October 26, 2026
Determinants of producer decision in contracting rural credit
Matheus Devens dos Santos; Lygia Maria Napoli
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601209
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Rural credit is fundamental for the development of Brazilian agribusiness, but its contracting is complex, influenced by economic, institutional, and behavioral factors. This study analyzed the factors that influence rural producers’ decision to contract credit, considering variables such as costs, deadlines, guarantees, bureaucracy, knowledge, institutional trust, and technical support. The research was characterized as applied, with a mixed, descriptive, and exploratory approach. A documentary analysis of credit lines was performed, along with a field study with 64 producers, using a structured questionnaire with closed-ended questions, Likert scales, and open-ended questions. The data were analyzed by descriptive statistics and thematic categorization. The results indicated high utilization of rural credit, predominantly for operating expenses and investment. Economic variables, such as interest rates and deadlines, exerted greater influence, while guarantee requirements and bureaucracy stood out as the main institutional barriers. Behavioral factors, including knowledge, previous experience, trust in financial institutions, and technical support, also showed a relevant impact. It was concluded that rural credit functions as a productive incentive, but is conditioned by institutional restrictions. Its effectiveness depends on the reduction of operational bottlenecks, greater flexibility in requirements, and strengthening of information and technical assistance to expand access and efficiency in the agricultural sector.
Keywords: Agribusiness; Agricultural financing; Agricultural policy.
1. Introduction
Rural credit is one of the main instruments for supporting the development of Brazilian agribusiness, playing a strategic role in enabling the financing of productive activities. Covering costs, investment, and commercialization, it is fundamental for maintaining production cycles and expanding the investment capacity of properties. Its performance contributes significantly to the technological modernization and increased competitiveness of the sector, integrating agricultural policies aimed at production stability and strengthening agro-industrial chains, with a structuring function in the economic development of the rural environment (Central Bank of Brazil, 2023; Bacha, 2012).
In Brazil, the rural credit system was conceived as a public policy instrument with the purpose of reducing productive risks and expanding access to resources under differentiated conditions. Its organization is marked by subsidies, resource allocation, and segmentation by producer profile and purpose, which highlights its institutional nature. These characteristics directly influence the availability of resources and the way producers interpret and use financing alternatives (Wedekin, 2022; Central Bank of Brazil, 2023). The relevance of rural credit is also manifested by the need for advance financing of agricultural activities, which are characterized by long cycles and high exposure to climate and market risks. In this context, access to credit is essential for the continuity of production, the adoption of new technologies, and the reduction of economic vulnerability, functioning as a crucial tool for financial management and risk mitigation (Borges and Parré, 2022; Tavares, 2018).
However, the decision to hire rural credit is not an automatic process, being influenced by a complex interaction of economic, institutional, and behavioral factors. In the economic dimension, variables such as interest rates, terms, and guarantees are determinants. The institutional dimension encompasses bureaucracy, access to information, and operational rules. Behavioral aspects, on the other hand, include risk perception, trust in financial institutions, and the producer’s previous experience (Souza and Clemente, 2008; Souza and Mendes, 2020). This decision-making process is, therefore, multidimensional, involving both rational criteria and individual perceptions. The choice between different credit lines depends on the producer’s ability to interpret information and assess risks, being conditioned by the informational and institutional context (Gil, 2002; Dias, 2020).
In this sense, the producer’s level of knowledge directly influences the probability of contracting credit, while informational asymmetry can limit access to resources, even when they are available (Figueira, 2020; Gaspar et al., 2024). Trust in financial institutions also stands out as a determining factor, as it reduces uncertainties and favors credit adherence, especially in consolidated relationships (Souza and Mendes, 2020; Ribeiro et al., 2023). On the other hand, collateral requirements and excessive bureaucracy can restrict access, increasing indirect costs and hindering contracting, particularly for producers with less structure (Oliveira and Pereira, 2025; Silva and Pereira, 2023; Gaspar et al., 2024; Crepaldi, 2019). Additionally, the heterogeneity of the agricultural sector influences decision-making behavior, with small producers tending to rely more on credit and medium and large producers using it more strategically. The type of activity, production cycles, and prior experience, as well as technical and institutional support, also impact the decision (Bacha, 2012; Machado et al., 2024; Servo, 2019; Dias, 2020; Santos and Oliveira, 2022).
Given this scenario, the decision to hire rural credit is a result of the complex interaction between economic, institutional, and behavioral variables, which demonstrates that the mere availability of resources does not guarantee their effective use (Silva and Pereira, 2023; Wedekin, 2022). The perception that credit only partially meets productive needs indicates a significant gap between institutional supply and the operational reality of the field. This disparity suggests that, although public policies are comprehensive in normative terms, they still present limitations in their capacity to capture the structural diversity of the agricultural sector, compromising their effectiveness in meeting the specific demands of different productive profiles. The improvement of the rural credit system depends not only on the expansion of financial resources but also on the restructuring of its operational and informational mechanisms, requiring the development of more adaptable instruments that incorporate the regional, productive, and organizational specificities of the sector.
Therefore, this study aims to analyze the economic, institutional, and behavioral factors that influence the decision of rural producers in contracting rural credit, seeking to identify how knowledge, size, and product characteristics are crucial for the decision-making process and how this information can improve credit supply and financial education for producers.
2. Material and Methods
The research was characterized as applied, seeking to generate knowledge aimed at understanding concrete problems related to access, utilization, and institutional conditions of rural credit. This type of study has the potential to contribute to the improvement of public policies and financing strategies in the agricultural sector, according to Gil (2002). The applied nature was justified by the analysis of factors that influence producers’ decisions in contracting rural credit, based on empirical data.
Regarding the objectives, the study adopted a descriptive and exploratory character. The descriptive dimension focused on the identification and systematization of the institutional characteristics of rural credit lines, as well as on the characterization of the producers’ profile and their decision-making criteria. The exploratory character was justified by the need to deepen aspects that are little systematized in the literature, especially regarding the producers’ decision-making rationalities and the institutional barriers perceived in accessing rural credit (Gil, 2002).
The methodological approach employed was mixed-methods, combining qualitative and quantitative data. The qualitative dimension allowed for the understanding of subjective aspects of the decision-making process, such as risk perception, institutional trust, and the producer’s knowledge level. The quantitative dimension enabled the measurement of objective variables, such as interest rates, deadlines, and collateral requirements. The integration of these approaches followed Günther’s (2003) methodological perspective, aiming for a more comprehensive analysis of the investigated phenomenon.
The research design was structured in two complementary stages. In the preliminary phase, a qualitative analysis of normative and institutional documents regulating rural credit in Brazil was carried out. The Rural Credit Manual, the Safra Plan, resolutions from the National Monetary Council, circulars from the Central Bank of Brazil, as well as specific laws, decrees, and government programs were consulted (Brasil, 2023).
This first stage allowed the identification of operational criteria, financial conditions, and institutional requirements that structure the rural credit offering and the producers’ decision-making environment. The documentary analysis provided the basis for the development of the data collection instrument for the subsequent stage, ensuring that the questions addressed the relevant elements of the rural credit system.
In the second stage, of an empirical nature, a field study was developed with the collection of primary data from rural producers. The target population consisted of small and medium-sized rural producers, with direct participation in the financial decisions of the properties. The sample was non-probabilistic by convenience, composed of 64 respondents, defined based on accessibility and operational feasibility criteria.
Inclusion criteria considered were: engagement in rural activity for a minimum period of two years, direct participation in financial decisions, and previous experience or interest in contracting rural credit. As an exclusion criterion, individuals who do not participate in the property’s financial decisions were considered, ensuring that participants had direct involvement with the object of study.
The data collection instrument consisted of a structured questionnaire, developed based on specialized literature and the elements identified in the documentary analysis (Nogueira, 2002). The choice of the questionnaire was justified by its suitability for the standardized collection of information from a larger number of respondents, allowing for the measurement and comparison of variables relevant to the study.
The questionnaire consisted of closed-ended questions, Likert-type scales, and open-ended questions, allowing for the combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis. Its structure was organized into thematic blocks, covering: socioeconomic and productive characterization; experience with rural credit; economic and institutional factors; behavioral factors; and open-ended questions for qualitative deepening of perceptions.
Data collection was carried out in the municipality of Corbélia, located in the western region of Paraná, by applying the questionnaire on the Google Forms platform. Access to producers was facilitated with the support of a local private non-profit civil union association for rural production, which assisted in disseminating the research instrument, providing the link and QR Code for access during one of its quarterly meetings. The collected data were organized into a tabular database for subsequent analysis.
Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, including absolute and relative frequencies, means, and dispersion measures, such as standard deviation. This technique was chosen for its suitability for synthesizing and interpreting data from structured questionnaires, allowing for the clear and objective identification of patterns, trends, and relationships between the analyzed variables.
The qualitative data, from the open-ended questions, were analyzed through thematic categorization, according to the principles of content analysis (Sampaio and Lycariãao, 2021). This approach enabled the systematization of respondents’ perceptions, allowing for the identification of meaning patterns and complementing the quantitative analysis. The integration between quantitative and qualitative data was performed through triangulation, allowing for an expanded understanding of the investigated phenomenon and conferring greater consistency to the results (Günther, 2003).
The analysis of the results was structured in thematic blocks, in line with the organization of the data collection instrument, comprising: characterization of producers; access and use of rural credit; economic and institutional determinants; and behavioral factors. This organization contributed to greater coherence between the research stages and facilitated the integrated interpretation of the results.
The research followed the ethical principles established by Resolution No. 510/2016 of the National Health Council (Brazil, 2016), ensuring the anonymity of participants, the confidentiality of information, and the exclusive academic use of the collected data. As it concerns a public opinion survey with unidentified participants, the study was exempted from submission to the Research Ethics Committee (CEP), with the proper completion of the Ethical Considerations Form (ECF).
3. Results and Discussion
The analysis of the collected data revealed a detailed panorama of the factors influencing the decision of rural producers in hiring credit, highlighting the complexity of the decision-making process. Initially, a balanced distribution was observed between small and medium-sized producers, with 30 (46.9%) classified as small and 34 (53.1%) as medium. This structural heterogeneity of the Brazilian agribusiness sector, where different productive profiles coexist under the same institutional framework, emphasizes the need for differentiated financing and management approaches, as pointed out by Bacha (2012).
The educational profile of the producers indicated a predominance of high school education, with 59.4% of respondents, followed by higher education, with 28.1%, and elementary school, with 12.5%. This level of education can directly influence producers’ ability to interpret credit information and assess financial risks, as discussed by Figueira (2020). Such a configuration suggests the importance of technical assistance and rural extension instruments to mediate qualified access to credit, ensuring that contractual conditions are fully understood.
Regarding productive activities, the distribution was relatively homogeneous, with 34.4% of producers engaged in grains, 32.8% in livestock, and 32.8% in mixed activities. This scenario reinforces the need for credit policies that are flexible and adaptable to the specific demands of each segment, considering distinct production cycles, seasonality, and capital needs. Productive heterogeneity prevents a homogeneous analysis of rural credit, requiring consideration of the particularities of each profile to understand decision-making patterns (Servo, 2019).
The producers’ experience in the agricultural sector also proved to be a relevant factor. The average tenure of over 18 years indicates that most respondents have consolidated experience, which, according to Ribeiro et al. (2023), tends to reduce risk perception and increase the propensity to use formal financial instruments. This operational maturity of producers positively influences their relationship with the rural credit system, facilitating decision-making and the search for financing tailored to their needs.
Access and use of rural credit
Regarding access to and use of rural credit, the data revealed that 51 producers, corresponding to 79.7% of the sample, had already contracted this type of financing, while 13 (20.3%) had not used it. This finding underscores the centrality of rural credit as a fundamental pillar for the sustainability of agricultural activities in Brazil, especially in contexts of high dependence on working capital, as highlighted by Wedekin (2019). The high utilization rate demonstrates the intrinsic relevance of credit for the continuity and expansion of production in the countryside.
The frequency of rural credit contracting was also investigated, with 37 cases (57.8%) indicating annual use and 27 cases (42.2%) of occasional use. This recurrence, especially in cost financing operations, is directly associated with the maintenance of the rural properties’ production cycle, as pointed out by Borges and Parré (2022). The annual usage pattern suggests that credit is not perceived as a one-off tool, but rather as an integrated and essential component of the operational logic and financial planning of agricultural activities.
The most used credit modalities were operating costs, with 27 respondents (42.2%), and investment, with 26 (40.6%), in addition to 11 producers (17.2%) who use both modalities. This distribution highlights the coexistence of short- and long-term decisions among producers, reflecting different levels of production planning, as observed by Machado et al. (2024). The results indicate that producers not only finance current production but also seek to expand or modernize their activities, using credit as a strategic tool for the development of their properties.
The analysis of the most sought-after financial agents, although not detailed numerically in a table, revealed the strong presence of public banks and cooperatives. This predominance is consistent with the central role of these institutions in the operationalization of rural credit policies in Brazil, as indicated by the Central Bank of Brazil (2023). The lower participation of private banks, on the other hand, suggests the existence of market restrictions or a lower attractiveness of these operations outside the subsidized environment, which points to structural limitations in the rural financial system.
Economic determinants of the decision
Regarding the economic determinants of the credit contracting decision, the results indicated that interest rates, with an average of 4.5 and a deviation of 0.6, and payment terms, with an average of 4.6 and a deviation of 0.5, are the main factors considered by producers. This finding corroborates the centrality of classic economic variables in investment theory, where the cost of capital and the time horizon directly influence decision-making, as elucidated by Bacha (2012).
The strong influence of payment deadlines highlights the importance of compatibility between financing and the productive cycle of agricultural activities. This aspect is widely discussed in the literature, as by Vila Verde (2000), who emphasizes the relevance of adequate deadlines for the sector. In the agricultural context, financial returns are intrinsically conditioned by biological and climatic factors, making the flexibility and adequacy of deadlines a crucial element for the viability of operations and the producer’s security.
Despite the importance of favorable economic factors, the research also identified significant institutional barriers. Guarantee requirements averaged 4.2 with a deviation of 0.7, demonstrating that, although credit is widely used, these requirements condition its obtainment, limiting access, especially for smaller producers (Oliveira and Pereira, 2025). This factor reveals a persistence of requirements that may discourage or make contracting unfeasible for a portion of rural producers.
The bureaucracy of the hiring process also stood out as a significant limiting factor, with an average of 4.1 and a deviation of 0.8. This result corroborates studies that point to administrative hurdles as one of the main obstacles to rural credit, as indicated by Gaspar et al. (2024). The analysis of this data reveals a structural duality in the system: while credit is encouraged by relatively favorable economic conditions, its operationalization still faces institutional restrictions that hinder full and efficient access to resources.
Behavioral factors and financial decision
The analysis of behavioral factors revealed that knowledge about credit lines strongly influences producers’ decisions, with a mean of 4.3 and a deviation of 0.7. This result confirms the relevance of information as a strategic asset, suggesting that access to credit depends not only on objective conditions but also on the ability to understand and interpret institutional rules (Figueira, 2020). More informed producers tend to make more assertive decisions and to better seize financing opportunities.
Confidence in financial institutions also proved to be a determining factor, with an average of 4.2 and a deviation of 0.6. This aspect indicates that institutional relationships play a relevant role in mediating access to credit (Ribeiro et al., 2023). Confidence reduces uncertainties and favors credit adherence, especially when there is a consolidated relationship between the producer and the financial institution, which facilitates negotiation and the perception of security in long-term operations.
Previous experience with credit, with a mean of 4.3 and a standard deviation of 0.6, contributes to the reduction of perceived risk, in line with the financial learning theory applied to the behavior of rural producers (Dias, 2020). This result suggests that the continued use of credit tends to generate greater familiarity and security in the decision-making process, making producers more capable of managing their financing and identifying the best options available in the market.
Technical support emerges as one of the most relevant factors, with a mean of 4.5 and a deviation of 0.5, evidencing that the decision to contract credit is not purely financial, but is mediated by external agents, such as consultants and technical assistance institutions. This set of results reinforces the idea that the decision-making process is multidimensional, involving economic, institutional, and cognitive aspects, where specialized support can optimize resource utilization and mitigate risks.
Critical synthesis of the results
The answers to the open-ended questions reinforced that the main difficulties faced by producers are associated with guarantee requirements and bureaucracy. These perceptions confirm the patterns observed in the quantitative data and suggest that such barriers are not isolated, but structural, reflecting inherent limitations in the very institutional design of rural credit. Although conceived to expand access to financing, the system still operates under logics that restrict its effectiveness, especially for more vulnerable segments, such as small producers (Bacha, 2012).
The difficulty of accessing information also emerged as a relevant factor, especially among small producers, in line with behavioral results and the informational asymmetry discussed by Gaspar et al. (2024). This scenario highlights that the rural credit problem is not restricted to the dimension of resource supply, but significantly involves the capacity of economic agents to understand, interpret, and operationalize the available institutional conditions, reinforcing the role of information as a strategic element in the decision-making process.
Additionally, the perception that credit only partially meets productive needs indicates a gap between institutional supply and the operational reality of the field. This mismatch suggests that, although public policies are comprehensive in normative terms, they still have limitations in their capacity to capture the structural diversity of the agricultural sector, compromising their effectiveness in meeting the specific demands of different productive profiles.
In this context, the suggestions presented by the respondents converge on the need for relevant institutional adjustments. These include the simplification of bureaucratic processes, the flexibility of guarantee requirements, particularly for small producers, and the expansion of access to qualified information through continuous technical assistance. Such proposals indicate that the improvement of the rural credit system does not depend exclusively on the expansion of financial resources, but on the restructuring of its operational and informational mechanisms.
Therefore, the development of more adaptable credit instruments is recommended, capable of incorporating the regional, productive, and organizational specificities of the Brazilian agribusiness sector. This approach would allow a shift from a model centered on institutional standardization to a more responsive logic oriented towards the producers’ reality, making credit not only formally available but effectively accessible and functional within the productive context, contributing to the improvement of financial education and credit supply.
In summary, the results of this research demonstrate that the decision of rural producers to hire credit is a multifaceted process, influenced by a complex interaction of economic, institutional, and behavioral factors. Although rural credit functions as a productive incentive, its effectiveness is conditioned by operational and informational constraints. Overcoming these barriers, through bureaucratic simplification, flexible guarantees, and strengthening technical assistance and knowledge, is fundamental to expanding access and efficiency of agricultural financing, aligning credit supply with the needs and characteristics of producers.
4. Conclusion
This study analyzed the economic, institutional, and behavioral factors that influence the decision of rural producers to contract credit, seeking to understand how knowledge, size, and product characteristics are crucial for the decision-making process. It was found that rural credit is widely used by producers, predominantly for operating expenses and investment, highlighting its essential role in agribusiness. The findings indicated that economic variables, such as interest rates and payment terms, exert a strong influence on the decision. However, significant institutional barriers, such as collateral requirements and process bureaucracy, were observed to limit access to and effectiveness of credit, especially for smaller producers. Additionally, it was identified that behavioral factors, including knowledge about credit lines, trust in financial institutions, prior experience, and technical support, play a relevant role in mediating the contracting decision. This complex interaction of dimensions reveals that the decision-making process is multifaceted, going beyond mere financial analysis.
The main contribution of this work lies in the explicit identification of the gap between the institutional supply of rural credit and the operational reality of the field, suggesting that public policies, although comprehensive, do not yet fully capture the structural diversity of the agricultural sector. The study’s limitations, arising from the size and type of the sample, as well as data collection in a single municipality, restrict the generalization of the results, but do not compromise the analysis of decision-making patterns in the investigated context. For future studies, the development of more adaptable credit instruments is recommended, incorporating the regional, productive, and organizational specificities of producers. The improvement of the rural credit system, therefore, depends on the restructuring of its operational and informational mechanisms, with bureaucratic simplification, flexible guarantees, and strengthening of technical assistance and financial education, aiming to make credit effectively accessible and functional for the sector’s development.
Bibliographic References
Bacha, C. J. C. 2012. Economia e política agrícola no Brasil. 2.ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Banco Central Do Brasil. 2023. Crédito rural: manual de crédito rural (MCR). Banco Central do Brasil, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Borges, M. J.; Parré, J. L. 2022. O impacto do crédito rural no produto agropecuário brasileiro. Revista de Economia e Sociologia Rural 60 (2).
Crepaldi, S. A. 2019. Contabilidade Rural. Grupo GEN Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Dias, T. K. M. 2020. O crédito rural sob as perspectivas da posse da terra e da produtividade dos agricultores familiares. Dissertação (Mestrado em Economia Rural). Universidade Federal do Ceará, Fortaleza, CE, Brasil.
Figueira, S. R. F. 2020. Impactos dos preços e do crédito rural sobre a produção de cana-de-açúcar no estado de São Paulo. Revista de Economia e Sociologia Rural 58 (4): e186266.
Gaspar, A. S.; Silva, J. A. P.; Nascimento, T. A. 2024. Acesso ao crédito rural e seus impactos socioeconômicos para agricultores familiares de Cacoal, Rondônia. Revista Ibero-Americana de Humanidades, Ciências e Educação 10 (11): 6638–6652.
Gil, A. C. 2002. Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. 4.ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Günther, H. 2003. Como elaborar um questionário. Laboratório de Psicologia Ambiental – Universidade de Brasília, Brasília, DF,
Machado, B. S.; Neves, M. C. R.; Mattos, L. B. 2024. Determinantes do acesso a programas de financiamento de crédito rural no Brasil: uma análise a partir da PNAD 2014. Revista Econômica do Nordeste 55 (2): 27–46.
Oliveira, C. A.; Pereira, R. M. 2025. Inadimplência no crédito rural no Brasil: uma avaliação econométrica do impacto dos fatores macroeconômicos. Revista de Economia e Sociologia Rural 63: e292119.
Ribeiro, I. G. et al. 2023. Efeitos do crédito rural sobre a produção de soja na região do Matopiba. Revista de Economia e Agronegócio 21 (1).
Santos, D. O.; Oliveira, A. L. 2022. Crédito rural e comportamento do produtor: fatores que influenciam a tomada de decisão no campo. Revista de Economia e Sociologia Rural 60 (3): 1–17.
Servo, F. 2019. Evolução do crédito rural nos últimos anos-safra. Carta de Conjuntura 43 (2).
Silva, J. F.; Pereira, C. M. 2023. Determinantes do acesso ao crédito rural no Brasil: uma análise dos produtores familiares. Revista de Política Agrícola.
Souza, A.; Clemente, A. 2008. Decisões financeiras e análise de investimentos: fundamentos, técnicas e aplicações. 6.ed. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Souza, R. A.; Mendes, L. H. 2020. Tomada de decisão e gestão financeira no agronegócio: desafios e perspectivas. Inter Saberes, Curitiba, PR, Brasil.
Tavares, M. F. F. 2018. Introdução à gestão do agronegócio. 2.ed. SAGAH, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
Wedekin, I. 2022. Desafios da política agrícola brasileira. Revista Política Agrícola 31 (1).
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Agribusiness of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform