilities in 2021 is a point of attention, as, according to Brigham and Ehrhardt (2016), a negative NWC indicates that the company is financing part of its permanent assets with short-term resources, which increases liquidity risk. From 2022 onwards, there was a recomposition of the long-term structure, with the NWC reaching R$ 1,556,090 and advancing to R$ 2,904,011 in 2024, suggesting a recovery in the financing capacity of working capital through permanent resources. The evolution of NWC was associated with the behavior of financial current assets. In 2021, the strong expansion of financial investments, which went from R$ 760,816 in 2020 to R$ 2,471,032, was not enough to offset the even more significant growth in current liabilities, resulting in the only negative NWC of the period. In subsequent years, the recomposition of NWC is linked to the growth in accounts receivable and the reduction in short-term loans, which fell from R$ 2,095,235 in 2021 to R$ 937,851 in 2024, alleviating pressure on the short-term financing structure. This fluctuation highlights the need for active and adaptive working capital management, especially in sectors like diagnostic medicine, which depend on a high volume of procedures and efficient management of payment and receipt terms.
Table 3. Dynamic analysis indicators (in thousands of reais) of Company B in the period from 2020 to 2024
|
2024 |
2023 |
2022 |
2021 |
2020 |
|
|
CCL |
2.904.011 |
1.390.139 |
1.556.090 |
(82.134) |
1.197.759 |
|
NIG |
1.946.533 |
1.220.710 |
(358.719) |
(1.600.957) |
29.250 |
|
ST |
957.478 |
170.213 |
1.914.809 |
1.518.823 |
1.168.509 |
Source: Original research results
Regarding NIG, Company B showed fluctuating behavior. In 2020, the indicator was positive (R$ 29,250), turned negative in 2021 and 2022, notably (R$ 1,600,957) in 2021, and returned to positive values in 2023 and 2024, reaching R$ 1,946,533. This variation indicates significant changes in the relationship between current assets and current liabilities. A positive NIG, as in 2020, 2023, and 2024, means that operations require resources to be sustained, demanding that the company mobilize additional financing sources. Conversely, a negative NIG, as in 2021 and 2022, suggests that operations generate internal resources. This alternation can be explained by the nature of the diagnostic medicine business, which involves managing inventory of supplies and receiving payments from health plans and patients, whose deadlines can vary significantly. The instability of the NIG reflects the complexity of managing the operational cycle in a dynamic healthcare environment, where predictability of demand and payments can be challenging, as pointed out by Carvalho (2020) regarding uncertain environments.
Despite variations in CCL and NIG, Company B’s Treasury Balance (ST) remained positive in all years analyzed, although with a significant reduction in 2023 (R$ 170,213), followed by a partial recovery to R$ 957,478 in 2024, as can be observed in Figure 2. The maintenance of a positive ST, even in periods of greater pressure, indicates that the company managed, in some way, to balance its short-term financial sources and applications. However, the reduction in 2023, combined with the increase in NIG, suggests pressure on immediate liquidity, a warning sign for financial management.
Source: Original research results
Figure 2. Financial indicators of Company B according to the Fleuriet Model
The transition of the NIG to positive values in recent years is associated with the significant growth of operational assets, especially accounts receivable, which increased from R$ 1,743,233 in 2020 to R$ 4,950,821 in 2024. In contrast, operational liabilities did not keep pace with this expansion proportionally: suppliers decreased from R$ 1,549,633 in 2022 to R$ 1,438,273 in 2024, and other short-term liabilities, after an increase in 2021, reduced from R$ 2,746,356 to R$ 1,703,480 in the same period. Social and labor obligations and tax obligations, although growing, maintained a more moderate variation throughout the period. This mismatch between the growth of operational asset accounts and the more limited evolution of operational liability accounts reveals a greater need for working capital financing in recent years, which aligns with the observed positive NIG. The ST, although positive throughout the period, reflected the growing pressure of the operating cycle on short-term financial resources, especially in 2023, when it reached its lowest value of R$ 170,213 due to the combination of a significant drop in financial investments and an increase in the NIG. Company B transitioned through different classifications of the Fleuriet Model: Type 1 (Excellent) in 2022, Type 2 (Solid) in 2020, 2023, and 2024, and Type 6 (High Risk) in 2021. The occurrence of Type 6, with negative CCL and NIG and positive ST, in 2021, is an indication of transient structural imbalance, where short-term resources finance long-term investments, a high-risk scenario according to Silva (2023). The recovery in subsequent years, however, demonstrates the company’s ability to adjust its financial structure.
Finally, Company C, a large hospital network, presented a predominantly favorable and robust working capital structure. The CCL remained positive in all years, with significant growth from R$ 18,570,851 in 2020 to R$ 33,505,653 in 2024, according to Table 4. This substantial growth in CCL suggests a continuous strengthening of liquidity and the ability to finance working capital with permanent resources, which is crucial for a company with high investment volumes and operational complexity, such as a hospital network. The ability to generate and maintain such a high CCL provides Company C with a considerable financial safety margin, allowing it to absorb shocks and finance its expansion without compromising short-term liquidity.
Table 4. Dynamic analysis indicators (in thousands of reais) of Company C in the period from 2020 to 2024
|
2024 |
2023 |
2022 |
2021 |
2020 |
|
|
CCL |
33.505.653 |
28.885.934 |
24.933.887 |
16.740.556 |
18.570.851 |
|
NIG |
(1.216.910) |
73.079 |
(439.488) |
5.740.974 |
3.506.549 |
|
ST |
34.722.563 |
28.812.855 |
25.373.375 |
10.999.582 |
15.064.302 |
Source: Original research results
The Need for Working Capital (NIG) of Company C showed an oscillating behavior. The years 2020 and 2021 recorded positive values (R$ 3,506,549 and R$ 5,740,974, respectively), indicating a demand for financing the operational cycle. However, from 2022 onwards, the NIG began to oscillate close to equilibrium or assume negative values, reaching (R$ 1,216,910) in 2024. This transition to a negative NIG in recent years signals that operational liabilities have begun to exceed operational cycle assets, indicating a more favorable financial cycle. The behavior of the NIG is directly related to the significant growth in operational liabilities, especially other short-term liabilities, which evolved from R$ 1,315,053 in 2020 to R$ 10,431,560 in 2024. This expansion far exceeded the growth of operational assets: accounts receivable advanced from R$ 5,163,870 to R$ 9,463,784 in the same period, while inventories went from R$ 607,948 to R$ 912,877. Social and labor obligations and tax obligations also showed growth, but to a much lesser extent. This configuration indicates that the company benefits from a progressively more favorable operational cycle, in which the growth of operational liabilities exceeds the expansion of cycle assets, reducing the need for external financing to sustain working capital. This ability to manage operational liabilities to finance operational assets is an indicator of efficiency in working capital management, a characteristic valued by Fleuriet and Zeidan (2015).
The Company C’s Treasury Balance (ST) remained positive and growing throughout the entire analyzed period, evolving from R$ 15,064,302 in 2020 to R$ 34,722,563 in 2024, as shown in Figure 3. This performance demonstrates a high financial margin, resulting from the combination of a favorable financing structure, accumulation of financial resources in highly liquid assets, and a progressively more balanced operational cycle. The CCL’s growth over the period is strongly associated with the expansion of financial current assets, especially financial investments, which increased from R$ 15,580,374 in 2020 to R$ 32,067,003 in 2024. This movement indicates the maintenance of significant volumes of resources in highly liquid assets, contributing to the strengthening of the company’s liquidity position. However, this evolution does not stem directly from the operational dynamics of working capital, being more related to the financial management of available resources. The results indicate a progressive reduction in financial risk for Company C, which in 2022 and 2024 is classified as Type 1 (Excellent), with a positive CCL, negative NIG, and positive ST, characterizing high financial solidity and financing of operations by the productive cycle itself. In the years 2020, 2021, and 2023, the classification is Type 2 (Solid), with all three indicators positive, reflecting a balanced financial condition and the capacity to finance working capital with permanent resources.
Source: Original research results
Figure 3. Financial indicators of Company C according to the Fleuriet Model
The comparison between the three companies analyzed highlights relevant differences in how working capital is managed in the healthcare sector, even during a period of uncertainty. Company A and Company C presented stable and robust financial structures, with a predominance of positive CCL and comfortable ST, indicating largely self-financed working capital models with high internal financing capacity. This pattern is consistent with what Rossi (2022) found when analyzing health plan operators, where the majority maintained solid financial ratings, with low levels of insolvency risk. Company A, in particular, consistently remained in the Type 1 (Excellent) rating, even in the face of the adverse scenario imposed by the pandemic, which can be attributed to its characteristic financial cycle, which generally involves advance receipt of monthly fees and later payment of expenses, generating a structural negative NIG.
In contrast, Company B presented greater variability in the indicators, alternating periods of structural balance with moments of greater operational cycle pressure, which suggests a working capital management more sensitive to changes in the economic and operational environment. This heterogeneity among the analyzed companies, with Company B transitioning through higher risk classifications, suggests that individual management and operational structure factors exert significant influence, even within a sector with structural tendencies towards solidity. This variation converges with the findings of Silva (2023) and Morel (2019), who documented that, even in sectors with a structural tendency towards solidity, differences in financing strategy, cost structure, and operational revenue generation capacity can produce quite heterogeneous financial classifications. The results found here reinforce the conclusion that the aggregated analysis of the sector, by itself, is insufficient to capture the specificities of each organization, making individualized analyses indispensable for a more precise assessment of the financial health of companies.
The temporal scope from 2020 to 2024, which covers the pandemic period and its developments, makes the analysis of working capital indicators particularly sensitive to the macroeconomic context. Carvalho (2020) identified that Brazilian companies increased their cash reserves during the pandemic as a response to economic uncertainty. This movement is noticeable in the growth of CCL and ST for Companies A and C, driven by greater allocation in short-term financial investments, which is consistent with a defensive pattern. At the same time, Simão and Carvalho (2023) highlight that the healthcare sector faced additional pressure during the crisis, with a simultaneous increase in demand for services and operational costs, creating tensions on dynamic indicators. This dynamic is especially relevant for Company B, which presented the only negative CCL in the period in 2021 and a Type 6 classification, precisely in the years of greatest pandemic turbulence, followed by a gradual recovery as the economic environment stabilized. Company C’s transitions between Types 1 and 2 follow a similar logic, indicating that working capital management in the sector required continuous adaptations to fluctuations in the operational and economic environment.
Regarding the Scissors Effect, companies A and C did not present evidence of this phenomenon in the analyzed period, as both maintained increasing CCL and controlled NIG, with a consequent expansion of treasury balance. In Company B, on the other hand, isolated indications of this effect are identified between the years 2022 and 2023, when NIG showed a significant increase of R$ 1,579,429, while CCL registered a reduction of R$ 165,951, resulting in a strong compression of ST, with a drop of R$ 1,744,596. As described by Fleuriet and Zeidan (2015), the Scissors Effect occurs when the growth of NIG consistently exceeds the growth of CCL, progressively pressuring short-term liquidity. This configuration, observed sporadically in Company B during this interval, signals a fragility in the working capital financing structure, where operational investments are not accompanied by structural financing sources. However, in 2024, a reversal of this movement is observed in Company B, with CCL growing R$ 1,513,872 against an increase of R$ 725,823 in NIG, allowing the recovery of ST to R$ 957,478. This indicates that the identified imbalance was transient and did not result in structural deterioration of the company’s financial position, but reinforces the importance of continuous monitoring of these indicators to prevent isolated situations from becoming structural problems.
The Fleuriet Model proved to be an effective tool throughout this study for capturing those particularities that traditional liquidity ratios tend to hide, allowing for a more dynamic and integrated understanding of working capital management. The ability to distinguish between the operational and financial components of the balance sheet, and to analyze the interaction between CCL, NIG, and ST, offers a more complete view of companies’ financial health and self-financing capacity. Nevertheless, the analysis has limitations that deserve recognition. The sample, restricted to three companies, does not allow for generalizations to the entire Brazilian healthcare sector, and the temporal scope coincides with a period of strong macroeconomic disturbance, making it difficult to distinguish structural trends from conjunctural effects. Future research could expand the sample and the period of analysis to validate and deepen these findings.
4. Conclusion
It is concluded that the objective was achieved, as this study successfully analyzed the dynamics of working capital in three Brazilian healthcare companies between 2020 and 2024, understanding the behavior of Net Working Capital (NWC), Working Capital Requirement (WCR) and Treasury Balance (TB), and their implications for liquidity and financial structure. The results revealed distinct patterns: Company A and Company C demonstrated robust and predominantly self-financed financial structures, with positive NWC and comfortable TB. In contrast, Company B exhibited greater variability, with moments of imbalance and the occasional occurrence of the Scissor Effect, evidencing management more sensitive to environmental fluctuations. Fleuriet’s Dynamic Model proved to be an effective tool for uncovering these particularities, which traditional liquidity ratios tend to hide, offering an integrated view of working capital management.
Despite having achieved its purpose, this analysis has inherent limitations. The sample, restricted to only three companies, prevents the generalization of findings to the entirety of the Brazilian healthcare sector. Furthermore, the temporal scope from 2020 to 2024, which coincides with a period of strong macroeconomic disruption due to the pandemic, makes it difficult to clearly distinguish between structural trends and conjunctural effects. For future studies, it is suggested to expand the sample of companies and the analysis period in order to validate and deepen these results. Additional research could also investigate the influence of specific sectoral variables or compare the dynamics of working capital in different healthcare subsegments.
Bibliographic References
“””.strip().split(‘\n’)
# Citações identificadas no resumo
# Referências extraídas do documento PDF
“`python
Ambrozini et al., 2014
Ambrozini, M.A.; Matias, A.B.; Pimenta Jr., T. 2014. Análise dinâmica de capital de giro segundo o Modelo Fleuriet: uma classificação das empresas de capital aberto no período de 1996 a 2013. Revista Contabilidade Vista & Revista 25(2): 15-37.
Assaf Neto e Silva, 2011
Assaf Neto, 2020
Assaf Neto, A.; Silva, C.A.T. 2011. Administração do Capital de Giro. 4ed. Atlas, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil. E-book. Disponível em: <https://app
Brigham and Ehrhardt, 2016
Carvalho, 2020
citations_raw = “””
Fleuriet and Zeidan, 2015
Fleuriet et al., 1978
Gil, 2008
Gitman, 2004
import re
Marques and Braga, 1995
Morel, 2019
pdf_references_raw = “””
Rossi, 2022
Silva, 2023
Simão and Carvalho, 2023
Article originating from the Final Course Project of the Specialization in Finance and Controllership of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform