Education
School Management
March 31, 2023
School management actions based on the recognition of the historical-cultural capital of its community
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-20230019
E&S 2023,4: e202300019
Vera Maria Pupim Perdonatti; Milena Pedroso Ruella Martins
Many are the variables to be taken into account when analyzing quality, equity, and equality in the offering of education, since it must be clear that the actors involved are also diverse and the contextual and circumstantial conditions in which they develop their actions in the field of schooling are multiple. It can thus be inferred that, when school management in pedagogical dimension actions does not consider the family’s historical-cultural heritage, it tends to exclude those who have not received the dominant culture which legitimizes – thus tending to collaborate with the reproduction of social inequalities[1]. This is, for example, the logic reproduced in the educational institution that forms people as different and ends up producing permanent differences in them[2].
The political-pedagogical project is the school’s letter of intent. In this sense, it can be understood as an instituting instrument of a set of principles, among them the educational principle advocated by democratic management. Given this thinking, the political-pedagogical project is an instrument that makes it possible to materialize the aspirations and dreams where each school envisions arriving – hence the term “political,” which strengthens the idea of autonomy and management. In the nature of the pedagogical act, autonomy and democratic management are featured, and in making its choices, designing its paths, envisioning future reflections, this school exercises autonomy and makes a political choice that legitimizes the school community, considering its place[3]. That is, its territoriality, defended here as a form of appropriation of social spaces that are its own, mobilizing itself for collective action and, therefore, valuing its historical-cultural capital[4].
In this logic, Paulo Freire[5] provokes reflection when he tells us that in a progressive educational practice, one cannot disregard the issue of students’ cultural identity – referring to the individual and class dimensions. Hence the role of school management in democratically involving its internal and external community in thinking about and executing the school’s political-pedagogical project. Therefore, from this perspective, and focusing on schooling, it is up to the school to consider the cultural identity of its students, as well as to take into account the history of each student’s entire school trajectory, and furthermore, to consider the variables and diversity of student groups, acting politically, in favor of the learning to which they are entitled[2].
Thus, under such foundations, this research work aimed to understand, analyze, reflect on, and generate suggestions for school management practices and how it identifies and recognizes the historical-cultural capital of its community and how it considers it in the school’s pedagogical project proposals, aiming at improving learning outcomes. The research gathered data and information contained in the pedagogical proposals of schools from two municipal networks and one private education institution, identifying in the records of these documents indicators of the characteristics of the school community, such as: socio-historical-cultural profile, parents’ or guardians’ schooling, parents’ level of education, school’s territorial location, community customs and habits, among others, and pedagogical action proposals that considered them, aiming at improving learning outcomes.
Data collection occurred through an online questionnaire with the respective school managers, gathering indicators of professional training, time in the profession, socio-historical-cultural perception of the school community – including teachers – and managerial actions generated from this perception, which aimed at improving and guaranteeing learning rights and the consequent quality of the offered education. The pedagogical projects belonged to eight schools from the municipal and private education network, located in four micro-regions of the state of São Paulo – Araraquara, Barretos, Ribeirão Preto, and São José do Rio Preto. These are four school units from municipal education networks affiliated with a certain educational system, including one early childhood education school and three elementary schools, one for early years and two for later years.
From private educational network schools, four are participating in the research, which operate: one with early childhood education, initial, final and secondary education, and three with initial, final and secondary education. This analysis sought to detect the characteristics and peculiarities of each school in favor of equity, equality, and the right to quality learning, considering for this the historical-cultural capital of its community and the understanding of the characteristics of the territory where the school is located.
The documentary analysis of the political-pedagogical projects of each selected school was guided by guiding questions, namely: 1. Do the document records consider the socio-historical-cultural characteristics of the school community?; 2. Are there proposed actions to promote the approximation of students’ families to the school with the aim of recognizing their historical-cultural capital?; and 3. Are there proposals for pedagogical action involving management and teaching practices that consider the historical-cultural capital of the school community, aiming to improve student learning outcomes?
Regarding the field research, an “online” questionnaire was applied, through a digital platform with the school managers of the mentioned schools, hereinafter referred to as school principals, pedagogical coordinators, and educational technicians, totaling approximately twenty-two invited participants. Five questions were proposed, namely: 1. What is your professional background and how long have you been working in school management*? *(School Management or Pedagogical Coordination); 2. Do you live in the neighborhood or region of the school? Does this facilitate or hinder the possibility of knowing the cultural, social, and economic characteristics of the school community? Why?; 3. What is your perception regarding the historical-cultural capital (life history, family culture) of the school community (families/students, school staff, and teachers)?; 4. What kind of actions does the school take to promote the approximation of students’ families to the school for the purpose of recognizing their historical-cultural capital of life and family culture)?; and 5. What do you, as a school manager, consider when formulating and systematizing management action proposals in the pedagogical project, aiming to improve student learning?
The socio-historical-cultural characteristics of the schools correspond to the analysis criteria of the pedagogical projects of the municipal network schools – Municipal Basic Education School (EMEB) and private network – Educational Center (CE), called the school management plan. From the recorded analyses and taking the first analysis criterion (Records of the consideration of the socio-historical-cultural characteristics of the school community), in EMEB 1, the socioeconomic condition, the families’ work situation, the characteristics of the community’s social relations, and housing conditions are identified. It is observed that in three of the municipal network schools analyzed, EMEB 2, 3, and 4, the consideration of the community is evidenced only in the matter of offering vacancies.
From private schools, in CE 1 and CE 3, the location of student housing and the percentage of students with tuition waivers due to low income are evident, while in one of the CE 4 schools, the socioeconomic and cultural characteristics and their relationship with learning are highlighted, and in one of them, CE 2, no consideration was given to the socio-historical-cultural characteristics of the school community.
Regarding the second criterion (Proposals to promote the approximation of students’ families to the school for the purpose of recognizing their cultural historical capital), the proposals from municipal schools tend, in the case of EMEB, to involve the local school community and parents in participating in school matters, inviting the community to participate in meetings for planning festive and cultural activities, strengthening the bond with the family and community in partnership in the students’ formation process, orientation measures for parents and students regarding absences and the resulting harm to students. In EMEB 2, approximation with families for better communication about children’s incidents and experiences. In EMEB 3, the approximation proposal refers to problems with indiscipline, and in EMEB 4, there is a proposal for family involvement in school, attendance project, and approximation through a June festival.
From the private network to school CE 1, proposals for approaching families are made with the aim of, through research, identifying weaknesses and strengths to address student performance and learning. School CE 2 presents the goal of intensifying the school-family partnership to raise awareness of their role, as well as to support the improvement of students’ interest in studies and learning. School CE 3’s proposal for approach is to offer families the opportunity to express their vision of the school, and for school CE 4, the approach will be through meetings to deliver results and information on students’ difficulties, progress, and overall performance, and through family support in problem-solving.
Regarding the third analysis criterion (Proposals for pedagogical action involving management and teaching practices that consider the historical-cultural capital of the school community aiming at improving student learning outcomes), municipal schools such as EMEB 1, with the intent of the citizen school, propose to rescue the student’s identity as a subject of the learning process, foster student participation in the social and political life of the community, and strengthen ethical domain in interpersonal and group relations. EMEB 2 presents a goal of making the school a space for coexistence and the construction of identity and educational opportunities among different social classes, concerning access to cultural goods and the possibilities of experiencing childhood. EMEB 3 proposes a commitment to developing learning situations that start from the knowledge students possess and a goal of valuing the cultural spaces of the city and region as learning spaces, and EMEB 4 also presents a proposal to develop learning situations that start from the knowledge students possess, establish communication with the school community and society, and provide attention to students with learning difficulties and their families.
Regarding private schools, CE 1 presents a proposal for studies by the management team and teachers on student performance, a survey of contextual information about the school and its surroundings to provide subsidies for learning advancement, holding everyone involved in the educational process accountable. CE 2 proposes to identify factors that hinder family involvement in daily school life and to support and contribute to the student’s formation as a conscious citizen who recognizes themselves as a subject capable of intervening in social reality, consolidating their plans into a life project and for society. CE 3 presents a proposal to contribute to the elevation of the historical-cultural capital of the school community, and CE 4 proposes to expand communication channels between schools and families, such as moments of listening to families and conducting satisfaction surveys.
Based on the documentary analysis of the pedagogical projects and school management plans of the schools in the education networks referenced in this research, more broadly, it is possible to infer that although all documents identify a concern with considering the community or students’ families, this consideration is expressed sometimes by seeking assistance focusing only on the teaching process or general education, sometimes for students’ behavioral and attendance issues, sometimes for participation in festivities, or it is verified with less evidence to involve them in school matters, or to observe their satisfaction with what the school proposes in its teaching processes.
It is observed that, in the case of three out of the four private schools for which it was possible to identify records for the first criterion, there is a concern to present the characteristics of the school community. However, these identified characteristics are hardly reflected in the school management proposals in favor of considering them in the teaching and learning process, as can be observed through the analysis of the second and third criteria. In the case of three out of the four municipal schools, the consideration of the socio-historical-cultural characteristics of the community occurs in the provision of vacancies, which, according to the records, are considered as community needs. In one of them, the recognition is presented taking into account other factors such as housing, employment, and social characteristics of the families. As in the private schools, these characteristics are little demonstrated in the pedagogical projects in favor of school management proposals considering the analysis criteria 2 (Proposals to promote the approximation of students’ families to the school for the purpose of recognizing their historical-cultural capital) and 3 (Proposals for pedagogical action involving management and teaching practices that consider the historical-cultural capital of the school community aiming at improving student learning outcomes).
Regarding the second criterion, which deals with the approximation of families to the school with the aim of recognizing their historical-cultural capital in favor of seeking curricular proposals that enable the improvement of learning, both in the records of municipal and private schools, the school’s consideration of students’ families presents itself, broadly speaking, as an intentionality to enable better conditions for student performance. However, upon closer analysis of the proposals, in private schools, this approximation is presented in three of the four schools as an opportunity to inform about learning outcomes, a partnership in solving teaching problems, or family involvement in supporting students, and in one of the schools, the approximation is shown in listening to families about their perceptions of the school’s actions.
In municipal network schools, the approximation occurs in proposals for festivities and school events, for the solution of problems of attendance, indiscipline, improvement of communication about incidents and with a view to the students’ school experiences, and in only one of the schools, the intention to value the community as a partner in their formation is identified. In view of the records, in both cases, the form of approximation between school and family distances itself from the action of recognizing their historical-cultural capital in favor of school proposals for the improvement of learning.
When analyzing the records based on the third criterion, which addresses pedagogical action involving management and teaching practices that consider the community’s historical-cultural capital to improve learning outcomes, it is observed that this concern is present in schools from both education networks. However, upon detailed analysis of each school, it is found that in private schools, the proposed pedagogical actions are aimed at gathering contextual information about the school and its surroundings, identifying family factors that hinder student support in their life project and their formation as citizens, improving communication and listening to families, and one of the four schools points out the intention to contribute to the elevation of the school community’s historical-cultural capital.
In municipal network schools, pedagogical actions indicate an intention to rescue the student’s identity as the subject of the learning process, fostering their participation in the social and political life of the community, making the school a place for coexistence and the construction of identity and educational opportunities among different social classes, a commitment to starting from students’ knowledge, valuing cultural spaces as learning spaces, establishing a communication process with the community and society.
Thus, by relating the aspects pointed out by private schools, as well as municipal networks, to the third analysis criterion, no effective pedagogical action proposals are verified involving management and teaching practices that seek to identify and take into account the characteristics of the socio-historical-cultural capital of the school community. The propositions point to the possible existence of a perception of the need to consider the peculiarities and characteristics of the community and territory, but, however, they present themselves as generalist and not very close to the intentions of planning pedagogical practices that enable better learning conditions for students.
The questionnaire applied to the school managers of the schools under study totaled nineteen respondents out of the twenty-two invited school managers from the two municipal education networks and the private education network. When analyzing the data from the first question proposed to the represented research participants, it is identified that 94.73% of the professionals working in school management in the two education networks hold a degree in pedagogy. In addition to pedagogical training, they inform that they have a bachelor’s or licentiate degree in art, biological sciences, computer science, literature, history, and mathematics. They also inform that 40% of the school managers in the municipal networks and 33.3% of the managers in the private network have completed postgraduate studies.
Regarding the time of experience in school management, they have an average of approximately nine years, with the average years of experience for managers of municipal schools being 5.2 years and for private schools being 12.7 years. Such data serve as important indicators for understanding school managers’ perception of their community and for proposing management actions and practices to improve student learning.
When analyzing the responses of participants from the two educational networks to question 2, it is observed that 84.2% of managers reported not living in the school’s neighborhood, and 15.8% reported living there. Of those who fully answered the question, all affirm that not living in the school’s neighborhood does not hinder the possibilities of knowing the cultural, social, and economic characteristics of the school community. Although, those who reported living in the neighborhood affirmed that it facilitates this knowledge.
Faced with the question, it is identified from the participants’ answers that 84.2%, considering the two education networks, demonstrate a clear perception of the school community’s historical-cultural capital, confirming what they stated when answering question 2. The answers to question 4 provide clues as to how this perception is built from the schools’ action proposals to bring families closer in favor of knowing their historical-cultural capital.
According to the responses presented by 94.73% of school principals to question 4, they highlight the report of actions aimed at fostering the approximation of families to school, such as: bringing parents to discuss school needs like renovations, resolving student situations, problems with teachers and staff, sports, and citizenship actions; family listening project to perceive families’ socioeconomic conditions; parent meetings, exhibitions and presentations, get-togethers, lectures, school council meetings; open and democratic communication seeking the best family-school relationship; interaction through media groups; interaction through online meetings; phone calls, sending messages, inviting families to school; open projects such as: sports-related project, cultural exhibition, meetings; proposals for valuing everyone’s culture; reflections in meetings with families, active listening to the needs of the school community; specific needs surveys; analysis for collective decision-making and validation with parents in meetings; institutional evaluation identifying with families the impacts of actions developed by the school throughout the school year; analysis of data collected in surveys; project to bring reading closer to families; valuing local artists; use of official communication channels.
Through the related actions, it can be inferred that there are many possibilities for school managers to recognize, gather analysis indicators, and build knowledge about the historical-cultural capital of their community. And, through these, reverberate in actions of studies, reflections, analyses, and propositions of the political-pedagogical project together with teachers, staff, parents, students, and other members that aim for proposals to improve student learning outcomes.
When analyzing the responses given by 100% of the research participants to question 5, it is observed that, according to their intentions and contexts, they present in their narratives multiple aspects of the school community that they take into consideration when formulating and systematizing management action proposals for the political-pedagogical project, aiming to improve student learning. Likewise, through the same narratives, they demonstrate possessing knowledge that may have been built through their own professional training, continuing education offered by their education networks, or empirically in daily school life over time of acting in school management. This is presumed to enable the recognition, analysis, and reflection on the pedagogical needs of the school according to the scope of each person’s understanding, as well as proposing actions in the political-pedagogical project as observed in the analyzed tables.
However, by taking the responses and criterion 3, which address elements of the schools’ political-pedagogical project, for analysis, it is identified that the narratives presented do not always translate into effective proposals for pedagogical project actions, as can be observed through the records. They also proposed various management actions to bring families closer to school, which can generate important indicators of the characteristics of families’ historical-cultural capital. However, these possible indicators and data, which can be gathered in these events, are not revealed to be articulated with the political-pedagogical projects in the form of actions aimed at pedagogical practices that favor the improvement of student learning, as described in criterion 3 for schools in both education networks.
Therefore, as a brief conclusion to the analyses presented, the political-pedagogical project should be understood by school management as a valuable opportunity for the involvement and consideration of the entire community in and for the awareness of the reality of the socio-historical-cultural capital and the territoriality in which the school is constituted, reverberating, according to Azanha[6], in reflections on its problems and difficulties, in the search for solutions and identification of collective and individual commitments in favor of propositions for actions and pedagogical practices that provide the improvement of student teaching and learning.
The research identified that school managers recognize or value the historical-cultural capital of the school community, but this does not always translate into effective actions for improving learning in the educational proposals of the pedagogical projects of public and private schools that were studied. Therefore, what becomes an essential issue given this finding is the need for managers to have clarity about what the data collected or gathered on the historical-cultural capital of the community that constitutes the school reveals.
So that, together with all those involved in the construction of the political-pedagogical project, they can reflect on the quality of the information and data that can be collected. From this perspective, the data collected through the instruments of this research point to a paradox between the proposals of the pedagogical projects and the reality of the schools, that is, it was observed that the analytical and reflective competence of school managers, regarding what the characteristics of the school community context reveal, impacts pedagogical proposals that are often disconnected from the real learning needs of students. Therefore, it is concluded that it is relevant to understand that there is a close link between the consideration of the historical-cultural capital of the school community and student learning, because, once considered in the schools’ pedagogical project, in the transposition of the prescribed curriculum to the curriculum in action on the classroom floor, it can be adjusted to learning needs, but without reducing it to superficiality, but favoring its reach and legitimation for all students, consequently improving the quality of learning.
Therefore, it is concluded about the need for school managers to critically and reflectively analyze what the data collected about the historical-cultural capital of their community reveal, so that they can, together with those involved in the construction of the political-pedagogical project, reflect and make decisions about what they indicate and what deserves attention, such as the six paths or hypotheses that follow: 1. needs pointed out to be addressed in favor of students’ permanence and success in their school trajectory; 2. curricular adjustments that must be made in the transposition of the prescribed curriculum to the curriculum in action in the teacher’s practices on the classroom floor; 3. bring the knowledge legitimized by the school closer to the students’ knowledge so that it also becomes legitimate to them; 4. value and consider in their educational proposals the territory and territorialities of which the school is constituted and part; 5. propose necessary strategies for families to participate in school decisions and validate school actions and, 6. identify which beliefs will need to be reviewed within the school universe in favor of the quality of student learning. In view of this analysis, it is certain that it will be up to the school manager to be willing to lead and conduct the process of self-reflection and reflection for the school, just as the need for public policies and internal policies of the education networks to favor this is also certain, therefore, it being a topic that urgently needs to be more widely explored.
References
[1] Bourdieu P.; Passeron J.C. A reprodução: elementos para uma teoria do sistema de ensino. 7ed. Petrópolis (RJ): Editora Vozes. 2014.
[2] Bourdieu P. O campo econômico. Política e Sociedade. 2005; 4(6): 15-57.
[3] Gadotti M. Escola Cidadã. 12ed. São Paulo (SP): Editora Cortez. 2008.
[4] Barroso J. A emergência do local e os novos modos de regulação das políticas
educativas. Educação: Temas e problemas. 2013; 12: 13-25.
[5] Freire P. Pedagogia da autonomia: saberes necessários à prática educativa.19ed. São Paulo (SP): Editora Paz e Terra.1996.
[6] Azanha J.M.P. Proposta Pedagógica e autonomia da escola. In: FIESP, SESI e SENAT. O que muda na educação brasileira com a nova lei de diretrizes e bases. 1997. Disponível em: <http://www3.fe.usp.br/secoes/inst/novo/acervo_jmpa/PDF_SWF/176.pdf>.
Como citar
Perdonatti V.M.P.; Martins M.P.R. Ações da gestão escolar a partir do reconhecimento do capital histórico-cultural de sua comunidade. Revista E&S. 2023; 4: e20230019.
Sobre os autores
Vera Maria Pupim Perdonatti, Supervisora de Ensino, Especialista em Gestão Escolar, Monte Alto, SP, Brasil.
Milena Pedroso Ruella Martins, Mestre em Educação e Coordenadora Pedagógica, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
Link para download: https://cms.revistaes.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/ES_23019.pdf