October 16, 2026
The difficulty in using the reporting channel in medium and large companies by employees
The Difficulty in Using the Whistleblowing Channel in Medium and Large Companies By Employees
Pamela Daiane da Rosa Siqueira; Tatiane Dutra Romana
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202603335
Article derived from a Course Conclusion Work (TCC), with content based on the student’s original work and adapted to the editorial format of the E&S Magazine with the support of the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by Instituto Pecege for textual synthesis and organization.
Summary
The strengthening of corporate governance in recent years has elevated the whistleblowing channel to a central role in preventing and detecting irregularities. However, its effectiveness is compromised by difficulties in its use by employees, such as fear of retaliation, disbelief in investigation, and anonymity. This study investigated the factors associated with employees’ difficulty in using the whistleblowing channel in medium and large-sized companies. A field survey was conducted with 41 participants, which revealed the behavior of these individuals in relation to the whistleblowing channel. The results indicated a significant percentage of non-utilization of the channel, mainly due to a lack of trust in the system, the perception that it was not anonymous, or simple distrust. A considerable portion of participants also did not receive adequate training on the channel. It was concluded that, for companies to achieve good results, it is essential to ensure effective training, periodic refreshers, and emphasize anonymity. The work contributes to the improvement of integrity programs, highlighting the need to strengthen communication and institutional trust.
Keywords: Anonymous; Whistleblowing Channels; Confidence; Survey; Training.
1. Introduction
The whistleblower channel consolidated itself as a relevant instrument in the United States in the 1970s, driven by a series of corporate frauds and scandals. This period marked a crucial turning point in ethical and democratic terms, as indicated by the National Library of Medicine (NIH, 2018). At that time, society began to question authorities more and value transparency. Although challenging authorities has always existed, it was from the 1960s and 1970s onwards that this demand intensified, motivated by social movements, investigative journalism, and major political scandals, such as the Watergate case and the Pentagon Papers (Scheuerman, 2014). In this context, whistleblowing was formalized as a legitimate practice, especially after Ralph Nader’s conference, consolidating itself as an instrument of transparency, social control, and democratic strengthening.
In Brazil, starting in 2014, there has been a notable growth in initiatives aimed at strengthening corporate ethics. This included the creation of codes of conduct, training sessions, internal communication actions, and the implementation of investigation processes and disciplinary measures. In this context, the whistleblowing channel stood out as one of the most effective mechanisms for detecting and monitoring irregularities, as pointed out by the Brazilian Institute of Corporate Governance (IBGC, 2021). The pursuit of transparency in contemporary times values the whistleblowing channel as a crucial instrument for institutional accountability (Brown et al., 2014).
Communication channels, also known as reporting channels, hotlines, or whistleblowing hotlines, can be understood as mechanisms or services intended for receiving reports. Their function is to connect different participants within the compliance system (Williams, 2023), serving as a means to collect information about irregular acts. Such acts are reported by current or former members of the organization and refer to illegal, immoral, or illegitimate practices occurring in the organizational environment, which may lead to actions with an effect on the reported object (Near and Miceli, 1995).
Despite the undeniable relevance of these channels, their effectiveness still faces significant difficulties in their use by employees. In many companies, even with the formal existence of a reporting channel, the volume of reports remains below expectations (Chen, 2018). This scenario reveals a mismatch between the formal structuring of compliance programs and the effective trust of employees in these instruments. Among the main factors contributing to this difficulty are the fear of retaliation, the perception of lack of anonymity, and disbelief in the investigation and actions taken by the company (Chen, 2018). In the context of compliance programs, the reporting channel is a structuring element, as Treviño and Nelson (2016) indicate, contributing to organizational integrity when associated with effective practices of governance, transparency, and accountability.
This research is justified by the need to deepen the understanding of the obstacles that prevent the full use of reporting channels, considering factors such as organizational culture, trust in the system’s confidentiality, and the perception of possible retaliation, in accordance with the General Data Protection Law (LGPD, 2018) for data collection. Thus, the work aimed to investigate the factors associated with employees’ difficulty in using the reporting channel in medium and large-sized companies.
2. Material and Methods
This research was characterized as descriptive, with a quantitative methodological approach, and was carried out through a field survey. This type of study sought to describe the characteristics of a specific phenomenon and its population, according to the guidelines of Gil (2008, 2017). The objective was to interpret facts of the organizational reality, focusing on the identification of possible relationships between the analyzed variables. The choice of the quantitative approach aimed at the interpretation and consolidation of the structured collected data.
The research strategy adopted was the field survey, known as survey, as recommended by Bigaton, Aline et al. (2024). This procedure involved formulating direct questions to participants, with the aim of understanding their behaviors and perceptions. The unit of analysis consisted of employees from medium and large-sized companies, randomly selected, who worked in organizations from various segments. The study focused on investigating the factors associated with the difficulty these employees had in using the whistleblowing channel.
The target population of the research comprised employees from medium and large-sized companies. For data collection, approximately forty-five participants were invited, holding positions such as analyst, supervisor, manager, and director. The participants worked in organizations from various segments, including certification bodies, technology companies, manufacturers, and financial institutions. Small and micro-enterprises were excluded from the sample, as it was considered that their processes and reduced staff numbers would not provide the necessary depth of detail for the study.
The data collection instrument used was an online questionnaire, developed and administered through the SurveyMonkey platform. This software allowed for the creation of a structured instrument, composed of eleven questions, two of which were structured and nine multiple-choice, according to the primary information questionnaire technique (Malhotra, 2004). The questions were formulated concisely and objectively, addressing aspects related to the whistleblowing channel in companies, as well as information about the respondents’ business segment, size, and organizational structure.
The data collection procedures began with the application of a pre-test on September 12, 2025, involving ten participants. The objective was to verify the clarity of the questions and the adequacy of the response time, which was one minute and forty seconds. After adjustments, including the addition of response options such as “not applicable” and “others”, the final version of the questionnaire was made available. The instrument was sent to the participants via an electronic link and remained accessible for responses throughout December 2025.
After collection, the data were organized and submitted to quantitative analysis. The sample was segmented based on company size and participant positions, prioritizing medium and large organizations to deepen the understanding of the data. The quantitative analysis aimed to interpret and consolidate the collected information, seeking to identify patterns and relationships between the studied variables, without, however, presenting empirical findings in this section.
Ethical considerations were rigorously observed during all stages of the research. Responses were collected anonymously, and the confidentiality of participants’ personal data was fully guaranteed. At no time were company or individual names used, which obviated the need for approval by an ethics committee. The treatment of the collected information occurred in strict compliance with the General Data Protection Law (LGPD, Law No. 13.709/2018), ensuring participant consent.
Despite the application of the described procedures, a limitation related to the sample size was recognized, which was influenced by the time available for obtaining responses. Additionally, the investigation focused on the use of the reporting channel and the perception of its efficiency, without delving into the analysis of how the reports were described, due to the unavailability of sufficient information for such detail within the scope of the study.
3. Results and Discussion
This section of Results and Discussion details the research findings, seeking to interpret the data collected through the field survey and connect them to the objective of investigating the factors associated with employees’ difficulty in using the whistleblowing channel in medium and large-sized companies. The analysis focused on the responses of forty-one participants, excluding micro and small enterprises, to ensure greater relevance of the data for the studied organizational context. This approach allowed for a deeper understanding of the dynamics present in more complex corporate structures, where communication and trust challenges tend to be more pronounced, as indicated by the literature on corporate governance.
The research sample was composed of respondents from medium and large-sized companies, with 64.44% of participants linked to large or multinational organizations and 26.67% to medium-sized companies. This segmentation is crucial because, as pointed out by Gil (2008), sampling in social research allows for direct knowledge of the investigated reality, with the advantage of quantifying data. The diversity of company segments, which included information technology, services, auditing, automotive, and legal, among others, demonstrated that the difficulty in using the whistleblowing channel is not restricted to a specific sector but is a transversal challenge in organizations with more complex hierarchical structures, where the distance between senior management and operational employees can hinder the construction of a trusting environment, a fundamental aspect for the channel’s effectiveness.
Regarding the participants’ profiles, the analysis of job roles revealed that the majority of respondents were analysts, representing 43.90% of the sample, followed by managers with 26.83%. Supervisors and directors represented 7.32% and 4.88%, respectively, while 17.07% fell into the “Others” category. This distribution is significant because, as observed by the SciELO (2021) survey, the perception of operational employees is essential for identifying flaws in internal processes, and an analysis restricted to management may not be sufficient to understand the real functioning of organizations. Directors and managers, being more involved in the implementation of integrity programs, tend to be more familiar with the channel, while analysts, with more superficial contact, offer a valuable perspective on the channel’s effectiveness at all organizational levels.
The research revealed that 92.50% of participants were aware of the existence of a whistleblowing or compliance channel in their companies. This initial data suggests that the formalization of the instrument is present in most of the organizations studied. However, the mere existence of the channel does not guarantee its effectiveness, as highlighted by Chen (2018), who points to a mismatch between the formal structuring of compliance programs and the effective trust of employees. The high percentage of knowledge about the channel, therefore, does not automatically translate into its full utilization, indicating that other factors, beyond simple availability, influence employees’ decisions to report irregularities.
One of the most relevant findings was the identification of gaps in training on the whistleblowing channel. It was found that 24.39% of respondents did not receive any training on the subject. Detailing this information by hierarchical level, it was observed that, among the 13 managers and directors in the sample, two did not receive training, while among the 25 analysts, supervisors, and other positions, eleven were not adequately trained. This disparity highlights a more pronounced awareness problem at the operational and tactical levels, suggesting that communication and training on the channel are not reaching all employees homogeneously, which may compromise the perception of its importance and functionality, according to the literature on the dissemination of integrity programs.
The analysis of the objectivity and clarity of the trainings received also brought important insights. Although 60.98% of participants stated that the training was clear and objective, a considerable portion of 26.83% reported failures in the training process, and 12.20% could not inform. These results indicate that, even when training is offered, its quality and effectiveness may be insufficient, hindering the understanding of the correct use of the channel and the available access methods. The literature, such as the study by Botha and Van der Merwe (2025), emphasizes that evaluating the effectiveness of compliance trainings is still a challenge, and measuring their practical impact on employee behavior is limited, which corroborates the need to improve training approaches.
Use of Whistleblowing Channel
The investigation into the effective use of the whistleblowing channel revealed an alarming fact: only 7.32% of participants (three individuals) reported having ever used the channel, while 90.24% (thirty-seven individuals) never used it. This low usage rate is a critical indicator of the instrument’s perceived ineffectiveness, despite its formal existence in most companies. The reduced utilization suggests that, although organizations invest in implementing these channels, employee trust and perceived security remain significant barriers, directly impacting the channel’s ability to fulfill its role in detecting and preventing irregularities, according to Near and Miceli’s (1992) perspective on the importance of whistleblower protection.
When delving into the reasons for not using the channel, the research identified that 53.66% of respondents stated they had no situations that needed to be reported. Although this may seem like a positive aspect, literature suggests that a low perception of irregularities may be linked to a lack of knowledge about what constitutes a report or disbelief in the channel’s effectiveness. However, the options “simply do not trust” (24.39%) and “do not trust the channel, as it is not anonymous” (12.20%) accounted for 36.59% of the responses, highlighting a significant lack of trust in the system. This distrust, whether due to the perception of a lack of anonymity or for unspecified reasons, represents a substantial obstacle to the full utilization of the channel, aligning with Chen’s (2018) findings on the fear of retaliation and disbelief in the investigation.
The analysis of factors contributing to the lack of confidence in the reporting channel allowed for the identification of three main situations. The perception that the channel “is not anonymous” was pointed out by 12.19% of respondents, while the absence of training represented 24.39% and ineffective training, 26.83%. These data, although originating from different questions, converge on the idea that a lack of clarity about the channel’s functioning, the absence of adequate training, and uncertainty regarding confidentiality are interconnected elements that undermine employee confidence. The guarantee of anonymity and protection against retaliation are, in fact, crucial aspects for the channel’s effectiveness, as emphasized by Hernandes (2024), who highlights the need for mechanisms that ensure the whistleblower’s safety.
The ineffectiveness of training, which manifests in both absence and lack of clarity, directly contributes to employees’ difficulty in understanding communication methods, record-keeping procedures, and the types of situations reportable. This knowledge gap can lead to the submission of inadequate reports or the underutilization of the channel for issues that should be reported. The importance of adequate training and periodic refreshers, preferably annual, is reinforced by Sousa et al. (2024), who suggest that the mere existence of a channel does not guarantee its use, with clear communication and training for managers and employees being fundamental. The provision of informative materials, such as brochures, can also complement communication, ensuring that guidelines on accessing and using the channel are widely disseminated.
Regarding the few cases of channel usage, one of the three participants used it to suggest “improvements in the company”. This use, although positive for the organization, demonstrates a training failure, as the reporting channel is primarily intended for reporting irregularities, not for collecting suggestions, which would be more suitable for other internal communication channels. The other two participants used the channel to report cases of “abuse and harassment”, which is in line with the instrument’s purpose. However, the analysis of the feedback received by these whistleblowers revealed another significant fragility of the system.
The issue of feedback was particularly revealing. Of the two cases of reports of “abuse and harassment”, only one received a response from the organization, resulting in 50% absence of feedback. In the case of the report of “improvements in the company”, the participant received no response, totaling 100% lack of feedback. This absence of response or adequate attention from the company is a critical factor that undermines trust in the channel. International guidelines, such as ISO 37001 (Anti-bribery) and ISO 37301 (Compliance) standards, recognize the importance of bidirectional communication mechanisms capable of clarifying facts and ensuring investigation. The lack of feedback can generate disbelief in the investigation, internal conflicts, and potentially lead to external reports, damaging the entity’s reputation, as pointed out by Lavor (2024) and Silva et al. (2020) regarding the dependence of belief in the channel on the adequate treatment of reports.
The findings of this study corroborate the literature that highlights the influence of factors such as whistleblower protection, organizational culture, risk of retaliation, and trust in the reporting system on the decision to report irregularities (Near and Miceli, 1992). The low utilization of the channel, lack of trust in anonymity, and deficiencies in training are significant barriers that prevent the full effectiveness of the reporting channel. Although most participants have not experienced situations that required reporting, this perception may be linked to a lack of knowledge about what constitutes an irregularity or to disbelief in the channel itself, highlighting the need to strengthen organizational culture and trust in the system through more robust and practical training.
In summary, the research demonstrated that, despite the formalization of the whistleblowing channel in medium and large-sized companies, its effectiveness is compromised by a combination of factors. Low utilization of the channel, the perception of lack of anonymity, and general distrust in the system, added to deficiencies in training and communication, create an environment where employees feel insecure or uninformed to use it. For the channel to fulfill its role as an integrity instrument, it is fundamental that organizations invest in continuous and effective training, reinforce the guarantee of anonymity and protection against retaliation, and establish transparent investigation and feedback processes, thus responding to the objective of mitigating usage difficulties and strengthening corporate governance.
4. Conclusion
This study investigated the factors associated with employees’ difficulty in using the whistleblowing channel in medium and large-sized companies. It was found that, although the majority of participants were aware of the channel’s existence, its effective use was significantly low. The main barrier to using the channel was identified as the perception of a lack of anonymity and general distrust in the system, aspects that undermine employees’ security in reporting irregularities. Furthermore, it was observed that a considerable portion of respondents did not receive adequate training on the channel, or considered the training received to be ineffective, which compromised their understanding of its purpose and access methods. The absence of feedback after making reports was also a critical factor that contributed to disbelief in the investigation and the actions taken by the organizations.
The main contribution of this work lies in the improvement of integrity programs, by highlighting the need to strengthen institutional communication and trust. For the whistleblowing channel to fulfill its role in preventing and detecting irregularities, it is essential that companies invest in continuous and effective training, reinforce the guarantee of anonymity and protection against retaliation, and establish transparent processes for investigation and feedback. As a limitation, the sample size is noteworthy, which, due to the limited time for data collection, was reduced. It is suggested for future studies to deepen the investigation into employees’ fears of reprisal and explore the types of reports made, as well as to detail the effectiveness of training, questioning the modality and the performance of post-training evaluations.
Bibliographic References
Bigaton, Aline et al. 2024. Metodologias de Pesquisa para Trabalhos de Conclusão de Curso. Editora PECEGE, Piracicaba, São Paulo, Brasil.
BROWN, A. J.; VANDEKERCKHOVE, W.; DREYFUS, S. 2014. Research Handbook on Transparency. 1ed. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, United Kingdom.
Chen, C. 2018. Internal Whistleblowing and Underreporting: A Literature Review. Journal of Service Science and Management 11(4): 364-378.
Gil, A. C. 2008. Métodos e Técnicas de Pesquisa Social. 6ed Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Gil, A. C. 2017. Como elaborar Projetos de Pesquisa. 6ed. Gen Atlas, São Pualo, SP, Brasil.
Instituto Brasileiro de Governança Corporativa [IBGC]. 2021. O protagonismo do canal de denúncias na promoção da ética corporativa. Disponível em: <https://www.ibgc.org.br/blog/artigo-camila-araujo-ticiana-chicourel-canal-de-denuncias>. Acesso em: 21 Set 2025.
Malhotra, N. K. 2004. Pesquisa de Marketing: uma aplicação orientada. 3ed. Bookman, Porto Alegre, RS, Brasil.
National Library of Medice [NIH] (2018). Understanding the knowledge gaps in whistleblowing and speaking up in health care: narrative reviews of the research literature and formal inquiries, a legal analysis and stakeholder interviews – Chapter 2, The conceptual underpinnings of whistleblowing. Disponivel em: < https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519622/> Acesso em 14 de Outubro 2025.
Near, J. P.; Miceli, M. P. (1992). Blowing the whistle: The organizational and legal implications for companies and employees. 1ed. Lexington Books, Nova York, NY, USA.
Presidência da República Federativa do Brasil. 2018. Lei nº 13709 de 14 de agosto de 2018 – Lei Geral de Proteção de Dados Pessoais (LGPD). Diário oficial da União, Brasília, 15, Agosto, 2018. Seção 1, p.59.
Scheuerman, W. E. 2014. Whistleblowing as civil disobedience: The case of Edward Snowden. Philosophy & Social Criticism 40(7): 609-628.
Scielo Brasil.2021. O processo de organizacional interna:um estudo realizado em uma Associação Comercial e Empresarial do Paraná. Diseponivel em: < https://doi.org/10.15
Treviño, L.K.;Nelson, K.A .2016. Managing business ethics: Straight talk about how to do it right. 6ed. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey, USA. Disponivel em: <oreilly.com>. Acesso em: 20 jan 2026.
Williams, 2023 [Full reference not found in the original document]
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in Compliance and ESG of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform