Article

Project Management

School Management

April 20, 2023

Implementation of agile discipline and education 3.0 in sustainable educational projects

DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-20230008
E&S 2023, 4: e20230008

Rútilo Pinheiro de Melo Neto; Maria Paula Novakoski Perides

The major changes the world is undergoing, since the beginning of the Innovation Era in 1980, have challenged traditional teaching models. The speed at which these changes occur makes content quickly obsolete and, increasingly, professionals will be valued for their skills, such as: autonomy, creativity, attitude, ability to perform under pressure, and problem-solving. In this context, the school needs to focus on developing these competencies. Learning based on Education 3.0 is a teaching method that promotes the development of competencies and skills through new digital pedagogical practices for the elaboration of well-planned and structured activities[1].

The educational process of this methodology is based on solutions linking content, whether in-person or virtual, with technological tools to dynamize knowledge construction, in a more significant and assertive way. Science, technology, and innovation provide quality educational scientific development for all involved. It is, therefore, an active methodology that promotes student autonomy and protagonism, stimulating self-learning and critical thinking with the use of new technologies to promote innovation in education[2].

Still within this active “mindset”, “Disciplined Agile” (DA) is also an approach that seeks to use the best project management practices and tools to produce a product that adds value to customers. To this end, a “Way of Working” (WoW) must be defined, meaning the team must choose the best way to work. To assist in improving project performance, following DA principles, the system of meetings (Scrum) and organization (Kanban) can be used, along with “Think-pair-share”, “Brainstorming”, planning screen (“Team Canvas basic” – Metric), identification of strengths and weaknesses, opportunities, and threats (SWOT), organization with a “Checklist” and continuous improvement actions (“Kaizen”).   

In educational projects, studying the problems and their solutions requires activities that must be developed from a common and shared target[3], with the aim of encouraging approaches to everyday problems, whether from the school community or its surroundings. Evaluating the project’s life cycle within the planned strategy with organization, execution, and monitoring of activities, provides more efficient and effective time and resource management.

Integrative projects are fundamental for the formation of expanded and complementary knowledge, skills, and attitudes, as they provide practical and multidisciplinary experience, being the foundation of integrated teaching (common and technical base). In parallel, participation in external events reinforces integrated activity for the development of this competence. Thus, Education 3.0 and “Disciplined Agile” present themselves as approaches that can contribute greatly to the conduction of integrative projects in schools, assisting in the proposal to develop students’ skills and competencies effectively. 

The objective of this study was to describe the application of the concept of Education 3.0 and “Disciplined Agile” in sustainable integrative projects of the State Technical School (ETE) and in a national science fair. Specifically, the following can be highlighted: i. Analyze the interactivity among participants through pair activities, “think-pair-share”, integrative projects, and external events; ii. Evaluate the use of technology practice in Education 3.0 and Disciplined Agile in weekly and virtual meetings; iii. Monitor the dynamics of integrative projects and event editions regarding the participation and improvement of members, including sustainability in educational projects; iv. Consolidate information to obtain performance data on the use of active methodologies in the ETE under analysis; v. Propose continuous improvement actions for future integrative projects and educational events.

This case study involved two integrative projects from a wastewater treatment plant (ETE) in Pernambuco with full-time and vocational education, selected in the Technological Development (DT) category for an event, which is one of the largest Science Fairs in Brazil. In this study, the use of these approaches in two integrative projects was analyzed: a. The HL project, focused on the sustainable restructuring of a school garden with knowledge dissemination to the school community about the importance of planting fruit trees and ornamental cacti. It also sought to bring new possibilities with recycled materials for the assembly of organic gardens; b. the GS project, which aimed at the integration of students with environmental education, through technological resources to raise awareness among students in elementary school II and high school in Pernambuco. In terms of environmental protection with the application of science, technology, and innovation, as well as promoting quality education, one of the Sustainable Development Goals – SDG-04, of the United Nations[4].

In 2020, the integrated project submitted was PROJETO HL and participated in the Science Fair. This research line was composed of seven students from integrated education. For the Science Fair, the team leader chose one member for the paired development of activities for the event. In 2021, the same quantitative procedure as the previous year was applied for the elaboration of the integrated project, that is, seven new members; and, once again, the leader chose one team member to form the pair for PROJETO GS submitted for the event. 

The proposition to improve the didactic-pedagogical process of the project was based on the integration of students with the DA and 3.0 education, which consisted basically of: involving active methodologies and WoW practices; monitoring student participation; and consolidating information. For the planning, execution, and control of projects, the approaches presented in Figure 1 were used, offering a set of tools (“tool kit”) to students, enabling the organization of the stages of acquired knowledge and the practice of self-management of actions, as well as assisting in the overall project management itself. This development of activities is based on virtual and technological procedures.

Thus, the continuous improvement cycle (Kaizen) proposed by the DA was adopted, which consisted of improving and perfecting the WoW, that is, adopting a change if it works; or discarding it if it does not meet expectations. In this Kaizen context, the models of the tools used to manage the project are included: Trello/Kanban, SWOT, Checklist, and Team Canvas Basic – Metric. Continuous improvement is the act of applying a series of “loops” to improve the WoW over time, guiding the orientation to help teams identify techniques that will likely work in a given context. This significantly increases the percentage of successful experiments and, therefore, increases the overall improvement rate of the learning process[5].

Figure 1. Approaches used in the integrative projects and science fair editions in the base years: (a) 2020 and (b) 2021 of events
Source: Prepared by the author.

The exploratory research was based on the application of questionnaires for the collection of qualitative evaluation data on the application of active methodologies in the ETE under study. For this purpose, the participants in this research were defined as professionals from the state technical school unit, who worked on integrated projects, life projects, external scientific events, and/or educational management projects; as well as, the high school technical students participating in the integrated projects HL (2020) and GS (2021) and the national science fair, simultaneously.     

To reach the target audiences, two academic research questionnaires were developed, available from February 4, 2022, to February 13, 2022. The first was applied to ETE professionals and consisted of 16 questions, 15 closed-ended and one open-ended, covering the respondent’s general data, self-assessment, active methodology assessment, and institution assessment. The second focused on students from the same ETE, as participants in the aforementioned projects, and contained 18 questions, 16 closed-ended and two open-ended, with sections for respondent’s general data, facilitator teacher assessment, active methodology assessment, and self-assessment. With the data obtained from the questionnaires, partial and total performance measurement was carried out on the use of active methodologies, applying the scale (0 to 5) to indicate totally disagree, partially disagree, indifferent, partially agree; and, totally agree.

Questionnaire 1 aimed to collect information regarding the perception of ETE professionals who worked with projects, obtaining 20 responses. The first question addressed the identification of job title and role of the respondents at ETE, and in summary, the survey identified the participants as: 75% from common and technical base teachers; and 25% management team. Revealing that, among the participating teachers, the majority were from the technical base, representing 55%. Regarding the type of project applied, 75% of teachers responded that they worked with integrating projects and only 10% with scientific projects for external events.

From the self-assessment stage, regarding the commitment to the integration of new learning technologies and engagement with the proposed digital practices, all respondents agreed with the propositions. Regarding the ability to arouse interest in new project practices, 90% agreed and 10% responded indifferent. From the active methodology evaluation stage, regarding the use of active methods for project development, all agreed on the application. Among the active methodologies applied in the projects, the institutional “Google Classroom” and “Google Forms” stand out, both achieving 90% of the responses. With regard to the application time of active methodologies in the ETE under study, 55% of the responses were from 1 to 3 years. 

Still in the stage, all respondents agreed that they obtained positive results by applying the active methodology for agility and engagement in the project’s actions. Regarding the effectiveness of virtual platforms, 75% of respondents agreed, with 90% agreeing that there was engagement to strengthen active methodologies in projects. From the stage about the institution’s evaluation, 80% of respondents stated that the technological resources met the needs, in contrast, regarding the issue of broadband access, 80% of respondents agreed with the difficulty in developing “online” practices for project development. 

The total performance, from the partial and total performances of questionnaire 1 applied with teachers and management team, pointed to a total yield of 81%, specifying the stage of self-assessment and active methodology assessment, the achieved indices were 92% and 86%, respectively. For the stage of the institution’s assessment in terms of technological resources and broadband connection, it achieved a performance of 55%.

According to the responses from professors and management staff, the most applied active methodologies in the projects were the institutional “Google Classroom” and “Google Forms”, indicating that few professors apply specific project tools, and consequently, are unaware of the potential to add value to deliverables. The respondents stated that they obtained positive results with the application of the methodologies and intend to continue using them, with more than half of the respondents having used active methodology for less than 3 years, coinciding with the period when the use of digital tools became mandatory due to the pandemic situation. Regarding the effectiveness of virtual platforms and engagement, the majority of respondents agreed that they were welcomed and participated in the process. Concerning broadband access, the majority of respondents agreed on the difficulty of developing “online” project development practices due to the lack of technological resources. This fact was minimized after the research was conducted, as the “professor conectado” program distributed “notebooks” and provided assistance for internet access to permanent professors, including contracted professors, as well as the management team.

Questionnaire 2, the students participating in the integrated projects and external event, totaling four respondents, namely, two students from the second year of the integrated HL Project and two students from the first year of the integrated GS project. Regarding the facilitator professor’s evaluation, all students from the HL and GS projects agreed that the professor was committed to the insertion of new technologies and digital practices, provided mechanisms for data collection and joint decision-making throughout the project.

Regarding the evaluation of the active methodology, the students of the HL and GS project agreed that the virtual platform (Trello/Kanban) was functional for understanding the project phases, as well as for adding agility and engagement to the actions. They also agreed that the virtual meetings (“on-line” meetings, Scrum type) were effective in the project development. 

For the members of the HL project, they agreed that access to broadband for online project practices was difficult, and one of them disagreed that the technological resources met all the needs. Whereas for the components of the GS project, it was not significant, regarding the difficulty of access to broadband at ETE, and there was no agreement on the supply of technological resources in relation to all needs. According to the evidenced calculations, regarding the partial and total performance of questionnaire 2, applied to the integrated technical high school students involved with the integrative project and external event, a total performance of 86% was achieved, and breaking down stage I of the facilitator professor’s evaluation, a yield of 96% was achieved, regarding stage III, the student’s self-evaluation was 82%. For stage II, the evaluation of the active methodology and technological resources and connection had a yield of 79%.   

Regarding the facilitator professor’s evaluation, all students from the HL and GS projects agreed that the professor was committed to the insertion of new technologies and positively evaluated the results of using active methodologies, reinforcing the positioning of teacher engagement in the process. Students from the HL and GS projects agreed that the virtual platforms (Trello/Kanban) were functional for understanding the project phases, as well as for adding agility, organization, and order to actions. They also agreed that the dynamics of virtual meetings (online meetings, Scrum type) were effective in the project’s development. 

For the members of the HL project in 2020, participants agreed that access to broadband for “online” project practices was difficult, and one of them disagreed that technological resources met all needs. For the components of the GS project in 2021, half partially agreed and the other half were indifferent. Regarding the difficulty of accessing broadband at ETE, half of the respondents disagreed that technological resources supplied all needs, showing a tendency for improvement in the need for digital resources, but indicating that this is still a limiting factor.

Thus, with the consolidation of knowledge through active methodologies tools, it is expected that students increase their engagement in research, including through the application of new technologies for practical assimilation of theoretical knowledge, currently studied in the integrated teaching of ETE. The tools of education 3.0 and DA will provide greater dynamism and technological impetus for questioning and learning, student protagonism at the center of learning, contextualization of knowledge, improvement of skills for problem-solving, as well as the development of competencies such as logical, creative, and analytical thinking aspects of projects. It is worth noting that the research results pointed to a low utilization of important active methodologies tools, such as “Design Thinking”, Gamification, “Project Based Learning”, indicating opportunities for improving this process through more training in active methodologies for teachers, discussion forums, and sharing of experiences, including, as a proposition, approaches between institutions.

References

[1] Sassaki C. Educação 3.0: Uma proposta pedagógica para a educação. 2019. Disponível em: <https://orientaeducacao.files.wordpress.com/2019/02/educac3a7c3a3o-3.0-uma-proposta-pedagc3b3gica.pdf>.

[2] Cavalcante A.N.; Lira G.V.; Cavalcante Neto P.G.; Lira R.C.M. 2018. Análise da produção bibliográfica sobre problem-based learning (PBL) em quatro periódicos selecionados. Revista Brasileira Educação Médica. 2018; 42(1).

[3] Walker A.; Leary H.; Hmelo-Silver C. E.; Ertmer P. A. Essential Readings in Problem-Based Learning. West Lafayette (IN): Purdue University Press. 2015.

[4] Organização das nações unidas. Objetivo de Desenvolvimento Sustentável: 4 – Educação de qualidade. 2021. Disponível em: <https://brasil.un.org/pt-br/sdgs/4>. [5] PMI. Foundation for Business Agility: Disciplined Agile. 2021. Disponível em: <www.pmi.org/disciplined-agile>.

Como citar

Melo Neto R.P.; Perides M.P.N. Implementação do discipline agile e educação 3.0 em projetos educacionais sustentáveis. Revista E&S. 2023; 4: e20230008.

Sobre os autores

Rútilo Pinheiro de Melo Neto, Professor na Secretaria de Educação do Estado de Pernambuco, Especialista em Gestão de Projetos, Recife, PE, Brasil

Maria Paula Novakoski Perides, Doutora em Administração, Gerente de Projetos Senior, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

Link para download: https://cms.revistaes.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/23008.pdf

You may also like

Project Management

November 06, 2026

Technical-economic Feasibility of Two Automation Levels in the Transition of an Industrial System

The study analyzed the technical-economic justification of medium and long-term investments in industrial systems automation, focusing on plastic industry factories that still maintain a significant part of their operations in manual routines. In these environments, the investment decision is complex, as production already generates revenue, even with losses, rework, low traceability, and unreliable data. The objective was to compare the implementation of Human-Machine Interface (HMI) and supervisory systems at different production scales. The methodological approach was mixed and applied, developed from a project management perspective, considering cost, risk, operational safety, raw material quality, traceability, data governance, production continuity, and decision-making support. Four reference cases were compared: HMI on one line, HMI on seven lines, supervisory on one line, and supervisory on seven lines. The results indicated that the HMI contributed to organizing and standardizing local operations, while the supervisory system expanded the capacity to record information, track histories, generate reports, support audits, and investigate bottlenecks. It was concluded that the investment justification should not be limited to immediate returns but should consider the reduction of uncertainties, losses, operational risks, and costs that accumulate over time.

Keywords: Data governance; Risk management; Traceability; Supervisory; Decision making.

School Management

October 13, 2026

Potentialities and Limits of Work Studios in the School Inclusion Process

The growing heterogeneity of the classroom and inclusive legislation have driven the search for pedagogical strategies that cater to student diversity, with active methodologies and the atelier organization, proposed by Celestin Freinet, standing out. In light of neuroscience, the potentialities and limits of organizing pedagogical work in ateliers for the school inclusion process were identified. To this end, a descriptive field survey research was conducted. Questionnaires were administered to six elementary school teachers from the public school system in Campinas, São Paulo, who used ateliers in their teaching practice. The responses were qualitatively analyzed to identify the contributions and limits of this pedagogical organization for inclusion. The results revealed that ateliers were configured as a powerful strategy for promoting personalized learning, peer interaction, and the development of student autonomy. However, significant limitations were observed related to the concrete working conditions of teachers, such as the high number of students per class, the absence of support staff, and the lack of time for collective planning. It was concluded that, although teachers have a broad conception of inclusion and knowledge of active practices, the effectiveness of inclusion is directly related to the institutional and structural conditions of the school.

Keywords: Inclusive education; Freinet; Active methodologies; Neuroscience; Pedagogical practice.

School Management

October 13, 2026

From bureaucracy to recognition: school management strategies to reduce teacher overload

Given the intensification of bureaucracy in the contemporary educational context, especially in the post-pandemic period, the study analyzed the impacts of administrative demands on teaching work, considering their implications for school organization and teaching quality. The objective was to investigate the perception of pedagogical coordinators and principals regarding school bureaucracy, as well as to identify management practices capable of reducing administrative overload and promoting greater institutional balance. A qualitative, exploratory-descriptive approach was adopted, based on the multiple case study method. Data collection was carried out through semi-structured questionnaires applied to three managers from two private basic education institutions, with the responses analyzed using the content analysis technique. The results indicated that bureaucracy is recognized as a necessary element for the organization of school work, especially regarding planning, evaluation records, and pedagogical monitoring. However, when structured in a fragmented and redundant way, it was associated with rework, loss of pedagogical time, and intensification of teaching work. On the other hand, collaborative management practices and strategies for integrating and organizing processes showed potential to mitigate these effects. It was concluded that the effectiveness of school bureaucracy depends on its organization on integrated bases and its articulation with pedagogical purposes.

Keywords: Bureaucratization of education; Organizational culture; Organizational efficiency; Process improvement; Professional appreciation.

School Management

October 09, 2026

Teacher Training for Socioemotional Skills: an analysis of management strategies in Belo Horizonte – MG

This study investigated management practices that support teacher training for socio-emotional skills in the municipal network of Belo Horizonte (MG). The objective was to analyze the municipal network’s management strategies for socio-emotional training, confronting them with the state guidelines of Minas Gerais and observing how they align or diverge. A qualitative documentary research was used, which traced the itinerary of public policies and analyzed how the guidelines were transposed and reorganized between the state and municipal spheres. Content analysis, based on Bardin (2011), was applied to the Minas Gerais Reference Curriculum, the Training School platform, and the Socio-emotional Project. The results revealed that the municipality recontextualized the state guidelines, adapting them to local realities and generating a diversity of strategies. However, a prioritization of self-instructional models was observed, which weakened dialogue and knowledge exchange, as well as an intensification of teacher work with the attribution of socio-emotional responsibilities without adequate institutional support. It was concluded that, despite the documentary alignment, management strategies lack effective mechanisms for practical viability and the materialization of proposals in daily school life, requiring a structure that sustains the complexity of teaching practice.

Keywords: Socio-emotional skills; Teacher training; School management; Educational policies.

School Management

October 09, 2026

Active Methodologies: A New Look at Pedagogical Practice in the School Space

Brazilian education faced challenges related to student engagement, motivation, and proactivity in the teaching-learning process, which drove the adoption of innovative pedagogical practices in the school context. The impact of active methodologies on the pedagogical process was investigated, analyzing their contribution to student engagement, autonomy, and proactivity, as well as to the redefinition of the teacher’s role. The research was characterized as a field survey, with a quantitative approach, complemented by qualitative analyses of open-ended responses. It was conducted with teachers from Elementary Education in public and private schools in the city of São Paulo. Data were collected through digital questionnaires, which addressed the frequency of use of active methodologies, teacher perception of student engagement and autonomy, implementation challenges, and impacts on pedagogical planning. The results indicated that the use of active methodologies favored student participation, expanded their autonomy, and promoted significant changes in classroom dynamics, in addition to contributing to the transformation of the teacher’s role, who assumed the function of a mediator. Challenges such as lack of planning time, inadequate infrastructure, and the need for continuous training were identified. It was concluded that active methodologies constitute relevant strategies for the improvement of pedagogical practices and for the promotion of more meaningful learning in the school environment.

Keywords: Meaningful learning; Teaching-learning; Pedagogical innovation; Teaching practice; Student proactivity.

School Management

October 09, 2026

Reliable professional activities in the internship of the technical nursing course: evaluation of competence development

The staged evaluation in technical nursing education faces challenges in the fragmentation of criteria and in monitoring student development. The objective was to describe and analyze the creation process of Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) as an educational management tool in technical nursing education. A qualitative, applied case study was conducted in a private institution in São Paulo. The research used documentary analysis of institutional records, evaluation rubrics, and materials produced during the construction of the EPAs, between 2023 and 2024, with content analysis. The results revealed that the previous evaluation model presented limitations in the fragmentation of criteria and the absence of explicit progression. The creation of the EPAs was mediated by the coordination, which managed faculty disagreements and defined evaluation criteria. The selection of activities prioritized practical feasibility and observability during internships. The final model organized the evaluation by levels of confidence and made the progression explicit, requiring continuous alignment between evaluators and institutional adaptation. It was concluded that the creation of the EPAs was configured as a management process that involved pedagogical mediation, definition of criteria, and adaptation to institutional conditions.

Keywords: Educational evaluation; Health education; Nursing internship; School management.