Education
School Management
January 21, 2023
Diversity of cultural capital: relationship between culture and knowledge
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-20230003
E&S 2023,4: e20230003
Josilaine Caetano Guizo e Tatiana Gisele Guimarães Lopes
The school requires all students to have an academic record without failures or dropouts and to become accustomed to an effective culture. It is the school administrator’s responsibility to ensure the quality of education offered to the students of that institution, in addition to leading the development of the Political Pedagogical Project (PPP), verifying and monitoring their students’ learning by detecting what is working or not, and based on this data, adjusting the appropriate pedagogical practice to minimize errors.
As a manager, it is important to always be prepared to foster incentive and development for everyone, in addition to providing a transparent relationship with the community. Pedagogical management encompasses all extensions of school management, as it is linked to the school’s interest, which consists of enabling students to acquire knowledge, as well as their development, so that all others have the same objective, since the main point of teaching is organized action to promote the formation and learning of students, enabling them to develop fundamental social and personal skills to be integrated into society and the workplace[1].
When it comes to learning differences, there is always a question that is asked, and for which one sometimes does not have an adequate and/or sensible answer: what is the reason that leads some students to have more knowledge, having a much more profitable school path, and others not? Students’ cultural capital establishes a fundamental theory capable of clarifying problems of school performance, related to the diversities of cultural capital, such as school success or failure among students[2].
The concept of Cultural Capital is of extreme importance not only for the research area, but it is even accepted outside the academic field, such as in the cultural press[3]. The idea of cultural capital was initially established as an important theory to explain the issue of inequalities regarding the academic performance of students from different social classes. “School success” would be the advantages that children from different class groups could achieve at school by sharing cultural capital among classes. This point of view breaks with the thinking of those who judge school success or failure as a consequence of skills considered natural[4].
Social Capital is also established as a relevant factor in this theme, as it can be understood basically as contacts, that is, a sum of resources that can be associated with the retention of a lasting network of relationships[4]. Overcoming external inequalities is too difficult; it is necessary to dedicate oneself to each student according to their individualities and needs, proposing solutions for the most diverse learning difficulties during the student’s school life. To this end, it is important to emphasize that time must be dedicated and a qualified team must be available to assist these students. It is essential to invest time in acquiring knowledge and cultures[5]. Therefore, it is considered the manager’s duty to focus on the training of students and the school’s pedagogical team. Based on this assumption, the school should include the student through content that is part of their reality, with content that values and expands the cultural capital of all students.
In order to seek alternatives for this problem, it is understood that this issue is not just a topic pertinent to teachers, but to the entire school team, not only passing through the classroom but also through the entire school organization. Managers and teachers have attributed low school performance to students’ incompetence or lack of interest, or even to the disorganization of their families[6]. The manager’s role is not just to administer the school, but to care for the training of their pedagogical team, as well as the training of their students. The practice of school management is intrinsically related to power relations. To interpret what drives subjects to act the way they do, the concept of habitus[7] is necessary. Throughout the subjects’ trajectory, the habitus is aggregated. The starting point is the habitus acquired in the family, later expanded by the school and then by subsequent experiences.
It is understood that failure is still part of the school routine and the school manager has a fundamental role in identifying paths that minimize failures, seeking school success in the life of each student. Therefore, the objective was to investigate the differences in cultural capital brought by students to school, as well as the obstacles that this factor can bring to their school performance. For this, Systematic Mapping (SM) was established as the methodology. This methodology consists of a deep investigation regarding a certain topic. It provides a broader overview of the area to be researched, also enabling the definition and classification of the results obtained and indicating research evidence on the chosen theme[8].
The CAPES (Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior) Periodicals Portal was the chosen platform, as it is a virtual library containing over 45,000 titles, 130 reference databases, among other content. The synthesis of the parameters established for the research can be observed in Figure 1.

Figure 1. Parameters established for the research in the journal portal
Source: Prepared by the author
The results obtained through searches in the CAPES Periodicals Portal for the keyword combination are presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Results obtained on the journal portal of the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES) for the keyword combination
| Keywords | Articles | ||||
| Total obtained by the search | Peer reviewed | Period from 2010 to 2021 | Topic of Education | Of Interest | |
| Cultural Capital AND School Inequality | 1331 | 1135 | 882 | 117 | 1 |
| Cultural Capital AND Schooling | 462 | 365 | 295 | 39 | 3 |
| Cultural Capital AND School Management | 815 | 637 | 552 | 69 | 3 |
| Habitus AND School | 821 | 701 | 533 | 43 | 4 |
| Sum | 3429 | 2838 | 2262 | 268 | 11 |
Source: Elaborated by the author
It was observed from the result of the descriptor search that researchers are concerned with inequalities, whether due to a lack of cultural, economic, or social capital, as these attitudes still permeate the school environment. After examining the results of the 268 articles found for the Topic Education, 11 studies of interest were selected for the research because they relate to the role of the manager in the face of the diversities of cultural capital brought by students to school (Table 2).
Table 2. Result of the Systematic Mapping (SM) for the search of the keywords, Cultural Capital “AND” School Inequality, Cultural Capital “AND” Schooling, Cultural Capital “AND” School Management, Habitus “AND” School in the Periodicals Portal of the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES)
| Author | Title | Contributions to the state of the art |
| Petroski (2015) | The school performance and the cultural capital that structures the students of Pedagogy at UNEMAT in Sinop | Research based on Pierre Bourdieu’s cultural capital and highlights the school as a reproducer of social inequalities by relating cultural capital to academic performance |
| Carvalho (2015) | Pierre Bourdieu, Edmond Goblot and bourgeois education | Analysis of the work of two authors who related social classes with culture and school |
| Souza (2013) | Expectations of high school graduating students in the Recôncavo of Bahia: (Re)constructing ties from Public school to University | Research conducted analyzing the difficulties encountered in the educational path, as well as the reasons for entering and remaining in Universities |
| Coradini (2013) | Effects of formal education, occupational categories and social position | The study shows that the performance in formal education changes according to the social position the individual holds |
| Souza e Silva (2017) | School Recovery: a tool for meaning on the path to the selection of social subjects | The study questions the evaluative methods and contributes by seeking alternatives to traditional assessments |
| Idelbrando (2019) | Representations of Teachers and Managers of a school that calls itself a research school | Case study conducted in a suburban school in São Paulo, relating pedagogical practices and the construction of student knowledge |
| Vicente (2010) | Teaching and Schooling Culture: the habitus in the process of structuring the social field of the school | Presented studies in the field of the education system as a social and cultural factor. Also addressed the issue of habitus as cultural heritage |
| Faria and Pinto (2009) | Habitus and composition of cultural, economic and Social capitals as explanatory factors for the constitution of expectations and practices of training and work of students of a State Public School | The expectations regarding education and work were analyzed, relating work to human education in the academic and professional path |
Penna (2012) | Social Origin of Professors and aspects of teaching practice | Analyzed the concept of the familiar habitus of teachers who teach in the early years of elementary school in public schools |
| Penna and Marin (2019) | Social trajectory, habitus and school engagement | Analyzed the work carried out by the director and coordinator of two schools and the relationship with the other members of the management team and the school community |
Source: Elaborated by the author
Despite the breadth of studies related to learning, school failure or success, the selected articles show that the concept of cultural capital is directly linked to the success or failure in students’ learning and that school management is intimately linked to the evolution of this capital. The school reproduces social inequalities by practicing so-called symbolic violence, establishing the culture of dominant classes as correct[9].
Pierre Bourdieu explains the dominant power relations related to the concept of cultural capital, expressing the need to understand the ways in which subjects exercise their culture in school settings, as he considers school a space that reproduces social inequalities. One of the factors for this assertion is the traditional pedagogy of the school, which uses its power to impose a cultural judgment, subject to the interests of the dominant classes[9]. Poor families are the biggest victims of school failure, and this fact occurs not due to an inability to learn, but is directly related to the school’s mode of operation, which does not favor the permanence and valorization of these layers in school benches[6].
Regarding Bourdieu’s theory, Petroski[9] points out that individual talent loses strength, so that school success depends on factors external to the individual, mainly concerning culture. He also classifies dominant culture as privileged in education and that school success is dependent on cultural capital, social capital, and economic capital, highlighting cultural capital as the most relevant in the school process. From this perspective, educational institutions have reproduced the culture of the dominant classes, supporting the theory that it is the correct culture. With this, they would guarantee that symbolic goods remain among small groups.
The subject needs to have access to cultural goods and appropriate these values. Only with this, educational institutions will be able to conduct fairer analyses and/or evaluations. The working class has a greater interest in the courses offered in the evening, which leads to numerous difficulties encountered by these students, who seek to improve their living conditions through higher education courses. Among the difficulties in staying at university, the devaluation of their cultural capital can be highlighted, as they cannot dedicate themselves as much due to having to work during the day and study at night[9]. The subject is defined by an economic and cultural heritage, and this heritage includes attributes external to the individual that can characterize their academic success. In this sense, Bourdieu points out that school is not a neutral space, but rather one of capital transfers[10].
Faced with this scenario, Carvalho Filho[11] makes a comparison between the two works, namely: “A barreira e o nível: estudo sociológico sobre a burguesia francesa moderna” (1925), by Edmond Globot and, “A Distinção: crítica social do julgamento” (1979), by Pierre Bourdieu. Both works were of great contribution regarding the relationship between social classes associated with school and culture, with Bourdieu’s work being the one that has contributed the most and continues to contribute. Bourdieu’s works as a whole have generally contributed to the investigation of schools, as well as the Brazilian school system, with his thesis on the sociology of education[11].
Even with all the programs created with the objective of expanding access to Universities by the most popular classes, this goal has not occurred as expected, so the adversities in this process are many[12]. The most popular classes only had access to education in Brazil after the citizen constitution, resulting from struggles for citizenship rights. Education also becomes a right and it was no different with higher education. It is important to know the students’ expectations, how they see themselves, as well as the type of action used for their goals to be achieved regarding their admission to university. In this sense, it is fundamental that the school acts as a supporter for the students’ aspirations in their future[12].
Souza[12] states that the University appears as a possibility for the future for students, but there is an immediate need to be inserted into the job market. This fact can be explained by the social/economic conditions that these students experience in their daily lives, often leading to their later entry into the University and/or alongside work. It is also important to highlight external influence regarding the continuation of studies, and the influence that the family has on the school process. Analyzing the relationship between family education and school education, it can be said that effectiveness and scope are totally dependent on social origin, changing according to the level of distinct cultural practices used by the school system, also including the influence of social origin[4].
We still see schools that refrain from discussing their students’ expectations for the future, as social interactions and learning for a future in society are processes that are also part of school. The school space is indeed a place for learning for life and needs to be seen as a place to address the desires and expectations of these young people for their future. It requires a change so that it can be a guiding and expanding place in the construction of goals[12].
However, still regarding the path of a high school student to university, it is necessary to contribute so that students can have continuity in their academic journey, so that democratization of higher education occurs. As a result of the research, students point out that school should be a place where the university is presented as accessible, discussing the principles of admission and permanence in higher education, bringing great impacts on the students’ journey and strengthening the relationship between public school and the university[12].
The relationships between education and income, as well as other factors that indicate social class in Brazil, show that schooling outcomes are related to the subject’s social position[13]. Coradini’s[13] study was based on general objectives that encompass distinct and complex content regarding the relationships between schooling, income, and social position, as well as on the available data models. For Bourdieu[14], social class is a functional theory capable of theoretically clarifying formation and which has a relationship for a possibility of acting in certain ways in specific cases. However, they only come into existence in theoretical space; the concept only points to possibilities that may or may not be confirmed.
Still from Coradini’s perspective[13], regarding the research carried out, it is possible to observe that there is a variable between the amount of income and study time. However, the reasons that interfere with the different results of schooling need to be examined in the differences in conditions and investments made for schooling according to social status. The problem between schooling and income diverges due to social position. Supposedly, the importance of schooling and academic titles are linked to social classes.
Assessments are combinations of methods that tend to observe the student with consent for such a normative practice, that is, it is a control over the conventional student, allowing them to be qualified, classified, or punished. It establishes a focus for the student to be made visible by what they are differentiated[15]. Souza and Silva[16] highlight the importance of discussions about evaluative pedagogical practices. They also point out the importance of thinking about the evaluative process in other ways.
Idelbrando[17] reflects with the purpose of contributing to the educational community, both on the concepts of teachers and managers of a public school in the periphery of the city of São Paulo, as well as the practical relationships of knowledge conception of its students. The school would be labeled as an immutable institution that is not susceptible to change, but that is not quite the case. The Law of Directives and Bases of National Education [LDB] nº 9394[18], provides in its Art. 14, items I and II that “The education systems shall define the norms of democratic management of public education in basic education, in accordance with their peculiarities and according to the following principles: participation of school communities or equivalents”. In general, educational institutions follow these guidelines, containing themselves within such determinations so that the Law is fulfilled; it is likely that before this, there is no type of reflection and discussion regarding democracy. Considering that Idelbrando’s[17] study school is in the process of democratization, it is evident that many still remain governed by traditionalist processes. The school reinvented itself in the knowledge previously brought by the students, from their experiences, requiring the entire school to face and overcome a diversity of obstacles and contradictions. This promoted the institution’s teachers to a differentiated condition, the condition of creative characters.
Regarding the access and permanence of students in higher education, Maciel et al.[19] report that this theme is deeply linked to the schooling process, that is, it is determined by the expansion of capital already in basic education. The success in the school trajectory of the students of the college in question is due to the fact that the institution seeks to add multiple factors that contribute to students having a successful path in university. The first differential that the institution has is the fact of having a conservative and careful management regarding rules. The second differential is the issue of valuing and worrying about the student, covering the monitoring of their performance as well as their difficulties, both pedagogical and psychosocial. It is important to highlight that all these practices involve the family. The third point highlighted, as it is a school based on meritocracy, is the act of encouraging the student, ensuring satisfactory results[19]. Cultural capital is an immensely important inheritance in a person’s life, as it is attributed as an influencer in the student’s school path. With the expansion of cultural capital, the chances of school success will be greater[20]. In this sense, Maciel et al[19] show that the institution aims to value the principles of discipline and responsibility, values its students by highlighting their symbolic capital and favoring their social capital.
Faria e Silva[21] analyzed, based on Bourdieu, high school students from a public school regarding study and work. With this, they sought to understand how expectations are built for both the training and the work of future high school graduates. Thus, it is impossible not to note the influences of cultural, economic, social capital, and habitus on the trajectory of these students. The concept of habitus manifested the need to understand the relationships of behaviors. The theory was systematized by Bourdieu initially with research carried out in Algeria among common farmers[22], [23]. It happens that when cultural customs somehow become part of family routine, this cultural practice and the dominant languages begin to be integrating parts of that child. Bourdieu[24] points out that this cultural heritage are symbolic goods pointed out by society as goods that must be achieved and possessed.
Regarding the cultural capital of the students in the study by Faria and Silva[21], it was found that the majority possessed higher cultural capital and schooling than their parents. They also noticed that morning students held greater cultural capital compared to evening students, which highlights a consequence of economic/social capital. Concerning the students’ life context, research shows that work seems to be a predetermined factor in their minds, with qualification being a gateway to the job market. Studies as a form of personal satisfaction come second.
Penna[25] conducted interviews with first-grade teachers in public schools, with the aim of contributing to and understanding teachers’ pedagogical practices in their daily lives, as well as their thoughts regarding students. In light of this, it is important to highlight the concept of teachers’ habitus and that of their families, relating this theory to their teaching pedagogical practices. Teaching is seen by the teachers as the achievement of a dream, or even a vocation. However, it emerged as a means of social evolution, as becoming teachers offered the possibility of social ascent and maintenance in relation to their families, allowing for an elevation of economic capital and also cultural capital.
In his research, Penna[25] can point out important aspects that characterize a similarity in the family origin of the interviewees, which constitutes habitus, as they sought to compose it for the performance of teaching, being expressed in reference to school culture. A more promising future for these families was directly linked to the continuation of studies, with the prospect of achieving better-paid jobs and having a more promising future.
In the theory proposed by Bourdieu, the concept of field is represented by a symbolic space, where subjects’ struggles prove and legitimize representations, that is, it allows investigating how agents position themselves[4]. The educational space is defined by the symbols of knowledge and world construction. In this line of thought, Penna and Marin[7] consider Bourdieu’s theory of cultural capital, with regard to the power of knowledge, as legitimate an element that justifies the possession of cultural capital which is built and/or acquired throughout life. They also point out that in the field of management, political symbolic capital is of extreme importance for the premises regarding the various functions associated with social relationships.
Regarding the practice of the manager’s function, two forms of management and organizational conduct of school work are evident, expressed by differences in relationships reproduced by distinct domination behaviors, given that the subjects were motivated by principles referring to their trajectories[7]. The coordinator operates in the educational field with her own pedagogical functions, but with little cultural capital and insufficient experience in the field. As a result, she constantly needs to prove to herself and others her competence in the work she performs, evidencing traditional habitus to conduct her work in the pedagogical field. The director, on the other hand, presents traits of bureaucratic domination aligned with his charismatic domination, due to possessing high cultural, social, and political capital, resulting from his trajectory including vast experience in the educational field. He is a dominant figure in the field in which he operates, manifesting habitus with a balanced posture regarding school work, supporting pedagogical initiatives by working with families.
The respective articles analyzed here show important research for understanding the manager’s role in students’ academic success and/or failure. It is understood from them that the agent must transcend their bureaucratic field of work to the pedagogical field. This attitude can generate collectivity among peers, also contribute to supporting the teaching staff, and collaborate effectively in the student’s educational journey, ultimately helping to expand students’ cultural capital by reducing trajectories of academic failure (Figure 2).

Figure 2. The manager’s role in the academic success and/or failure of their students when bridging the bureaucratic and pedagogical fields
Source: Elaborated by the author
Therefore, in the schooling process, the concept of cultural capital and habitus can be observed due to the importance it holds not only for the student’s educational trajectory but also for life. The school plays a fundamentally important role in the student’s daily life, observing its competence as a space for the production and reproduction of culture. However, these institutions have often acted as a place that favors the dominant class, thereby contributing to the school failure of the less favored class, that is, those who arrive at school with shallow cultural capital. With this, it is important to emphasize that the manager’s role is fundamental for these examples of conduct and policies to be extinguished from the school environment. It is important for the manager to have a broad vision and not focus solely on the bureaucratic tasks that permeate the field of management. Furthermore, understanding that exceeding the limits of the pedagogical field, always being one step ahead, would contribute to the entire school community becoming engaged in seeking ways to expand the cultural capital of its students, thereby providing mechanisms for the academic success of these students.
References
[1] Lück H. Dimensões da gestão escolar e suas competências. Curitiba: Positivo; 2009
[2] Bourdieu P. Questões de Sociologia. Rio de Janeiro: Marco zero; 1983.
[3] Muzzetti L.R.; Suficier D.M.; Santos A.A. Conhecimento, currículo e cultura. Piracicaba: Editora Pecege; 2019. Série Acadêmica.
[4] Bourdieu P. Espaço social e espaço simbólico. In: Bourdieu P. Razões Práticas: sobre a teoria da ação. Corrêa M. (tradução). 4 ed. Campinas: Papirus; 2003. p. 13-34.
[5] Lahire B. Sucesso escolar nos meios populares.As razões do improvável. 1 ed. São Paulo: Ática; 2004.
[6] Patto M.H.S. A família pobre e a escola pública: anotações sobre um desencontro. Psicologia USP. 1992; 3(1-2): 107-121.
[7] Penna G.O.; Marin A.J. 2019. Trajetória social, habitus e engajamento no trabalho escola. Educ. Pesqui. 2019; 45:1-17.
[8] Oliveira A.M.C.A.; Rodrigues R.L.; Garcia V.C. Um mapeamento sistemático para Problem Based Learning aplicado à Ciência da Computação. In: XVIII Workshop de Informática na Escola; 2012. 1-10, Rio de Janeiro, RJ.
[9] Petroski I. A. O rendimento escolar e o capital cultural que estrutura os alunos de pedagogia na UNEMAT em Sinop. Rev. Even. Ped. 2015; 6(4): 180-190.
[10] Nogueira C.M.M; Nogueira M.A. 2002. Sociologia da educação de Pierre Bourdieu: Limites e contribuições. Educ. Soc. 2002; 23(78): 15-36.
[11] Carvalho Filho J.L. Pierre Bourdieu, Edmond Globot e a educação burguesa. Pesq. Soc. 2015; 14(31): 180-199.
[12] Souza G.K.A. Expectativas de estudantes concluintes do ensino Médio no recôncavo da Bahia: (Re) construindo laços da escola pública à universidade. [Monografia]. Cachoeira: Universidade Federal do Recôncavo da Bahia; 2013.
[13] Coradini O.L. Efeitos da educação formal, categorias ocupacionais e posição social.Rev. Soc. estado. 2014; 29(2): 511-538.
[14] Bourdieu P. A escola conservadora: as desigualdades frente à escola e à cultura. Educ. Rev. 1989; (10): 3-15
[15] Foucault M. Vigiar e punir: nascimento da prisão. 1977. Petrópolis: Vozes; 1977.
[16] Souza D.M.X.B.; Silva M.A. Prática Avaliativa de Matemática: um dispositivo pedagógico de subjetivação. Educ. Real. 2017; 42(2): 793-807.
[17] Idelbrando A.G. Representações de professores e gestores de uma escola que se diz pesquisadora. Rev. latinoam. cienc. soc. niñez juv. 2019;17(2): 58-81.
[18] Brasil. Lei nº 9.394, de 20 de dezembro de 1996. Estabelece as diretrizes e bases da educação nacional. Brasília, DF; 1996.
[19] Maciel C.E.; Assis, J.H.V.P.; Silva M.F.A. Acesso e permanência na educação superior: estratégias de ingresso mobilizadas no ‘Colégio Militar de Campo Grande’. Acta Sci. Edu. 2018; 40 (1): e37648.
[20] Bourdieu P. O capital social: notas provisórias. In: Nogueira M.A.; Catani A. (Org). Escritos de Educação. Petrópolis: Vozes; 1998.
[21] Faria R.M.; Silva E.P. Habitus e composição dos capitais cultural, econômico e social como fatores explicativos da constituição das expectativas e práticas de formação e trabalho de alunos de uma escola Pública Estadual. Trab. Educ. 2009; 18(3): 72-92.
[22] Bourdieu P. Travail et travailleurs en Algérie. Paris: Mouton; 1963.
[23] Bourdieu P. Les stratégies matrimoniales dans le système de reproduction. Annales. Histoire, sciences sociales. 1972; 27(4-5): 1105-1127.
[24] Bourdieu, P. A economia das trocas simbólicas. Miceli S. (Org.). São Paulo: Perspectiva; 2013. 361 p.
[25] Penna G.O. Origem social de professores e aspectos da prática docente. Educação. 2012; 35(2): 199-207.
Como citar
Guizo J.C.; Lopes T.G.G. Diversidade de capital cultural: relação entre cultura e conhecimento. Revista E&S. 2023; 4: e20230003.
Sobre os autores
Josilaine Caetano Guizo, Especialista em Gestão Escolar, Piracicaba, SP, Brasil.
Tatiana Gisele Guimarães Lopes, Doutora em Ciências, Especialista em Psicopedagogia, Piracicaba, SP, Brasil.
Link para download: https://cms.revistaes.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/ES_23003.pdf