October 26, 2026
Economic and Productive Evaluation of Aquaculture Systems: Comparison between Net Cages and Excavated Tanks
Marco Antônio Uliano; Evaldo Alves Dos Santos
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601171
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
Aquaculture has consolidated itself in Brazilian agribusiness, demanding economic analyses for decision-making regarding production systems and risks. The study aimed to analyze and calculate the economic feasibility of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) aquaculture production systems, specifically net pens and excavated ponds, and their sensitivity to cost and price variations. The research, of an applied, quantitative, and comparative nature, was developed from a bibliographic, documentary, and primary data survey obtained from two properties in Mato Grosso do Sul. The fattening production cycle, lasting six to eight months, was considered. Implementation and operational costs, and revenue estimates were collected. The economic analysis used cash flows with a ten-year horizon and a minimum attractive rate of return of 10% per year, calculating financial indicators such as Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), Payback, and Profitability Index (PI). A sensitivity analysis was also performed to evaluate the financial robustness of the systems against market fluctuations. The results indicated that both systems presented economic feasibility, but the net pen system demonstrated superior performance, with an NPV of R$ 931,343.65, an IRR of 59.34%, and a simple payback of 1.67 years, evidencing greater efficiency in value generation and capital recovery. The excavated pond system, although feasible, presented inferior indicators and greater vulnerability to market variations. It was concluded that the net pen system presented itself as the most economically efficient alternative, but the choice of production system should also consider factors such as water resources and operational management.
Keywords: economic feasibility indicators; Fish farming; Excavated tanks; Net tanks; Tilapia.
1. Introduction
The Brazilian agribusiness has consolidated itself as one of the fundamental pillars of the national economy, contributing significantly to the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP). In 2024, for example, the sector represented 23.5% of the GDP, according to data from the Center for Advanced Studies in Applied Economics (CEPEA, 2025). Within this scenario of expressive growth, fish farming emerges as an activity of growing relevance, with a notable highlight for tilapia production (PEIXE BR, 2025).
The advancement of fish farming in Brazil is driven by a combination of favorable factors. The vast availability of water resources, the favorable climate for cultivation, the abundant production of grains that serve as inputs for feed, and the presence of feed factories contribute to the development and competitiveness of the sector (Kubitza, 2015). These elements attract investors and allow fish farming to offer high-quality protein at affordable prices, consolidating its position in the market.
In the productive sphere of fish farming, two systems stand out: the net-pen and the excavated pond. The net-pen system involves the installation of floating structures in rivers and lakes, where fish are confined. On the other hand, the excavated pond system consists of ponds built directly on the ground, requiring technical engineering planning to create an artificial environment suitable for fish production (Schulter; Vieira Filho, 2017).
The choice of the production method is a critical factor that directly influences productivity, profitability, and the risks associated with aquaculture (Kruger; Lalom; Gotardo, 2023). From an economic perspective, feasibility analysis makes it possible to identify which system guarantees the best financial return, considering all factors involved in an economic activity, such as initial investment, operational costs, revenues, and capital return (Souza; Souza, 2023; Elejalde, 2023). The selection of the production method seeks to optimize production at the lowest possible cost, always prioritizing the sustainability of the activity (Dantas et al., 2017; Ribeiro; Longhini; Santos, 2023).
Despite the growing relevance of fish farming, there is a gap in the availability of detailed technical and financial information that can assist fish farmers and investors in making strategic decisions. The lack of an in-depth comparison between net-pen and excavated pond systems hinders the clear identification of their economic advantages and limitations, especially in a scenario of fluctuating costs and market prices. Understanding how these different systems impact profitability is fundamental for the sustainable development of the sector.
In this context, this study is justified by the need to provide objective data and comparative analyses that fill this gap. By detailing the costs and returns of each system and evaluating their robustness against market fluctuations, the research aims to support decision-making, mitigate risks, and optimize resource allocation. Thus, the present study aims to analyze and calculate the economic feasibility of two Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) aquaculture production systems, specifically the net-pen and excavated pond systems, and to evaluate the sensitivity of these systems to variations in market costs and prices, providing objective parameters for costs and returns.
2. Material and Methods
The study was classified as applied research, quantitative and comparative in nature. The applied approach sought solutions for fish farming management, while the quantitative nature was based on the collection and analysis of numerical data on costs, productivity, and revenue. The comparative character focused on the analysis of two distinct production methods for Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) farming.
The investigation was developed through bibliographic and documentary research, complemented by primary data. Bibliographic research used scientific articles, books, dissertations, and technical reports from recognized institutions. Documentary research consulted information from institutional websites and sectoral databases, providing conceptual grounding and foundations on fish farming and economic feasibility analysis.
The unit of analysis consisted of two Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) aquaculture production systems: the net-pen system and the excavated tank system. Primary data collection occurred on two rural properties located in the municipalities of Aparecida do Taboado and Dourados, in the state of Mato Grosso do Sul.
The properties were selected based on the availability of organized and reliable information. Records of settlement, input control, feed and medication consumption, as well as detailed production data, were included. This selection aimed to ensure the reliability of the data for the economic and productive analysis of the systems.
The production cycle considered was the Nile tilapia grow-out, with an average duration of six to eight months per batch, until the fish reach a commercial weight between 700 g and 1 kg. Start-up costs were surveyed, covering infrastructure, equipment purchase, and initial labor. Operational costs, such as the acquisition of fingerlings, feed, electricity, maintenance, depreciation, and continuous labor, were also collected.
The consultation of cost and operational data was carried out directly with the producers of the mentioned properties. For the revenue estimation, the average selling price of tilapia was used as a reference, according to updated data from the Center for Advanced Studies in Applied Economics (CEPEA). All these elements were organized into financial spreadsheets, serving as the basis for comparative analysis.
The comparative economic analysis was structured using cash flow spreadsheets, with a ten-year horizon. A minimum attractive rate of return (MARR) of 10% per year was adopted, defined based on the average yield of pre-fixed Treasury Direct bonds. This MARR was used to evaluate the return on investment in relation to conservative financial investments.
Based on the cash flows and the WACC, the financial indicators were calculated: Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), Payback (simple and discounted), and Profitability Index (PI). The NPV was determined by the sum of the future discounted cash flows, subtracting the initial investment. The IRR was adjusted until the NPV was equal to zero, and the Payback estimated the investment recovery period.
The Excel software was used for the preparation of the cash flow spreadsheets and for the calculation of financial indicators. Complementarily, a sensitivity analysis was performed. This analysis evaluated the financial robustness of the systems against variations in feed costs and fish selling price, recalculating the economic indicators for different scenarios.
3. Results and Discussion
The economic analysis of Nile tilapia aquaculture production systems, specifically net cages and excavated ponds, revealed important distinctions in their economic feasibility and robustness against market scenarios. The evaluation was based on detailed premises for the construction of cash flows, covering implementation and operational costs, as well as revenue estimates. The results obtained were compared with a Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) of 10% per year, established based on the average yield of pre-fixed Treasury Direct securities, indicating the economic attractiveness of the investment. It is relevant to note that the analyses considered an equity investment, without the inclusion of financial expenses.
Productive and zootechnical data of the batches
The tilapia production batches selected for the analysis were sized to correspond to the volume of fish housed in both systems. In the net-tank system, 50,400 tilapia were housed, while in the excavated-tank system, the stocking was 50,000 fish. A mortality of 11.12% was observed in the net tanks and 5.40% in the excavated tanks. The final production in the cycle was 38,349 kg for net tanks and 40,820 kg for excavated tanks, with final average weights of 856 grams and 863 grams, respectively. The cycle duration was six months for net tanks, allowing two cycles per year, and seven months for excavated tanks, resulting in 1.71 annual cycles. The feed conversion ratio was 1.372 for net tanks and 1.409 for excavated tanks, with feed consumption of 49,848.88 kg and 54,697.24 kg, respectively.
The observed differences in productive and zootechnical data, such as mortality rate and feed conversion, demonstrated a significant impact on the final economic feasibility of the systems. Higher mortality in net cages, for example, implies direct losses in the final biomass sold and an increase in costs associated with fish acquisition and inputs consumed by these animals. On the other hand, feed conversion, which measures the efficiency with which fish gain weight relative to feed consumed, directly affects feed costs and the duration of production cycles. Batches with better feed conversion tend to have lower feed costs and shorter production cycles, optimizing profitability.
Initial investment required
The determination of implementation costs was carried out based on the productive structures and equipment necessary for each system, using primary data collected from the analyzed properties. For the net-cage system, the initial investment totaled R$ 345,300.20. The main items included 56 net cages of 9 m³ (R$ 179,200.00), an anchoring system (R$ 18,000.00), a 60 m² floating walkway (R$ 22,000.20), a 5-ton floating feed silo (R$ 22,000.00), a 10 m barge (R$ 50,000.00), a boat with a 15 HP engine (R$ 25,000.00), handling equipment (R$ 8,100.00), and costs for technical project, licenses, and miscellaneous fees (R$ 21,000.00). These investments were sized for a grow-out capacity of 50,400 tilapia, ensuring the stability and safety of the structures and the operationalization of daily management.
In the excavated tank system, the initial investment was significantly higher, totaling R$ 666,400.00. Costs were concentrated on the acquisition of 1.5 hectares of bare land (R$ 180,000.00), excavation of ponds and slopes in 12,500 m² (R$ 275,000.00), supply and drainage system (R$ 27,000.00), construction of three monk structures (R$ 24,600.00), and fencing of the production area (R$ 17,500.00). For water oxygenation, 18 2 HP fountain-type aerators were dimensioned (R$ 37,800.00), in addition to an electrical panel and cabling (R$ 10,000.00), a metal silo for feed (R$ 8,000.00), six automatic feeders (R$ 21,000.00), a 15 kVA diesel generator (R$ 28,000.00), two hydraulic pumps (R$ 9,000.00), handling equipment (R$ 6,500.00), and technical project, licenses, and miscellaneous fees (R$ 22,000.00). The production capacity was 50,000 tilapia, and the choice of some semi-new equipment was a strategy to reduce the initial investment without compromising production efficiency.
Fixed costs of the production cycle
Fixed costs, representing the minimum expenses necessary for the operation of production systems regardless of production volume, were surveyed for one production cycle. For the net-tank system, fixed costs totaled R$ 42,341.69, distributed among depreciation (R$ 20,126.68), insurance and taxes (R$ 8,000.00), and maintenance (R$ 14,215.01). In the excavated-tank system, fixed costs were R$ 49,355.63, with depreciation (R$ 23,315.63), insurance and taxes (R$ 7,500.00), and maintenance (R$ 18,540.00). The depreciation of structures and equipment was calculated based on the initial investment, while the values for insurance, taxes, and maintenance were obtained from the reality of the properties. The difference in fixed costs reflects the larger quantity of equipment and infrastructure required for oxygenation and water management in the excavated-tank system, resulting in higher depreciation and maintenance.
Variable costs of the production cycle
Variable costs, which change according to the production level and batch management, were detailed for each production cycle. In the net-tank system, variable costs totaled R$ 212,334.14, with the main components being the acquisition of fingerlings (R$ 18,224.83) and, predominantly, extruded feed (R$ 157,023.96), which represented the largest share of operational cost. Other costs included electricity (R$ 1,575.00) for support demands, fuel (R$ 12,558.00) for boat usage, operational labor (R$ 17,200.00) for handling and harvesting, and technical assistance (R$ 5,752.35). For the accommodation of 50,400 tilapia juveniles, 49,848.88 kg of feed were consumed.
For the excavated tank system, variable costs totaled R$ 230,542.96. The acquisition of fingerlings (R$ 18,080.19) and extruded feed (R$ 169,014.47) were also the most significant items. Additionally, expenses were recorded for virgin lime (R$ 4,000.00) and common salt (R$ 60.00) for the preparation and maintenance of water quality in the ponds. Electricity (R$ 11,113.50) primarily served to operate the aerators, essential for water oxygenation at high stocking densities. Fuel (R$ 9,315.00) was used for the diesel generator, crucial for energy contingency. Operational labor (R$ 22,000.00) and technical assistance (R$ 5,959.80) were also considered, totaling 50,000 fingerlings and 54,697.24 kg of feed consumed.
Annualized costs
From the identification of fixed and variable costs per production cycle, the consolidation of this information into an annualized cost structure was carried out, considering the average number of production cycles for each system. For the net cage system, which operates with two cycles per year, the annualized costs were: depreciation (R$ 40,253.33), insurance and taxes (R$ 16,000.00), maintenance (R$ 28,430.02), fingerlings (R$ 36,449.66), extruded feed (R$ 314,047.92), electricity (R$ 3,150.00), fuel (R$ 25,116.00), operational labor (R$ 34,400.00), and technical assistance (R$ 11,504.70), totaling R$ 489,851.63. For the excavated pond system, with 1.71 cycles per year, the annualized costs were: depreciation (R$ 37,305.00), insurance and taxes (R$ 12,857.14), maintenance (R$ 31,782.86), fingerlings (R$ 30,994.61), extruded feed (R$ 289,739.09), quicklime (R$ 6,857.14), common white salt (R$ 102.86), electricity (R$ 19,051.71), fuel (R$ 15,968.57), operational labor (R$ 37,714.29), and technical assistance (R$ 10,216.80), summing to R$ 451,026.14. This annualization allowed for a consistent comparison between the models and served as the basis for the cash-flow statement.
Revenue and Cash Flow
The revenue obtained from the sale of live tilapia was calculated based on annual production and the average selling price per kilogram, using data from the Center for Advanced Studies in Applied Economics (CEPEA) as of 12/05/2025 as a reference. The net cage system, with two annual production cycles of six months each, generated an annual revenue of R$ 715,745.74. The excavated tank system, with approximately 1.71 annual cycles of seven months each, generated an annual revenue of R$ 761,862.61. The cash flow was structured for a ten-year analysis horizon, considering the tax incidence under the Presumptive Profit regime, widely adopted by commercial aquaculture companies. The initial investment, allocated in period zero, corresponded to the project’s CAPEX, allowing for the identification of the capital recovery period and the comparison of economic performance between the systems.
Upon observing the accumulated discounted cash flow over the ten years, it was found that the net cage system presented a final Net Present Value (NPV) of R$ 931,343.65. On the other hand, the excavated tank system achieved an NPV of R$ 339,473.11. These values, which represent the sum of all future cash flows brought to present value and subtracted from the initial investment, indicate that both systems are economically viable, as they resulted in positive NPVs. However, the net cage system demonstrated a significantly greater capacity for value generation over the analysis period, surpassing the performance of the excavated tank system.
Economic indicators of production systems
The complementary economic indicators confirmed the feasibility of both systems, but highlighted the superiority of the net-tank system. For the net-tanks, the Net Present Value (NPV) was R$ 931,343.65, the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) reached 59.34%, the Simple Payback was 1.67 years, the Discounted Payback was 1.92 years, and the Profitability Index (PI) was 3.70. These results indicate a robust financial return and a quick recovery of the invested capital, with an IRR substantially higher than the Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) of 10% per year.
In contrast, the excavated tank system, although also viable, presented lower indicators. Its NPV was R$ 339,473.11, the IRR of 17.87%, the Simple Payback of 5.25 years, the Discounted Payback of 6.65 years, and the Profitability Index of 1.51. Although the IRR is still higher than the MARR, the investment return period is considerably longer, and the Profitability Index is lower, suggesting lower efficiency in generating value per unit of invested capital compared to the net tank system. The analysis of these indicators reinforces the greater economic attractiveness of the net tank system under the evaluated conditions.
Sensitivity analysis
To deepen the analysis and verify the financial robustness of the systems, a sensitivity analysis was performed, varying the feed cost and the selling price of tilapia at intervals of 10% and 20% more and less. In the net-cage system, a 20% reduction in feed cost resulted in an NPV of R$ 1,317,281.36 and an IRR of 77.84%, with a simple payback of 1.28 years. Even with a 20% increase in feed cost, the project maintained a positive NPV of R$ 545,405.95 and an IRR of 40.35%, with a simple payback of approximately 2.40 years. The Profitability Index remained above 1 in all scenarios, ranging from 4.81 to 2.58, demonstrating the net-cage system’s ability to remain attractive even in the face of significant cost increases.
The variation in the selling price of tilapia for the net-cage system showed an even greater impact on the indicators. In the scenario of a 20% reduction in selling price, the NPV was R$ 100,747.25 and the IRR reached 16.33%, with a simple payback estimated at 4.82 years. However, a 20% increase in selling price raised the NPV to R$ 1,761,940.06 and the IRR to 98.93%, reducing the investment recovery time to about 1.01 year. The Profitability Index followed this behavior, varying from 1.29 in the most unfavorable scenario to 6.10 in the most favorable one, confirming the high robustness of the net-cage system against market fluctuations.
For the excavated tank system, the sensitivity analysis revealed greater vulnerability. A 20% reduction in feed cost resulted in an NPV of R$ 652,123.38 and an IRR of 24.93%, with a simple payback of 4.39 years. However, a 20% increase in feed cost made the NPV negative at -R$ 60,005.13 and the IRR reduced to 8.57%, a value below the MARR, indicating that the investment would become unfeasible, as it would not be recovered considering the discounted cash flow. In scenarios of reduced tilapia selling price, the excavated tank system also proved unfeasible, with a negative NPV of -R$ 396,538.16 for a 20% reduction and -R$ 28,532.52 for a 10% reduction, resulting in a negative IRR or below the MARR.
With the increases in the marketing price, the excavated tank system showed significant improvement, with an NPV of R$ 707,478.75 and an IRR of 25.86% in the scenario of a 10% increase. When a 20% rise was considered, the NPV reached R$ 1,075,484.39 and the IRR reached 33.48%, reducing the simple payback to 2.69 years. These results indicate that economic efficiency is directly associated with the productive dynamics of each system. The higher productive intensity and the possibility of carrying out more cycles throughout the year in net tanks contribute to greater revenue generation and better utilization of invested resources. Furthermore, the lower implementation cost of the net tank system reduces the need for initial capital and accelerates the return on investment, making it more accessible and financially attractive.
On the other hand, the excavated tank system presents greater capital immobilization, which impacts its competitiveness, especially in less favorable market scenarios. From an operational and structural perspective, the excavated tank system can offer advantages, such as direct implementation on the property, reducing dependence on public water bodies and initial logistical complexity. However, this system requires the availability of water resources for water intake and obtaining the due environmental permits and licenses. Proximity to the production structure provides greater control over operations, facilitating the management and logistics of inputs, granting the producer greater autonomy. In regions where there are no suitable water bodies for net tanks, the excavated tank system may be the only viable alternative.
In summary, the research results indicate that both Nile tilapia production systems are economically viable under the analyzed conditions, with positive financial indicators. However, the net cage system demonstrated superior economic performance, characterized by a higher NPV and IRR and a significantly shorter payback period, in addition to greater robustness against cost and price fluctuations. The excavated pond system, although viable in the base scenario, proved more vulnerable to market variations, potentially becoming unviable in adverse scenarios of increased costs or reduced prices. Thus, the choice of production system should consider not only financial indicators but also factors such as water resource availability, operational management, and the specific conditions of the market and the property.
4. Conclusion
The present study aimed to analyze and calculate the economic feasibility of Nile tilapia aquaculture production systems, specifically net cages and excavated tanks, and their sensitivity to cost and price variations. It was found that both systems showed economic feasibility under the analyzed conditions, with positive financial indicators. However, the net cage system demonstrated superior economic performance, evidenced by a Net Present Value (NPV) of R$ 931,343.65, an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 59.34%, and a Simple Payback of 1.67 years. These results indicated greater efficiency in value generation and a faster recovery of invested capital, driven by the lower initial investment requirement and the possibility of carrying out two production cycles annually, optimizing resource utilization.
In contrast, the excavated tank system, although viable with a NPV of R$ 339,473.11 and an IRR of 17.87%, presented inferior indicators and a longer investment payback period of 5.25 years. Sensitivity analysis revealed that the tank-network system maintained its attractiveness even with significant variations in feed costs and tilapia selling prices. On the other hand, the excavated tank system proved more vulnerable, potentially becoming unfeasible in adverse scenarios of increased costs or reduced prices, due to higher capital immobilization and lower productive intensity. The main contribution of this study lies in providing objective cost and return parameters, supporting the strategic decision-making of fish farmers and investors. However, the choice of production system transcends financial indicators, and should consider factors such as water resource availability, operational management, and the specific conditions of the market and property. For future studies, it is recommended to deepen the market analysis and production absorption capacity, as well as to conduct evaluations at different production scales and regions, aiming to increase the reliability of the results and the scope of decision support in the aquaculture sector.
Bibliographic References
Cepea – Centro de Estudos Avançados em Economia Aplicada. 2025. PIB do Agronegócio Brasileiro. Piracicaba: ESALQ/USP. Disponível em: https://www.cepea.org.br/br/pib-do-agronegocio-brasileiro.aspx. Acesso em: 2 set. 2025.
Kruger, S. D.; Lopes, A. C.; Gotardo, R. 2023. Análise da viabilidade das atividades agrícolas desenvolvidas em uma propriedade rural. Extensão Rural, Santa Maria, v. 30, n. 1: 25-42. Disponível em: https://periodicos.ufsm.br/extensaorural/article/view/68647. Acesso em: 11 set. 2025.
Kubitza, F. 2015. Panorama da aquicultura: principais espécies, áreas de cultivo, rações, fatores limitantes e desafios. Revista Panorama da Aquicultura, Rio de Janeiro, n. 150: 10-11.
Peixe BR – Associação Brasileira da Piscicultura. 2025. Anuário Peixe BR 2025: panorama da piscicultura no Brasil. São Paulo: Associação Brasileira da Piscicultura, v. 1, n. 1: 1-120. Disponível em: https://peixebr.com.br/Anuario2025/AnuarioPeixeBR2025.pdf. Acesso em: 3 set. 2025.
Schulter, E. P.; Vieira Filho, J. E. R. 2017. Evolução da piscicultura no Brasil: diagnóstico e desenvolvimento da cadeia produtiva de tilápia. Rio de Janeiro: IPEA. Disponível em: https://portalantigo.ipea.gov.br/agencia/images/stories/PDFs/TDs/td_2328.pdf. Acesso em: 7 set. 2025.
Souza, M. C.; Moraes, R. F. 2023. Viabilidade econômica da pecuária de leite e da pecuária
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Agribusiness of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform