October 26, 2026
The compatibility between occupational well-being and institutional productivity: the effects of people management for the servants of the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia
Murilo Patrick Cerqueira Guedes Tramontini; SEM ORIENTADOR
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-202601245
Article prepared by the ResumeAI tool, an artificial intelligence solution developed by the Pecege Institute focused on synthesis and writing.
Summary
The research analyzed people management at the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA), focusing on the dichotomy between institutional productivity and the occupational well-being of the staff. The general objective was to evaluate the effects of productivity policies on the workforce, investigating whether the goal-oriented management model, under the aegis of the managing judge and awards such as the National Council of Justice (CNJ) Diamond Seal, was capable of reconciling quantitative efficiency with mental health. Methodologically, the study adopted a mixed approach, combining qualitative and quantitative methods, and was based on a literature review, analysis of recent judicial decrees (2024-2026), and data from “Justiça em Números” (2023-2025). The results indicated that statistical success coexists with high rates of mental disorders among the staff, demonstrating that institutional efficiency, as measured, ignored the biopsychosocial costs of production and focused on short-term results, compromising the longevity of the workforce. It was concluded that people management at TJBA has not been able to sustainably reconcile productivity and well-being, and that institutional efficiency should be conditioned to the viability of a “Mental Health Seal” to ensure the sustainability of the judicial system.
Keywords: Occupational well-being; Managing Judge; Quality of Work Life; Mental Health Seal; TJBA.
1. Introduction
The Brazilian Judiciary has undergone a continuous process of administrative modernization, driven by institutional strategies aimed at improving judicial services. The creation of the National Council of Justice (CNJ), through Constitutional Amendment No. 45, in 2004, was a fundamental milestone, consolidating national policies for planning, productivity, and performance monitoring. This scenario led the Judiciary to adopt management models oriented by goals, indicators, and comparative rankings, altering the way work is evaluated.
In this context, the evaluation of the work of magistrates and clerks transcended the legal-procedural perspective, coming to be measured by administrative parameters of institutional efficiency. However, Sekunda and Junior (2022) point out that traditional efficiency indicators tend to favor quantitative results, such as the volume of cases and processing time, without necessarily capturing the organizational and human complexity involved in judicial activity. This perspective is crucial for understanding the concrete working conditions.
Efficiency and productivity, although close, are not equivalent, especially when dissociated from labor conditions. Freitas and Odelius (2021) show that the design of work within the judicial sphere, characterized by a high cognitive load, pressure for results, and low decision-making autonomy, directly impacts servers’ perceptions of control, recognition, and exhaustion. Furthermore, Batista and de Figueiredo (2021) highlight that leadership in the Judiciary, often exercised by magistrates without management training, assumes a strategic role in leading teams and in conflict management.
In the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA), aligned with national guidelines, internal norms for administrative modernization, strategic management, and addressing organizational moral harassment were established, such as Resolution n. 09/2025 of the TJBA itself. Despite these initiatives, data from Nascimento et al. (2024) reveal the persistence of leaves of absence due to psychological illness, hierarchical conflicts, and functional overload, evidencing the practical limits in implementing these policies. The functioning of the Judiciary depends directly on the performance of the court officials, who are the basis of daily execution (Pozzi, 2023; Freitas and Odelius, 2018).
Technological modernization, with the implementation of the electronic process (PJe), for example, has increased the degree of functional responsibility of public servants, who are now accountable not only for the material practice of acts but also for the correct input of data into systems and compliance with electronically controlled deadlines (Cardoso and Godinho, 2025; Batista and Figueiredo, 2021). This intensification of work, combined with the emphasis on the principle of efficiency, has led public administration to adopt more rigorous planning and performance evaluation mechanisms, with the CNJ establishing national goals for the entire Judiciary starting in 2009 (Kim and Silva, 2020).
Quality of Work Life (QWL) and organizational climate are essential guiding concepts for this discussion. Muniz (2024) and Kilimnik (2006) emphasize that QWL depends on adequate leadership and people management practices, while organizational climate reflects the collective perception of leadership, communication, and recognition. The pressure for productivity, often perceived as “natural” (Pozzi, 2023), ends up having an intense impact on employees, who do not hold decision-making power but are directly responsible for daily deliveries.
Faced with this scenario, the central problem of this research arises: in what way has people management within the Judiciary, and specifically in the TJBA, been able to reconcile the pursuit of productivity with the preservation of the occupational well-being of court officials? The hegemony of statistical indicators, such as those that guide the CNJ’s Diamond Seal, tends to make Quality of Work Life a peripheral factor, resulting in occupational illness, according to the hypothesis that guides this study.
The practical and theoretical gap lies in the fact that the current managerial model operates in a data vacuum regarding occupational well-being, where what is not quantified by the CNJ metrics becomes strategically invisible to senior management (Mello; Wander, 2024). This approach, which prioritizes procedural flow over the individual, generates a disconnect between institutional prestige and the biopsychosocial exhaustion of the base, as evidenced by the high rates of leave due to mental disorders (F41, F32, F33) among TJBA servers (CNJ, 2024; Nascimento et al., 2024).
The justification for this investigation lies in the pressing need to humanize Public Administration in the face of growing pressure for results, ensuring the sustainability of the judicial system. Statistical success, although commendable, coexists with high rates of mental disorders, indicating that institutional efficiency must be conditioned by the viability of a “Mental Health Seal”. Thus, the general objective of the present work is to analyze how people management can act as an element of compatibility between occupational well-being and institutional productivity within the scope of the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia.
2. Material and Methods
This research was characterized by a mixed methodological approach, combining qualitative and quantitative elements. This choice was based on the premise that the complex relationship between institutional productivity and occupational well-being in the Judiciary requires a multifaceted understanding. Regarding its nature, the study was classified as applied, aimed at analyzing a concrete institutional problem at the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA). In relation to its objectives, the research was exploratory and descriptive, seeking to deepen the understanding of a contemporary phenomenon and identify the characteristics and tensions inherent in people management in the investigated context.
The development of the study was structured in three complementary methodological axes. Firstly, a bibliographic survey was carried out, focused on the examination of specialized literature pertinent to the theme. Secondly, a normative-institutional analysis was carried out, dedicated to the regulatory framework and the administrative organization of the Judiciary. Finally, an analytical-interpretive axis was adopted, which consisted of a critical reading and triangulation of the collected data and documents.
The literature review was conducted in the CAPES and SciELO databases. For the search, the keywords “people management in the Judiciary”, “quality of work life”, “institutional productivity” and “TJBA” were used. A predominantly contemporary temporal scope was established, covering the period from 2020 to 2026, with a special focus on academic production published between 2024 and 2026. Works prior to this period, such as those by Cardoso and Godinho (2015) and Kilimnik (2006), were exceptionally included to contextualize the evolution of discussions on the topic.
On the normative-institutional axis, the regulatory framework governing people management in the Brazilian Judiciary was analyzed. Significant changes driven by Constitutional Amendment No. 45, of 2004 (BRASIL, 2004), which created the National Council of Justice (CNJ), were examined. Highlighted were CNJ Resolution No. 240, of 2016 (CONSELHO NACIONAL DE JUSTIÇA, 2016), which establishes the National People Management Policy, CNJ Resolution No. 102, of 2009 (CONSELHO NACIONAL DE JUSTIÇA, 2009), on administrative transparency, and CNJ Provision No. 156, of 2023 (CONSELHO NACIONAL DE JUSTIÇA, 2023).
Specifically at the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA), a triangulation of institutional documents and recent administrative acts was carried out. This included the TJBA Management Plan for the 2024-2026 and 2026-2028 biennia (BAHIA, 2024), the 100-day Report (BAHIA, 2024), Judicial Decree No. 150 of 2026 (BAHIA, 2026), and Decree No. 167 of 2024 (BAHIA, 2024). For a critical comparison, performance indicators associated with the Diamond Seal, as well as technical notes and inquiries from the OAB-BA (2025) and the trade unions SINTAJ (2024-2026) and SINPOJUD (2024-2026) were analyzed.
The research unit of analysis focused on the court staff linked to the TJBA, excluding the judiciary. This delimitation was justified by the more direct submission of the servers to administrative routines, internal control policies, and the fulfillment of institutional goals. The functional structure of the TJBA, according to data from the Human Resources Secretariat (TJBA, 2025), was composed of 7,655 permanent positions on December 31, 2025, including analysts and judicial technicians, in addition to specialized support functions.
For the collection of data on occupational well-being, statistical data related to occupational health were used, focusing on diseases classified in Group F of the ICD-10. This information was obtained through a survey on the institutional portal of the National Council of Justice (CNJ), specifically on the Dashboard for Monitoring the Comprehensive Health Care Policy for Magistrates and Public Servants of the Judiciary. A selection was made for the year 2024, covering the State Justice system and, in particular, the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia, with access on March 31, 2026. Complementarily, data on employee absenteeism due to illness in the state justice system for the year 2023 were consulted, as systematized by Nascimento et al. (2024).
The analysis of the collected data and documents was carried out through an analytical-interpretive approach. A critical reading of the information was performed, seeking to confront institutional performance indicators, such as those related to the Diamond Seal, with the occupational health data of the court officials. This confrontation aimed to verify whether the goal-based management model, adopted in the Brazilian Judiciary, considered occupational well-being parameters and whether formal efficiency aligned with the biopsychosocial reality of the functional body.
3. Results and Discussion
The administrative modernization of the Brazilian Judiciary, although it has brought greater transparency and speed to procedural flows, has established a management model that operates under a predominantly quantitative logic. The analysis of the scenario at the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA) revealed that the pursuit of excellence seals and productivity rankings has created a high-pressure environment, where institutional efficiency is measured by the volume of case closures, often at the expense of the occupational health of the court staff. This phenomenon highlights a disconnect between the prestige of the awards achieved by the administrative leadership and the real well-being of the functional base, demanding a critical reassessment of the human limits of jurisdictional production.
In this context, the study resumed the challenge of reconciling institutional productivity with occupational well-being within the TJBA, investigating the effects of this managerial model on the court officers. The research problem sought to verify whether the current performance targets policy of the National Council of Justice (CNJ) allows for balanced management, a hypothesis that was overcome upon identifying that efficiency is treated as a hegemonic criterion that renders Quality of Work Life (QWL) invisible. The analyses demonstrated that the current incentive system prioritizes statistical output, often under the guidance of a manager judge focused on the strict fulfillment of indicators, treating the staff as an extensible resource devoid of mental health indicators in official reports.
The work in the Judiciary and the condition of the servant of the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia: quality of work life, hierarchy and organizational climate
The functioning of the Judiciary depends on a human structure that goes far beyond the figure of the magistrate, being sustained by a set of civil servants responsible for the daily execution of jurisdictional activity. In practice, the progress of cases, the holding of hearings, the fulfillment of orders, and the service to the parties depend directly on the performance of court officials. For this reason, understanding the nuances of these civil servants’ work, as well as the conditions under which it is performed, becomes fundamental for any analysis involving People Management in a Court of Justice (Pozzi, 2023; Freitas and Odelius, 2018).
The technological modernization of the Judiciary, with the implementation of the electronic process (PJe), has significantly altered the way tasks are executed, but has not reduced the complexity of the work performed by civil servants. On the contrary, the computerization of judicial activity has increased the degree of functional responsibility, as civil servants are now responsible not only for the material execution of acts, but also for the correct input of data into the systems and for compliance with electronically controlled deadlines (Cardoso and Godinho, 2025; Batista and Figueiredo, 2021). This intensification of work requires constant adaptation and raises the level of functional responsibility.
The emphasis on the principle of efficiency, provided for in art. 37 of the Federal Constitution (Brazil, 1988), led public administration to adopt more rigorous mechanisms for planning, performance evaluation, and productivity monitoring. This movement intensified after the creation of the CNJ by Constitutional Amendment No. 45/2004, which began to exercise a relevant function of administrative control, strategic planning, and institutional coordination within the Judiciary (Lenza, 2024). Starting in 2009, the CNJ established national goals, promoting the consolidation of strategic planning in the courts and reinforcing the adoption of management practices focused on institutional efficiency, known as the “Diamond, Gold, and Silver Seals” (Kim and Silva, 2020).
The TJBA’s functional structure is not limited to a single category of servers, but is organized from a plural set of positions and functions, which requires a more careful analysis of working conditions. Law No. 10.845/2007 provides for several positions linked to jurisdictional activity, including technicians, analysts, bailiffs, advisors, and unit heads (Bahia, 2007). Data from the TJBA’s Human Resources Secretariat, as of December 31, 2025, indicate an effective staff of 7,655 positions, with 4,065 judicial analysts and 3,590 judicial technicians, highlighting the dimension and complexity of people management (TJBA, 2025).
In this scenario, commissioned positions and gratified functions, common in offices and secretariats, tend to concentrate greater responsibility and pressure for results, as they are linked to performance and the immediate superior’s trust (Batista and De Figueiredo, 2021). The demand for productivity comes to be perceived as “something natural” in the institutional environment, especially when remaining in the position depends on the performance presented (Pozzi, 2023). This dynamic reinforces the pressure on civil servants, who, although they do not hold decision-making power, are directly responsible for daily deliveries.
The magistrate holds a distinct position, exercising not only the jurisdictional function but also the responsibility for the administrative management of the unit, acting as head of the office or court (Freitas and Odelius, 2021). However, this management function, performed by professionals trained in Law and not in administration, can generate difficulties in team leadership and in the organization of the work environment (Batista and De Figueiredo, 2021; Silva and Arena Filho, 2020). Quality of work life (QWL) and organizational climate, essential concepts for People Management, depend on adequate leadership and administration practices, reflecting the collective perception of leadership, communication, and recognition (Muniz, 2024; Kilimnik, 2006).
People management at TJBA between biennia: between proactive interventions by the Court and institutional criticisms of the staff’s people management
The management of the TJBA unfolds between successive mandates, with distinct administrative inflections on the promotion of magistrates, definition of priorities, and dialogue with the court’s careers. In the 2024–2026 biennium, the presidency was held by Judge Cynthia Maria Pina Resende; in the 2026–2028 biennium, the administration passed to Judge José Edivaldo Rocha Rotondano. This alternation of administrative guidelines can destabilize the logic of predictability and the expectations of civil servants, regardless of whether the change is positive or negative.
The literature produced about a decade ago already indicated that the problems of work organization and institutional climate in the Bahian Judiciary were not new (Kilimnik, 2006). Previous research identified that workers’ perception of leadership, recognition, and working conditions directly interfered with the quality of the organizational environment (Nunes, 2015). Furthermore, the computerization and reconfiguration of decision-making flows demanded a new form of work organization, and technological modernization alone did not resolve administrative and human difficulties (Cardoso and Godinho, 2015).
When these old diagnoses are compared with the most recent literature, one perceives the persistence of problems with new guises. Socio-labor factors, power relations, and organizational demands continue to influence workers’ mental health (Freitas Júnior e Barbosa, 2022). The transformation of the Judiciary into a strongly goal-oriented organization has profoundly altered work management (Pozzi, 2023). Thus, the problems previously described in terms of organizational climate and technological adaptation now begin to dialogue with categories such as strategic management, governance, productivity, and occupational health, reinforcing the need to observe TJBA as an institution of people, and not just of numbers.
Within this framework, the 2024–2026 administration presented formal guidelines for the entire management of the TJBA. Judicial Decree No. 167/2024 established priorities such as strengthening the first instance, access of vulnerable groups to justice, adequate methods for conflict resolution, a healthy work environment, workforce expansion, continuous training programs, and the promotion of technological innovation. Specifically, item IV of Article 1 provides for the promotion of a healthy work environment and the appreciation of judges and servers in a human resources management that prioritizes well-being, the development and retention of talent, as well as the improvement of skills and validation of efforts (TJBA, 2024).
The report of the “100 days of TJBA” from the 2024–2026 administration highlights the logic of strategic management adopted by the administration, marked by internal reorganization and a focus on results monitoring. In administrative terms, this can be seen as an effort to align governance, productivity, and People Management (Machado and Camargo, 2023). However, a gap persisted regarding the transparency of the organizational structure for People Management for the 2026–2028 biennium, as, until the conclusion of this research on 04/23/2026, there was no due public disclosure.
On February 2, 2026, at the inauguration of the new Board of Directors, Judge Rotondano stated that his administration intends to “take care of people” and promote actions with a positive impact on the Court’s results and society (TJBA, 2026). This new phase has already been accompanied by the atendimento of some agendas from representative entities, such as the regulation of performance progression for permanent servers, through Judicial Decree No. 150, of February 24, 2026, and the update of health assistance ceilings starting in January 2026. This demonstrates that functional appreciation has begun to appear more explicitly as a dimension of the administrative agenda (SINPOJUD, 2026).
From the perspective of perennial programs, the institutionalization of the Local Committee for the Governance of People Management Policy (CGP), created in accordance with CNJ Resolution No. 240/2016, deserves attention. The CGP has the attributions to propose and coordinate the local strategic people management plan, monitor results, disseminate performance, and establish discussion and working groups (TJBA, 2025). Its composition seeks to balance interactions among the various stakeholders, bringing together members of the judiciary, representatives of institutional management, and representatives of the servers, such as Maria Lenilda Cordeiro de Almeida (SINPOJUD), Luiz Cláudio da Silva Oliveira (SINTAJ), and Carmen Silvia Bonfim dos Santos Rocha (ASSETBA), ensuring the participation of the functional base in deliberations pertinent to the People Management policy (TJBA, s.d.).
Another positive point is the policy for preventing and combating moral, sexual harassment, and discrimination, structured by Resolution n. 09/2025 of the TJBA. This policy is also applicable to conduct practiced through virtual means and covers interns, apprentices, service providers, and other collaborators. The resolution defines “Organizational moral harassment” as a continuous process of abusive conduct supported by organizational strategies aimed at obtaining intensive engagement or excluding employees, through disrespect for their fundamental rights. It also defines “Workplace health,” “Manager,” “Quality of Work Life,” and “Organizational Climate,” revealing a transition from a reactive model to a more preventive and psychosocial risk-oriented stance (TJBA, 2025).
Despite normative advances, the harshest criticism arises when this institutional apparatus is confronted with what the unions — SINTAJ and SINPOJUD — have effectively been sustaining. In 2017, SINTAJ already pointed to TJBA as the worst in the country in terms of case backlog and congestion rate, associating the situation with staff shortages, overload, and precarious working conditions (SINTAJ, 2017). Almost a decade later, SINTAJ’s priority agenda for 2025 still insisted on a linear adjustment, a Career and Salary Plan (PCCV), an increase in health and food allowances, the appointment of approved candidates, and the payment of back pay (SINTAJ, 2025), revealing the persistence of structural demands.
When a personnel policy needs to be permanently overseen by representative entities to materialize or be understood, it suggests that strategic management has not yet achieved full internal legitimacy. In terms of people management, the court works with “enrollment numbers,” but actually deals with men and women who spend more time in judicial units than in their own homes. Therefore, the appreciation policy cannot be thought of solely as a salary table, but must also involve “emotional salary,” that is, recognition, respect, predictability, a healthy environment, institutional listening, and a perception of dignity at work (Machado; Camargo, 2023).
The harmonization of occupational well-being and institutional productivity as an efficiency criterion for obtaining the CNJ Diamond Seal
The analysis of occupational health and safety policies reveals that, although regulatory frameworks exist, practical execution clashes with a management model that prioritizes workflow over the individual. This transition to a judicial administration of results, consolidated at the TJBA, established a dialectical tension where the pursuit of the CNJ’s Diamond Seal began to dictate the rhythm of work life. In this scenario, efficiency ceases to be a multidimensional concept to become a cold metric of procedural output, resulting in a dangerous distance between the institutional prestige of the leadership and the biopsychosocial exhaustion of the base (Machado and Camargo, 2023).
Management based exclusively on quantitative productivity incentives generates negative externalities that the current measurement system cannot capture (Yeung, 2024). At TJBA, this reality is flagrant, as the court has been reaching the top of statistical “efficiency”. In 2025, 93% of the productivity measured by the IPC-Jus method was recorded, second only to the TJ’s of Amazon, Pará, and the Federal District (CNJ, 2025). In 2024, TJBA ranked 5th, with 87% productivity (CNJ, 2024). However, from the analysis of “Justiça em Números”, there is no metric that considers people management or innovation in this foundation as a classification or bonus criterion, appearing only secondarily within the scope of the courts through CNJ guidelines (Mello; Wander, 2024).
The phenomenon of “institutional isomorphism” pressures state courts to mimic “high-performance” behaviors to guarantee legitimacy and national awards (Salazar, 2024). In this context of systemic pressure and the emptying of subjectivities in the workplace, the organization of work can become a vector of alienation and mental suffering when it prevents the expression of creativity and desire. Suffering begins when the man-work relationship is blocked, that is, when the worker can no longer intervene in the organization of work to adapt it to their physiological needs and psychic desires (Yeung, 2024).
Furthermore, Brazilian judicial governance, by focusing on reducing the congestion rate, ends up institutionalizing Digital Taylorism (Oliveira, 2022). The PJe, far from being just a facilitation tool, operates as an uninterrupted virtual production line, where algorithmic monitoring replaces humanized management. The Bahian civil servant experiences the fallacy of modernization, where technology that should have freed up work time has been converted into a surveillance mechanism, adding to the demands via WhatsApp that invade private space, characterizing organizational moral harassment (Vieira, 2024).
Based on a survey made available by the National Council of Justice, in the Dashboard for Monitoring the Comprehensive Health Care Policy for Magistrates and Servers of the Judiciary, a sensitive piece of data was observed regarding the causes of leave among TJBA servers in the year 2024. There was a predominance of illnesses classified in Group F of the ICD-10, related to mental and behavioral disorders. The records of anxiety (F41), with 120 leaves, depressive episodes (F32), with 37 leaves, and recurrent depressive disorder (F33), with 23 leaves, stood out.
Specifically for anxiety disorders (F41), there were 79 leaves of absence for women and 41 for men. For depressive episodes (F32), 32 leaves of absence for women and 5 for men were recorded. For recurrent depressive disorder (F33), 19 leaves of absence for women and 4 for men were identified. These data are relevant indicators, as such occurrences usually correlate, to a greater or lesser extent, with factors related to organizational climate, occupational overload, pressure for results, and the absence of specialized people management.
Regarding the scope concerning magistrates in the base year of 2024, the CNJ panel reveals that, among the most frequent occurrences, convalescence (Z54) stood out, with 16 records summed between sexes, dorsalgia (M54), with 14 records, essential primary hypertension (I10), with 9 records, viral diseases (B34), with 11 records, and diarrhea and gastroenteritis of presumed infectious origin (A09), with 7 records. In addition, other joint disorders (M25) also appeared, with 7 occurrences (CNJ, 2024).
The data reveals that, among magistrates, absences related to clinical recovery, musculoskeletal diseases, and physical wear and tear illnesses stand out, while among civil servants, more significant numbers and a greater presence of mental disorders, such as anxiety and depressive episodes, are observed. This distinction reinforces Vieira’s (2024) hypothesis that civil servants and members of the judiciary are institutional antagonists, such that organizational pressure affects both groups, but manifests differently according to the position occupied in the institutional structure and the type of activity performed.
On a national scale, Nascimento et al. (2024) examined the sick leave data of state court employees for the year 2023, systematizing the main causes of absence. The study shows that mental disorders classified in group F of the ICD-10 also have repercussions on a national scale within the Brazilian state judiciary, with F41 (other anxiety disorders) being the leading cause of absence in several courts, including the TJBA. This framework allows the Bahian case to be situated within a broader reality of the state Judiciary.
Borba, Yoshida, and Oliveira (2024) argue that high-performance judicial management is only legitimized when it manages to reconcile legal certainty, institutional efficiency, and protection of worker health. However, in practice, the “Managerial Judge” is often guided by productivity dashboards and statistical indicators, in an effort to avoid negative exposure of the judicial unit before institutional rankings and goals, which can widen the gap between effective leadership and mere numerical demands. The OAB-BA Presidents’ College (2025) contested the data from the Justice in Numbers 2025 report for the TJBA, arguing that certain formal indicators do not reflect the reality experienced by attorneys and litigants, mentioning dismissals without merit resolution, dilatory orders, and artificial entries in the electronic procedural system as factors capable of inflating apparent productivity without translating into real effectiveness.
Nascimento and Abers (2020) emphasize that administrative creativity in manipulating productivity statistics often hides the invisibility of support activities and public service. Consequently, the civil servant who prioritizes the humanization and reception of the justiciable is “punished” by the criteria of Judicial Decree No. 150/2026, which links functional progression and remuneration to purely quantitative indicators (TJBA, 2026). This “performance collar” transforms salary appreciation into a pressure tool, forcing the clerk to choose between their mental health and financial stability, especially in rural districts where functional loneliness aggravates the situation of institutional helplessness.
Freitas and Chaves (2024) point out that the use of DataJud as the sole source of administrative truth creates a dangerous distance between data and life. The TJBA, by focusing on knowledge processes that generate quick scores for the Diamond Seal, ends up neglecting the “blind knot” of execution, where the process remains stagnant for years. Therefore, the efficiency touted by the court is incomplete: it is an efficiency of counters and digital paperwork, which consumes the server in rework and bureaucracy, but does not deliver the effective jurisdictional provision that Bahian society demands and that the OAB-BA constantly demands in its official notes (OAB-BA, 2025).
Turbay and Corrêa (2021) analyze how the digital panopticon intensifies dehumanization through the algorithm, where the server is reduced to a production unit in the system. A glaring budgetary mismatch is perceived, in which millions of reais are invested in software updates and IT infrastructure, while funds allocated to QVT (Quality of Work Life) programs and Burnout prevention are negligible and treated as accessories. This administrative choice reveals that, for the hegemonic efficiency model, human capital is seen as a disposable and replaceable resource, rather than the fundamental pillar that sustains the very legitimacy of the Judiciary.
TJBA Resolution nº 09/2025 emerges as a tacit confession that organizational moral harassment has reached critical levels in the state. As Yeung (2024) reiterates in his economic analysis, a court that sickens its workforce is, in the long run, inefficient, as the cost of replacements, leaves of absence, and the drop in decision quality outweigh the immediate gain of a statistical premium. Therefore, the dichotomy established at TJBA demands a transition to what can be called Sustainable Efficiency, where occupational well-being ceases to be a topic of “motivational lectures” and becomes a mandatory requirement for auditing and scoring for the CNJ quality seals.
In summary, the research proved that the speed achieved is, to a large extent, the result of individual overload and not of structural improvement, which is corroborated by the constant criticisms from the legal profession regarding the real slowness in the basic courts. The efficiency measured by the court proves to be partial, as it ignores the biopsychosocial costs of production and focuses on short-term results that compromise the longevity of the workforce. Thus, the compatibility between productivity and occupational well-being is not only an ethical imperative but a strategic management necessity for the survival of public institutions, requiring that the Diamond Seal be conditioned on the rigorous measurement of a “Mental Health Seal” and organizational climate indicators as necessary brakes to the unbridled acceleration of the work pace.
4. Conclusion
This study sought to analyze how people management can act as a reconciling element between occupational well-being and institutional productivity at the Court of Justice of the State of Bahia (TJBA). It was observed that the administrative modernization of the Judiciary, although it has promoted greater transparency and procedural speed, established a predominantly quantitative management model. The results demonstrated that the TJBA achieved high productivity rates, such as 93% in 2025 and 87% in 2024, according to the IPC-Jus, and obtained the CNJ Diamond Seal. However, this statistical success coexisted with high rates of absenteeism due to mental disorders among court employees, particularly anxiety (F41), depressive episodes (F32), and recurrent depressive disorder (F33) in 2024. It was observed that the management model, often under the guidance of judges focused on indicators, treated the staff as an extensible resource, without integrating mental health metrics into official reports. The efficiency proclaimed by the court proved to be partial, as it ignored the biopsychosocial costs of production and prioritized short-term results, compromising the longevity of the workforce. The speed achieved, in large part, resulted from individual overload, not structural improvement, which was corroborated by the criticisms of the legal profession regarding the real slowness in the basic courts.
The research showed that People Management at TJBA has not been able to sustainably reconcile productivity and well-being, revealing that institutional efficiency, as measured, has ignored the biopsychosocial costs of production. The study’s main contribution lies in demonstrating the need for a transition to Sustainable Efficiency, where occupational well-being is a fundamental pillar. As limitations, a gap in the transparency of the People Management organizational structure for the 2026–2028 biennium and the absence of an organizational climate study widely disseminated by TJBA itself were identified. It is suggested, for future studies and as an intervention proposal, that obtaining the CNJ’s Diamond Seal be conditioned on the rigorous measurement of a “Mental Health Seal” and organizational climate indicators. Such a measure would ensure that institutional efficiency is based on preserving the health and quality of life of public servants, ensuring the sustainability of the judicial system and recognizing that the shine of the institutional diamond cannot be sustained by the hidden illness of those who produce it.
Bibliographic References
BATISTA, Francisco Eduardo Fontenele; DE FIGUEIREDO, Luiza Vieira Sá. Liderança: Ativo Estratégico do Poder Judiciário. Revista Judicial Brasileira, v. 1, n. 1, p. 251-276, 2021.
CONSELHO NACIONAL DE JUSTIÇA (Brasil). Justiça em Números 2024. Brasília, DF: CNJ, 2024.
FREITAS, Pablo F. P.; ODELIUS, Catarina C. Work design: características do trabalho de servidores do superior tribunal de justiça. RAM. Revista de Administração Mackenzie, v. 22, p. eRAMG210192, 2021.
NASCIMENTO, Leandro Lago et al. Principais causas de absenteísmo por doença na justiça estadual brasileira. Revista Observatorio de la Economía Latinoamericana, Curitiba, v. 22, n. 10, p. 1-12, 2024.
POZZI, Jessyca Pacheco et al. As alterações na gestão do trabalho
SEKUNDA, André; JUNIOR, Arlos Eleodoro Seixas Risden. O que dizem os dados? Uma análise factual da (in) eficiência do poder judiciário brasileiro. Enfoque: Reflexão Contábil, v. 41, n. 2, p. 171-190, 2022.
Article originating from the Final Course Work of the Specialization in People Management of the MBA USP/Esalq
To learn more about the course, click here and access the MBX Academy platform