Administration
Stock Exchange
Tax Management
January 13, 2023
Management of tax risks in the recognition of contingent assets by publicly traded companies
DOI: 10.22167/2675-6528-20230001
E&S 2023,4: e20230001
Rafaella Alencar Ribeiro e Eliza Remédio Alecrim
Given the international convergence of accounting standards in Brazil, Resolution CFC No. 1,055/2005[1], from the Federal Accounting Council (CFC), created the Accounting Pronouncements Committee (CPC), with the objective of elaborating technical documents on accounting procedures, in order to centralize and standardize the process of standard production by the Brazilian regulatory entity and avoid the risks related to the subjectivity of each company in the elaboration and disclosure of information of this nature. In September 2009, Technical Pronouncement CPC 25[2] was released, which determines the criteria for the appropriate recognition and measurement basis for provisions, liabilities, and contingent assets.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM), established by Law No. 6.385/1976[3], with the objective of overseeing and developing the Brazilian securities market, plays a significant role in accounting elaborations for these companies, as the technical areas of this federal autarchy are responsible for issuing guidelines and opinions on the subject, in order to preserve the quality of information disseminated in the market.
The concern of these technical areas is regarding the risk to which companies listed on the B3 stock exchange are subjected, and also to their investors, whether due to the impact on share prices, or the possibility of distributing dividends and/or remunerating administrators based on untrue results.
Risk management in the disclosure of accounting statements is essential for reducing investor uncertainty, increasing the effectiveness of the financial market and the company’s corporate governance. Furthermore, accounting information offers greater transparency to users about the risk and return of their investments, which is essential for maintaining the reliability of publicly traded companies[4], so that mandatory disclosure for companies serves as a commitment instrument, as it is necessary for such information to be disclosed at any time, whether good or bad.
To illustrate its relevance, an emblematic case involving the recognition of contingent assets that significantly affected the accounting statements of a company listed on B3 is cited: a company that overvalued its net worth by 4.38% by recognizing an active contingency amounting to R$ 28 million, thereby increasing investor uncertainty regarding the company’s future.
In this sense, the assessment of the tax risks to which these companies are subjected when registering and disclosing their financial statements is essential, considering that it is up to each company’s management, supported by the opinion of its legal advisors, to decide on the accounting recognition of tax credits in the financial statements, and it is not up to the technical areas of the Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) to delve into the merits and procedures adopted by each company. Therefore, good corporate governance is ideal.
Technical Pronouncement CPC 25
The CPC, created by CFC Resolution nº 1.055/2005[1], aims to reduce the risk related to subjectivity in the preparation of companies’ financial statements, through the development of technical standards on the subject. In June 2009, the CPC approved Technical Pronouncement CPC 25[2], which determines the accounting treatment and disclosure requirements for provisions, contingent liabilities, and contingent assets.
For a better understanding of the topic, however, before analyzing each of these items, it is essential that the concepts probable, possible, and remote are presented. The CFC, through Resolution CFC No. 1.022/2005[5], established, for independent auditors, the minimum procedures to be considered for the identification of liabilities and assets related to judicial processes, in order to ensure the best form of disclosure to its users. According to CFC[2]: probable indicates the highest probability of the event occurring, as when the matter is undisputed and there is unanimous jurisprudence on the subject in the Courts, in repetitive and/or general repercussion proceedings; possible: indicates that this gain and/or loss may occur, as the matter is controversial in the Courts; and remote indicates that the probability of the company losing is high, either due to repetitive proceedings contrary to the defended thesis or lack of evidentiary elements.
Furthermore, if the company has a present obligation from a past event, it is probable that an outflow of financial resources will be required to settle that obligation and the amount involved can be reliably measured, it is a provision[6].
Contingent liabilities, in turn, can arise in three situations:
- when there is an obligation (expense) that will possibly occur due to past events, depending on some future event that is not under the entity’s control;
- when there is a present obligation that also results from past events, but which is not recognized due to the absence of financial expenditure to fulfill that obligation;
- when there is a present obligation resulting from past events, but which is not recognized due to the absence of reliable measurement of the amount paid (item 10 of CPC 25[2]).
Thus, provisions are distinguished from contingent liabilities. In this sense, Table 1 presents the accounting treatment to be adopted for the recording of provisions and contingent liabilities, as set forth in Appendix A of CPC 25[2]:
Table 1. Accounting Treatment: Provisions and contingent liabilities
| Definition | They arise in situations involving the outcome of past events, in which an outflow of resources is possible involving future expenses in the settlement of that (a) present obligation; or (b) obligation that may arise, depending on the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more future uncertain events. | ||
| Accounting treatment | Probable: There is an obligation present that will certainly lead to an outflow of financial resources. | Possible: There is a possible obligation or present obligation, which may or may not have a resource outflow. | Remote: There is an obligation possible or present whose probability of outflow of resources is low. |
| Accounting recognition | The provision (item 14) is recognized. | The provision (item 27) is not recognized. | The provision (item 27) is not recognized. |
| Disclosure in explanatory notes | The disclosure is required for the provision (items 84 and 85). | Disclosure is required for the contingent liability (item 86). | Disclosure is not required (item 86). |
Source: Elaborated by the author based on Technical Pronouncement CPC[2].
Contingent assets, in turn, arise from a probable, but uncertain, inflow of economic benefit (revenue), the existence of which – as with contingent liabilities – will be confirmed by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events, over which the company has no control. Contingent assets may arise from: i. repetition of undue taxes collected at a higher and/or incorrect amount; ii. actions for the non-existence of legal relationships, resulting in an inflow of economic benefits[4]. Incidentally, according to Technical Pronouncement Adapted from CPC 25[2], the accounting treatment to be given to these records can be understood, as presented in Table 2:
Table 2. Accounting Treatment: Contingent Asset
| Definition | They arise in situations involving the outcome of past events, in which there is a possible revenue, the existence of which may or may not be confirmed due to an uncertain future event, over which the company has no control. | ||
| Accounting treatment | It is practically certain the entry of economic benefits. | The economic benefits inflow is not certain, but it is probable. | The cash inflow is not likely. |
| Accounting recognition | The asset is not contingent (item 33). | The asset is not recognized (item 31). | The asset is not recognized (item 31). |
| Disclosure in explanatory notes | The disclosure is required (item 89). | No disclosure is required (item 89). | |
Source: Prepared by the author based on Technical Pronouncement CPC 25[2].
When the inflows of economic benefits are virtually certain, the asset is not contingent and should be recognized in earnings as accounts receivable. Therefore, the accounting treatment, in light of what is determined by Technical Pronouncement CPC 25[2], must be subjectively evaluated by each publicly traded company, supported by its administrators and independent auditors, since such information impacts the price of its shares. Thus, the recorded and disclosed information is significant for investors and creditors alike, and from an administrative and managerial perspective, for the company.
Hernandez and Martins[8]allege that, based on the consolidated financial statements, investors or creditors are allowed a more thorough analysis to guarantee the profitability of their investments. Furthermore, these statements offer information about i. the group’s liquidity and debt ratios; ii. resource generation potential; and iii. the company’s profitability ratios.
From an administrative and managerial point of view, consolidated financial statements enable companies to: i. cash flow; ii. better administration and management of their financial resources; iii. bank reciprocity; iv. evaluation of financial expenditure needs; v. reduction of taxes on unrealized profits; and vi. better tax planning.
Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM)
Law No. 6.385/1976[3] created the Securities and Exchange Commission of Brazil (CVM) – a federal autarchy linked to the Ministry of Finance, but without hierarchical subordination – with the objective of developing, disciplining, inspecting, and standardizing the Brazilian securities market. In this regard, normative guidelines are issued by CVM’s technical areas regarding the aspects to be observed by companies in the preparation and disclosure of accounting statements, as is the case with Guidance Opinions and circular letters.
The Opinions of Guidance issued by the CVM guide companies regarding the accounting procedures necessary for the disclosure of information, whether in explanatory notes or in the administrators’ report. The circular letters, in turn, aim to express the understanding of the technical areas of the Superintendence of Accounting and Audit Standards (SNC) and the Superintendence of Corporate Relations (SEP) regarding the adequate preparation of the financial statements of these companies.
As the aforementioned technical areas of the CVM do not have legal competence nor specific technical capacity in tax matters, they are not permitted to delve into the merits of the tax accounting and tax procedures adopted by each company. However, they present significant information to be followed by the companies, as it is up to the management of each company, supported by the opinion of its legal advisors, to decide on the accounting recognition of tax credits in the financial statements.
Tax risk management
So that revenues or assets are not overvalued and expenses or liabilities are undervalued, it is necessary for companies to be supported by a statement from their legal advisors, as well as by their independent auditors, who are responsible for evaluating, administering, and managing tax risks.
The risk occurs when there is a possibility that the results will not materialize[7]. In other words, the realization of results is essential for the corporate governance of each company, as financial crises with global impacts have caused great losses for publicly traded companies, not only enhancing the need for disclosure of these risks in their accounting statements, but also reducing informational asymmetry and the degree of uncertainty of users regarding the investment made in a given company[4].
Given the exposure to credit, liquidity, market, and operational risks, risk management is fundamental for the survival of these companies, which justifies its relevance in the disclosure of information in their financial statements[7]. The risk of disclosing financial statements arises from the subjectivity of the analysis to be made by the company, as well as by the technical areas of the CVM, including, for example, judgments involving asset impairment, collateral, or returns, which impacts not only the stock price but also bonus payments.
Given the subjectivity regarding the correct accounting treatment, there may be a divergence between the accountant and the external auditor, which may consequently lead to a reservation in the external audit opinion or its republication[4]
The concern of CVM’s technical areas is that users of financial statements have the conditions to assess the risk of misleading information and, also, that there is the possibility of distributing remuneration to administrators and/or dividends based on results that may not materialize, due to, for example, the recognition of tax credits in the billions of reais, which may be reversed later.
Business and financial disclosure risks mutually influence each other, as the management of a company with strong competition and below-expected financial results may be motivated to disclose in the financial statements information that does not represent its economic reality. The same risk affects the tax auditor, who may be sued by the company, in case of bankruptcy or significant losses, in addition to being held responsible by the CVM, through an administrative sanctioning process[8]
Regarding passive contingencies, companies must be even more attentive, as they will have the effect of disbursing financial resources (expenses), and it is up to the company to re-evaluate them periodically, verifying if the treatment remains adequate.
The records of contingent liabilities in the financial statements guarantee users the absence of: i. distortions in balances (overstated or understated); ii. omitted liabilities. Furthermore, they protect the company against possible claims for not disclosing probable future disbursements in its financial statements[4]. This occurs because, for passive contingencies, there can be two forms of accounting: provision or reserve. If the accounting triggering event occurs, the passive contingency will be provisioned, with a reduction in the period’s result as a counterpart.
Provisions for contingencies are non-deductible expenses for tax purposes. However, when the loss materializes, the company may exclude them for the purposes of calculating Income Tax (IR) and Social Contribution on Profit (CSLL), since their constitution occurred in that fiscal year, which reflects the temporal criterion for calculating both taxes.
If the taxable event does not occur, a reserve is made, through which the company appropriates part of its profit, avoiding the possibility of dividend distribution, since there is an expectation of future financial disbursements. Unlike provisions, these reserves do not affect the company’s results and do not impact the calculation of Income Tax and Social Contribution on Net Profit, as these taxes are calculated individually.
The same understanding is applied to contingent assets, as overvaluing the company’s net worth, inflating its assets and revenues, allows for the distribution of administrator remuneration and/or dividends based on results that can be operated.
In this study, it is noted that accounting statements are an instrument of great relevance for publicly traded companies, as they allow for the management and administration of their tax risks, in addition to ensuring greater transparency to their investors and increasing market efficiency. By establishing appropriate recognition criteria and measurement bases for provisions and contingent liabilities or assets, current laws, norms, and resolutions serve as a guarantee for these companies in tax management, since, by following such criteria, companies reduce the risk of disclosing misleading information to their investors, maintaining market efficiency and financial transparency, in addition to avoiding eventual oversight by the CVM.
Regarding the aforementioned federal autarchy, although it does not have the competence to delve into the merits of each company’s accounting recognition, it is noted that the guidelines elaborated by it, such as opinions and circular letters, correspond to a significant instrument for the regularization and standardization of accounting disclosures by these companies. The standardization of these disclosures interacts with the rules stipulated by the Accounting Pronouncements Committee, allowing auditors and legal advisors of publicly traded companies to have greater legal certainty in the recognition of tax credits in the financial statements, thus enabling them to manage the risks of eventual inspection by the CVM and of Administrative Sanctioning Processes.
References
[1] Conselho Federal de Contabilidade (CFC). Resolução CFC nº 1.055/2005, de 7 de outubro de 2005. Cria o Comitê de Pronunciamentos Contábeis (CPC), e dá outras providências. Diário Oficial da União. 2005 out. 24.
[2] Comitê de Pronunciamentos Contáveis (CPC). Pronunciamento Técnico CPC 25 – Provisões, Passivos Contingentes e Ativos Contingentes. CPC; 2009. Disponível em: <http://static.cpc.aatb.com.br/Documentos/304_CPC_25_rev%2014.pdf>.
[3] Brasil. Presidência da República. Lei nº 6.385, de 7 de dezembro de 1976. Dispõe sobre o mercado de valores mobiliários e cria a Comissão de Valores Mobiliários. Brasília, DF; 1976. Disponível em: < https://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L6385.htm>.
[4] Costa B.M.N.; Ponte P.H.L.V. Determinantes na divulgação de Informações de Risco de Mercado por empresas não financeiras. RACE. 2017; 16(2): 729-756.
[5] Conselho Federal de Contabilidade (CFC). Resolução CFC nº 1.022, de 18 de março de 2005. Aprova a NBC T 11.15 – Contingência. Diário Oficial da União. 2005 abr. 22.
[6] Oliveira A. M.S.; Faria A.O; Oliveira L.M; Alves P.S.L.G. Contabilidade internacional: gestão de riscos, governança corporativa e contabilização de derivativos. 2008. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.
[7] Goulart A.M.C. Evidenciação contábil do risco de mercado por instituições financeiras no Brasil [Dissertação]. São Paulo: Universidade de São Paulo; 2003. Disponível em: <https://teses.usp.br/teses/disponiveis/12/12136/tde-08122003-122400/publico/Dissertacao_AndreGoulart.PDF.
[8] Martin, E., Gelbec, E R., Santos A.; Iudícibus S. Manual de Contabilidade Societária: Aplicável a todas as Sociedades de acordo com as Normas Internacionais e CPC. 2013. Atlas, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.9.
Como citar
Ribeiro R.A; Alecrim E.R. Administração dos riscos tributários no reconhecimento de ativos contingentes pelas companhias de capital aberto. Revista E&S. 2023; 4: e20230001.
Sobre os autores
Rafaella Alencar Ribeiro, Advogada, Especialista em Gestão Tributária, Brasília, DF, Brasil.
Eliza Remédio Alecrim, Mestre em Direito Tributário, Campinas, SP, Brasil.
Link para download: https://cms.revistaes.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/ES_23001-1.pdf