Article

Financial Management

Tax Management

February 03, 2023

Legal limits in the development of business tax planning

DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-20230006
E&S 2023,4: e20230006

Marcela Robles Queiroz e Leonardo Cosme Formaio

The analysis on the legal limits affecting the development of tax planning aims to present its relevant importance for companies, in such a way that tax planning carried out assertively and effectively consists of reducing the high tax burden existing in Brazil[1]. What does tax planning do?

Tax planning, in addition to allowing the reduction of the amount of taxes by postponing payment without incurring fines, penalties, and the occurrence of the taxable event, is the legal way to decrease the tax burden. There are two factors that determine the importance of tax planning in companies, namely, the high fiscal burden and the complexity of the existing tax legislation[2], [3]. It is important to note that the constitutional principles that support the development of corporate tax planning are Tax Avoidance and Tax Evasion.

Tax avoidance must be considered an effective method, being the lawful way available to taxpayers who aim for a less burdensome tax burden and which presents legal limits, being a practice accepted by the legal system, thus opposing illicit and illegitimate practices. In contrast, there is tax evasion, which consists of carrying out illicit acts, such as fraud, tax evasion, and simulation, to avoid paying taxes[4].

Furthermore, the importance of tax planning consists in reducing the business’s tax burden, being carried out lawfully, within the applicable legal limits, aiming at the analysis of the real motive sought by the taxpayer, that is, whether the planning’s purpose is tax economy or tax evasion.

In this context, the problem consists of developing an assertive and effective tax planning, generating tax reduction, as well as its applicable legal limitations and the scope of the sole paragraph of article 116 of the National Tax Code[5].

The research conducted and the practical case analyzed made it possible to identify the existing legal limits in tax planning, its principles, and its fundamental importance and applicability, thus aiming for assertiveness in reducing the tax burden with bases provided for in the legislation.

Currently in Brazil, there is a complex tax system and legislation with established rules and norms that overload the understanding of which is the best taxation regime and which taxes apply to business. To assist in the taxation of companies with the reduction of high tax burdens, tax planning emerged, which aims at the optimization of the reduction of the tax burden in a lawful manner and a better understanding of current legislation[6], [7].

Business tax planning aims to evaluate the business, applying the appropriate tax legislations and, consequently, reducing exorbitant payments and avoiding tax losses, double taxation, and high payments of unnecessary taxes for the business.

For the development of tax planning, Fiscal Evasion and Tax Evasion are relevant principles. Regarding Fiscal Evasion, it is something lawful that avoids or reduces the incidence of taxes, whereas in the case of Tax Evasion, it is something unlawful, which generates intent, fraud, and the practice of illicit business[6].

In order to ensure effective and assertive tax planning, it is supported by Tax Avoidance, with the purpose of avoiding legal penalties, being a broader and more comprehensive concept of carrying out planning within the law.

It is important to note that legal limits aim to analyze the real motive behind the taxpayer’s intended reduction of the tax burden, verifying if such a method truly and lawfully characterizes tax savings in the business. This concept aligns with the duty to pay and does not oppose tax avoidance, provided that simulation, which aims to reduce the tax burden by using atypical means to conceal a hidden transaction, does not occur.

Regarding the legal limits (article 116 of the National Tax Code – CTN[5]), it is important to remember that many scholars understand it as an anti-avoidance rule, aimed at opposing the dissimulation of the real tax-generating event, which conceals the actual activity to benefit from the reduction of the tax burden. The anti-avoidance rule does not aim to combat tax avoidance, but rather tax evasion[2], [3]. Thus, the legal aspect developed in article 116 of the National Tax Code[5] is a legal imposition, which determines as a limit in tax planning the illicit way of concealing activity to benefit from the reduction of the tax burden. It is of fundamental importance for the taxpayer to benefit from the reduction of the tax burden lawfully, with the use of assertive tax planning that aims to analyze the real business and the best Tax system, where a reduction in the tax burden and, consequently, savings in tax collection will be possible.

The doctrinal manifestations regarding article 116 CTN[5] define the understanding as the anti-avoidance rule, which aims at the lawful form of carrying out tax planning. It is necessary to consider that tax planning has legal bases that aim at tax reduction, as the taxpayer has the right to improve the structure of their business, thus seeking cost reduction, including taxes unnecessary to the nature of the business operation, contributing to better fiscal and financial regularity of the company.

The applicability of tax planning in companies, and the analysis of the applicable legal limits, must be carried out within the legally established frameworks, in such a way that they lead to a lawful reduction of the tax burden, avoiding penalties, non-payment of taxes, and fiscal burdens on companies.

The analysis carried out consisted of the installation service of air conditioning units with partial and total global contracting, requiring the development of engineering projects with the supervision of specialized engineers and teams at the locations where the services are performed, as well as the application of essential materials intended for the execution of services and the installation of equipment.

For the performance of air-conditioning installation services, contained within civil construction services, it is essential to have engineers involved, as provided for in Article 7 of Section IV of Law 5194/1966[8], which regulates the exercise of the engineering profession. Among the activities and attributions of an engineer, we have some examples: planning, design, supervision, and execution of the work; services which are listed within civil construction.

As provided for in Article 156 of the 1988 Federal Constitution[9], [10], the Tax on Services of Any Nature (ISSQN) is a tax within the competence of the Union, the States, the Federal District, and the Municipalities, and, in Article 146, item III of the same Constitution, it establishes as general rules that each municipality needs to regulate the tax, always respecting the dictates of Complementary Law 116/2003[5], which regulates the service tax nationwide.

In Complementary Law 116/2003[5], there are some important articles. Article 3 lists the services that characterize the incidence of ISS. For service 7.02, related to civil construction, it is found in item III of the aforementioned article. Article 7, in its second paragraph, establishes that the calculation basis for services performed in civil construction related to engineering will be the price of the service, excluding the materials applied in the execution of the services.

It turns out that, in the aforementioned Law, there is no characterization of applied material or permitted percentage for deduction, only that materials are not included in the calculation base of the ISS, generating several impasses related to the real interpretation of the Legislation by the fiscalizations and Municipal Laws.

It is worth remembering that the services subject to ISS retention, considered in Article 3 of Complementary Law 116/2003[5], are due in the place where the service is provided, and it is of utmost importance to observe, in addition to the aforementioned Law, the Municipal Laws where the service was provided, as this will be the place for the due tax collection.

Given some impositions by municipal inspections, regarding applied materials, where many understand as incorporated material to the work that which cannot be removed from the site, such as cement, this material requires a new construction to be removed, where it will be totally dismantled. As another example, the screw can be cited, which is understood to be removable, not being incorporated into the work, this fact opposes Complementary Law 116/2003[5], regarding materials applied in the provision of services that do not integrate the tax base. In other cases, there are municipalities that do not allow the deduction of applied materials, forcing the retention of ISS on the total service value, including applied materials in the tax base, thus causing double taxation of the tax, thereby generating distinct understandings among municipalities regarding the legislation regulating ISS, which is Complementary Law 116/2003[5].

In the installation service of air conditioning units, such units and materials used have already been taxed by ICMS, as in practice the ICMS has its value included in the price of the product at the moment of its sale or the service provided.

It is worth remembering that construction materials, as of 2009, were subject to the ICMS tax substitution system in member states. Therefore, it can be analyzed that the ICMS is collected by the industry throughout the circulation of goods until they reach the final consumer, which is why it cannot be taxed by the ISS. The ISS is mandatorily taxed only on the service performed, with the material or equipment deducted from the ISS calculation base[11], as provided for in Complementary Law 116/2003[5], thus avoiding double taxation of the tax.

Thus, determining the inclusion of materials in the calculation base of the ISS leads to the understanding of taxing twice, different taxes, for the same taxable event. That is, ICMS has already been taxed on the circulation of goods until it reaches the final consumer, which in some States is taxed by tax substitution. If the materials are included in the ISS calculation base, there will thus be taxation by the latter as well. It is evident that materials acquired from third parties and applied in the construction cannot be part of the ISS calculation base, and therefore must be deducted from the tax calculation base.

It is necessary to consider that some municipalities strictly follow Complementary Law 116/2003[5], allowing the deduction of materials from the ISS calculation base without limiting the deduction percentage. Other municipalities create rules and limits related to the allowed deduction percentage, and there are others that do not allow the deduction, thus being in disagreement with the tax’s regulatory Law.

It should be noted that the present research aimed to present the importance of effective and assertive tax planning, carried out through the analysis of the business and the adaptation of the tax system in the company, thus avoiding the exorbitant payment of taxes. However, with the use of Tax Evasion, we can have lawful tax planning and thus achieve savings in the tax burden[12]. The sole paragraph of article 116 of the National Tax Code[5] and doctrinal manifestations are well articulated and defined, concluding that its objective is to avoid tax dissimulation, which occurs illicitly. In this context, it is worth remembering that the objective was to demonstrate the oppositions related to Complementary Law 116/2003[5], which regulates the tax on any service, which significantly impacts some aspects related to the tax burden, generating double taxation in the incidence of the tax on any service (ISS) and, consequently, generating a burden for businesses. As a result, it was found that it is of fundamental importance to review municipal legislation or include a regulation in Complementary Law 116/2003[5], with the definition of materials that can be deducted from the tax base and their percentages. With the elaboration of a single regulation, it will be possible to avoid different interpretations by municipal tax authorities related to the subject matter, thus avoiding double taxation.

References

[1] Sabbag E. Manual de direito tributário. 5ed. São Paulo: Editora Saraiva; 2013.

[2] Borges H.B. Planejamento tributário. 12ed. São Paulo: Editora Atlas; 2012.

[3] Borges H.B. 2011. Gerência de Impostos. 7ed. São Paulo: Editora Atlas; 2011.

[4] Rodrigues A.O; Proença A.E.; Busch C.M.; Garcia E.R.; Toda W.H. Aspectos jurídicos do Planejamento Tributário. 1ed. São Paulo: IOB; 2012.

[5] Brasil. Presidência da República. Lei n. 116, de 31 de julho de 2003. Dispõe sobre o Imposto Sobre Serviços de Qualquer Natureza, de competência dos Municípios e do Distrito Federal, e dá outras providências. Brasília, DF; 2003.

[6] Torres R. Planejamento tributário. 2ed. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Elsevier; 2013.

[7] Brasil. Presidência da República. Lei n. 5172, de 25 de outubro de 1966. Dispõe sobre o Sistema Tributário Nacional e institui normas gerais de direito tributário aplicáveis à União, Estados e Municípios. Brasília, DF; 1966.

[8] Brasil. Presidência da República. Lei n. 5194, de 24 de dezembro de 1966. DF, Senado Federal. Regula o exercício das profissões de Engenheiro, Arquiteto e Engenheiro-Agrônomo, e dá outras providências. Brasília, DF; 1966.

[9] Brasil. Presidência da República. Emenda constitucional nº 3, de 17 de março de 1993. Brasília, DF; 1993

[10] Brasil. Presidência da República. Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil. Brasília, DF; 1988.

[11] Brasil. Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF). Tema 247 – Incidência do ISS sobre materiais empregados na construção civil. 2020. Disponível em: <https://portal.stf.jus.br/jurisprudenciaRepercussao/verAndamentoProcesso.asp?incidente=3771005&numeroProcesso=603497&classeProcesso=RE&numeroTema=247>.

[12] Machado, H.B. Introdução ao planejamento tributário. Vol. II. 2ed. São Paulo: Malheiros Editores; 2014.

Como citar

Queiroz M.R.; Formaio L.C. Limites jurídicos na elaboração de um planejamento tributário empresarial. Revista E&S. 2023; 4: e20230006.

Sobre os autores

Marcela Robles Queiroz, Graduada em Ciências Contábeis, Especialista em Gestão Tributária, Diadema, SP, Brasil.

Leonardo Cosme Formaio, Mestre em Direito Negocial, Especialista em Direito Empresarial, Londrina, PR, Brasil.

Link para download: https://cms.revistaes.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/ES_23006_.pdf

You may also like

Tax Management

October 13, 2026

Impacts of the Tax Reform on Fiscal Incentives in the Fertilizer Industries in Rio Grande do Sul

This study analyzed the potential impacts of the tax reform on tax incentives applicable to the fertilizer industries in Rio Grande do Sul. The objective was to identify the main state tax incentives, analyze the changes resulting from the reform, and evaluate their effects on the tax burden of operations. The research adopted a mixed methodological approach, of an exploratory-descriptive nature, combining qualitative and quantitative analysis. Documentary analysis of Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and tax legislation was used, complemented by a case study in a company in the fertilizer sector, whose data supported simulations. A simulation of the incidence of the Tax on Goods and Services (IBS) and the Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS) was carried out, considering estimated rates and the sectoral reduction foreseen for agricultural inputs. The results showed a change in the logic of tax incentives, with the substitution of direct benefits for a non-cumulative system and greater potential for credit utilization. However, the impact of the reform was not uniform, being directly related to the operational structure of companies and the nature of suppliers. It was concluded that the sector’s competitiveness will depend on efficient management of the credit chain and the reorganization of operations, requiring companies to adapt to the new rules proposed by the Tax Reform.

Keywords: CBS; Tax credit; IBS; ICMS; Non-cumulativity.

Tax Management

October 09, 2026

Cryptocurrencies as an investment asset: risks and opportunities for the Brazilian investor

The growing insertion of cryptocurrencies in the financial market and the uncertainties about their role in investment portfolios motivated this study. Cryptoassets, focusing on Bitcoin and Ethereum, were analyzed as investment assets, evaluating their impacts on the risk and return of portfolios composed of traditional assets for the Brazilian investor. The methodology was based on Modern Portfolio Theory, simulating portfolios with different allocation levels in cryptoassets (0%, 5%, 10%, and 20%) using daily data from January 2018 to December 2024. Performance metrics were calculated, such as annualized average return, volatility, and Sharpe ratio, in addition to risk measures, including Value at Risk and Conditional Value at Risk, and a dynamic evaluation was performed using rolling windows of 252 business days. The results indicated that the inclusion of cryptoassets contributed to the improvement of the risk-return relationship of the portfolios. However, it was found that the gain in risk-adjusted performance was accompanied by a disproportionate increase in volatility and exposure to extreme losses, configuring a trade-off between efficiency and absolute risk. Moderate allocation levels (5% to 10%) proved to be more compatible with the profile of the Brazilian investor. The evidence suggested that cryptoassets can be used as a diversification tool in investment portfolios, provided that their allocation is carried out judiciously and is compatible with the investor’s risk profile.

Keywords: Asset allocation; Digital assets; Portfolio diversification; Sharpe ratio; Modern portfolio theory.

Tax Management

October 09, 2026

Fiscal Governance and the Transition to the IBS: Strategic Challenges in the Municipalities of Cioeste/SP

The Tax Reform, instituted by Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023, imposed a management challenge on Brazilian municipalities by replacing the Service Tax (ISS) with the Tax on Goods and Services (IBS), shifting the collection paradigm from origin to destination. The research investigated the vulnerability of fiscal sustainability and budgetary autonomy of the municipalities belonging to the Cioeste-SP Consortium during this structural transition. The objective was to project collection scenarios for the period from 2026 to 2032 under the transition rules and evaluate the impact of tax substitution on municipal revenue. The methodology adopted consisted of a multiple case study, with a quantitative and descriptive approach, based on the comparative analysis of ISS and ICMS quota collection data from 2022 to 2025. The main results revealed a profound disparity in the region: service hubs showed a dependence on ISS greater than 40% and high per capita collection, while dormitory-profile municipalities operated with dependence rates below 10%. The implications for tax management indicated the need for administrative reengineering, including the restructuring of teams to work with the IBS Management Committee and the strengthening of direct revenues. It was concluded that strategic fiscal governance and inter-municipal planning were vital instruments to mitigate risks and ensure budgetary predictability during the period.

Keywords: Destination-Based Collection; Municipal Autonomy; Fiscal Federalism; Tax Reform; Fiscal Sustainability.

Tax Management

October 09, 2026

Corporate Social Responsibility and business performance in a market influenced by new generations

Socio-environmental issues have gained increasing relevance in the corporate context, influencing consumer evaluation of organizations and their purchasing choices. The influence of sustainability and corporate social responsibility on consumption decisions and organizational performance was analyzed, considering differences between age groups. The research, of an applied nature, with a qualitative and quantitative approach and exploratory character, was conducted through a field survey with a structured questionnaire, applied to 104 respondents. The data were analyzed with descriptive statistics and by constructing socio-environmental engagement indices, complemented by comparisons between age groups. The purchase decision was predominantly determined by traditional attributes, such as quality and price, while sustainability acted as a brand exclusion criterion, establishing minimum acceptability limits. Higher levels of socio-environmental engagement were observed among older individuals, revealing a mismatch between declared engagement and actual behavior. Sustainable practices showed an indirect relationship with organizational performance, mediated by corporate reputation, risk perception, and long-term value generation. It was concluded that sustainable action constitutes a requirement for legitimacy and permanence of companies in the contemporary market, transcending the role of a competitive differential. The study contributed methodologically with the proposition of behavioral and perceptual engagement indices for sustainability analysis.

Keywords: Consumer behavior; Purchase decision; ESG; Organizational reputation; Sustainability.

Tax Management

October 09, 2026

Utilization of ICMS Credits on Intermediate Products: Jurisprudence and Impacts on Corporate Tax Management

The ICMS tax credit regime on intermediate products has gained practical and legal relevance due to the jurisprudential expansion of the functional essentiality criterion and the impacts of its application on corporate tax management. The study analyzed how two industries in the furniture sector located in Rio Grande do Sul applied the understanding of the Superior Court of Justice regarding ICMS credits related to intermediate products, evaluating the conformity of the observed practices with the examined normative and jurisprudential parameters. The investigation was applied in nature and conducted through a multiple case study, with a qualitative and descriptive approach, based on the documentary analysis of fiscal, accounting, and operational information from two medium-sized industries located in Rio Grande do Sul, complemented by the examination of normative, doctrinal, and jurisprudential sources and the development of a checklist of essentiality criteria. The results revealed that recent jurisprudence favored the functional essentiality of the input, allowing the crediting of items consumed or gradually worn out when necessary for the core business activity. However, it was evident that the effectiveness of this regime depended on the companies’ ability to internalize these parameters into uniform classification and documentation criteria. The secure implementation of credit utilization was conditioned less by the existence of legal support and more by overcoming internal filters of economic materiality, classificatory heterogeneity, and evidentiary insufficiency in borderline items, which highlighted the need for consistent fiscal governance.

Keywords: Functional essentiality; Multiple case study; Fiscal governance; Non-cumulative taxation; Furniture sector.

Tax Management

October 09, 2026

Internationalization in the Fabric Processing Industry: A Comparative Study between Presumed Profit and Actual Profit

This study analyzed the tax impacts of internationalization in a Brazilian textile processing industry, comparing the Presumptive Profit and Real Profit regimes and their effects on business competitiveness. The research, of an applied nature and qualitative approach, used a case study based on the analysis of the organization’s economic, fiscal, and operational data for the fiscal year 2025. Tax incentives applicable to exports were examined, such as the exemption of Tax on Industrialized Products (IPI), ICMS, PIS, and COFINS, and the possibility of maintaining tax credits. Comparative scenarios were developed between the regimes, considering the effective tax burden, pricing, cash flow, administrative complexity, and economic viability. The results showed that export operations provided a significant reduction in the indirect tax burden and the maintenance of credits, improving competitiveness. However, the simulations indicated that, even with the utilization of PIS and COFINS credits under the Real Profit regime, the overall tax burden calculated was higher than that of the Presumptive Profit regime, resulting in a lower net profit. It was concluded that remaining in the Presumptive Profit tax system proved more advantageous for the company in the analyzed scenario, and that taxation plays a strategic role in competitiveness, providing subsidies for decision-making in a complex fiscal environment.

Keywords: Tax credits; Tax exemption; Calculation regime.